Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nosy friend with finances

191 replies

LololaLo2012 · 21/11/2022 21:21

My DH is very fortunate to have CEO level job with good salary. He has worked hard to get to where his is, has to work many hours and take trips away most weeks.

I work part time as we have 3 children 6, 5 and 2. My money that I earn is my own and for the kids/extra food after the main shop/myself.

I am just going to state and reiterate that we are in a very fortunate position and I am very grateful. Neither of us grew up as financially comfortable. My mum was a single mum, husband dad was a teacher and mum stayed home)
The kids don’t go without anything, we can afford days out/holidays/decent clothes/x2 cars. Live in a semi detached x4 bed house.
We are not fancy people or materialistic.

I have this friend “Anna” that constantly comments on anything and everything we have.
Like:
how do you afford 2 cars such big fancy cars?
Please don’t tell me you pay £xx amount to go to this gym? (As she is sat in the softplay for free with her children)
Why don’t you claim children benefit again? (I have repeatedly told her nicely and brushing it of almost as not to come across like a bitch - my husband is over the salary threshold)
Why didn’t your daughter do 30 hours at preschool? (Again, nicely, you can only do 15 hours over the threshold)
How much did you spend on your kitchen again?
You do a clothes order from Zara for the kids???
comments on our friends car (same as mine) how much did they pay for that?
Questioning me on how our friend took their 3 children to Disney Paris and the cost?
She alway comments when my husband is “working late” or “working away” as she puts it. Commenting on me having to deal with the kids alone and he needs to pull his weight and help (I’m fine, he has to work these hours. More money comes more responsibly 🤷‍♀️)

So today.. this is why I’m pissed off. I know before anyone says - whatever, get over it! I know I’m just annoyed and I know there are more important things in the world going on!!!

I spoke to “Anna” about my sons Frog for his birthday a couple of days ago just casually as I got a good deal secondhand.
We brought him a secondhand Frog bike £190 vs £380 new.

I found out that “Anna” has been speaking to a mutual friend “Jane” of ours about me and the Frog bike.
“what bike will you get “Sam” this Christmas… not one of those fancy and stupidity expensive Frog bikes” she was trying to get a reaction out of my Jane and Jane felt like “Anna” wanted a “yeah it is a really fancy and expensive bike for a child” Jane did not take the bait, and is actually thinking of getting her son in too!

”Anna” then went on to talk out my friends new car and how much it costs and your husband must be on a good wage! “Jane” was shocked at her basically trying to get out of her how much her husband earns!

I don’t know or want to know “Annas ”financial situation. She works part time and her husband works and they seem to be doing ok? X2 Okish cars, Kids do after school activities, nice clothes and days out and holidays! So I’m a bit shocked that she’s like this at times.

I just ignore her on the whole, it’s more the talking behind my back that I don’t like - but today I just felt a little sad that maybe our friendship isn’t as I thought.
Any advice?

OP posts:
dontcallmethatyoucunt · 24/11/2022 19:40

TomTraubertsBlues · 24/11/2022 19:39

I also don't get it. Your husband is a CEO and you earn a respectable salary, but your joint account might be short if you buy sandwiches?! And why doesn't your normal budget include a basic like cleaning products?

Can you see how that doesn't stack up? Having to think about, and budget for, food and cleaning products is not normal for a high income family.

It might be with 3 lots of school fees a £1m mortgage….

not seeing it, nor is OP

TomTraubertsBlues · 24/11/2022 19:39

I also don't get it. Your husband is a CEO and you earn a respectable salary, but your joint account might be short if you buy sandwiches?! And why doesn't your normal budget include a basic like cleaning products?

Can you see how that doesn't stack up? Having to think about, and budget for, food and cleaning products is not normal for a high income family.

Firethrice · 24/11/2022 19:31

LololaLo2012 · 24/11/2022 18:54

To make it very clear my husband is in no way financially abusive.

I just just use my own account when I buy stuff just for me! Like my own lunch but if I put it on the joint account my husband wouldn’t be having words with me!! Same with cleaning stuff I’m just in there buying I don’t know - presents for children’s parties and I pick up a bottle of flash! All of which I could put on the joint account I just don’t. That the way in works for us.

not that need to explain myself - both me and husband have personal accounts and a joint account with equal access to. The joint account is to pay bills, mortgage, food, household items etc… to which I contribute £0. I wouldn’t expect my husband to pay for his trip to the pub from the JA, even though he earns enough to coving living expenses we still have a budget per month. So if I went around and brought lunch everyday we would be short on direct debits going out.

