Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask HOW he/they or she/they works?

258 replies

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:14

On a DE&I video call at work and the session panel did intros with pronouns stated - 2 of them said ‘I’m he/them’ and one said ‘she/they’. All panellist were trans identifying.

asking a practical question - if someone is he/ them, I’m fine just to to refer to him as he or him? As in ‘ let’s wait 2 mins to see if Josh is coming. He said he could make it’ or I’m I supposed to be saying them ??
the panel was all about trans day of remembrance or something like that so it didn’t feel appropriately to start asking them…

OP posts:
Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 12:17

Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 12:09

Wow, this opened a can of worms.

inwas actually hoping that some who uses those pronouns would come on to comment but I guess MNs probably not super popular with lGBTQ+ people in general

I'm really curious to know if my guess is right. Ie that "they" is preferred but he/she is acceptable if clarity is required. Doubt I'll ever get an answer here or anywhere else.

The topic is so loaded you can't ask anything anywhere.

AlisonDonut · 22/11/2022 12:12

@Cw112

it's certainly what I see on the ground as a community worker on the daily. "They say that because they are told to say it to strong arm medics into referring them for treatment" who is telling people to say that? Where are you getting that info from? Because in all the time I've worked with trans people I've never seen them be told to lie to medical professionals- infact exactly the opposite. I have seen them actively attempt to end their lives though and be recommended to attend counselling which is the correct advice. Recognising that isn't manipulating anything or anyone its just recognising what I at least witness on the ground as do many of my colleagues in similar roles which is why we get extensive training in this area.

Who trained you and what training did you receive?

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 12:12

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 11:59

As far as I'm concerned as a straight white female the only social group who really need to make room for me are men and that is again somewhat nuanced depending on the individual man (eg i wouldn't necessarily expect the same from a transmale as I would from another man.)

Please explain what a transmale is? A male is someone born with male biology. So a transmale is a transwoman yes? A transman is not and never can be male. So you want men to make room for you but not transwomen. Why not given that they retain male privilege?

I don't expect other women who are perhaps more marginalised than I am to make space for me- it's my responsibility to make more space for them so we can all benefit in the long run
Yes but this has nothing to do with the trans issue. I guess that the more marginalised than you women are people with disabilities, in poverty, refugees perhaps? Transwomen are not women so can never be 'other women'. If you continue to insist that they are then can you explain how you expect to protect the rights of the vast majority of females? Here you are centring just cis women (i.e. those small minority who identify as such) and transwoman. You are abandoning most females. Do you genuinely think it's OK to say to them that feminism has nothing to offer them because they don't identify as women? I would be appalled by such a stance.

So I perhaps should have said transmen rather than transmale then by your definition. As in someone born as a woman who identifies as male. However I can also accept that certain groups of men or transwomen will have different sets of challenges that I will not face. I don't accept that transwomen retain all forms of male privilege, some yes, but not all and in other ways I feel they are more persecuted than I personally feel. Eg. No stranger has ever tried to burn my house down with me inside just because I'm female as happened in my area recently. "If you continue to insist that they are then can you explain how you expect to protect the rights of the vast majority of females? " I think it's possible to accept that they are without denying that they may have different needs from other females and that other females may have different needs from transwomen. I don't think the two have to be completely exclusive and safe spaces are needed for both which is why I think more flexibility and accessibility is needed across the board so that the needs of all are taken into account and provided for.

Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 12:09

Wow, this opened a can of worms.

inwas actually hoping that some who uses those pronouns would come on to comment but I guess MNs probably not super popular with lGBTQ+ people in general

OP posts:
Changeyncchange · 22/11/2022 12:04

I think it would be to assist in talking about them after the panel.

People say that we use "they" as a singular all the time which is true but we only do it in specific circumstances. They as a pronoun becomes a nightmare to use when you are talking about a group.

Person A- I thought the panel were really good.

Person B-I didn't think what X [they/them] said about Y was good.

Person A-Yes but they rest of what they said was great.

Is person A talking about X or the panel? Having the option of he/she gives clarity.

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 11:59

As far as I'm concerned as a straight white female the only social group who really need to make room for me are men and that is again somewhat nuanced depending on the individual man (eg i wouldn't necessarily expect the same from a transmale as I would from another man.)

Please explain what a transmale is? A male is someone born with male biology. So a transmale is a transwoman yes? A transman is not and never can be male. So you want men to make room for you but not transwomen. Why not given that they retain male privilege?

