Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Those not wanting children, what’s your plan for old age?

509 replies

Katelyn88 · 21/11/2022 20:49

before people pounce on me:
I do NOT expect my children to be my carers, but I expect my children to ARRANGE care and keep an eye on the quality of care and finances.

Those not wanting children - who will supervise your care and finances when you are too weak/forgetful ?

It’s a genuine question. My parents both looked after their parents. Granny lived with us until she passed away. Me and my sister live within 5 miles from parents and inlaws live around the corner from BIL. I have no idea how childless people manage.

OP posts:
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 22/11/2022 07:11

Why can’t you sort your own care out? I have children and I plan to make my own arrangements,

I'm guessing you and others saying similar have no experience of dementia or a relative who went into rapid decline?

EnterFunnyNameHere · 22/11/2022 07:11

What exactly are you after OP? Numerous people have replied and you've ignored or shot them down.

I don't know - and it scares me. I also expect I'll be lonely in old age because I'm not great at making friends and that scares me too. But neither compel me to have children in the hope they will magically resolve those problems for me, and at approaching 40 I'm running out of time to "change my mind" or "meet the right person" (plus my DH might be a bit put out if I did).

So yes, thanks, already worried about these things along with hundreds of other things, but thanks for reminding me.

Polkadotties · 22/11/2022 07:07

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 07:03

What a fucking disgusting sentiment. Implying people who want to continue to live with a disability are weak or cowardly.

Utterly vile. People with disabilities lives are just as meaningful and worthwhile as anybody elses

What?! You have completely misread that post

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 22/11/2022 07:07

Unless you develop dementia, IMO it’s up to adults to sort out their own care, and should make sure there are both powers of attorney (Finances and Health and Welfare) in place, in case for whatever reason they’re unable to.

Unfortunately some old people do become very selfish/self centred, so whatever their ideas earlier, they still expect adult children to run around after them. And/or, even if they can well afford it, they become too miserly to shell out for carers, or they don’t want strangers in the house. And/or they still insist that they can manage everything, when it’s obvious that they can’t.

Can you tell I’m speaking from experience here? 🙁

JackTorrance · 22/11/2022 07:06

What a fucking disgusting sentiment. Implying people who want to continue to live with a disability are weak or cowardly.

She's talking about advanced old age, not a disability.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 07:03

Fucket · 22/11/2022 06:58

I hope to have the courage of two of my grandparents who knew that they could no longer live alone, stopped medication and also didn’t let on when they felt another stroke/heart attack coming on.

grandad swore blind he’d never go in a home. He had an exit plan, he knew he wouldn’t make it to Xmas kept telling us as such. Bless him such a courageous man.

grandmother had a stroke and was in hospital and told the staff she didn’t want any medication and passed a couple of months later.

I worry about losing my marbles first so I won’t be able to make that decision. But if I am that far gone I suppose it won’t matter where I am so long as my kids feel they’re doing the right thing for themselves.

What a fucking disgusting sentiment. Implying people who want to continue to live with a disability are weak or cowardly.

Utterly vile. People with disabilities lives are just as meaningful and worthwhile as anybody elses

Fucket · 22/11/2022 06:58

I hope to have the courage of two of my grandparents who knew that they could no longer live alone, stopped medication and also didn’t let on when they felt another stroke/heart attack coming on.

grandad swore blind he’d never go in a home. He had an exit plan, he knew he wouldn’t make it to Xmas kept telling us as such. Bless him such a courageous man.

grandmother had a stroke and was in hospital and told the staff she didn’t want any medication and passed a couple of months later.

I worry about losing my marbles first so I won’t be able to make that decision. But if I am that far gone I suppose it won’t matter where I am so long as my kids feel they’re doing the right thing for themselves.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 06:57

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 06:43

This is the most sensible post on this thread! The number of people who think it’s all in their control is unbelievable! they seem to look down up on people who depend on their children for support. It’s not a choice!!

I agree with you and the poster you are quoting. I think people are niave about the reality of old age.

As I said on my post above this is my line of work. When we come across older people who are in a bit of a mess we speak their family/friends in the first instance and ask them to get involved. In the vast majority of cases they do (I cant remember somebody saying no outright initially). Even if their relative is saying they don't want them involved they do.

CocoLux · 22/11/2022 06:54

@Katelyn88 your children may decide they don't want to help you. You can't force them to. Many many people don't speak to their parents or have no relationship with them. I really wouldn't be so smug.

Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 06:48

I haven't read the thread but wanted to point this out for people who don't have kids.

I have worked in Adult Social Care for years and we have a not insignificant number of people who don't talk to their kids. We also have a not insignificant number of people (both with and without kids) who are supported by neices/nephews, great neices/nephews, children of friends and neighbours. The children of friends and neighbours are much more frequent than you would imagine. Why does this happen? Usually they are good people who made meaningful relationships.

Also me and my siblings support my childless great aunt and uncle until their deaths. It made no difference to me that they were not our grandparents, I adored them and miss them every day.

JoolsVerne · 22/11/2022 06:48

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 06:38

Yes, without a question if there are no immigration issues

Lol. There will be. And health care issues. I can't get my mum to where I am, assuming she wanted to uproot her entire life and come. Neither can my sibling. There aren't visas for the elderly.

Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 06:43

TealSapphire · 22/11/2022 01:17

I'm always astounded when these types of threads come up with all the people being martyrs and saying they expect nothing of their children at all once they are adults.