This OP wasn’t about my actual financial situation I just gave background as to help get my main point of my friend asking me rude questions!

I don't understand if you bought a sandwich in Aldi every day - you'd be short at the end of the week - what kind of CEO-level job does he have, it doesn't seem to pay well. You know CEOs are on £200k plus - and that's a very small business. None of this sounds right? I'm really not sure what's going on here.
BTW - you are telling us this stuff - you don't want to discuss stuff I get that - but don't post about it.

LololaLo2012 · 24/11/2022 19:25

@TomTraubertsBlues
same with my job, lower salary but still decent, and not “needed”. Also, love my job as I’m please I can work in the industry I trained in part time and keep myself in the game so to speak. Once the kids are older I can work more hours.

I didn’t mean I get personal held accountable just a general sense of where the money is going it still has to be taken into account.

funds are not tide but not endless

OP posts:
dontcallmethatyoucunt · 24/11/2022 19:04

Surely your DH gives you money?

LololaLo2012 · 24/11/2022 18:54

To make it very clear my husband is in no way financially abusive.

I just just use my own account when I buy stuff just for me! Like my own lunch but if I put it on the joint account my husband wouldn’t be having words with me!! Same with cleaning stuff I’m just in there buying I don’t know - presents for children’s parties and I pick up a bottle of flash! All of which I could put on the joint account I just don’t. That the way in works for us.

not that need to explain myself - both me and husband have personal accounts and a joint account with equal access to. The joint account is to pay bills, mortgage, food, household items etc… to which I contribute £0. I wouldn’t expect my husband to pay for his trip to the pub from the JA, even though he earns enough to coving living expenses we still have a budget per month. So if I went around and brought lunch everyday we would be short on direct debits going out.

This OP wasn’t about my actual financial situation I just gave background as to help get my main point of my friend asking me rude questions!

OP posts:
TomTraubertsBlues · 24/11/2022 18:01

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 24/11/2022 17:59

Yes was going to say this! We are over the threshold and do this.

People keep saying this, but the OP works. she is getting NI credits from her earnings, she doesn't need to claim CB.

TomTraubertsBlues · 24/11/2022 17:59

My DH earns well and I also work (lower salary, but still decent). We don't strictly 'need' my salary, but I value my career and the financial freedom it gives me.

When I buy a sandwich for lunch or cleaning products, I do it on the joint account. And I don't get held "accountable" or questioned on it. Ever.

I agree that what the OP says about being glad she can buy cleaning stuff without any questions is weird in a household where funds are not tight.

ScroogeMcDuckling · 24/11/2022 17:59

dontcallmethatyoucunt · 24/11/2022 17:50

*so I don’t have to “ask” every time I wanted to do something.

OK now THATS weird. Asking to spend family money?

Is this thread being drip fed?

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 24/11/2022 17:59

PanicAtTheDisco2000 · 21/11/2022 23:11

Slightly off main topic.
Claim child benefit, yes DH will have to repay it under the high income charge, BUT you will get a deemed NI credit for each year you claim. This builds up your state pension entitlement free of charge.

Yes was going to say this! We are over the threshold and do this.

Firethrice · 24/11/2022 17:51

TomTraubertsBlues · 24/11/2022 17:22

I agree. Why would you be "held accountable" (as you describe it) if you bought cleaning stuff from B&M from the joint account? It's a household essential, why would you, as an adult woman, not be trusted to do that. It's bizarre that you feel you have to do it with your personal money?

Same goes for the sandwich.

You say your dh isn't financially abusive but you wouldn't like to have to ask to buy a bloody sandwich at Aldi, why would you have to ask, wouldn't you have a joint account? I don't know OP, everyone does things differently it sounds very like you and your dh do not have a joint account, there's just something in your posts that suggests this is your dh's wealth and your lack of access to it your friend is questioning. Are you expected to pay your "fair share" in buying the extras like top-up food and cleaning material in B&M? Does your friend think you are being financially abused?

dontcallmethatyoucunt · 24/11/2022 17:50

*so I don’t have to “ask” every time I wanted to do something.