I don't expect other women who are perhaps more marginalised than I am to make space for me- it's my responsibility to make more space for them so we can all benefit in the long run
Yes but this has nothing to do with the trans issue. I guess that the more marginalised than you women are people with disabilities, in poverty, refugees perhaps? Transwomen are not women so can never be 'other women'. If you continue to insist that they are then can you explain how you expect to protect the rights of the vast majority of females? Here you are centring just cis women (i.e. those small minority who identify as such) and transwoman. You are abandoning most females. Do you genuinely think it's OK to say to them that feminism has nothing to offer them because they don't identify as women? I would be appalled by such a stance.

potniatheron · 22/11/2022 11:34

Orangepolentacake · 22/11/2022 11:27

Language is a live organism, constantly changing to reflect the society, world and times which it currently is spoken in. Teaching needs to reflect that.
of course, we’ll next have JRM as education secretary as the tory musical chair runs out of options but that’s a different story

Language is a live organism, but it changes by implicit consent, organically. You cannot change it by compelling the speech of others.

Language evolved as a way to refer to and naviaget objective reality. Therefore you cannot force it to change to reflect a religion or ideology that not everyone shares.

Orangepolentacake · 22/11/2022 11:27

Lancrelady80 · 22/11/2022 01:58

outdated grammatical reasons,

it's not grammar, it's definition. "Their" = plural. "Susan went to fetch their coat" is as wrong as "the cat barked." People who insist on appropriating specific pronouns for themselves are mangling our language and confusing a hell of a lot of people by forcing a change in meaning.

We have to teach pronouns at KS1, so age 5 and upwards.How do we teach our children pronouns for a world where a vocal minority no longer use them in the way they are intended, and insist on the rest of us following?

So would people like us to continue to knowingly teach "wrong" and "outdated" pronouns, throw in trans education at age 5 to explain why it's not the case some of the time, or simply ditch almost all pronouns altogether and use they/their in all contexts? (We don't have a choice, the curriculum states we have to teach to this "outdated" grammar.)

Language is a live organism, constantly changing to reflect the society, world and times which it currently is spoken in. Teaching needs to reflect that.
of course, we’ll next have JRM as education secretary as the tory musical chair runs out of options but that’s a different story

BloodyHellKen · 22/11/2022 11:24

Aquivers · 22/11/2022 11:18

I'm a proud trans exclusionary radical feminist. I believe in science and biology and not gender woo woo. Hope that helps.

Count me in as well. TERF and proud of it😚

Oujiawoowoo · 22/11/2022 11:21

I'm a proud trans exclusionary radical feminist. I believe in science and biology and not gender woo woo. Hope that helps.

Then I think I must be one too - where do I sign up? 😂

Aquivers · 22/11/2022 11:18

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 11:14

You also need to know that you have just outed yourself as transphobic and a TERF.

Quite. Most of us go TERF at some point, it's about whether we acknowledge that fact or not.

I'm a proud trans exclusionary radical feminist. I believe in science and biology and not gender woo woo. Hope that helps.

potniatheron · 22/11/2022 11:18

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 10:15

And why are trans rights never required to be intersectional? 🤔

This is an important question. Trans rights are currently very dismissive of disabled people, neaurodiverse people, and non-English speakers. To the extent of being outright racist or ableist.

it would be nice is the trans rights movement could be less Anglocentric and Anlgosupremacist. The momvement really needs to confront this and do better if they are to be truly intersectional.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 11:16

One thing I don't understand is when we started pretending that pronouns refer to gender not sex? That's manifestly not the case, they're used from birth.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 11:14

You also need to know that you have just outed yourself as transphobic and a TERF.

Quite. Most of us go TERF at some point, it's about whether we acknowledge that fact or not.

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 11:11

ChateauMargaux · 22/11/2022 11:04

Please don't use 'they' for people who don't put their preferred pronouns.. follow the long established conventions of using the sex based pronouns unless otherwise indicated.

I do not wish to declare my pronouns as it puts me, as a female, at a disadvantage. I also do not identify with the gender stereotypes associated with non sex based stereotypes and therefore by declaring my pronouns in this way, I feel that I would be declaring that I do. I do not want to be referred to as 'they' but I do want you to follow the long established conventions. The default should be sex based pronouns, not gender based ones.

How would I distinguish which ones to use - the same as you always have done.

This. You will cause massive offence if you assume people align themselves with 50 year old culturally specific white-centric stereotypes.

ChateauMargaux · 22/11/2022 11:04

Henuinequest · 22/11/2022 09:59

Anyway - I think the question has been answers for me. Those using He/they or she/they are happy to be addressed by either so I’ll do what I do with non-binary identifying people - use he for men, she for women and they sometimes as I would for someone who hasn’t got pronouns announced.

Please don't use 'they' for people who don't put their preferred pronouns.. follow the long established conventions of using the sex based pronouns unless otherwise indicated.

I do not wish to declare my pronouns as it puts me, as a female, at a disadvantage. I also do not identify with the gender stereotypes associated with non sex based stereotypes and therefore by declaring my pronouns in this way, I feel that I would be declaring that I do. I do not want to be referred to as 'they' but I do want you to follow the long established conventions. The default should be sex based pronouns, not gender based ones.

How would I distinguish which ones to use - the same as you always have done.

