Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask HOW he/they or she/they works?

258 replies

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:14

On a DE&I video call at work and the session panel did intros with pronouns stated - 2 of them said ‘I’m he/them’ and one said ‘she/they’. All panellist were trans identifying.

asking a practical question - if someone is he/ them, I’m fine just to to refer to him as he or him? As in ‘ let’s wait 2 mins to see if Josh is coming. He said he could make it’ or I’m I supposed to be saying them ??
the panel was all about trans day of remembrance or something like that so it didn’t feel appropriately to start asking them…

OP posts:
electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:42

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:34

There's nothing in that which can be reasonably taken to mean trans people as a whole. That's so far from showing trans hatred as to be laughable.

Come on, where is the evidence that trans people threaten to rape and murder women?

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:39

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:32

I think you've got a typo in there somewhere. I'm not accusing you of lieing. I just wondered if people had said you're not Bi because you only date men or something. There seems no other sensible reason to exclude you.

So I think where we've got to is straight is same sex attracted, L and G are opposite sex B is both and everything after that has nothing to do with the sex of the person you're attracted to and is used by people who want to tell you about their identity and the identity of the people they're attracted to instead. You've not shown any exceptions which make queen anything different from what L G B cover.

Some people would consider your conceding that straight is same sex attracted transphobic btw. It's dangerous close to TERF territory if not actually in it.

I’m currently in a relationship with a man, but my longest relationship was with a woman. The people in my current circle all knew me when I was in a relationship with a woman so I don’t know why they think I’m something other than bisexual. I’d say in general yes, straight is opposite sex attracted, and gay is same sex attracted, and bi is both. But I think a straight man dating a trans woman doesn’t make them gay - if a trans woman presents as a woman and appears to be a woman, then they are treated as such. My beliefs around trans people relies mostly on them “passing”, which I accept is problematic. If a trans woman is “post-op” and looks like a female, how does anyone looking to approach them romantically know they’re anything other than a female? I don’t really mind if anyone thinks I’m a TERF lol, I’m not necessarily a trans activist, nor would I class myself as a TERF, but for me what people choose to do with their lives is their business. I also don’t understand the subject enough to form an opinion, despite significant research. I don’t know what it feels like to be trans, so I don’t understand it.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 22:37

There's nothing in that which can be reasonably taken to mean trans people as a whole. That's so far from showing trans hatred as to be laughable.

Totally agree, but I'm sure the poster knows they're grasping at straws.

Anything else?

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:34

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:26

This was the quote:
Trans hatred? I don't see women screaming threats of rape, murder, spitting and shouting down transpeople, it's always the other way round. Right minded women just want their rights and safety upheld and not trampled on

Whether you take that to mean trans people as a whole are threatening rape and murder against women or not is subjective I suppose, but that’s how it read to me.

There's nothing in that which can be reasonably taken to mean trans people as a whole. That's so far from showing trans hatred as to be laughable.

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:32

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:19

Are you trying to suggest that I’m lying about being queer here? I can’t tell. I don’t know why they would exclude me - I can’t speak for other people. From the ones I’ve spoken to about this issue, they don’t think straight people are men or women and are some sort of abnormality, thus not fitting into the two sexes/genders/whatever you see it as, that bisexual people are attracted to. I don’t think it’s the same with queer because it’s used as more of an umbrella term so I can’t imagine a situation in which someone would say, you’re not queer cause queer means x y z and you’re not those things. It seems much more fluid with its definition of just “not straight” so that’s where I feel most comfortable. Without having the “well you’re not bisexual because that means x y and z”.

I think you've got a typo in there somewhere. I'm not accusing you of lieing. I just wondered if people had said you're not Bi because you only date men or something. There seems no other sensible reason to exclude you.

So I think where we've got to is straight is same sex attracted, L and G are opposite sex B is both and everything after that has nothing to do with the sex of the person you're attracted to and is used by people who want to tell you about their identity and the identity of the people they're attracted to instead. You've not shown any exceptions which make queen anything different from what L G B cover.

Some people would consider your conceding that straight is same sex attracted transphobic btw. It's dangerous close to TERF territory if not actually in it.

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:26

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:20

Do you mean they said all TW did that? Because if so that's unacceptable and you can report it. If they said that TW have the same offending patterns as other males and that some people will use or fake a trans identity to access women then that's born out by.research and is nothing like racism and homophobia

This was the quote:
Trans hatred? I don't see women screaming threats of rape, murder, spitting and shouting down transpeople, it's always the other way round. Right minded women just want their rights and safety upheld and not trampled on

Whether you take that to mean trans people as a whole are threatening rape and murder against women or not is subjective I suppose, but that’s how it read to me.

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:20

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:03

Someone accused trans people earlier in the thread as threatening to assault and rape women with no evidence. I’m not saying no trans person has ever acted in such a manner, but we can’t tar groups of people with the same brush like this. It’s a slippery slope into racism, homophobia, sexism etc.