OK now THATS weird. Asking to spend family money?

Rewis · 24/11/2022 17:47

dontcallmethatyoucunt · 24/11/2022 16:52

Lottery win, drug dealing, porn. I’ve seen it all 😂

Not gonna lie...would do all three if it gets me the same lifestyle 😅
Maybe time to get googling!

ScroogeMcDuckling · 24/11/2022 17:47

I haven’t read all the comments that people have left.

We’ve all had “friends” like this in our lifetime and now I’ve realised just play them at their own game.

if she is questioning you about someone’s car, say nothing, ask them how much their car is to run.

if you keep turning it back on them, it won’t be long before you realise what her situation is which is probably living to their means possibly over and that’s why they are so worried what everyone else has.

Your husband has worked hard, and it sounds like you know the value of a pound - it’s not always what you earn - it’s how you spend it.

TomTraubertsBlues · 24/11/2022 17:22

Firethrice · 24/11/2022 11:23

I'm telling you that your DH earns in the top 1% in the country and it is very unusual that you say you work to pay for extras like food and cleaning materials from B&M. If you said you work to build up your pension, your escape if your dh runs away with another women savings, to pay for lux holidays, for private school, cosmetic surgery, your expensive handbag habit, your expensive hobby or some other large expense but you work to buy extra food and cleaning material at B&M like your household income wouldn't cover it otherwise - it's very curious and unusual... I'm saying I'd question you too because it's so odd and I can't believe given how odd it is that you haven't come out with other odd things regarding money with your friend. Please remember I don't know you - I am going by what you have said but I'm offering you an alternative explanation for why you are getting the third degree.

I agree. Why would you be "held accountable" (as you describe it) if you bought cleaning stuff from B&M from the joint account? It's a household essential, why would you, as an adult woman, not be trusted to do that. It's bizarre that you feel you have to do it with your personal money?

Same goes for the sandwich.

dontcallmethatyoucunt · 24/11/2022 16:52

Rewis · 24/11/2022 16:42

Inheritance is only thing I can come up with but we see each other weekly and but nobodys death hasn't come up in years! But could be. Or families are subsidising significantly but they have several siblings and i know both their parents so cant be to that extend. I know they don't make too much cause they get childcare discount from the council. Could be bonus from work but I don't think they are too significant for retail workers. Could be wrong! Is it any of my business? Nope and I won't ask. I'm just very curious and I really want to use them as my financial advisor if they've figured something out 😅

Lottery win, drug dealing, porn. I’ve seen it all 😂

Rewis · 24/11/2022 16:42

dontcallmethatyoucunt · 24/11/2022 16:00

Usually it’s inheritance, or they earn more in their job than you think.

I remember a friend once asking me directly how much my bonus was. She nearly fell over when I told her.

Inheritance is only thing I can come up with but we see each other weekly and but nobodys death hasn't come up in years! But could be. Or families are subsidising significantly but they have several siblings and i know both their parents so cant be to that extend. I know they don't make too much cause they get childcare discount from the council. Could be bonus from work but I don't think they are too significant for retail workers. Could be wrong! Is it any of my business? Nope and I won't ask. I'm just very curious and I really want to use them as my financial advisor if they've figured something out 😅

Rainn21 · 24/11/2022 16:12

You could just tell her what things cost when she asks and if she asks how you afford it you could say with my husbands salary.

BoudiccaVibes · 24/11/2022 16:08

Herejustforthisone · 21/11/2022 23:17

You’re not unreasonable, but for people who claim to not be materialistic, you all seem rather obsessed with what each other has.

Omg is this a thing? I've 'refused' CB for years because of high earnings. Have I shot myself in the foot?

Chickapea77 · 24/11/2022 16:03

I witnessed a similar situation with some friends on a WhatsApp chat. One of them married a very well off guy who at some point received a big sum from his family, they purchased a very luxurious property abroad and this other friend was constantly asking about the cost of everything and making snide comments about holidays and stuff like that. In the end she sort of stopped sharing things as she is not someone who would like to brag or show off, shame because I feel most of us loved to see her fabulous lifestyle.

It all came crashing when her husband was caught in an airport at the time of a terrorist scare and this other friend asked her, shit you not, if she was covered by a good life insurance… just imagine saying that to someone who has not heard from her husband in those circumstances.

