Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask HOW he/they or she/they works?

258 replies

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:14

On a DE&I video call at work and the session panel did intros with pronouns stated - 2 of them said ‘I’m he/them’ and one said ‘she/they’. All panellist were trans identifying.

asking a practical question - if someone is he/ them, I’m fine just to to refer to him as he or him? As in ‘ let’s wait 2 mins to see if Josh is coming. He said he could make it’ or I’m I supposed to be saying them ??
the panel was all about trans day of remembrance or something like that so it didn’t feel appropriately to start asking them…

OP posts:
Orangepolentacake · 22/11/2022 10:25

Beanbagtrap · 21/11/2022 20:13

Do also remember that if someone is a she/her or a he/him then they/them-ing the person can also be misgendering.

This is why I no longer leave the house unless I absolutely have to

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 10:15

And why are trans rights never required to be intersectional? 🤔

BloodyHellKen · 22/11/2022 10:13

This is why feminism must be intersectional if its to benefit all women imo.

Why stop at feminism? How about intersectional healthcare for people who identify as (furry) animals? It's a lot easier to get an appointment at the vets than the GPs and they are always very keen to refer you too a specialist as well.

Intersectional education for all those people who identify as school children anyone?

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 10:09

This is why feminism must be intersectional if its to benefit all women imo.

Okay just answer me this. How does intersectional feminism benefit vulnerable women who need single sex spaces for their safety and dignity?

Abuse/rape victims for example looking for refuges and therapy? Disabled/ill women who want female only personal care? Women prisoners?

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 10:09

I mean TW get into female shelters just as they get into female prisons, sports and other places. This may not happen in all but that is the direction of travel which men's rights activists are aggressively (literally) campaigning for. If you think the trans umbrella is too wide I think you need to take it up with Stonewall, not me!

This is why feminism must be intersectional if its to benefit all women imo.

I'm confused by this - TW are not women. Feminism, whether intersectional or not, can't include them. They're males and always will be. If they are 'women' then most people we formerly called women aren't because there are no points of similarity.

BloodyHellKen · 22/11/2022 10:05

Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 09:59

Anyway - I think the question has been answers for me. Those using He/they or she/they are happy to be addressed by either so I’ll do what I do with non-binary identifying people - use he for men, she for women and they sometimes as I would for someone who hasn’t got pronouns announced.

I think if you use 'they' for people who don't have pronouns announced which is 99.9% of people you will sound like a (really hard to understand) lunatic 😂

Most people don't care about pronouns OP!!!

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 10:04

knittingaddict · 22/11/2022 03:03

If you work in this field then I'm sure you are also aware that many, many women also don't report DA?

@knittingaddict yes... which I addressed and acknowledged in the post you quoted. Doesn't mean that some people dont face additional barriers than others however? This is why feminism must be intersectional if its to benefit all women imo.

@AlisonDonut it's certainly what I see on the ground as a community worker on the daily. "They say that because they are told to say it to strong arm medics into referring them for treatment" who is telling people to say that? Where are you getting that info from? Because in all the time I've worked with trans people I've never seen them be told to lie to medical professionals- infact exactly the opposite. I have seen them actively attempt to end their lives though and be recommended to attend counselling which is the correct advice. Recognising that isn't manipulating anything or anyone its just recognising what I at least witness on the ground as do many of my colleagues in similar roles which is why we get extensive training in this area.

@howmanybicycles "I'm a bit baffled as to what assumptions you'd think I was making?" I just meant the assumption that anyone who you are describing that would fall under the umbrella term of trans is happy to be referred to as trans because this isn't always the case. Usually due to the stigmas attached to being trans and the associations that individual might attach to it. That wasn't directly aimed at you, moreso the general language used at points during this thread, my apologies if that wasn't clear. In terms of your point re: dv shelters do you mean transmales who were originally natal women are allowed in? Or are you meaning transwomen? Where I am in the UK I know for fact all women's hostels are 100% female only dv specialising or homeless specialising. Tw are turned out of day centers with all the men and expected to go to men's shelters so the majority sleep rough as they feel that would be safer for them. It leaves tm with the difficulty of knowing where to go, either a women's shelter which may be safer for them but this causes issues in itself around gender dysphoria and how comfortable the women there feel depending on how 'male' someone looks visually. Therefore adding another barrier to tm accessing anything.

BloodyHellKen · 22/11/2022 10:02

Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 09:57

For those asking, I do use names but it’s really awkward and odd to carry an entire convo using someone’s name the whole time.I have a manager that I do this with but a convo using someone’s name can get really fucking stupid very quickly.

‘Mary wondered if we should go with the blue because she thinks that the client will like it. In her experience they like those cooler shades better, so I’ll go back to her now and let her know we were all thinking green might be a good compromise.’

