Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask HOW he/they or she/they works?

258 replies

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:14

On a DE&I video call at work and the session panel did intros with pronouns stated - 2 of them said ‘I’m he/them’ and one said ‘she/they’. All panellist were trans identifying.

asking a practical question - if someone is he/ them, I’m fine just to to refer to him as he or him? As in ‘ let’s wait 2 mins to see if Josh is coming. He said he could make it’ or I’m I supposed to be saying them ??
the panel was all about trans day of remembrance or something like that so it didn’t feel appropriately to start asking them…

OP posts:
Oujiawoowoo · 21/11/2022 21:26

BeanieTeen · 21/11/2022 21:22

The short answer is that is doesn't OP because it's a un natural way of speaking and life really is too short.

I think unless English is not your first language there isn’t much to be confused about though. Aren’t people a bit embarrassed to get so confused over how their first and often only language works? It always surprises me how quick people are to admit their don’t understand how to substitute ‘they’ for ‘she’ in a sentence. It’s not hard…

Because it is expecting a very high level of cognitive dissonance in humans that have evolved over eons to recognise that there are two sexes. So if I am confronted with a man who wants to be known as “she/her” it is going to make for a very difficult interaction/conversation with that person going forward. You are asking people to expend their belief system and everything they know.

Or are you being wilfully obtuse pretending you don’t understand how it could be troublesome?

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 21:25

BeanieTeen · 21/11/2022 21:22

The short answer is that is doesn't OP because it's a un natural way of speaking and life really is too short.

I think unless English is not your first language there isn’t much to be confused about though. Aren’t people a bit embarrassed to get so confused over how their first and often only language works? It always surprises me how quick people are to admit their don’t understand how to substitute ‘they’ for ‘she’ in a sentence. It’s not hard…

It works like the stroop effect so it slows down understanding. But also, I have got genuinely confused when being unable to understand whether the 'they' is one person in the story or both of them. English is confusing enough without adding in extra confusion. My first, and indeed only, language is English so it's not a second language thing. Pretending this does not cause some confusion is helping no-one.

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 21:23

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 20:22

Not sure whether they’d include agender under the trans umbrella or if there is separate data for them. I have read the original study as I used it for my degree but I can’t for the life of me find it anywhere! Also agree re domestic violence figures - I suppose it depends how they recorded their data? If it was like a census then you’d be unlikely to include domestic violence if the perpetrator had access to that information? I’m not sure. I’m also nowhere near knowledgeable about this to debate it, but I see a lot on here suggesting that trans people live in some sort of utopia where they go around abusing women and dreaming of stripping away their rights, and are never victims in their own right. This was just to show that they are often victims of violence - whilst that may be nothing close to what biological females experience, it’s clear they are at risk of violence too.

Can I be clear re: cis people? It's a very small percentage of the population who define themselves as cis so this, if we take it at face value, suggests that they are comparing a small percentage of the population with another small percentage and have not looked at the bulk of the population. Or have they instead just misgendered a load of people? Sadly I expect the latter.

I've not heard talk about a Utopia. I have heard a reservation about using stats from Brazilian sex workers to justify trans people being highly at risk in the UK and anger at the dismissal and normalising of violence/ rape/ murder to women.

I personally would find it impossible to believe that some trans people are not at increased risk of violence. Some trans people wear clothes which traditionally were for the opposite sex and most trans identifying males are very clearly male bodied. Some people, largely men, don't tolerate that kind of 'gender bending' and assault people for such 'crimes'. But saying they are the most vulnerable is something which needs robust and area specific data to justify as otherwise it detracts from other's vulnerabilities including, I believe, women.

BeanieTeen · 21/11/2022 21:22

The short answer is that is doesn't OP because it's a un natural way of speaking and life really is too short.

I think unless English is not your first language there isn’t much to be confused about though. Aren’t people a bit embarrassed to get so confused over how their first and often only language works? It always surprises me how quick people are to admit their don’t understand how to substitute ‘they’ for ‘she’ in a sentence. It’s not hard…

Oujiawoowoo · 21/11/2022 21:22

Absolutely disgusted that MN are deleting posts from people who are simply stating a fact. I expressed astonishment that there is such a thing as “trans Remembrance Day” and it gets deleted? Why?
There are two sexes. Male and female. That is a biological fact. Will this be deleted too I wonder? If so, why?

Why is “trans” suddenly a sacred rite that isn’t allowed to be questioned?

Mumsnet - you should be ashamed of yourselves.

