Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Those not wanting children, what’s your plan for old age?

509 replies

Katelyn88 · 21/11/2022 20:49

before people pounce on me:
I do NOT expect my children to be my carers, but I expect my children to ARRANGE care and keep an eye on the quality of care and finances.

Those not wanting children - who will supervise your care and finances when you are too weak/forgetful ?

It’s a genuine question. My parents both looked after their parents. Granny lived with us until she passed away. Me and my sister live within 5 miles from parents and inlaws live around the corner from BIL. I have no idea how childless people manage.

OP posts:
ExplainUnderstand · 22/11/2022 10:22

I don't think it's that old people can't use technology. My parents are well into their 70s and know as much as I do. However, they are becoming slower and more nervous of it and will probably, at some point, lose capacity for it, in the same way that they might lose capacity for many other things.

They're going to need some help. Some people will need more than others, some will die before they get to that stage, but we need to acknowledge that we won't all be organising all our own affairs until the end.

ComtesseDeSpair · 22/11/2022 10:21

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:07

@ComtesseDeSpair my example of new technology was to demonstrate that most of the time old people do find it hard to keep up with the world. Every generation complains about how old people cant keep up with new things - it used to be teletext, then online, we have no idea what it will be in 40 years time. However, I guarantee that in 40 years time all the young people will be complaining about their old people not being able to manage. My parents used to complain about my grandmother not managing the phone back in the early 90s, we are complaining about the internet. Who knows what it will be.

Generally old people also find it hard to keep track of processes. Things that young people dont even think about. However, keeping track of multiple referrals and different medications is something that most young people can do and most old people really really struggle with.

Both physical and cognitive mobility gets impaired when you age. People mostly dont go from fit and healthy to decrepit. It's often gradual and subtle.

But why is this point on a thread about the downsides of being childfree? Do you really think anyone’s adult DC, with their own jobs and families and busy lives, are going to appreciate picking up the phone to mum’s whiny voice saying she’s forgotten which medication to take again, or demanding help with paying the council tax bill again, or asking if they remember how to log into her email account again? All of us should learn from previous generations of elderly relatives who were a pain in the arse because they were technologically inept, and strive to ensure our skills remain current and that we can navigate the world around us.

Thinking that this is something your adult children are going to happily be the fallback for when you allow yourself to become incapable sounds like an example of a sure fire way to ensure those children distance themselves from you as much as possible and think of you as a pointless nuisance, rather than being an example of the importance of having children to help out.

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:20

@RunLolaRun102 I am not. I am just surrounded by old people really struggling. And come from a culture where families look after their elderly so have seen lots of old people. Yes, lots of old people can manage for a while but once they need things it is usually someone else who has to do it. My impression in England is actually that people think old folks just somehow pop over to an old home at a convenient time and old age is essentially just visits. Old age is usually miserable, prolonged and often soul destroying for most people involved

Blossomtoes · 22/11/2022 10:20

PurpleWisteria1 · 21/11/2022 23:26

You hold far more trust in the NHS communication and action than I do!

And me. Who’s going to enforce those legal consequences anyway?

RunLolaRun102 · 22/11/2022 10:18

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:07

@ComtesseDeSpair my example of new technology was to demonstrate that most of the time old people do find it hard to keep up with the world. Every generation complains about how old people cant keep up with new things - it used to be teletext, then online, we have no idea what it will be in 40 years time. However, I guarantee that in 40 years time all the young people will be complaining about their old people not being able to manage. My parents used to complain about my grandmother not managing the phone back in the early 90s, we are complaining about the internet. Who knows what it will be.

Generally old people also find it hard to keep track of processes. Things that young people dont even think about. However, keeping track of multiple referrals and different medications is something that most young people can do and most old people really really struggle with.

Both physical and cognitive mobility gets impaired when you age. People mostly dont go from fit and healthy to decrepit. It's often gradual and subtle.

This isn’t actually true. You’re just being incredibly ageist

JaneFondue · 22/11/2022 10:15

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 22/11/2022 10:08

The reality is that most people on here who plan to off themselves when they are old won't do so because - and I know this will come as a blow to the OP - most older people enjoy a reasonable quality of life and only a minority of them rely on care from their families.

None of us knows what the future holds. I had several childless great-aunts/uncles/cousins (either never had DC or the DC pre-deceased them), who lived into their late 80s independently and died after short illnesses. They were no worse off than their siblings, who did have children.

If you are an older person who needs help, and you have DC willing to help, that's great, but that only applies to a minority. Millions of people manage old age without help from their DC.

Or they hire a competent and cheery Lucy Eylesbarrow! I am saving for that.:)

Peteryougit · 22/11/2022 10:15

My father has ruined my life and was the main reason my first marriage failed with his constant demands for me to care for him and make him centre of my life. He’s in a care home now
with dementia but even now I am not free, I still have to deal with all the shit as POA.

