Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Those not wanting children, what’s your plan for old age?

509 replies

Katelyn88 · 21/11/2022 20:49

before people pounce on me:
I do NOT expect my children to be my carers, but I expect my children to ARRANGE care and keep an eye on the quality of care and finances.

Those not wanting children - who will supervise your care and finances when you are too weak/forgetful ?

It’s a genuine question. My parents both looked after their parents. Granny lived with us until she passed away. Me and my sister live within 5 miles from parents and inlaws live around the corner from BIL. I have no idea how childless people manage.

OP posts:
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 22/11/2022 11:07

We are all going to age and die, but not all of us are going to experience years of ill-health and dependence, as some posters seem to believe.

The problem is you cannot predict which way things will go for you.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 22/11/2022 11:04

Planning for old age - in practice - means everyone aged 60 moves into assisted living, gives over POA to someone and sorts out all their affairs. I have yet to meet anyone in their early 60s willing to do that. In practice, old age is often degenerative so you have to make sure you are all set when you are still young and fit. By the time you are not - it's too late

Some of the expectations of old age on this thread are absolutely barking. Of course, everyone slows down and becomes frailer. But most people do not get dementia. Three-quarters of people in their 80s live independently. The longer you live, the fewer years of ill-health you experience, on average (not as counter-intuitive as it seems - people with more health issues tend to die earlier).

We are all going to age and die, but not all of us are going to experience years of ill-health and dependence, as some posters seem to believe.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 11:04

RashOfBees · 22/11/2022 10:57

Honestly? This worries me. I will do my bit for my parents in the knowledge that nobody will be doing it for me, and that is a bleak thought. I’m more worried about loneliness than anything.

But since absolutely nothing about raising children appeals, what to do? Apart from the sheer selfishness (and most likely futility) of bringing someone into the world for the sole purpose of caring for my future elderly self, I’d be guaranteeing my best years are lived in a way I don’t want to live them in order to try and stave off something that may never happen - or may happen even if I did have kids.

Honestly you would be surprised at how many meaningful relationships you will continue to make throughout your life.

In my time working in adult social care I have encountered incredibly brilliant carers/advocates who are neighbours, children of friends and distant relatives. You name it and I've seen it. It's staggeringly rare that somebody will have nobody at all to provide some level of support and when it does happen its usually because of a multiple factors and not because they are child free.

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:58

@Seasidegirl5 exactly. Planning for old age - in practice - means everyone aged 60 moves into assisted living, gives over POA to someone and sorts out all their affairs. I have yet to meet anyone in their early 60s willing to do that. In practice, old age is often degenerative so you have to make sure you are all set when you are still young and fit. By the time you are not - it's too late.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 10:58

I'm confused at what "child free" means.

I thought it meant doesn't have children and is not planning to. Reading this thread it seems that it people think its actually a euphemism for "hermit".

RashOfBees · 22/11/2022 10:57

Honestly? This worries me. I will do my bit for my parents in the knowledge that nobody will be doing it for me, and that is a bleak thought. I’m more worried about loneliness than anything.

But since absolutely nothing about raising children appeals, what to do? Apart from the sheer selfishness (and most likely futility) of bringing someone into the world for the sole purpose of caring for my future elderly self, I’d be guaranteeing my best years are lived in a way I don’t want to live them in order to try and stave off something that may never happen - or may happen even if I did have kids.

JaneFondue · 22/11/2022 10:56

CallieQ · 22/11/2022 10:55

@JaneFondue people can you slim fit and engaged with the world and still get cancer... amazing isn't it

True. But one can only do so much. Still better than having children to serve as your care workers.

CallieQ · 22/11/2022 10:55

@JaneFondue people can you slim fit and engaged with the world and still get cancer... amazing isn't it

CallieQ · 22/11/2022 10:53

Katelyn88 · 21/11/2022 20:49

before people pounce on me:
I do NOT expect my children to be my carers, but I expect my children to ARRANGE care and keep an eye on the quality of care and finances.

Those not wanting children - who will supervise your care and finances when you are too weak/forgetful ?

It’s a genuine question. My parents both looked after their parents. Granny lived with us until she passed away. Me and my sister live within 5 miles from parents and inlaws live around the corner from BIL. I have no idea how childless people manage.