’Mary wondered if we should go with the blue, Mary thinks the client will like it because in Mary’s experience the client likes those cooler shades better. I’ll go back to Mary now and let Mary know we were all thinking green might be a good compromise.’

I agree @Henuinequest but it's no more or less awkward that referring to a man as 'she' or a woman as 'he' or either of them as a singular 'they'.

Also by using names there is the added bonus that no one can complain about being misgendered so as far as I can see it's a win win situation 😀

Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 09:59

Anyway - I think the question has been answers for me. Those using He/they or she/they are happy to be addressed by either so I’ll do what I do with non-binary identifying people - use he for men, she for women and they sometimes as I would for someone who hasn’t got pronouns announced.

OP posts:
Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 09:57

For those asking, I do use names but it’s really awkward and odd to carry an entire convo using someone’s name the whole time.I have a manager that I do this with but a convo using someone’s name can get really fucking stupid very quickly.

‘Mary wondered if we should go with the blue because she thinks that the client will like it. In her experience they like those cooler shades better, so I’ll go back to her now and let her know we were all thinking green might be a good compromise.’

’Mary wondered if we should go with the blue, Mary thinks the client will like it because in Mary’s experience the client likes those cooler shades better. I’ll go back to Mary now and let Mary know we were all thinking green might be a good compromise.’

OP posts:
ChateauMargaux · 22/11/2022 09:43

@BeanieTeen You said: 'Aren’t people a bit embarrassed to get so confused over how their first and often only language works? It always surprises me how quick people are to admit they don’t understand how to substitute ‘they’ for ‘she’ in a sentence.'

People get grammatical structures wrong all the time - in fact there are several structures that are frequently applied incorrectly. It is OK to ask how they should be used.

In this case - for most of the last 100 years, the literary and common usage of the male and female pronouns - he / she / they for subject pronouns and him / her / them for object pronouns and his / her's / their's for possessive pronouns applied to singular male / singular female and plural subjects, where male / female referred to the distinction between the sex classes, between those which are is on the developmental pathway to being capable of producing small gamets (males) and that which is on the developmental pathway to producing large gamets (females).

Recently - and it is very recently, there is a movement towards using the words male and female, the words man and woman and their associated pronouns to mean identifying with a set of gender based stereotypes, or a set of internally defined feelings that a person associates with one or other of the words previously used to define the sex classes, male / female and their associated nouns man / woman and to introduce a third concept of non binary humans that identify as neither.

We have become accustomed to seeing he/him, she/her and they/them as shorthand to help us identify people who wish to have these specific pronouns used when referring to them, especially where the previously held conventions do not apply, or in solidarity to those who feel that the conventionally applied pronouns do not apply to them.

The use of he/they and she/they, deviates from this new convention as it proposes two alternatives for the subject pronouns rather than proposing subject and object pronouns but does not define the circumstances under which one should apply he rather than they and likewise she rather than they.

Much of how we use language comes from observing the behaviour of others and from reading, watching and listening to narratives and this use of language becomes reflexive if not entirely instinctive, so we have learned to use he / she / them in the situations where we have seen, heard or read their use the past. To over ride these reflexes / instincts (I use that word cautiously as it see it more reflexive than instinctive) we need to consciously relearn how to apply the rules in new situations and on an individual basis, similar to the way we learn the names of new people when we meet them, however, now we need to learn additional pieces of information for some people and apply our reflexive learned responses to others.

This is similar to how adults learn second and subsequent languages compared to how children acquire language. Typical adult language learning uses a translation of our existing words to the new language whereas typical childhood language acquisition assigns a word in the language to the object, subject, concept that is being learnt.

You might be embarrassed to ask.. but it is better to ask than to continue in confusion.

potniatheron · 22/11/2022 09:42

ofwarren · 22/11/2022 02:24

Why would it not be for real?
I'm autistic and struggle immensely with this.

I come from an immigrant family whose first language is gendered and inflected. the members of my family whose English is not great, struggle already with English pronouns and with using them correctly. They would struggle even more if they were asked to use them incorrectly.

I also have a relative who suffered a traumatic brain injury 15 years ago that left them with partial aphasia and they struggle with particles, pronouns and tenses. They would find it very difficult to communicate if asked to remember incorrect or changing pronouns, or ones that do not make syntactical sense.

This is why I am confident that inability to use preffered pronouns will never become punishable in law, because it would be clearly against the various laws preventing discrimination against non native speakers and the disabled.

potniatheron · 22/11/2022 09:38

Spiderboy · 21/11/2022 23:50

Is your last paragraph for real?

If you mean, do I mean what I say in my last paragraph, then yes, of course.