Isitsixoclockalready · 21/11/2022 21:20

Personally, I'd always try my best to interact with someone who is trans in a way that makes them comfortable; however in an already stressful and anxiety inducing modern society, I am not going to drive myself crazy running a gauntlet of alternating pronouns.

Cherryblossoms85 · 21/11/2022 21:11

Whatever.

BloodyHellKen · 21/11/2022 21:05

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:14

On a DE&I video call at work and the session panel did intros with pronouns stated - 2 of them said ‘I’m he/them’ and one said ‘she/they’. All panellist were trans identifying.

asking a practical question - if someone is he/ them, I’m fine just to to refer to him as he or him? As in ‘ let’s wait 2 mins to see if Josh is coming. He said he could make it’ or I’m I supposed to be saying them ??
the panel was all about trans day of remembrance or something like that so it didn’t feel appropriately to start asking them…

To ask HOW he/they or she/they works

The short answer is that is doesn't OP because it's a un natural way of speaking and life really is too short.

Just use their names instead.

Livingbyariver · 21/11/2022 21:03

Do also remember that if someone is a she/her or a he/him then they/them-ing the person can also be misgendering.

in the name of the wee man!

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 21:02

MagpiePi · 21/11/2022 20:47

@electricdreaming

yeah whatever.

Careful now, the GC mask is slipping and your homophobia is showing

Endwalker · 21/11/2022 20:51

MagpiePi · 21/11/2022 20:28

I am LGBT too

So you are a Lesbian Gay Bisexual Transvestite?

Make your mind up!

😂

The T doesn't stand for Transvestite, if you're going to be a bigot at least get your terms right.

MagpiePi · 21/11/2022 20:47

@electricdreaming

yeah whatever.

TheOriginalEmu · 21/11/2022 20:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Trans people have existed forever, you ignorant fuckwit.

TheOriginalEmu · 21/11/2022 20:37

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 20:31

Lots of people identify as LGBT. It’s an umbrella term. Being BAME doesn’t make you every other ethnicity bar white. Don’t be an ignorant prick. Makes you look stupid and bigoted.

👏👏 well said.

TheOriginalEmu · 21/11/2022 20:37

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:25

‘Use either as you see fit. Some people are very uncomfortable with using “they” for outdated grammatical reasons, or for gender critical reasons.’

ok. Seems almost pointless announcing it then. I would have takin either of the he’s to be anything other than he if they hadn’t have announced it.

the reason these kinds of panels etc ‘announce it’ is so everyone is the same. So a ciswoman who presents very femininely announces the same as a very androgynous looking gender fluid person.
Its about making it an inclusive thing to do.

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 20:31

MagpiePi · 21/11/2022 20:28

I am LGBT too

So you are a Lesbian Gay Bisexual Transvestite?

Make your mind up!

😂

Lots of people identify as LGBT. It’s an umbrella term. Being BAME doesn’t make you every other ethnicity bar white. Don’t be an ignorant prick. Makes you look stupid and bigoted.

PaleBlueMoonlight · 21/11/2022 20:30

Yes, to make sense of the study you would need to know how they were using the terms - who are they comparing with who and is it self declared. Also it would be instructive to know the stats broken down by sex so you could really understand what is going on.

MagpiePi · 21/11/2022 20:28

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:23

@Endwalker its not about ‘forgetting’ it’s about how to address when someone says that. If it was they/them I’d be fine.
I am LGBT too btw but none of my trans friends are anything but he/him or she/her

I am LGBT too

So you are a Lesbian Gay Bisexual Transvestite?

Make your mind up!

😂

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 20:22

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 20:14

Do they actually mean cis? What about agender people? I'm confused re what they're actually reporting. This must be excluding violence in the home is that right? Given how many women experience domestic violence? I guess it's hard to make sense of without seeing the whole study report. I wonder how this compares in the UK. Things are obviously very different in the US which is a hugely aggressive country. Interesting though.

Not sure whether they’d include agender under the trans umbrella or if there is separate data for them. I have read the original study as I used it for my degree but I can’t for the life of me find it anywhere! Also agree re domestic violence figures - I suppose it depends how they recorded their data? If it was like a census then you’d be unlikely to include domestic violence if the perpetrator had access to that information? I’m not sure. I’m also nowhere near knowledgeable about this to debate it, but I see a lot on here suggesting that trans people live in some sort of utopia where they go around abusing women and dreaming of stripping away their rights, and are never victims in their own right. This was just to show that they are often victims of violence - whilst that may be nothing close to what biological females experience, it’s clear they are at risk of violence too.