No one knows how things will work out in the future do they? None of us lived 'round the corner' from our parents and my oldest son now lives in America. Do you think everyone is the same? Both my parents went too young and fairly quickly

JaneFondue · 22/11/2022 10:53

EndlessRain · 22/11/2022 10:46

Really the best thing you can do is ensure that you have a decent pension so you can afford assistance with your needs. Whether that be care, residential, cleaning, admin etc.
My mum worked in social care and the amount of children who either can't or won't help their parents is vast. They might not have a good relationship or the children live their own lives that prevent any kind of hands on help. Personally I think it's an unfair expectation that children should drop their lives to help their parents - sure easy to pop around to help with the bills if you are down the road, but what if they live in another part of the country or the world? What if the children are going through their own hardships? Or if the children have their own care needs?
Having children isn't some kind of insurance for old age. In fact I would say good financial planning and doing what you can to take care of your healt is much mor important.

Agree. Also try to stay fit. My mum works very hard at staying fit, slim and engaged with the world. Tries hard to make friends and keep relationships. It makes life much easier for me.

Seasidegirl5 · 22/11/2022 10:51

I really hope everyone saying they will plan for their own care truly do, myself included, but I think it's really hard to say what we would do now because we are not in that situation.

My parents are mid 70s, my dad has spent many years helping and advising older relatives on care and finances, yet he has done absolutely no planning regarding himself. I have asked him about this and he says it's because he can't face his own mortality and can't accept that he is getting older. He is the only one left out of his circle of friends already. They've all passed away.
I think any/most people likely will feel the same way that he does, and then at some point a line will be crossed where they suddenly become frail /start with dementia/have a fall/stroke etc and then it is too late.

ButterCrackers · 22/11/2022 10:51

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:29

@ComtesseDeSpair I am now in my 40s - it is certainly not a relationship that I would want but in my experience it is usually what happens. And as I said - I am not British. Do I assume that my kid would arrange my care (even if not do all the personal care themselves) - yes, I do. I expect that I will do that for my parents, we are doing that for the in laws and both my parents and the in laws did it for their parents. Thats the definition of family. I may not like it getting up in the night when my kid is sick but thats my job as a parent, my job as a child is to support my parents. Neither will automatically make me jumping for joy but do I assume that I have some responsibility towards both the younger and older generation - yes, I do

This is also how family is for me too. My parents have passed away so I don’t have the elder care responsibility now. When my mother was unable to make decisions due to sudden illness myself and family had to sort out everything but there was a limit to what we could do easily because we didn’t have power of attorney. We paid for everything ourselves and it was a big cost. We got part back afterwards. We stepped up to the task because that’s what family is for. It was a huge work and my family had to put in more time than me because I was on medical bed rest before giving birth. Hours spent travelling after work with getting back a few hours before starting work and being there plus getting what was needed. They did this without a second thought. I did what I was able to do as well - no doubling thinking it. Once I was ok I was back to the work of helping in person. From what I have read here we did over and above what others would do to help family. I’ve made a plan for my family so that their help, when/if needed will be less complicated for them to do. I respect and value my family and, no matter what, I’m there for them and they are on my side too.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 22/11/2022 10:50

I'll also tell you what happens when you're child free. You get to be the one looking after your parents

Very true. The care of my parents fell on me (no biol DC) and my sib whose DC were grown up. DSis with school-age kids opted out completely, even though her DC were in their teens, pretty independent and she only works very, very p-t.

EndlessRain · 22/11/2022 10:46

Really the best thing you can do is ensure that you have a decent pension so you can afford assistance with your needs. Whether that be care, residential, cleaning, admin etc.
My mum worked in social care and the amount of children who either can't or won't help their parents is vast. They might not have a good relationship or the children live their own lives that prevent any kind of hands on help. Personally I think it's an unfair expectation that children should drop their lives to help their parents - sure easy to pop around to help with the bills if you are down the road, but what if they live in another part of the country or the world? What if the children are going through their own hardships? Or if the children have their own care needs?
Having children isn't some kind of insurance for old age. In fact I would say good financial planning and doing what you can to take care of your healt is much mor important.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 10:45

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:40

In theory, people should be able to have advocates who are not their kids. However, this isnt how the British system is currently designed. It essentially went from women doing most of the burden to this complex, messed up thing called the NHS/social care. Our entire health system is collapsing because we havent figured out how to care for old people. So clearly it's not all as simple as saying 'oh well I'll just thing about it well ahead of time'. I mean if it was so simple, the NHS would function but it doesnt in part because we havent figured out this issue or how best to manage it.