BloodyHellKen · 22/11/2022 09:05

Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 07:53

‘Just call him Jim or Bob or whatever’

inahve done this with some they/ thems as I trip over that one a lot but in this instance I was hoping someone who was he/ they could just be called ‘he’.

Why, why were you hoping they could just be called 'he'? OP I don't understand why you are naval gazing about this non-issue.

Just call people by their name.

BTW just because it's TR Day doesn't mean the panel should be all trans because that is not diverse is it?

Out of interest where do you work OP because it sounds really like a really hard-work environment 😂

BloodyHellKen · 22/11/2022 08:56

BeanieTeen · 22/11/2022 07:35

it's not grammar, it's definition. "Their" = plural. "Susan went to fetch their coat" is as wrong as "the cat barked."

Well a few years ago people didn’t tweet either - times change. Language evolves - it’s very naive and foolish to think language is set in stone and can’t or shouldn’t change. Especially definitions. That’s the most basic part of language evolving. Grammar is actually harder to change. But also not set in stone.

Tweeting has not changed the language and only a tiny percentage of people use Twitter so suggesting that using pronouns is the modern way is just not played out in reality.

Obviously language isn't set in stone new words or meanings of words change all the time however in order to do that they have to be common parlance. Using mangled pronouns is not common parlance. The number of people who are pronouners must be miniscule compared to the population of the UK as a whole - unless you are in an echo chamber. I work in an arty field and I've come across 2 people who use pronouns in their email footers. 2 people in the 12 years I've done this job. One of my daughters friends decided she was a non-binary they/them but gave up after a bit as it was such a massive hassle because most people don't get it and so don't do it.

People have more important things to think about than pronouns.

As I and many others have already commented just use peoples names instead. that way every pronoun is catered for, no one can claim offense and it's already part of the language.

AlisonDonut · 22/11/2022 08:22

Cw112 · 21/11/2022 23:52

Trans people are massively more likely to die due to suicide so trans day of remembrance is to encompass that moreso than murder specifically.

Nope. Not true.

They say that because they are told to say it to strong arm medics into referring them for treatment. The study that 'proved' this stat was debunked years ago.

Suicide stats should never be used to manipulate people. The Samaritans are quite clear on that. Shame on you.

ClaryFairchild · 22/11/2022 08:15

I can barely remember peoples' names, how the fuck am I supposed to remember pronouns as well??!! Everyone can be they/them now as far as I'm concerned.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 08:00

the speed this thread went echo chamber is quite scary

challenge it then

cimena · 22/11/2022 07:53

the speed this thread went echo chamber is quite scary

Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 07:53

‘Just call him Jim or Bob or whatever’

inahve done this with some they/ thems as I trip over that one a lot but in this instance I was hoping someone who was he/ they could just be called ‘he’.

OP posts:
Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 07:52

‘All panellist were trans identifying

Doesn't sound like a very diverse panel.’

it was specific to trans Remembrance Day. There was one a while back just with no people for bi visibility.

OP posts:
BeanieTeen · 22/11/2022 07:35

it's not grammar, it's definition. "Their" = plural. "Susan went to fetch their coat" is as wrong as "the cat barked."

Well a few years ago people didn’t tweet either - times change. Language evolves - it’s very naive and foolish to think language is set in stone and can’t or shouldn’t change. Especially definitions. That’s the most basic part of language evolving. Grammar is actually harder to change. But also not set in stone.

Badgirlriri · 22/11/2022 03:08

the world’s gone mad.

knittingaddict · 22/11/2022 03:03

Cw112 · 21/11/2022 23:42

As someone who worked with dv for many years this is a nonsense. Tw tm and in general members of the lgbtqa+ community are less likely to report domestic violence for a wide range of reasons including but not limited to: heternormative language used in awareness campaigns and by providers, inadequate responses in policing etc, lack of neighbours willing to intervene and report on a victims behalf, lack of available safe houses for tw or tm, fear of further stigma and stereotypes, lack of support networks from prior family breakdown upon 'coming out' and therefore feeling more dependent on the abusive partner etc etc etc. So I'll call bs on this from a professional standpoint any day of the week. It's extremely difficult for any woman accessing support for dv, it's even harder when that woman has another barrier such as gender/sexuality/language/race/disability to contend with and this is reflected in what workers see on the ground and why its essential staff working in dv are trained in inclusive practice which the vast majority of women's dv charities will promote because they recognise these gaps in service.

If you work in this field then I'm sure you are also aware that many, many women also don't report DA?

ofwarren · 22/11/2022 02:24

Spiderboy · 21/11/2022 23:50

Is your last paragraph for real?

Why would it not be for real?
I'm autistic and struggle immensely with this.