Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask HOW he/they or she/they works?

258 replies

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:14

On a DE&I video call at work and the session panel did intros with pronouns stated - 2 of them said ‘I’m he/them’ and one said ‘she/they’. All panellist were trans identifying.

asking a practical question - if someone is he/ them, I’m fine just to to refer to him as he or him? As in ‘ let’s wait 2 mins to see if Josh is coming. He said he could make it’ or I’m I supposed to be saying them ??
the panel was all about trans day of remembrance or something like that so it didn’t feel appropriately to start asking them…

OP posts:
Lancrelady80 · 22/11/2022 02:06

Yes, still polite and respectful but doesn't insist on screwing up language and grammar.

mackthepony · 22/11/2022 02:00

Just call him Jim or Bob or whatever

Lancrelady80 · 22/11/2022 01:58

outdated grammatical reasons,

it's not grammar, it's definition. "Their" = plural. "Susan went to fetch their coat" is as wrong as "the cat barked." People who insist on appropriating specific pronouns for themselves are mangling our language and confusing a hell of a lot of people by forcing a change in meaning.

We have to teach pronouns at KS1, so age 5 and upwards.How do we teach our children pronouns for a world where a vocal minority no longer use them in the way they are intended, and insist on the rest of us following?

So would people like us to continue to knowingly teach "wrong" and "outdated" pronouns, throw in trans education at age 5 to explain why it's not the case some of the time, or simply ditch almost all pronouns altogether and use they/their in all contexts? (We don't have a choice, the curriculum states we have to teach to this "outdated" grammar.)

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 00:35

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 00:24

I didn't assume that everyone is cis, I merely used that as an example. Trans is commonly used as an umbrella term, you're right, but not everyone who identifies for example as non-binary will identify as transgender. That's why I personally feel it's usually safest to go along with requested preferred pronouns and not make assumptions until you know the person better and they give you more info about themselves.

I'm a bit baffled as to what assumptions you'd think I was making? I think this just points to the need for a proper clear system of definitions. If you think stonewall have got it wrong in saying that everyone except that small percentage of cis people are trans then fair enough but they are the ones setting themselves up as the experts. Any system which says the vast majority of the population are trans seems a bit off to me.

Personally I do think it's a bit bonkers as it means my male and male looking oh and myself who looks and is female are both trans and therefore considered more vulnerable than cis people. In the olden days, as it were, we looked like a middle aged heterosexual couple. I.e. some of the leadt vulnerable. It's confusing

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 00:29

Womens dv hostels are female only protected spaces and rightly so

I don't think so. Trans identifying males are now allowed in. So they're mixed sex spaces. Clearly there should be spaces for trans people. But that doesnt justify making spaces mixed.

As a female, such moved disenfranchise me. Its a whole other issue butbi am struggling with menopause. I looked for a support group but they are for 'anyone who identifies as a woman". Well I don't and neither do I want to go to a support group and discuss an experience which a male can never have with them. When I hear people lay claim to female pronouns, I am reminded thatbthere are no such spaces for me anymore. Its actually pretty traumatising.

Anyway, back to my wish that we have proper gender neutral pronouns. They could be used both by progressive feminists and people who align themselveswith old fashioned stereotypes and we'd have a point of commonality!

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 00:24

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 00:15

You do know that most people don't identify as anything, right? Please don't assume people are cis.

The others I thought all fell under the trans umbrella but I just got that from stonewall. My understanding of what they said was that anyone whose gender does not match their birth sex is trans. So all these people you mention here. Hence my surprise!

I didn't assume that everyone is cis, I merely used that as an example. Trans is commonly used as an umbrella term, you're right, but not everyone who identifies for example as non-binary will identify as transgender. That's why I personally feel it's usually safest to go along with requested preferred pronouns and not make assumptions until you know the person better and they give you more info about themselves.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 00:20

I couldn't be bothered to talk to any one who wants me to juggle language to appease their sense of self importance .

Basically this

I don't identify as cis either. I have no 'gender identity' in any meaningful way

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 00:15

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 00:04

Because not everyone who doesn't identify as cis identifies as transgender... some people identify as a-gender/gender fluid/non-binary etc some people will also use they/them because they feel they are still on a journey of figuring out exactly where they sit with themselves and havent quite found the right wording yet and that's OK too.

You do know that most people don't identify as anything, right? Please don't assume people are cis.

The others I thought all fell under the trans umbrella but I just got that from stonewall. My understanding of what they said was that anyone whose gender does not match their birth sex is trans. So all these people you mention here. Hence my surprise!

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 00:04

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 23:55

There are lots of reasons why people may identify as they/ them without identifying as transgender.

I'm genuinely surprised to hear this. What would those reasons be?