This is absolutely untrue.

This is how it works in practice (and law) not just theory.

You are correct that our system effectively does not work without unpaid advocacy/carers but incorrect to say they have to be children.

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:40

In theory, people should be able to have advocates who are not their kids. However, this isnt how the British system is currently designed. It essentially went from women doing most of the burden to this complex, messed up thing called the NHS/social care. Our entire health system is collapsing because we havent figured out how to care for old people. So clearly it's not all as simple as saying 'oh well I'll just thing about it well ahead of time'. I mean if it was so simple, the NHS would function but it doesnt in part because we havent figured out this issue or how best to manage it.

Daftasahoover · 22/11/2022 10:37

'childfree one' - see, even autocorrect can't compute 'childfree'

Daftasahoover · 22/11/2022 10:35

I'll also tell you what happens when you're child free. You get to be the one looking after your parents.

My DParents had 3 kids - DSis who has 2 kids and DBro who has 2 kids. And me, the children one.

DParent can't manage living alone. So they moved in with me and DH. Because DSis 'Oh, I have too much on, with DKids and all - you wouldn't understaaaaand because you don't have kids'. And DBro 'Oh, no, they can't live with us, we've got the kids, no extra space.....'

I should perhaps mention that none of 'the kids' actually live at home, all are NT and their parents see them every six months or so.

I would also add that if DH and I want a holiday or a weekend away, getting the siblings to step up is, well, challenging.

Redkettle · 22/11/2022 10:33

I don't understand the anger on this thread really. It's just as much a legitimate question as asking people with chikdren will they expect their kids to care for them or not? I have kids but I didn't have them so they could look after me in old age. You don't think like that anyway when you are young. If anything when I'm old I would prob prefer that I hadn't had them because feeling like I was a burden to them or them seeing me getting sick and the pain it would cause them would be heartbreaking. When my husbands mother died his main concern was that when he died our kids would go through that pain. I know that's life but it still jabs. Personally I want to look after my parents if I can it's the least I can do. But I'm not there yet, and I know I have no idea how hard that will be.

JaneFondue · 22/11/2022 10:30

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 22/11/2022 10:23

Or they hire a competent and cheery Lucy Eylesbarrow! I am saving for that

Indeed - double first in Maths optional, but must know how to search a sarcophagus.

And make syllabub!:) I really hope she didn't marry one of the useless male Crackenthorps and mummy them for the rest of their lives.

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:29

@ComtesseDeSpair I am now in my 40s - it is certainly not a relationship that I would want but in my experience it is usually what happens. And as I said - I am not British. Do I assume that my kid would arrange my care (even if not do all the personal care themselves) - yes, I do. I expect that I will do that for my parents, we are doing that for the in laws and both my parents and the in laws did it for their parents. Thats the definition of family. I may not like it getting up in the night when my kid is sick but thats my job as a parent, my job as a child is to support my parents. Neither will automatically make me jumping for joy but do I assume that I have some responsibility towards both the younger and older generation - yes, I do

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 10:29

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:22

@ComtesseDeSpair have a look at the threads about elderly parents. Thats usually what happens. You can say that we should learn or that is shouldnt but it usually does

That's called selection bias.

Why would anybody make a thread to say-

"I support my parents/aunt/neighbours with a few bits and I don't mind at all".

ComtesseDeSpair · 22/11/2022 10:26

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:22

@ComtesseDeSpair have a look at the threads about elderly parents. Thats usually what happens. You can say that we should learn or that is shouldnt but it usually does

Yes. I’ve seen. Their frustrated adult DC are generally at their wits’ end with them and resent their learned helplessness. Is that the relationship you want with your children when they’re older?

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 22/11/2022 10:23

Or they hire a competent and cheery Lucy Eylesbarrow! I am saving for that

Indeed - double first in Maths optional, but must know how to search a sarcophagus.

Hdiw747 · 22/11/2022 10:22

@ComtesseDeSpair have a look at the threads about elderly parents. Thats usually what happens. You can say that we should learn or that is shouldnt but it usually does

Swipe left for the next trending thread