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 20:14

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 20:08

Researchers at the Williams Institute at the University of California, Los Angeles, School of Law
found that trans people are over four times more likely than cis people to experience violent crime, including rape, sexual assault, and aggravated or simple assault. They also found that trans people have higher rates of property victimization than cis people.

For the study, researchers looked at data from the 2017 and 2018 National Crime Victimization Survey, the first national and comprehensive survey to include respondents' gender identity and sex assigned at birth.

Trans people age 16 and up experience 86.2 victimizations per 1,000 people, compared to just 21.7 per 1,000 for cis people, according to the study. Transgender women experience violent crime at the rate of 86.1 per 1,000 people, and trans men experience it at a rate of 107.5 per 1,000. That means that over one in 10 trans men are the victims of a violent crime at some point in their life. Those numbers drop to 23.7 and 19.8 per 1,000 people for cis women and cis men, respectively.

No, as far as I can see from this particularly study, there’s no mention of hate crime specifically. It seems more focused on physical and sexual assault. I acknowledge that this is for the US, not the U.K., but we are similar societies and the data for the U.K. is much harder to find.

Do they actually mean cis? What about agender people? I'm confused re what they're actually reporting. This must be excluding violence in the home is that right? Given how many women experience domestic violence? I guess it's hard to make sense of without seeing the whole study report. I wonder how this compares in the UK. Things are obviously very different in the US which is a hugely aggressive country. Interesting though.

Beanbagtrap · 21/11/2022 20:13

Do also remember that if someone is a she/her or a he/him then they/them-ing the person can also be misgendering.

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 20:08

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 20:03

Do you know if that 'violence' includes hate crimes? Because I think the reporting of those is problematic given that hate crimes against women will not be accepted as an issue (e.g. people calling me cis or assuming I identify as a woman) but every time a woman doesn't roll over, this can be a hate crime to a trans person even when a reasonable person would not see it as such (I do accept the possibility of actual hate crimes towards trans people BTW).

Researchers at the Williams Institute at the University of California, Los Angeles, School of Law
found that trans people are over four times more likely than cis people to experience violent crime, including rape, sexual assault, and aggravated or simple assault. They also found that trans people have higher rates of property victimization than cis people.

For the study, researchers looked at data from the 2017 and 2018 National Crime Victimization Survey, the first national and comprehensive survey to include respondents' gender identity and sex assigned at birth.

Trans people age 16 and up experience 86.2 victimizations per 1,000 people, compared to just 21.7 per 1,000 for cis people, according to the study. Transgender women experience violent crime at the rate of 86.1 per 1,000 people, and trans men experience it at a rate of 107.5 per 1,000. That means that over one in 10 trans men are the victims of a violent crime at some point in their life. Those numbers drop to 23.7 and 19.8 per 1,000 people for cis women and cis men, respectively.

No, as far as I can see from this particularly study, there’s no mention of hate crime specifically. It seems more focused on physical and sexual assault. I acknowledge that this is for the US, not the U.K., but we are similar societies and the data for the U.K. is much harder to find.

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 20:03

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 19:58

No - I mean that, for example, for every 10,000 people in the U.K. who aren’t trans, 1,000 of them are victims of violent crime, compared to every 10,000 people in the U.K. who are trans, 1,001 of them are victims of violent crime. Obviously with the actual data. I’m not comparing trans people v women, I’m comparing trans people v non trans people.

Do you know if that 'violence' includes hate crimes? Because I think the reporting of those is problematic given that hate crimes against women will not be accepted as an issue (e.g. people calling me cis or assuming I identify as a woman) but every time a woman doesn't roll over, this can be a hate crime to a trans person even when a reasonable person would not see it as such (I do accept the possibility of actual hate crimes towards trans people BTW).

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 19:58

waterlego · 21/11/2022 19:47

So who is the ‘average person’ then?

You mean men?

No - I mean that, for example, for every 10,000 people in the U.K. who aren’t trans, 1,000 of them are victims of violent crime, compared to every 10,000 people in the U.K. who are trans, 1,001 of them are victims of violent crime. Obviously with the actual data. I’m not comparing trans people v women, I’m comparing trans people v non trans people.

waterlego · 21/11/2022 19:47

electricdreaming · 21/11/2022 18:43

I never said they were more likely than females to be at risk - I provided evidence that showed that trans people were more likely than the average person to be at risk of violence. The majority of violence against women is also probably underreported, which skews the figures there too. We don’t need a race to the bottom.

So who is the ‘average person’ then?

You mean men?

Swipe left for the next trending thread