Because not everyone who doesn't identify as cis identifies as transgender... some people identify as a-gender/gender fluid/non-binary etc some people will also use they/them because they feel they are still on a journey of figuring out exactly where they sit with themselves and havent quite found the right wording yet and that's OK too.

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 00:01

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 23:52

I'm sure these barriers are true but keys not pretend there are not barriers foe others. There are now no dedicated female spaces which many women experience as a significant barriers and is a move away from equality. Moreover the stepping on women's boundaries gives a clear negative message a out women's value and how little they will be protected. Lack of police response, lack of neighbours willing to intervene - these affect women too of course? I would support trans support services and its a shame the TRA are not lobbying for more such services.

Of course there are which is why I said it's extremely difficult for any woman accessing dv support. Womens dv hostels are female only protected spaces and rightly so. The tw or tm equivalent doesn't exist meaning there is no safe his available to anyone identifying in this way. Lack of police response has been notably improved over the last few years with most areas now having a specialist dv team and delegates from dv specialist charities working within the police to promote good practice and more efficient support for women experiencing dv. There is no lgbt equivalent of this work happening yet within policing so yes that makes it harder. Most dv incidents are reported to police by neighbours and what is then reported to community bodies is very different so yes it's not a massive jump to conclude that neighbours are less willing to report dv in same sex or trans relationships also due to the stigmas and stereotypes joe public associate with lgbt relationships. Again I think it feels like a race to the bottom to argue these issues. The vast majority of reputable dv charities want to see dv stamped out in all forms so they'll acknowledge that there are barriers lgbtqa+ people will face that non-lgbtqa+ women won't face. Similarly to recognition that there are barriers that bame women face that white women will not.

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 23:55

There are lots of reasons why people may identify as they/ them without identifying as transgender.

I'm genuinely surprised to hear this. What would those reasons be?

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 23:52

Cw112 · 21/11/2022 23:42

As someone who worked with dv for many years this is a nonsense. Tw tm and in general members of the lgbtqa+ community are less likely to report domestic violence for a wide range of reasons including but not limited to: heternormative language used in awareness campaigns and by providers, inadequate responses in policing etc, lack of neighbours willing to intervene and report on a victims behalf, lack of available safe houses for tw or tm, fear of further stigma and stereotypes, lack of support networks from prior family breakdown upon 'coming out' and therefore feeling more dependent on the abusive partner etc etc etc. So I'll call bs on this from a professional standpoint any day of the week. It's extremely difficult for any woman accessing support for dv, it's even harder when that woman has another barrier such as gender/sexuality/language/race/disability to contend with and this is reflected in what workers see on the ground and why its essential staff working in dv are trained in inclusive practice which the vast majority of women's dv charities will promote because they recognise these gaps in service.

I'm sure these barriers are true but keys not pretend there are not barriers foe others. There are now no dedicated female spaces which many women experience as a significant barriers and is a move away from equality. Moreover the stepping on women's boundaries gives a clear negative message a out women's value and how little they will be protected. Lack of police response, lack of neighbours willing to intervene - these affect women too of course? I would support trans support services and its a shame the TRA are not lobbying for more such services.

Cw112 · 21/11/2022 23:52

VestaTilley · 21/11/2022 23:43

The whole thing is nonsense, and I don’t go along with it.

And Trans Day of Remembrance? Please. Three women a WEEK are killed in Britain at the hands of violent men. No single trans person has been killed in the U.K. since 2019.

Trans people are massively more likely to die due to suicide so trans day of remembrance is to encompass that moreso than murder specifically.

Cw112 · 21/11/2022 23:50

VestaTilley · 21/11/2022 23:43

The whole thing is nonsense, and I don’t go along with it.

And Trans Day of Remembrance? Please. Three women a WEEK are killed in Britain at the hands of violent men. No single trans person has been killed in the U.K. since 2019.

The thing that gets me about this is everyone is so quick to jump on the bandwagon with these posts re: Tw vs womens rights. There are lots of reasons why people may identify as they/ them without identifying as transgender. So if you're derailing a thread purely to point out your issues with trans people then at least acknowledge what you're doing (derailing so you can incite a pile on) and that you have a serious issue with a monitory group of people because that's not what the op initially asked about at all.

Op as far as I'm aware if someone gives you he/ they or she/they as pronouns then it's fine to use either they've provided you with. I tend to use they/ them most often when working with people who give me those options. It's ok to make mistakes as long as you are genuinely trying to get it right just correct yourself and move on.

Spiderboy · 21/11/2022 23:50

potniatheron · 21/11/2022 17:22

As I understand it, you should use the pornouns interchangeably, but make an effort to use the first preferred pronoun more than the second.

So, if a person goes by she/they, you should try to use say 60% she and 40% they.

Whereas if their preffered pronouns were they/he, you should use 60% they and 40% he.