Do you mean they said all TW did that? Because if so that's unacceptable and you can report it. If they said that TW have the same offending patterns as other males and that some people will use or fake a trans identity to access women then that's born out by.research and is nothing like racism and homophobia

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:19

AlisonDonut · 22/11/2022 22:16

You actually did both by asking if people have a DSD what does that make them?

You can't just invent new definitions and expect everyone to obey you because you have Butleresque sentence structures.

Someone else brought up DSD and I asked what they are if they’re not men or women. I didn’t bring them into the discussion.

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:19

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:09

Son where the confusion lies is your switch from sex to identity. The exceptions you quote are not exceptions at all. They are separate issues. Some straight people date trans people. Some do not. That is more an exception than some straight people dating Tories and some not. You don't have to date every single person of the opposite sex to be straight. Do some people not want you in the bi community because actually every person you fancy is a different sex from you? I.e. do they not have the gender faith and actually think you're straight? If that's not the reason, what does it matter what they think? If some people didn't want you in the queer community would you need a new category?

Are you trying to suggest that I’m lying about being queer here? I can’t tell. I don’t know why they would exclude me - I can’t speak for other people. From the ones I’ve spoken to about this issue, they don’t think straight people are men or women and are some sort of abnormality, thus not fitting into the two sexes/genders/whatever you see it as, that bisexual people are attracted to. I don’t think it’s the same with queer because it’s used as more of an umbrella term so I can’t imagine a situation in which someone would say, you’re not queer cause queer means x y z and you’re not those things. It seems much more fluid with its definition of just “not straight” so that’s where I feel most comfortable. Without having the “well you’re not bisexual because that means x y and z”.

scorpiogirly · 22/11/2022 22:18

Narcissism.

AlisonDonut · 22/11/2022 22:16

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 21:31

I didn’t.

You actually did both by asking if people have a DSD what does that make them?

You can't just invent new definitions and expect everyone to obey you because you have Butleresque sentence structures.

PriOn1 · 22/11/2022 22:15

If man and woman mean the same as male and female, why do we have two words to describe the same things?

There are words called nouns which are naming words. Man and woman are nouns.

There are words that modify nouns, when used with them. Male and female are adjectives. They are now sometimes used as nouns, but that use is a lot less frequent.

And as someone else pointed out upthread, male and female do not necessarily denote human beings.

I very much hope, OP, that the usage of they/them goes away as quickly as the attempts to wedge it in have risen up. It sounds ugly and causes confusion when talking about individuals within groups as it fast becomes impossible to tell which you’re talking about.

The descriptions in this thread, where you’re supposed to swap between he/she and they, or use them alternately are simply confusing and anyone expecting others to use them that way must be incredibly self-absorbed. I have enough problems remembering names, never mind which pronoun I used last and which I should use, if I’m not to use the appropriate one.

nilsmousehammer · 22/11/2022 22:14

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:03

Someone accused trans people earlier in the thread as threatening to assault and rape women with no evidence. I’m not saying no trans person has ever acted in such a manner, but we can’t tar groups of people with the same brush like this. It’s a slippery slope into racism, homophobia, sexism etc.

How many females would you need to see seriously harmed before you considered that recognising a class of males as a threat to females in vulnerable spaces is a necessary precaution for females?

Just asking, as the number of raped and assaulted females in prison by male prisoners is stacking up, and Baroness Nicholson is dealing with gathering evidence of females raped on women's wards in hospital and does not think it will be a small number.

I know this is really unpleasant evidence, but it was rather more unpleasant for those women who were harmed, don't you think? One of Karen White's multiply raped victims (accessed on a mental health ward White had self ID'd onto) has been left so badly injured she may never have children. And the trauma is likely to be lifelong. What measures are fair to protect more females from this awful actual, physical harm and lifelong impact?

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:11

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:09

Son where the confusion lies is your switch from sex to identity. The exceptions you quote are not exceptions at all. They are separate issues. Some straight people date trans people. Some do not. That is more an exception than some straight people dating Tories and some not. You don't have to date every single person of the opposite sex to be straight. Do some people not want you in the bi community because actually every person you fancy is a different sex from you? I.e. do they not have the gender faith and actually think you're straight? If that's not the reason, what does it matter what they think? If some people didn't want you in the queer community would you need a new category?

Correction - should say no more an exception than...

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 22:09

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 21:59

I think you might’ve misunderstood me - I think straight people are attracted to the opposite sex as stated previously. Gay/lesbians are attracted to people of the same sex and bisexual people are attracted to people of both sexes. There are exceptions to this - some straight people will date trans people, as will some gay people, as will some bisexuals. I have never stated that I disagree with any of this. What I have said is that some bisexuals wouldn’t class ME as bisexual, so I don’t want to be necessarily call myself part of a community that doesn’t want me.

