Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Those not wanting children, what’s your plan for old age?

509 replies

Katelyn88 · 21/11/2022 20:49

before people pounce on me:
I do NOT expect my children to be my carers, but I expect my children to ARRANGE care and keep an eye on the quality of care and finances.

Those not wanting children - who will supervise your care and finances when you are too weak/forgetful ?

It’s a genuine question. My parents both looked after their parents. Granny lived with us until she passed away. Me and my sister live within 5 miles from parents and inlaws live around the corner from BIL. I have no idea how childless people manage.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 22/11/2022 16:46

I don't have kids at least in part because of my health issues. I had already decided I didn't want to do that, and that my pretty horrible fairly late miscarriage had in fact been a narrow escape, before I found out that it would be pretty much lethal not to mention passing on dodgy genetics, to reproduce.

So my plan for old age is er, die before I get there? I have a life limiting condition and I am already a good 3 years over the estimate so the chances of me getting to 60+ are vanishingly small.

ipreferthecat · 22/11/2022 16:46

@Katelyn88

I don't feel you are getting attacked because of the question actually

But a combination of the incredibly patronising way you reply to things

Smug, goady and unpleasant to be honest

Not that you have managed to magically hit a nerve with people just that you seem utterly, utterly ghastly

BadNomad · 22/11/2022 16:32

Hopefully by the time we're all ready to go, they'll have brought in humane ways to allow us to pass when we're ready. No need to fly abroad to find dignity.

lieselotte · 22/11/2022 16:27

Scarecrowrowboat · 21/11/2022 20:51

I do have kids but I wouldn't necessarily expect them to do any of that anyway.
Honestly I'm naïvely hoping that, like my grandmother I stay active and independent right up until the point that I die in my sleep.

Same here.

SIL doesn't have kids but does have nieces and nephews. And she is looking after the affairs of a lady up the road. So you may find a friend or neighbour to help.

LOLsloth · 22/11/2022 16:23

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 15:11

At what point would you make that call?

I watched all four of my grandparents, each of whom had at least 3 children, suffer in the final years of their lives. Their children loved them to the end, but each of the four was crippled from strokes, cancer, or dementia in the final years, and were clearly miserable with pain and loss of dignity and mobility. The plan was to care for them at home, but this just wasn’t possible for the cancer and stroke victims, and finally the dementia victim. Their final years were hellish and I will not do that to myself or my family.

So based on the ages when my four grandparents went into decline, I have concluded that 85 is the age I need to book my exit with Dignitas. At that age, each of my grandparents was still lucid and mobile enough to make a decision like this and act on it. I will not wait longer than that because the strokes that two of my grandparents suffered rendered them immobile. So 85 it is.

That is my plan. And my son knows this. He’s a veterinarian, so I like to think he will be understanding about wanting to choose a dignified, humane end for myself when I am old.

Lentilweaver · 22/11/2022 16:17

There are so many threads right now berating the childfree for their poor choices. Baffled why you care so much if your choices are that great. The lady doth protest too much...

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/11/2022 16:08

I’ve worked on issues around ageing fir about 30 years. I can count on the fingers of one hand the numbers of older ppl who’ve said to me “I want my children to look after me” and yet 92% unpaid care is carried out by a spouse/partner or adult child. The older you get the more likely it is to be the adult child. Generally, as previous posters have said, they’re not providing hands on care but finding out info, arranging it, monitoring it & dealing with problems

it’s great how many ppl have got arrangements in place. Everyone whether they have children or not needs to think about this

Lentilweaver · 22/11/2022 16:04

You seem very angry, OP, at the fact that no one has applauded your incredible foresight in having children and indeed wanting to move/emigrate to where your DC are if necessary.

Anyway, my plan is to move to a cheaper country. Thailand, Malaysia, India. If you really want to know.

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 22/11/2022 15:45

Find a friend you trust.

I am POA for a friend who is 15 years older than me - no partner, family or children. He is guardian to my DD should anything happen to DH and I before she's an adult/self sufficient.

We have talked about what he wants should he become too incapacitated to give his own wishes so I know in advance.

PearlclutchersInc · 22/11/2022 15:39

Why do you think the children-havers and children-not havers lives are going to be dramatically different. Some people will end up in a home or with carers for a whole variety of reasons, the decisions of their children being at the top of the list.
Don't expect just because you have children its going to be happy extended family ever after.
You just have to read some of the threads/media to know its never going to happen.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 15:38

Childless people on MUMS net, making personal attacks and baseless accusations for just asking a simple question: “what’s your plan for old age?

When and where? Some are a bit defensive but that's understandable given that the undeniable implication of the question is that of you don't have kids nobody will care about you.

BlueLabel · 22/11/2022 15:34

Childless people on MUMS net, making personal attacks and baseless accusations for just asking a simple question: “what’s your plan for old age?”

You've been told not to use childless. The presence of childfree people on mumsnet is so overdone as a topic as well. Face it OP, you started a grim thread and you aren't smart enough to convince anyone it was out of innocent curiosity/research for your own back up plan.

Otherwise the question would have been "what plans does ANYONE have for old age and what contingencies do they have".