He too said he would end his life if he ever got ill or infirm. In the end, he simply couldn’t muster the courage so he’s ended up in a terrible state.

My children see the effect it’s all had on me and them and I will never, ever put them though the same.

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/11/2022 10:10

We have children. We will be arranging our care, if required, ourselves in good time. Most people know the time is coming but do nothing about it themselves. Not fair to their children, it’s not their responsibility.
If children want to help out, fine but sitting back and expecting them to facilitate your life as you seem to have decided is wrong.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 22/11/2022 10:08

The reality is that most people on here who plan to off themselves when they are old won't do so because - and I know this will come as a blow to the OP - most older people enjoy a reasonable quality of life and only a minority of them rely on care from their families.

None of us knows what the future holds. I had several childless great-aunts/uncles/cousins (either never had DC or the DC pre-deceased them), who lived into their late 80s independently and died after short illnesses. They were no worse off than their siblings, who did have children.

If you are an older person who needs help, and you have DC willing to help, that's great, but that only applies to a minority. Millions of people manage old age without help from their DC.

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:07

@ComtesseDeSpair my example of new technology was to demonstrate that most of the time old people do find it hard to keep up with the world. Every generation complains about how old people cant keep up with new things - it used to be teletext, then online, we have no idea what it will be in 40 years time. However, I guarantee that in 40 years time all the young people will be complaining about their old people not being able to manage. My parents used to complain about my grandmother not managing the phone back in the early 90s, we are complaining about the internet. Who knows what it will be.

Generally old people also find it hard to keep track of processes. Things that young people dont even think about. However, keeping track of multiple referrals and different medications is something that most young people can do and most old people really really struggle with.

Both physical and cognitive mobility gets impaired when you age. People mostly dont go from fit and healthy to decrepit. It's often gradual and subtle.

GristleToesAndWhine · 22/11/2022 10:02

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 10:01

That sounds amazing. Do you want an accomplice?

Yes! We can be a band of robbers for the day. Perhaps we shall even be sent to the same prison where we can start an oldies gossip group.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 10:01

GristleToesAndWhine · 22/11/2022 09:57

Or maybe I'll rob a bank, give the money to the local dog shelter and then end my days in prison. It'll also be horrid I suppose - but I shan't have to worry about the bills.

That sounds amazing. Do you want an accomplice?

Comedycook · 22/11/2022 09:59

I think you need someone... doesn't have to be your child necessarily but someone is needed to oversee what's happening to you.

RunLolaRun102 · 22/11/2022 09:59

ComtesseDeSpair · 22/11/2022 09:50

On the basis that a) like most people of my generation, I anticipate I’ll be working into my 60s and using all kinds of relevant latest technology to do and b) my out of work life also involves using technology to stay relevant and this will continue into my older age; no, I’m not especially worried that upon retirement I’ll suddenly lose the power of being able to access my online banking. Yes, this was a problem for older generations of women who weren’t in the workplace or didn’t do the sorts of jobs which kept their tech skills relevant. It shouldn’t be a problem now and I’m faintly horrified that there are still women out there in 2022 who are imagining themselves as doddery old women who are going to need their children’s constant help to do simply things like pay bills. What a selfish attitude. Empower yourself and make sure you’re never that kind of burden on those around you.

Yes true. Also in many countries old people have no choice but to work and use whatever system is required to do their banking. If my 85 yo uncle in India who has the reading level of a 9 yo can use online banking to manage his accounts in English then someone in the UK shouldn’t have a problem. The reason why they do here is more about financial literacy than tech illiteracy.

GristleToesAndWhine · 22/11/2022 09:57

GristleToesAndWhine · 22/11/2022 09:56

Sheltered accomodation until I have some kind of life ending accident which will, no doubt, be horrible but will also be the price I pay for remaining in my own home as long as possible.

Or maybe I'll rob a bank, give the money to the local dog shelter and then end my days in prison. It'll also be horrid I suppose - but I shan't have to worry about the bills.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 09:56

Maxipaws · 22/11/2022 09:50

I do not expect my children who are now adults to do anything. One of my children will probably emigrate and I don’t want to burden the other one. I think it’s unlikely either will have children, so I won’t be needed for the grandparent role.

I intend to work as long as I can and after that possibly assisted suicide. I have already joined Dignitas. I haven’t told anyone about this not even DH.

My mum is pushing 90 but is a vile human being who spreads misery wherever she goes. She lives completely independently but I would not help her any more than I had to. I stayed with her after she injured herself a couple of years ago and would not do so again. She can pay people or rely on the NHS in future.

My MIL also makes my SIL’s life hell.

I intend to work as long as I can and after that possibly assisted suicide. I have already joined Dignitas. I haven’t told anyone about this not even DH

And if somebody has secretly joined dignitas then immediately gets into a accident or has a stroke and is left with a high level of support needs.... then what?