If you've done your best as a parent and sacrificed for them and raised half decent humans then of course that relationship goes both ways. It's possible for your children to have a life of their own and still value their parents.

I don't believe the posters who say they'll off themselves at the first sign of old age either. The will to live is strong.

This is the most sensible post on this thread! The number of people who think it’s all in their control is unbelievable! they seem to look down up on people who depend on their children for support. It’s not a choice!!

OP posts:
Katelyn88 · 22/11/2022 06:38

JoolsVerne · 21/11/2022 22:25

You would move to another country? I live in a different country to my parents. So does my only sibling.

The world has changed.

Yes, without a question if there are no immigration issues

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · 22/11/2022 06:28

@PurpleWisteria1 well that's why I'm getting it put in the hospital record too. I do trust my current GP but of course he'll almost certainly be retired by the time this is relevant. I also trust the palliative care team once I can get to them.

Not sure what you think we do in the NHS all day long. I do know the outcome can be profoundly shit but that isn't the aim nor in fact always the staff's fault. I have these discussions most days and I know the difference between cases where the patient has made their wishes clear and the ones that haven't ever got around to writing it down.

Prism7 · 22/11/2022 05:57

'I have no idea how childless people manage'?! Really?! That's a little shortsighted and offensive. Some of us have had no choice but to live our lives without children for various reasons, and before the "why are you on Mumsnet' voices jump in - because I can, because I'm interested, because my partner, my friends, my siblings have kids, and I try to find ways to be more understanding and thoughtful with their parenting issues. Step in Mumsnet.
Without children, you manage just fine, you make arrangements for your own old age in advance, you ensure that your finances are in order at all times, you (in my case) silently grieve for something you never had, and hope that others around you are understanding. I'm assuming the op doesn't have any 'childless' friends, if you did, you should have ran this past them before posting.

onlythreenow · 22/11/2022 04:17

Why do people think being childfree is some new thing? There have always been women who don't have children - it's not so long ago that if it didn't happen naturally then it didn't happen at all, and not everyone adopted children. Somehow those people with no children managed in the past, I daresay they will manage in the future.

sashh · 22/11/2022 03:39

My dad lives in Lancashire, I'm in Wolverhampton, my brother is in Cornwall.

My dad is still fit and healthy and doesn't have a carer or even a cleaner he does send his ironing out to be done.

He has no expectation of us caring for him or arranging care.

LicoricePizza · 22/11/2022 02:58

How do you know they will be able to? They may not be in the same country, be able to themselves or things may change where they don’t for whatever reason want to. Don’t mean to be negative but nothing is a full fine conclusion. I’d make sure you plan for your own care with POA’s etc before assuming they’ll just step in.

TheWordHu88yIsMyPetHate · 22/11/2022 02:24

As soon as my health takes a nasty turn I'm off to Switzerland. I've no interest in being washed/fed etc.

ThirtyThreeTrees · 22/11/2022 02:13

With all the money I'll have saved on nappies, childcare, food, education, I'll be stinking rich of course

I will be well worth looking after for inheritance purposes. Might even be worth bumping off early!!

Your kids might even see looking after me as a more rewarding option!!!

What a shitty question to add to the numerous childfree bashing threads today.

Nagado · 22/11/2022 02:02

I do NOT expect my children to be my carers, but I expect my children to ARRANGE care and keep an eye on the quality of care and finances What will you do if they say no? What’s your plan B if they don’t want to because they’re too busy with their own families? Or because they’ve decided to concentrate on their career and simply don’t have time to hunt around for the best energy provider or make sure your carers aren’t dipping into your pension? I mean, if you’re putting all of your eggs into one basket and all of your expectations onto another person, and they’ve made their own plans, that’s going to be quite a bit of turmoil for you to deal with when you’re already starting to deteriorate. That would terrify me; aren’t you worrying about it?

MintJulia · 22/11/2022 01:58

My DM steadfastly refused any assistance at all, and resisted any interference until a week before she died.

I intend to do the same. She was perfectly happy living on her own and I hope I shall be the same. 😊

blueshoes · 22/11/2022 01:42

Dontaskdontget · 21/11/2022 23:03

Social services will not step in to stop your carers stealing from you.

Yeah yeah I know not all carers steal some are lovely.

Unfortunately I’ve only dealt with three (for different family members) and all of those three stole.

There is no guarantee that family members who are carers won't steal but the risk of an outsider carer stealing is much higher. I believe that some of these people are predators and look for old people who are losing their faculties with no close relatives who visit to prey on their assets. Even if they do not steal, you cannot trust their care either.

I have no answer.

rainydays365 · 22/11/2022 01:38

I don't know I think
About it all
The time

Aintgointogoa · 22/11/2022 01:38

@Yessha Power of attourney arrangements with solicitors, friends & siblings should my mind fail before my pension, savings, investments and retirement plans ensure I’m set til the end. Planning for live in care after downsizing.

Yes, this. I have already considerably downsized, now I am drawing my state pension. I have POA spread between friends/relatives and my son. I live in a different country and have no intention to return to UK. God forbid I would throw myself onto UK social services in, say, 15 years time ! My son is very grateful because he knows I am not leaving him (and his wife) with a huge burden to sort out, I have reduced my possessions to a bare minimum already. All the important (to me) stuff has been taken care of. Dying with dignity is not an option in this country, but there are means….plus live in care much cheaper and pretty much a fact of ‘life’ here. Forward planning is the way forward !