Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should MNHQ Keep the 'Similar Threads' feature?

134 replies

PiggyInTheLidl · 21/11/2022 18:22

IMO this 'You might also like' feature revives Zombie threads, causes Active Convos to be cluttered up with threads that are no longer relevant (The wedding was 6 months ago, hopefully she found a frock!) and generally makes MN feel like a dentists waiting room full of out of date magazines.

YANBU - The feature should go
YABU - It enhances my use of MN no end, how did we ever manage without it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
J0CASTA · 24/11/2022 22:22

Hawkins001 · 23/11/2022 20:35

I understand the perspectives, and points.
But using the search option you can already find a users posts and in the search results actually select which ones they started.

Yes but you have to know the users name.

Many poster change name very often to avoid being tracked by their partner / ex.

Hawkins001 · 23/11/2022 20:35

Howdoyoulikeyourtea · 23/11/2022 20:33

Just quoting this again so it doesn’t get missed by @MNHQ @JustineMumsnet

I understand the perspectives, and points.
But using the search option you can already find a users posts and in the search results actually select which ones they started.

Howdoyoulikeyourtea · 23/11/2022 20:33

barskits · 22/11/2022 11:34

I feel sorry for them too. Especially those whose abusive partners have installed spyware to monitor their emails, and who will now be able to see notifications of months-old resurrected threads which will give them the OP's MN username, so they can read all their threads on here. Like maybe one about them getting their ducks in a row and preparing to flee from their abuser for instance. The consequences of that are potentially horrific.

Just quoting this again so it doesn’t get missed by @MNHQ @JustineMumsnet

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 23/11/2022 15:02

Well, some good steps on the readers' side.

But there is still no "opt out" (or opt in) for contributors who didn't know that their long forgotten posts would be pushed at other readers months or even years after the fact.

And also a good way to manage "the right to be forgotten" for contributors from now on. Mitigation might be to offer a "30 days" option on all new posts or a "30 days after it all goes quiet" option on all new threads. Or a "keep out of the recommender" option, which could be ticked when you start a thread or post a message, or maybe retroactively if the person who started the thread or made the post has second thoughts?

ArcaneWireless · 23/11/2022 14:55

That is more like it errol

It would be a very accurate representation of how wanted it really was by the 33,000 users wouldn’t it?

I think it would be an excellent gauge of how useful folk find it and how wanted it really is.

All new loginners could be given the option when registering.

ErrolTheDragon · 23/11/2022 14:30

Yes, I think the ‘opt out’ features are ok, but:
Dont take account of the fact that new users arriving from Google will take ages to find them so will still blithely resurrect zombies…

Would be better if it was an opt in feature.

Blossomtoes · 23/11/2022 11:59

Thatboymum · 21/11/2022 18:33

It’s a no from me , they’d have been better putting an edit function in

This x 💯

PiggyInTheLidl · 23/11/2022 11:56

ArcaneWireless · 23/11/2022 11:39

There is now the option to hide similar threads and to not show anything older than 30 days in active.

Given that the threads I’m on can now be resurrected by an algorithm (relevant or not)forever more though, going forward I will probably now stick to 30 days only or the odd telly addicts where my posts don’t matter.

Yes, I think the ‘opt out’ features are ok, but:
Dont take account of the fact that new users arriving from Google will take ages to find them so will still blithely resurrect zombies…

Which leads to…

Notifications that old threads you are on will come in, which is a danger, as identified by a Pp, for those in abusive relationships.

OP posts:
ArcaneWireless · 23/11/2022 11:39

There is now the option to hide similar threads and to not show anything older than 30 days in active.

Given that the threads I’m on can now be resurrected by an algorithm (relevant or not)forever more though, going forward I will probably now stick to 30 days only or the odd telly addicts where my posts don’t matter.

Itwasntevenblackpudding · 23/11/2022 11:34

Update from the other thread:

YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet · Today 11:09
Hi everyone - thanks again for all your feedback. We're dropping in with a quick update.

The following changes have now been made and released:

the Similar Threads box is below the posting box for logged in users
only threads created within the last 30 days will appear in Trending

there are two new settings in Talk Settings - one to remove the Similar Threads box and a second to prevent threads more than 30 days old from appearing in Active.

We'll continue to monitor results and usage and improve things as we go along.