This plan everybody seems to have of offing themselves at the first available opportunity is very poorly thought out.

GristleToesAndWhine · 22/11/2022 09:56

Sheltered accomodation until I have some kind of life ending accident which will, no doubt, be horrible but will also be the price I pay for remaining in my own home as long as possible.

EndlessRain · 22/11/2022 09:54

And I agree this is a pretty shitty and smug thread.

EndlessRain · 22/11/2022 09:54

I have kids but plan to have my affairs in order so they don't need to look after me. I hope they will want to spend with me though.

Lots of children can't or won't help elderly parents.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 09:52

Withnoshoes · 22/11/2022 09:34

The subject isn’t having an accident when young. It was preparing for elder years without having children to look after you/organise you. It’s not the same. We can absolutely plan for the future of being elderly if we should get there.

No one can plan for an accident or the unexpected childfree or parents. But I could plan for funerals, research fare, maybe buy somewhere residential with care support in preparation.

But yes I have plenty of friends and a big family of relatives and a supportive partner currently that would help (and vice versa) in the event of me needing help right now. I don’t need children to do that now or elderly.

It's absolutely the same. The only difference is that it becomes more likely to the point of almost inevitable that you require some sort of support.

Many older people requiring support (be it long or short term) come into services via unplanned hospital admission.

Again, this isn't a childfree thing. Like you say people without children also have support networks they rely on.

My aim is not to dispell the idea that without children you will have no support as that is absolutely untrue.

My aim is to challenge the idea that it is possible to have an effective plan for disability or injury (becaue that is what we are talking about) that doesn't require an unpaid carer or advocate.

Maxipaws · 22/11/2022 09:50

I do not expect my children who are now adults to do anything. One of my children will probably emigrate and I don’t want to burden the other one. I think it’s unlikely either will have children, so I won’t be needed for the grandparent role.

I intend to work as long as I can and after that possibly assisted suicide. I have already joined Dignitas. I haven’t told anyone about this not even DH.

My mum is pushing 90 but is a vile human being who spreads misery wherever she goes. She lives completely independently but I would not help her any more than I had to. I stayed with her after she injured herself a couple of years ago and would not do so again. She can pay people or rely on the NHS in future.

My MIL also makes my SIL’s life hell.

ComtesseDeSpair · 22/11/2022 09:50

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 09:08

@ComtesseDeSpair the difference is that you dont know what the future holds. Yes, you currently do online stuff but do you know what they system will be like in 40 years time and whether you will be able to do it. My in laws were fine in their 40s but internet wasnt invented - they were very capable of going to the shops, going to a branch bank, they understood cheques. They have absolutely no idea how mobile phone works, how internet works, how you do online banking and why they cant just go to a branch - i mean there arent any of those anymore. Thats the point. Times change and mostly old people get left behind.

On the basis that a) like most people of my generation, I anticipate I’ll be working into my 60s and using all kinds of relevant latest technology to do and b) my out of work life also involves using technology to stay relevant and this will continue into my older age; no, I’m not especially worried that upon retirement I’ll suddenly lose the power of being able to access my online banking. Yes, this was a problem for older generations of women who weren’t in the workplace or didn’t do the sorts of jobs which kept their tech skills relevant. It shouldn’t be a problem now and I’m faintly horrified that there are still women out there in 2022 who are imagining themselves as doddery old women who are going to need their children’s constant help to do simply things like pay bills. What a selfish attitude. Empower yourself and make sure you’re never that kind of burden on those around you.

Kanaloa · 22/11/2022 09:49

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 08:18

@MephistophelesApprentice Did anyone tell you they were having children as a old age plan? You are assuming that to justify your own choices?

anyway, I like your idea of staying with friends!

I mean… you did. You said you expect your children to arrange your care then started a whole thread demanding what on earth ‘childless’ people are planning to do, arguing with anyone who doesn’t say ‘I’m just going to die alone and in agony as a burden to the state.’ That implies that you believe that the right thing to do is what you’ve done - have children to arrange it for you.

I guess you could ask similar questions to get your answer yourself. What will you do if your children grow up and go away to teach in Dubai? Or marry someone from another country and relocate there? It go no contact with you? Or turn out to be incapable of arranging your care for you? Or are selfish and just don’t want to? Whatever you’d do in that situation is what childfree people will do.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 22/11/2022 09:43

I plan to become a witch and sell other selfish childfree people poisonous plants from my garden.

Parents can't have them, because they have their famalam to look after them.

ipreferthecat · 22/11/2022 09:37

@Katelyn88

What an unpleasant post for the infertile as if things were not shit enough as it is
Unpleasantly smug and I can genuinely not think of no reason why anyone needs to know this, it doesn't have any relevance to you so why have you posted ? Other than to smugly gloat when you see the replies

Might as well just book a trip to Switzerland now