MNMH · 22/11/2022 15:30

Kanaloa · 22/11/2022 15:27

Well what’s your PLAN for if your children don’t/can’t/won’t meet your expectation to care for you? It’s the same question. You’re just comforting yourself that your choice to have children was incredibly clever and will guarantee you top level care in later life. I imagine that brings you some comfort, but in reality it’s better to accept the lack of control over the future. You may end up with children who don’t want to care for you. Elderly people without children may manage fine alone/be cared for by somebody else.

Why the concern and anger over other people’s choices when you’re so afraid to actually examine your own? If you’re happy in your expectations that your children will shoulder the burden of caring for you then why are you so worried about what others might or might not do?

Yeah the level of anger in her responses perplex me

Kanaloa · 22/11/2022 15:29

And the fact is if you wanted to start a thread about advice, you shouldn’t have opened it with ‘I expect my children to care for me - what will all you childless people do?’ Obviously that wouldn’t get the advice you supposedly wanted.

Maybe start a new thread asking about people’s plans for old age and advice on how you can prepare in case you need care. Because if it’s for advice for you then what’s it got to do with random child free people?

antelopevalley · 22/11/2022 15:28

There is always a bit of burying your head in the sand because no one knows what will happen. What if you have one child and they die before you? What happens if you and your partner both need care? What happens if government policy changes and you have to pay for medical care but can not afford to? Or if there are no carers or homes available in your area? Or if your house burns to the ground and insurance refuse to pay out as they say it was your fault? Or your adult children steal all your money from you?

One of the facts most people learn as they get older is there is only so much planning you can do. But things often happen you do not foresee.

Kanaloa · 22/11/2022 15:27

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 15:09

Childless people on MUMS net, making personal attacks and baseless accusations for just asking a simple question: “what’s your plan for old age?”

PLAN and HOPE are two different things.

Everyone HOPES to stay healthy, mobile and mentally active till the end. If things don’t turn out the way you HOPED, what’s the PLAN!?

Well what’s your PLAN for if your children don’t/can’t/won’t meet your expectation to care for you? It’s the same question. You’re just comforting yourself that your choice to have children was incredibly clever and will guarantee you top level care in later life. I imagine that brings you some comfort, but in reality it’s better to accept the lack of control over the future. You may end up with children who don’t want to care for you. Elderly people without children may manage fine alone/be cared for by somebody else.

Why the concern and anger over other people’s choices when you’re so afraid to actually examine your own? If you’re happy in your expectations that your children will shoulder the burden of caring for you then why are you so worried about what others might or might not do?

MNMH · 22/11/2022 15:24

Maybe we should just go back in time, procreate, and spend our offspring's childhood rigorously training them to prepare for our old age.

MNMH · 22/11/2022 15:23

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 15:15

I don’t know! That’s why I asked so I can plan! And I’m getting attacked because people don’t like questions the plan is to bury head in sand and live in denial.

No one is burying their heads in the sand and living in denial. They have answered your questions and you have shot down every explanation very rudely, as though it angers you that they dare have an alternative. (And not just the ones about assisted suicide.)

Not sure what you want from people. No wonder they think you're being goady.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 15:17

greenhousegal · 22/11/2022 14:53

@Changeyncchange
See my previous post and maybe YOU could enlighten us about what appear to be your reservations. Thanks. I can revoke mine at any time whilst composi mentos so will be interested to hear if I should.

Apologies, I got you mixed up with somebody else.

I have no reservations. Your plan sounds great. Some people throw around POA like it means that some sort of magic private entity will appear and sort everything out negating the need for any family or friend involvement.

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 15:15

Reaqc · 22/11/2022 15:12

Well what's your plan for if it doesn't go the way you hope and your kids can't or won't?

I don’t know! That’s why I asked so I can plan! And I’m getting attacked because people don’t like questions the plan is to bury head in sand and live in denial.

OP posts:
Reaqc · 22/11/2022 15:12

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 15:09

Childless people on MUMS net, making personal attacks and baseless accusations for just asking a simple question: “what’s your plan for old age?”

PLAN and HOPE are two different things.

Everyone HOPES to stay healthy, mobile and mentally active till the end. If things don’t turn out the way you HOPED, what’s the PLAN!?

Well what's your plan for if it doesn't go the way you hope and your kids can't or won't?

clairelip · 22/11/2022 15:12

Having worked in a care home, I can assure you not all children do what's best for their parents or even bother to make sure they are okay. I've seen residents kept alive against their best interest and elderly parents who were wonderful parents treated appallingly by their children. I hope you never get to experience this but having children is no guarantee you will be well cared for. I entend to enjoy my life to the full and have no worries about leaving an inheritance behind.

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 15:11

LOLsloth · 22/11/2022 15:07

I have a child, but don’t fancy being a burden and too ill or addled to care for myself, so Dignitas is the plan.

At what point would you make that call?

OP posts:
Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 15:09

Childless people on MUMS net, making personal attacks and baseless accusations for just asking a simple question: “what’s your plan for old age?”

PLAN and HOPE are two different things.

Everyone HOPES to stay healthy, mobile and mentally active till the end. If things don’t turn out the way you HOPED, what’s the PLAN!?

OP posts:
RandomCatGenerator · 22/11/2022 15:09

BadLad · 22/11/2022 12:41

When I get old Im going to lie on my bed bemoaning that I never knew real love (having not had kids) before dying of selfishness and lack of purpose in my life, if the other childless thread is anything to go by.

My last thought will probably be wondering why I came on mumsnet since I’m not a parent.

😂😂