BIWI · 23/11/2022 10:40

Makes it very festive @Dinoteeth Grin

Dinoteeth · 23/11/2022 10:30

Don't know why I have those stars

Dinoteeth · 23/11/2022 10:30

Good point. But I say "no" until everyone whose old content has been re-used has first agreed to it being dredged up again and made public to a new readership, and until everyone who doesn't agree has been given the opportunity to remove or hide their content.
**
MN would argue If posters don't want old threads getting dragged up they should use the 30 / 90 day boards.
But I think old irrelevant threads should be deleted.
**
**
**
**
**
**
**
**

GrubzUp · 23/11/2022 09:40

It makes MN feel like a dentists waiting room full of out of date magazines.

^ THIS, exactly. Couldn't have said it better.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 23/11/2022 09:38

I say yes, but only if threads older than 6(4?) months are locked until the OP posts an update.

Good point. But I say "no" until everyone whose old content has been re-used has first agreed to it being dredged up again and made public to a new readership, and until everyone who doesn't agree has been given the opportunity to remove or hide their content.

Because this is creating a new set of site rules that the people who wrote all those old posts didn't know about or agree to.

BadNomad · 23/11/2022 01:42

I say yes, but only if threads older than 6(4?) months are locked until the OP posts an update.

ArcaneWireless · 23/11/2022 01:33

Iaccgmooh

One of the suggestions?

‘Nub guess’

I can only imagine it is because ‘we’ve seen a couple of cocks in there’

Useful? Possibly not.

Luredbyapomegranate · 23/11/2022 00:32

No, it’s truly terrible and just creates lots of zombie threads.

People know how to use the search function if they want find lots of threads on one subject

blacksax · 23/11/2022 00:20

We've all seen how the 'similar threads' algorhythm works now, haven't we?! The trouble with it is that it is too random, picks up some bizarre options, and doesn't show the date the threads were created either. Having it as an option might work, but only for certain topics.

ErrolTheDragon · 23/11/2022 00:03

Or maybe even make the search function work properly again?

That'd be good, but a 'similar threads' would be a different thing.

blacksax · 22/11/2022 23:58

ErrolTheDragon · 22/11/2022 23:16

In some ways it makes sense if people are looking for advice on certain issues, like potty training, bottles, special needs and health issues.

Maybe replace this unloved feature with a button to bring up a 'similar threads' list so you can get it if and when you want it.

Or maybe even make the search function work properly again?

ErrolTheDragon · 22/11/2022 23:16

In some ways it makes sense if people are looking for advice on certain issues, like potty training, bottles, special needs and health issues.

Maybe replace this unloved feature with a button to bring up a 'similar threads' list so you can get it if and when you want it.

PiggyInTheLidl · 22/11/2022 23:08

barskits · 22/11/2022 11:34

I feel sorry for them too. Especially those whose abusive partners have installed spyware to monitor their emails, and who will now be able to see notifications of months-old resurrected threads which will give them the OP's MN username, so they can read all their threads on here. Like maybe one about them getting their ducks in a row and preparing to flee from their abuser for instance. The consequences of that are potentially horrific.

Bloody hell! That is a serious issue.

OP posts:
Dinoteeth · 22/11/2022 14:25

Baring in mind it's started as a parenting forum, parents have similar issues, potty training, weaning, Christmas ideas, teens, sports ADHD, ASD etc
Some issues are recurring and it might be worthwhile having similar issues pop up esp if a poster has come back and said what worked or what didn't.

But I'd agree things like what is this rash are only relevant to a particular thread and to me those should be deleted. While a MN thread isn't taking up the same space on a server as a Netflix episode it's still a waste of space keeping it there.

Yamadori · 22/11/2022 11:41

Dinoteeth · 22/11/2022 07:32

In some ways it makes sense if people are looking for advice on certain issues, like potty training, bottles, special needs and health issues.

However old threads should be locked. Chat used to delete after 3 months. I do think it would make sense for some threads to be deleted after a set period of time.

A handful of things might be useful, but not many. For instance in Gardening, someone trying to kill off the dreaded Japanese knotweed might like to read more threads on the same topic. But if they have posted a photo asking for a plant ID, they aren't going to want to know about umpteen other 'plant ID' threads, because the chances of them asking about the same plant are nil.