Son where the confusion lies is your switch from sex to identity. The exceptions you quote are not exceptions at all. They are separate issues. Some straight people date trans people. Some do not. That is more an exception than some straight people dating Tories and some not. You don't have to date every single person of the opposite sex to be straight. Do some people not want you in the bi community because actually every person you fancy is a different sex from you? I.e. do they not have the gender faith and actually think you're straight? If that's not the reason, what does it matter what they think? If some people didn't want you in the queer community would you need a new category?

Overthebow · 22/11/2022 22:08

potniatheron · 21/11/2022 17:22

As I understand it, you should use the pornouns interchangeably, but make an effort to use the first preferred pronoun more than the second.

So, if a person goes by she/they, you should try to use say 60% she and 40% they.

Whereas if their preffered pronouns were they/he, you should use 60% they and 40% he.

It might be quite challenging for anyone who is neurodiverse, has a brain injury, a speech impediment, or for someone who's first language is not English.

Are people really going to be spending time thinking about how often they have used ‘he’ and how often they have used ‘they’? Do people really have time for this? It’s unnecessary complicated and attention seeking to expect this.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 22:06

Someone accused trans people earlier in the thread as threatening to assault and rape women with no evidence.

What exactly did they say?

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:03

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 21:57

Any examples of the 'usual trans hatred'?

I'll wait

Someone accused trans people earlier in the thread as threatening to assault and rape women with no evidence. I’m not saying no trans person has ever acted in such a manner, but we can’t tar groups of people with the same brush like this. It’s a slippery slope into racism, homophobia, sexism etc.

BedTaker · 22/11/2022 22:02

If man and woman mean the same as male and female, why do we have two words to describe the same things?

Is this a serious question?

What is a female horse called? A female cow? A female chicken? A female human?

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 21:59

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 21:52

I'm not getting into DSDs as it's a derail. This info is easy to find. I suggest reading Kathleen Stocks material girl book.

I can't call myself any gender. That's the point. I don't have one. Thats your faith not mine. So I'm agender and fancy some people, but not other, based on very obvious physical differences but no clear gender identity differences. What am I in your categorization then? Not straight as that's fancying people the same gender as me. Not gay as that's fancying people of the opposite gender. What am I in your world view?

What's my husband who does not buy into the gender faith either and only ever fancies people with one body type. In the olden days he would have been considered 100 percent straight. Is he agender pan sexual with an absolute fetish for natal vaginas? Should it be LGBTQAPSAFNV to include him and the loads of other agender natal penis havers who have similar proclivities? Or do you think he's captured in the +? Seems odd tonhave letters representing a teeny tiny percentage of the population and then everyone else lumped into a large + category. What's the purpose of a categorisation system like that?

If we go down this route how do the agender natal vagina havers who fancy other agender natal vagina havers, and get treated badly as a result, organise themselves to fight their oppression?

Call it a faith if you will instead of religion but it's undefined, undebated and makes no sense to most people. Feels very much like a religion to those of us looking in particularly given its lack of clear purpose. Why do we need prisons, sports, other facilities segregated by an identity which has no correlation with physical body types and which only a small number of the population have?

I think you might’ve misunderstood me - I think straight people are attracted to the opposite sex as stated previously. Gay/lesbians are attracted to people of the same sex and bisexual people are attracted to people of both sexes. There are exceptions to this - some straight people will date trans people, as will some gay people, as will some bisexuals. I have never stated that I disagree with any of this. What I have said is that some bisexuals wouldn’t class ME as bisexual, so I don’t want to be necessarily call myself part of a community that doesn’t want me.

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 21:58

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 20:16

They’re not still men and women though, they’re just still male and female
What does this mean? Regardless of people's identity, unless they have a DSD, they're men and women.

Maybe attracted was the wrong word - they may be attracted to them, but would choose not to be in a relationship with them because of their difference in beliefs
Right, so you being a different sort of sexuality/not bi is nothing to do with sexuality though? I don't fancy Tories because of their beliefs. Do I need a different version of straight to describe myself compared to my Tory-fancying counterparts?

I was unclear with this and apologies to people with DSDs. They are of course still men or women. Mostly biology tells us which. When it doesn't, the person themselves will tell us. I will.move on from this as I fear focus on those is being used as a distractive derail.

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 21:57

Any examples of the 'usual trans hatred'?

I'll wait

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 21:57

Have you read material girl? She does explain it really well there.

No but I keep meaning to. Another reason to, thank you

Carlycat · 22/11/2022 21:55

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:47

I avoided asking this on the feminist boards not wanting to have the original post derailed with the usual trans hatred that lurks there under the guise of womens rights.

Trans hatred my arse. Just women ( you know, the default kind ) desperately clinging on to their rights 🙄

Carlycat · 22/11/2022 21:54

fairplayforwomen.com/pronouns/