BloodyHellKen · 22/11/2022 11:00

Pineapple41 · 22/11/2022 10:51

Does anyone in real life actually spend time worrying about which pronouns to use when the person in question isn’t even around?! I will treat every person I meet - regardless of sex or gender presentation - with respect unless I have good reason to do otherwise, but I draw the line at these emotionally draining mental gymnastics required by certain elements within this movement. And I’m certainly not teaching my kids to feel compelled to call a man “she” when he’s not even there, just because he wishes he was a member of the opposite sex.

Does anyone in real life actually spend time worrying about which pronouns to use when the person in question isn’t even around?!

In my experience no of course they don't they use the most obvious, easiest ones.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 10:57

If I'm picking you up right then I would say that's asking a minority group to make allowances for a much larger group

No it's asking what happens when two different 'minority' groups have needs/desires in opposition. Where is the TW concern for vulnerable abused women who need male free spaces for their safety and dignity?

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 10:57

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 10:47

Intersectional feminism goes wider than just including trans people it recognises that women may have different needs from those single sex spaces according to race/religion/disability etc as you say and which I stated earlier. And I do believe it can be done in a way that doesn't compromise womens only spaces such as having spaces that are more flexible and allow for everyone to exist without encroaching on each others needs. I recognise that some may feel differently and some may feel why should they bother to campaign for that. But I personally think it offers more benefit in the long run to have more varied spaces with protected components within those spaces. Eg having male/female/neutral bathrooms. I know some trans activists may disagree with that too but for me it's a reasonable middle ground and probably the best way to meet the majority of need.

You need to think about how decisions are made about the boundaries or these spaces. You also need to know that you have just outed yourself as transphobic and a TERF. Third spaces do not validate and you've just taken TWANW stance.

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 10:54

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 10:15

And why are trans rights never required to be intersectional? 🤔

Can you explain this a bit more I'm not sure I fully understand the question you're asking? If I'm picking you up right then I would say that's asking a minority group to make allowances for a much larger group. Similar to asking someone who's persecuted due to race to make allowances so white women can benefit too? As far as I'm concerned as a straight white female the only social group who really need to make room for me are men and that is again somewhat nuanced depending on the individual man (eg i wouldn't necessarily expect the same from a transmale as I would from another man.) I don't expect other women who are perhaps more marginalised than I am to make space for me- it's my responsibility to make more space for them so we can all benefit in the long run. I think the difficulty lies in that there's two marginalised groups that directly butt heads and I don't think the open and respectful dialogue is quite there yet to be able to reach a happy middle ground and allyship.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 10:54

And if a Transperson starts saying you are denying their dignity and safety by not allowing them access to women only prisons or refuges, what do you say to them then? How does that conversation go?

Pineapple41 · 22/11/2022 10:51

Does anyone in real life actually spend time worrying about which pronouns to use when the person in question isn’t even around?! I will treat every person I meet - regardless of sex or gender presentation - with respect unless I have good reason to do otherwise, but I draw the line at these emotionally draining mental gymnastics required by certain elements within this movement. And I’m certainly not teaching my kids to feel compelled to call a man “she” when he’s not even there, just because he wishes he was a member of the opposite sex.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 10:51

And I do believe it can be done in a way that doesn't compromise womens only spaces such as having spaces that are more flexible and allow for everyone to exist without encroaching on each others needs

But how does that work if men are asking to be recognised legally as women? If you think TWAW how do you keep them from women only spaces?

Aquivers · 22/11/2022 10:49

potniatheron · 21/11/2022 17:22

As I understand it, you should use the pornouns interchangeably, but make an effort to use the first preferred pronoun more than the second.

So, if a person goes by she/they, you should try to use say 60% she and 40% they.

Whereas if their preffered pronouns were they/he, you should use 60% they and 40% he.

It might be quite challenging for anyone who is neurodiverse, has a brain injury, a speech impediment, or for someone who's first language is not English.

FFS. So glad I don't work with any of these attention seekers.

Cw112 · 22/11/2022 10:47

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 10:09

This is why feminism must be intersectional if its to benefit all women imo.

Okay just answer me this. How does intersectional feminism benefit vulnerable women who need single sex spaces for their safety and dignity?

Abuse/rape victims for example looking for refuges and therapy? Disabled/ill women who want female only personal care? Women prisoners?

Intersectional feminism goes wider than just including trans people it recognises that women may have different needs from those single sex spaces according to race/religion/disability etc as you say and which I stated earlier. And I do believe it can be done in a way that doesn't compromise womens only spaces such as having spaces that are more flexible and allow for everyone to exist without encroaching on each others needs. I recognise that some may feel differently and some may feel why should they bother to campaign for that. But I personally think it offers more benefit in the long run to have more varied spaces with protected components within those spaces. Eg having male/female/neutral bathrooms. I know some trans activists may disagree with that too but for me it's a reasonable middle ground and probably the best way to meet the majority of need.

Swipe left for the next trending thread