It might be quite challenging for anyone who is neurodiverse, has a brain injury, a speech impediment, or for someone who's first language is not English.

Is your last paragraph for real?

VestaTilley · 21/11/2022 23:43

The whole thing is nonsense, and I don’t go along with it.

And Trans Day of Remembrance? Please. Three women a WEEK are killed in Britain at the hands of violent men. No single trans person has been killed in the U.K. since 2019.

Cw112 · 21/11/2022 23:42

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 18:53

Re these stats. I wonder if TW are more likely to report domestic violence? In many families, including my own, it's just been a fact of life. When you're brought up as the less valuable other then you can come not to notice how you're being treated badly. Indeed the TWAW movement depends on women accepting their status as givers and not demanders or takers which shows just how entrenched that way of looking at things is.

Some, but not all of course, TW delight in having, or believing themselves to have, experiences which women have. They convince themselves that despite being male bodied they have periods, they WANT to be able to have an abortion, they want to be sexually harassed. It's not a stretch to think that they are much more likely to report domestic abuse than women.

In terms of pronouns, I believe we need actually sex-neutral pronouns. It is ridiculous to expect people to remember each person's individuals requirements. Many people can't remember people's names and yet there is no examining of this requirement. They does not work because it destroys all rules of grammar and renders text incomprehensible.

As someone who worked with dv for many years this is a nonsense. Tw tm and in general members of the lgbtqa+ community are less likely to report domestic violence for a wide range of reasons including but not limited to: heternormative language used in awareness campaigns and by providers, inadequate responses in policing etc, lack of neighbours willing to intervene and report on a victims behalf, lack of available safe houses for tw or tm, fear of further stigma and stereotypes, lack of support networks from prior family breakdown upon 'coming out' and therefore feeling more dependent on the abusive partner etc etc etc. So I'll call bs on this from a professional standpoint any day of the week. It's extremely difficult for any woman accessing support for dv, it's even harder when that woman has another barrier such as gender/sexuality/language/race/disability to contend with and this is reflected in what workers see on the ground and why its essential staff working in dv are trained in inclusive practice which the vast majority of women's dv charities will promote because they recognise these gaps in service.

tricervixtops · 21/11/2022 22:07

Petition: Update the Equality Act to make clear the characteristic “sex” is biological sex www.mumsnet.com/Talk/petitions_noticeboard/4668426-petition-update-the-equality-act-to-make-clear-the-characteristic-sex-is-biological-sex?msgid=-4668426#-4668426

AlisonDonut · 21/11/2022 22:05

Loving that there are percentages involved in the she/they ratio these days, at least we can all keep track on our phones. There must be an app for that by now, right?

BloodyHellKen · 21/11/2022 22:00

BeanieTeen · 21/11/2022 21:22

The short answer is that is doesn't OP because it's a un natural way of speaking and life really is too short.

I think unless English is not your first language there isn’t much to be confused about though. Aren’t people a bit embarrassed to get so confused over how their first and often only language works? It always surprises me how quick people are to admit their don’t understand how to substitute ‘they’ for ‘she’ in a sentence. It’s not hard…

@BeanieTeen I didn't say it was confusing, I said it wasn't a natural way to speak because it isn't. Using someone's name is simpler and there is no risk of causing offence. Obviously the pronoun person doesn't get to feel as special but I can live with that.

howmanybicycles · 21/11/2022 21:57

tilder · 21/11/2022 21:46

All panellist were trans identifying

Doesn't sound like a very diverse panel.

Gosh yes, hadn't noticed that! Where are the biological women on this panel? A highly oppressed group who should be on EDI panels! I do hope someone just was off sick at the last minute otherwise that is a shameful reflection on the organisers.

tilder · 21/11/2022 21:46

All panellist were trans identifying

Doesn't sound like a very diverse panel.

SpudleyLass · 21/11/2022 21:39

From me, they will have the pronouns according to their sex.

Wrinklydinkly · 21/11/2022 21:32

I couldn't be bothered to talk to any one who wants me to juggle language to appease their sense of self importance .

ofwarren · 21/11/2022 21:32

BeanieTeen · 21/11/2022 21:22

The short answer is that is doesn't OP because it's a un natural way of speaking and life really is too short.

I think unless English is not your first language there isn’t much to be confused about though. Aren’t people a bit embarrassed to get so confused over how their first and often only language works? It always surprises me how quick people are to admit their don’t understand how to substitute ‘they’ for ‘she’ in a sentence. It’s not hard…

English is my first language and trust me, as an autistic woman I dread having to deal with this issue.
I misgender by accident already, to people who use sex based pronouns. I get mixed up with he and she when talking. I know what they are but my mouth doesn't say the words. My brain seems to default to he.

Swipe left for the next trending thread