Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask HOW he/they or she/they works?

258 replies

Henuinequest · 21/11/2022 17:14

On a DE&I video call at work and the session panel did intros with pronouns stated - 2 of them said ‘I’m he/them’ and one said ‘she/they’. All panellist were trans identifying.

asking a practical question - if someone is he/ them, I’m fine just to to refer to him as he or him? As in ‘ let’s wait 2 mins to see if Josh is coming. He said he could make it’ or I’m I supposed to be saying them ??
the panel was all about trans day of remembrance or something like that so it didn’t feel appropriately to start asking them…

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JackTorrance · 26/11/2022 22:10

no one is forcing anyone to out themselves and staring preferred pronouns doesn’t mean agreeing with the label of ‘cis’ either?

It does. I don't have preferred pronouns, I don't care in the least, I expect people to use their eyes to spot what biological sex I am and use the convenional grammar associated with that sex.
That's a far cry from the pick-n-mix of "personal preference".

Henuinequest · 26/11/2022 21:59

‘no one is forcing anyone to out themselves and staring preferred pronouns doesn’t mean agreeing with the label of ‘cis’ either?’

i disagree - I have trans friends who disagree.
but we don’t all have to agree on everything.

if someone feels the need to announce their pronouns, that’s fine but I’m not going to do the same. I’m a woman. I look like a woman, and no-one is going to get confused about how to address me.

OP posts:
nilsmousehammer · 26/11/2022 20:39

It's rather like being asked to join in a prayer before a meeting, of the denomination of the dominant group in the belief that obviously any decent people would be of that religion anyway so what does it matter?

I have no objection at all to someone who wishes to share their preferred language for the group to use, although I find it somewhat offensive as it is asking me to permit them to direct and control my language for their emotional comfort. I will mostly use their name as I am not comfortable to say something that me is untrue, and participation in which is harmful to the entire female sex class. I would prefer not to enable my own oppression thanks. I have no wish to be rude, but would appreciate the reciprocation of not being subjected to the rudeness of being placed in this position.

And yes, asking everyone to state their pronouns is unhelpful in that it directly places public pressure on everyone to participate and share information that for many reasons they may be unwilling to, with questions asked and assumptions made if they wish to ask to opt out. This is not inclusive, it is not taking equal care of everyone in the room. No one is every required to go around the table and state their ailments to make me as a wheelchair user more comfortable, and I would find it highly odd and embarrassing for them to do so. Rather than 'normalising' it would be an act of head patting. We do this for no other minority group.

Ericaequites · 26/11/2022 05:16

@TheOriginalEmu - Fowler, White, Warriner, and many other reputable grammar texts will disagree. Just because something can be done doesn’t mean it should!

TheOriginalEmu · 24/11/2022 10:27

Henuinequest · 23/11/2022 09:44

‘femininely announces the same as a very androgynous looking gender fluid person.’

the panel all ID as ‘trans’ including the non-binary ones so they all had pronouns that differed from the standard.
I personally don’t announce my pronouns because I don’t think it is inclusive at all. I think it alienates people who don’t feel they are ‘cis’ or like those terms and I think it puts pressure on people who may not be ready to come out to either come out early or declare pronouns that they may not be comfortable with.
Inhave come under pressure as a gay woman to declare my pronouns in solidarity, most recently by a 20 something straight white male ‘ally’ and I came close to telling him to go fuck himself when he started trying to tell me of the discrimination LGBTQ people face in the world…
Having been out for 30 years I am well aware of the homophobia in the world, thanks mate…

everyone on the panel was trans this time, but there will be times when they are the only trans person in a room and so it helps if others also affirm their preferred pronouns.
no one is forcing anyone to out themselves and staring preferred pronouns doesn’t mean agreeing with the label of ‘cis’ either?

Henuinequest · 23/11/2022 18:23

‘Until you travel to America and meet someone at an event with a name badge which has "Abcde" written on it.’

have you experienced this? I work a LOT in the USA, have done for 20 years,
and have yet to meet anyone called abcde

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 16:56

XenoBitch · 22/11/2022 21:01

I refer to people by their name. Can't go wrong with that.

Until you travel to America and meet someone at an event with a name badge which has "Abcde" written on it.

Henuinequest · 23/11/2022 09:44

‘femininely announces the same as a very androgynous looking gender fluid person.’

the panel all ID as ‘trans’ including the non-binary ones so they all had pronouns that differed from the standard.
I personally don’t announce my pronouns because I don’t think it is inclusive at all. I think it alienates people who don’t feel they are ‘cis’ or like those terms and I think it puts pressure on people who may not be ready to come out to either come out early or declare pronouns that they may not be comfortable with.
Inhave come under pressure as a gay woman to declare my pronouns in solidarity, most recently by a 20 something straight white male ‘ally’ and I came close to telling him to go fuck himself when he started trying to tell me of the discrimination LGBTQ people face in the world…
Having been out for 30 years I am well aware of the homophobia in the world, thanks mate…

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 09:37

TheOriginalEmu · 21/11/2022 20:37

the reason these kinds of panels etc ‘announce it’ is so everyone is the same. So a ciswoman who presents very femininely announces the same as a very androgynous looking gender fluid person.
Its about making it an inclusive thing to do.

What if someone isn't ready to come out? They'll either be forced to out themselves before they're ready, or misgender themselves which might cause them distress. At least if not everyone does it they can keep quiet without attracting attention.

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 09:06

It might be quite challenging for anyone who is neurodiverse, has a brain injury, a speech impediment, or for someone who's first language is not English.

I'm none of those things, and I can't keep up.

It almost seems like it's designed to trip you up so that they can have a tantrum.

AlisonDonut · 23/11/2022 09:03

The thing that people who haven't come across this need to realise is that this isn't about gay rights in the slightest.

Stonewall, who position themselves as Gay Rights V2, their CEO called actual lesbians 'sexual racists'. They employed the male who devised courses about 'The Cotton Ceiling' which is about how to break through lesbians underwear'. It is truly vile.

Mermaids, who position themselves as LGBTQ++ for kids, their CEO [how can I put this delicately] took her child's toys away until he said 'I'm a girl' to get them back, then ordered drugs off the internet to shrink his penis, then had it removed in Thailand on this 16th Birthday [they banned this after she did it], all because his dad didn't want a gay son.

This is the total opposite of Gay Rights. It is the most homophobic activism going so much so that 2 gay rights veterans have been attacked, called 'Faggot' and had coffee poured on them, one at a PRIDE event. It is shocking homophobia pretending to be 'inclusive'. And woe betide anyone who resists.

It's why they are so demanding about pronouns. They know you know what sex they are but woe betide you refer to them as their sex, you'll be into HR and out of a job before you know it.

TWAWmearse · 23/11/2022 07:58

nilsmousehammer · 22/11/2022 22:51

www.Terfisaslur.com

You may find the many, many screenshots there illuminating in terms of many, many threats. The 'kerb stomping' ones are particularly disturbing; who actually can envisage doing that to a living person?

You may also want to check out some of the replies to JK Rowling today. I believe one supporter of TQ+ politics asked if she would like a cock in her mouth to shut her up. You may like to look at the New York art gallery exhibition that celebrated TQ+ politically violent threats including a blood stained t shirt and the threat to punch 'terfs' and barbed wire wrapped baseball bats for the punishment of non compliant females. I believe all this was originally carried in a Pride parade.

Try Twitter, 'your view in my mentions' I think was the hashtag, where many TQ+ male people took photos of themselves with weapons, a machete was one of them, posed as if standing over and attacking a body, directly referencing what they would like to do to non compliant women. There was the TW who photographed themselves in a women's toilet brandishing a sword and threatening what they would do to a woman who dared to challenge their presence there.

Then there's Veronica Ivy - who was Rachel Mckinnon at the time - who said that non compliant women should die in a grease fire, (specifying a more awful and painful way to die than mere fire). This is the same person who says that lesbians should 'learn to cope' with heterosexual sex rather than distress male people with the words 'no thank you'.

I can find you more examples if it helps: these are just the threat ones.

Sickening. The lengths people will go to to deny this is happening…

waterlego · 23/11/2022 07:37

I’ve seen a lot of TW on social media who genuinely do pass. I suppose that’s on social media though so you don’t know how accurately they’re portraying themselves online

Indeed. I take social media photos with a pinch of salt- you can almost guarantee photos are heavily filtered.

A couple of days ago, I saw a thread on Twitter in which a poster had shared pairs of photos of prominent TW. One filtered, ‘tuned’ photo alongside a candid photo. The differences were staggering. The filtered photos made the TW look like women; in the undoctored photos they looked like men wearing make up and dresses.

It did feel like rather a cruel thread so I felt a bit conflicted looking at it, but most of the TW featured had been particularly unpleasant to women at times (and some had been downright predatory and threatening- Yaniv for example) which made me feel somewhat less conflicted about it.

Transmen often pass better but are usually much shorter than men which can ruin the effect somewhat (even though, yes, short men exist).

People who physically transition at a young age are likely to pass better by circumventing puberty and going straight to cross sex hormones. Some in the trans community see this as a great thing, but I suspect the rest of the population see this for the very troubling situation it is.

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 23:17

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 23:06

I agree that it’s rare, but I’ve seen a lot of TW on social media who genuinely do pass. I suppose that’s on social media though so you don’t know how accurately they’re portraying themselves online. Regarding the history of oppression, I suppose how early on in life they transition and therefore pass, and what their experiences are like afterwards. They’ll never experience the same struggles regarding health as biological women though, that’s true.

There will always be some years of being the most valued group.in society so its never equivalent to being female. Yes re social media. Its a fantasy life not reality. I live in Brighton. I see TW all the time. Its very obvious. There may be some who really do look like women but it must be rare surely or there'd be at least some in the public eye given how many obviously male TW their are there?

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 23:07

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 23:02

Christ, point well and truly proven. The stories on the bbc link are disgusting, and some of the images on the TERF is a slur site are terrifying. It’s not necessarily just from trans people though, but from trans activists too. It’s not very helpful to the trans cause though, and I wouldn’t want people threatening to kill and rape homophobes in my name. I’d genuinely never seen that stuff before, it’s vile.

The people they are threatening are invariably not transphobes so I think that parallel doesn't work. They are just women who think we should have sex segregated not gender segregated spaces. Most such people are very happy for the trans people who respect this to live their lives and be free of harassment and bullying whilst so doing. In whatever clothing they want.

nilsmousehammer · 22/11/2022 23:06

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 23:02

Christ, point well and truly proven. The stories on the bbc link are disgusting, and some of the images on the TERF is a slur site are terrifying. It’s not necessarily just from trans people though, but from trans activists too. It’s not very helpful to the trans cause though, and I wouldn’t want people threatening to kill and rape homophobes in my name. I’d genuinely never seen that stuff before, it’s vile.

You're right, it is unbelievably disturbing. Sorry to open your eyes in that way, I wish mine hadn't been either, but this is the reality we have to face.

And you are also absolutely right that this is not all 'trans people' or TQ+ identified people. This is a political lobby, many of whom are not themselves TQ+, and I have seen the way that they speak to and treat TQ+ people who dare to try to say that the lobby does not speak for them, or to share thoughts, experiences or views of being TQ+ that do not fit the political lobby's narrative. You only have to see how detransitioners are treated.

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 23:06

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 23:03

I'm off to bed but just wanted to say that I think it's a problem to think TW pass. Some will. It's rare. Think of Eddie Izzard, Alex Drummond. There's no way they experience female oppression as they look like every other male just in different clothes. Taking a few hormones doesn't change that either. Think of some.conrroversial swimmers and other high level sportspeople. They look like men in different clothes.

Even those who do get genuinely mistaken foe actual women when clothed are biologically different. You can't unandrogynise a body. Even those who do pass don't have the history and upbringing of female oppression and can't experience the health conditions which medicine has decided to neglect because its just women who are affected.

I agree that it’s rare, but I’ve seen a lot of TW on social media who genuinely do pass. I suppose that’s on social media though so you don’t know how accurately they’re portraying themselves online. Regarding the history of oppression, I suppose how early on in life they transition and therefore pass, and what their experiences are like afterwards. They’ll never experience the same struggles regarding health as biological women though, that’s true.

howmanybicycles · 22/11/2022 23:03

I'm off to bed but just wanted to say that I think it's a problem to think TW pass. Some will. It's rare. Think of Eddie Izzard, Alex Drummond. There's no way they experience female oppression as they look like every other male just in different clothes. Taking a few hormones doesn't change that either. Think of some.conrroversial swimmers and other high level sportspeople. They look like men in different clothes.

Even those who do get genuinely mistaken foe actual women when clothed are biologically different. You can't unandrogynise a body. Even those who do pass don't have the history and upbringing of female oppression and can't experience the health conditions which medicine has decided to neglect because its just women who are affected.

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 23:02

Christ, point well and truly proven. The stories on the bbc link are disgusting, and some of the images on the TERF is a slur site are terrifying. It’s not necessarily just from trans people though, but from trans activists too. It’s not very helpful to the trans cause though, and I wouldn’t want people threatening to kill and rape homophobes in my name. I’d genuinely never seen that stuff before, it’s vile.

nilsmousehammer · 22/11/2022 22:52

Link fail: my apologies. terfisaslur.com/

The blood stained t shirt is on the front page.

nilsmousehammer · 22/11/2022 22:51

www.Terfisaslur.com

You may find the many, many screenshots there illuminating in terms of many, many threats. The 'kerb stomping' ones are particularly disturbing; who actually can envisage doing that to a living person?

You may also want to check out some of the replies to JK Rowling today. I believe one supporter of TQ+ politics asked if she would like a cock in her mouth to shut her up. You may like to look at the New York art gallery exhibition that celebrated TQ+ politically violent threats including a blood stained t shirt and the threat to punch 'terfs' and barbed wire wrapped baseball bats for the punishment of non compliant females. I believe all this was originally carried in a Pride parade.

Try Twitter, 'your view in my mentions' I think was the hashtag, where many TQ+ male people took photos of themselves with weapons, a machete was one of them, posed as if standing over and attacking a body, directly referencing what they would like to do to non compliant women. There was the TW who photographed themselves in a women's toilet brandishing a sword and threatening what they would do to a woman who dared to challenge their presence there.

Then there's Veronica Ivy - who was Rachel Mckinnon at the time - who said that non compliant women should die in a grease fire, (specifying a more awful and painful way to die than mere fire). This is the same person who says that lesbians should 'learn to cope' with heterosexual sex rather than distress male people with the words 'no thank you'.

I can find you more examples if it helps: these are just the threat ones.

electricdreaming · 22/11/2022 22:46

AlisonDonut · 22/11/2022 22:45

Srsly!

There's even websites dedicated to recording it. A famous Scottish author could wallpaper her house with them.

please link them.

AlisonDonut · 22/11/2022 22:45

Srsly!

There's even websites dedicated to recording it. A famous Scottish author could wallpaper her house with them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread