Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband (who is main earner) wants to work part-time

141 replies

mugglewump · 21/11/2022 15:21

My husband started discussions with work today to move to part-time work. He is unhappy in his job and 57 years old. Part of me gets it, for his sake, but I am concerned about the drop in income. I work 4 days a week (most weeks - supply teacher and tutor), but earn a pittance in comparison and have a chronic health condition which leaves me fatigued and is the reason I am no long class teaching full time. We have two kids at university. Am I being unreasonable to expect him to bring home the bacon because I can't? Or should we both be able to do the same?

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 21/11/2022 19:26

I'm 53 and I am looking to be in a position to scale back in the next few years. DH is a few years older and he already works part time for himself. I am the main earner and I would really resent being told I had to carry on working full time at 57 unless it was absolutely necessary. I may choose to carry on full time but I don't want to be obliged to do so.

Lentilweaver · 21/11/2022 19:13

MN is a very very harsh place for women who have chosen to put their careers second and their family first, any woman who is or has been a sahm, or ever depended on her DH due to health or other reasons gets given a hard time here.

I did all of the above and still think she should allow her DH to go part time, unless they are absolutely desperate for money. My own DH is 54 and we are planning for him to retire by 57. I can see he is bloody tired and burnt out. Not easy working stressful high earning jobs in your fifties and if I could do it all again, I would not have been an SAHM. ( didn't have much choice as we were abroad)

Notjustabrunette · 21/11/2022 19:10

I think the first step is to look at how much money you actually need. Go through all your bank statements, pension contributions, savings etc.
once you’ve worked out your total outgoings, compare them to what your take home pay would be if he did reduce his hours. It might be there are things you are paying for that you don’t really need. For example a friend of mine was paying quite a lot of money each month in car payments, for a car that was bigger than she needed. She was able to exchange it for a smaller car which saved her £100 per month in payments, was cheaper to insure, tax and fuel. Me and my DH recently managed to re negotiate gym membership to a joint off peak membership which has saved us a few 100 for the year.
it sounds like he needs to reduce his hours for his own well being and you might need to work out what you could do without.

Testina · 21/11/2022 19:09

Cannot believe you’re even asking this.
He’s bringing in more than you, he’s 57, he’s working more than you…
Of course he should drop to 4 days if as a couple you can still cover your outgoings - which I expect you can.
You’re not just unreasonable, you’re really taking the piss.

HowDoYouOwnDisorder · 21/11/2022 19:07

Part time jobs are not an option for all students, if you do medicine or vet or engineering you spend a lot of time doing lab stuff/lectures/research

anyway, OP, it all depends on money and if you can still get to the dnd of the month ok

basically if you need to sacrifice holidays and newer cars and other luxuries yabu

but if you would now struggle to pay heating and food, yanbu

MN is a very very harsh place for women who have chosen to put their careers second and their family first, any woman who is or has been a sahm, or ever depended on her DH due to health or other reasons gets given a hard time here

it can be a pretty misogynistic place should you ever have made the decision to work part time or (whisper) be a sahm ever

Canthave2manycats · 21/11/2022 19:02

It's certainly easier to come by now than it was when my older two were looking for p/t jobs. My son has had several successful interviews. He's also in uni.

Well, I am now feeling wayyyyy over the hill.... 59, so is my husband - both of us still working full-time?!! I also hate my job (well, not the job per se, the management) and I would retire happily right now - but I want to do some upgrades to the house and build up as much pensionable service as possible before I retire.

I might consider partial retirement, where you can take some of your pension and reduce your hours - and I'm led to believe that there are no actuarial costs once you're 60, so my employer would be less likely to refuse!

GoldenCupidon · 21/11/2022 19:02

You haven't said whether between the two of you you're well of or not, this does obviously affect the answers.

If him dropping his working hours will mean you can't pay the bills and lose the house, YANBU

If him dropping his working hours will mean a drop in the disposable income you enjoy and are well used to having (without earning it yourself) and you just don't want that, YABU as it's his life.

user1471554720 · 21/11/2022 19:01

There are a few cnuts on here, saying that the dh should 'discuss' ask for permission to reduce hours. He, quite rightly thought that when his wife is on shorter hours, he should be entitled to do the same. Is his health not as important as his wife's?

If a person is not able to do it, they are not able. It is better to reduce than to get sick and give up altogether. Reducing means that people can carry on a bit longer.

Gwenhwyfar · 21/11/2022 18:58

"there is no shortage of part time work for them while they study."

Is that true??
There are part time jobs for all students who want them?

Scottishskifun · 21/11/2022 18:55

If your kids are at uni they can get jobs themselves and as long as you look at finances together to make sure that your still covered for things then why shouldn't he?

I would say he's being unreasonable if you can't afford things but at the same time you could switch to private tutoring and examiner/marker and earn more then supply work etc whilst still being part time.

Neanov · 21/11/2022 18:54

Theunamedcat · 21/11/2022 18:10

Can he not change jobs similar pay more fulfillment?

Why doesn't OP find a higher paying agency job by the same token?

ExplainUnderstand · 21/11/2022 18:51

If 4 days a week teaching is "a pittance" in comparison, he must have a very substantial income. Maybe you'll both need to make some adjustments to your out goings, but I'd be encouraging a man (anyone) of 57 who wants to reduce his hours to do exactly that.

IveDroppedMiBiscuitInMiBrew · 21/11/2022 18:47

You work part time though and probably have for many years, why should he work full time and feel overworked/unhappy? You should be thankful he has supported the arrangement this long, with uni aged kids the need to be pt for childcare will have ended years ago. You say you have a condition, well your husband's health is just as important, sounds like you need some lifestyle changes to adjust to a lower income.

Figgygal · 21/11/2022 18:42

So it's OK for your earning potential to be reduced due to health but not your husbands?

MsPrism · 21/11/2022 18:22

I think the answer could be to help your DH find a job he is happy to do to full time - especially if he could take early retirement from his current job ? In your position would speak to a financial advisor and see what can be done to make your money work for you. Supply teaching is pretty tough, is there a less stressful teaching/education-related job you could do? It sounds like you both need a life-change - could you downsize and then maybe both stop working?

Theunamedcat · 21/11/2022 18:10

Can he not change jobs similar pay more fulfillment?

Strangeways19 · 21/11/2022 18:08

I feel he should go part time if it's going to help his mental health especially as he doesn't like his job. Torturous having to spend hours doing something just for money, soulless.
Myself & are in same position, kids at uni, we both work part time. It's enough & money isn't everything.

skyeisthelimit · 21/11/2022 18:04

YANBU if you are physically unable to work full time due to ill health.

As PP have said, you need to look at your total income and outgoings and see what you can cut back on for him to work less hours if that is what he wants. He needs to recognise the lifestyle changes that it will bring if he reduces his hours (as do you).

It can't just be a tit for tat thing that he wants to work less because you work less, if he is the main breadwinner and fit and healthy.

Hankunamatata · 21/11/2022 18:01

I think you keep open mind and sit down and look at finances.
How would his pension be effected? Would help dropping one day to start etc.
Would uni kids be entitled to more financial assistance if income dropped?

JoeMaplin · 21/11/2022 17:51

ilovebrie8 · 21/11/2022 17:40

Maybe I’m wrong but don’t think it’s easy to get disability benefits. What do people do if they are not able to work but don’t have a private pension to draw on?

It’s not easy but it is possible. Pip is not means tested and you can get it if you work too, it is to pay for extra costs having a disability entails. In my case, so I can remain working 4 days instead of full time. . In terms of other benefits, you are expected to use any savings above £6k first and then household income is taken into account but ultimately you are supported by the state (although not grandly) if you are unable to support yourself due to disability or Ill health.

DPotter · 21/11/2022 17:49

Before he goes part time he needs to check it will not adversely effect any workplace pension. Some are calculated on the basis of earnings in the last 3 years. This was always a problem as in many ways it makes sense to start winding down pre-retirement but the way pensions were set up, worked against this happening.

DP retired from his FT job, claimed his pension and returned on a part time basis on a new contract because of this. I should imagine not all employers would allow this

HermioneWeasley · 21/11/2022 17:43

If you working 4 days as a supply teacher still has him earning significantly more then he must be quite a high earner. In which case, him dropping down to 3 or 4 days a week should be fine financially.

ilovebrie8 · 21/11/2022 17:40

Maybe I’m wrong but don’t think it’s easy to get disability benefits. What do people do if they are not able to work but don’t have a private pension to draw on?

mast0650 · 21/11/2022 17:35

I don't think you should "expect" anything. It's pretty obvious that you both need to sit down and work out exactly how much take home income he would lose and where you would have to cut back and/or reduce savings. Make sure you take into account the long term impact on pensions too. Then decide if the improvement in terms of having a more relaxed lifestyle is worth what you lose in ability to spend. No-one should feel they have to keep working full time just because they can. It makes sense to consider alternatives. You say yourself he is a high earner, but that means you can probably sustain a good material standard of living from 4 days a week of paid work and get the benefit of more time. Remember that his net pay won't fall anything like 20%.

Or if it doesn't quite work yet, wait 2-3 years since the kids have finished university so you are not paying for them anymore?

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 21/11/2022 17:35

You're 'allowed' to work part time but he isn't?

Reduce your outgoings. Downsize.

Your health (both) is the main thing here, not who earns the most.