Still not sure if she is jealous or just lacks any social skill and thinks that’s remotely appropriate. Eventually she disappeared from the group, feel sad but she did say hurtful things to me a couple of times too.

dontcallmethatyoucunt · 24/11/2022 16:00

Rewis · 24/11/2022 08:50

Does she know your husband is a CEO and travels a lot for work? (Often an indicator that it's not a one person local job) cause that really should answer all the questions in her head.

I really want to know how my friend can afford everything her family has. I know what she and her husband do for a living so I'm baffled. But I'm not asking eventhough she's one of my good friends.

Usually it’s inheritance, or they earn more in their job than you think.

I remember a friend once asking me directly how much my bonus was. She nearly fell over when I told her.

MinnieGirl · 24/11/2022 15:40

I’m afraid I would have to be blunt, especially if she did this all the time…

Why are you always so nosey about what I spend? It’s none of your business what we do with our money, and I’m getting fed up with your constant questions. Please don’t ask me how much I spend again

Job done.

KettrickenSmiled · 24/11/2022 14:44

If you don’t want your poorer friends to be triggered, either you could have a different vibe about your fortune so that it doesn’t feel like a threat (if the relationship is valuable to you) or you can have different friends who are seeing the world from the same place as you and have more in common with you.

Or you can decide to not make any of it about money, & just stick with people who are not slyly digging at you about wealth/income/status symbols. That doesn't mean they need to be in the same income bracket, surely? Some of my mates are very comfortable, I'm currently almost as skint as I've ever been - it doesn't cause any problems because I'm not envious, & not turned on by wealth.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 24/11/2022 14:40

LololaLo2012 · 24/11/2022 12:22

@Maybebabyno2
@Firethrice

So maybe, I seem a bit flippant when I say B&M for cleaning stuff, I go for a look around B&M and pick up those kind of items myself.
I meant it in general sense - I want lunch at work - walk to Aldi buy myself a sandwich and a coke. I like having my own money so I don’t have to “ask” every time I wanted to do something.

Like I have stated from the start and reiterated, I know I am in a very fortunate position that I can essentially use my money as pin money. Even with a higher household income you have to still be accountable for where money is going!

I really don’t think just because one person in the household earns the 1% top salary doesn’t automatically meant the other person money HAS to go on luxuries only.

My friend brings it up. I don’t tell her, come over and see my £xx kitchen. Or can you guess where and how much I paid for this… Now that would be weird!

She also buys herself plenty of “things”, decorated her house, went to centre parks recently over half term. I know how expensive centre parks is but I didn’t ask her. That’s my point! I don’t ask!

Ok then - so you've stated she goes to Center Parcs and buys herself things and decorates her house, so I'd just tell her as @2bazookas says to 'butt out and mind your own business 'Anna''. If after all this she still insists on making pointed comments then review your friendship.

It's obviously irking and irritating you that she's asking this and also getting 'Jane' involved so you have to decide whether a harsh word will work or not, try it, or not, and if it doesn't work, cut her loose.

BigMamageddon · 24/11/2022 14:33

The thing is, you love it. You love your life style and the things you buy. And no one is saying you shouldn’t.

But you know why she’s like this, you already know. You know she’s got a lower income and isn’t able to get what you’ve got. You know her self esteem is being triggered. It’s going to happen. Whatever you’ve got, whether it’s a loving relationship or children or money - when a friend is feeling the lack, it can get sticky. But you already know this.

It’s a weird one. Is it a case of you needing to be ok with your own wealth? Maybe you’re triggered by your own fortune? Maybe there’s a little awkwardness on your
part?

Do you need your friend to validate your wealth and are getting annoyed that she isn’t?

You clearly want all the things you’ve got (which is OK) and at the same time, you know they speak of your wealth. Whether you want them to or not is irrelevant - certain brands or products or material items say to the world ‘I have X amount of money’. It’s part of the deal. And some people are going to be excited about that and others are going to ask uncomfortable questions.

If you don’t want your poorer friends to be triggered, either you could have a different vibe about your fortune so that it doesn’t feel like a threat (if the relationship is valuable to you) or you can have different friends who are seeing the world from the same place as you and have more in common with you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread