Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cancelled Afterschool Activity

188 replies

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 14:54

Hard hat on, I've been on here for years but don't think I've ever braved an AIBU post before.

DD1 is 4 and started school in September. DH and I both work FT, and she goes to an afterschool club everyday. They're the same company as the nursery she went to for years and are thankfully very accommodating. They collect from many schools in the area and run a fleet of cars and do a huge amount of work to make sure everyone is picked up when they need to be.

Once a week DD does football after school - outside company, held at school, advertised through school but paid directly to the company. Afterschool club very nicely put on a car to collect DD and a few others from football, and when the day changed at one week's notice recently they adjusted as well.

It's miserable here today, and we got a text at noon that football was likely cancelled and they would confirm at 1pm.

AIBU to think that two hours notice that DC have to be picked up an hour early is taking the piss? I was embarrassed asking the after school club to make a change to their schedule at such short notice, which thankfully they can do as it would have been difficult for DH or I to make it on time.

Surely an outdoor activity in November needs a contingency plan?

OP posts:
CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 20:47

Oh yes, sorry, the ASC price is the same regardless of 2pm or 3pm. But I meant I need it for the 3-5:30 bit so I don't pay it purely as cover for football. I'm grateful they will do a different pickup time once a week and have no problem with them not adjusting the price. It's the same price for older DC who finish school later.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 21/11/2022 20:47

honeylulu · 21/11/2022 20:43

I'm not sure what the problem is and am confused at your ire

Because she's having to mess around the after school club staff at very late notice. Trust me, not great. After school club staff are human too. Ours is run on a not for profit basis by a church. Our school hobby clubs are run for profit by external providers.

But that's just the way it is - booking DC into the activity comes with that risk.

The activity couldn't know that rain would make the pitch unplayable. And they're not required to provide an alternative activity.

EarringsandLipstick · 21/11/2022 20:45

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 20:41

I don't pay the ASC to cover the football. They collect at 3pm after football and we collect from them at 5:30.

Again, lucky you! (But you are taking a risk!)

Most ASC I've used require a flat payment, you use it or don't but it's not by the hour. (I know it's different in the UK, but thought NI might be more like it generally is here in terms of payment).

You are trying to use the activity as childcare, and (again), it's not.

georgarina · 21/11/2022 20:44

YANBU
If parents expect their kids to be occupied at X time, they will need more notice on cancellation.
People are so quick to snarl at OP to accept it because 'that's just how it is,' and that's how nothing changes.

honeylulu · 21/11/2022 20:43

I'm not sure what the problem is and am confused at your ire

Because she's having to mess around the after school club staff at very late notice. Trust me, not great. After school club staff are human too. Ours is run on a not for profit basis by a church. Our school hobby clubs are run for profit by external providers.

EarringsandLipstick · 21/11/2022 20:43

When you're collecting the children from the classroom to train them on school grounds

It's simply a matter of the people running the activity using the school grounds. 🤷🏻‍♀️

It's not school. It's not childcare.

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 20:41

I don't pay the ASC to cover the football. They collect at 3pm after football and we collect from them at 5:30.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 21/11/2022 20:40

I think it's just another example of our broken childcare system and the way working parents aren't supported,

I couldn't agree more with you; and as a single parent working f/t, no family support, I have cried on so many occasions trying to make it work.

But this is not an example of 'broken childcare'. It's not childcare. The people running it have no responsibility to provide an alternative service. The same way my DC GAA team at the weekend is not required to or their soccer team or their music teacher. The exact requirements are part of their contract with you, but no, childcare is not one of them

titchy · 21/11/2022 20:37

I'm venting on here because I think it's just another example of our broken childcare system

But it's not childcare!!!! It's an activity club! The ASC is childcare - which you now appear to pay for on football days in order to have cover if the club is cancelled. So now I'm not sure what the problem is and am confused at your ire. Confused

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 20:31

I believe it's year round although we book in blocks of 8 weeks or similar. It's been cancelled (no charge) in advance for parent teacher meetings and similar which is fine as we can let after school club know in advance and they know what's what when they do their schedule. The day was changed with a week's notice recently which was less fine imo but ho hum.

If it was a sports club at a different site then of course it's not childcare. When you're collecting the children from the classroom to train them on school grounds then parents' arrangements change from "pick up DC at 2" to "pick up DC at 3" and I do think that blurs the lines.

Also, again, the school used to provide a classroom and no longer do "because covid". I'm guessing the prices haven't been adjusted to allow for that, for any of the parties involved!

OP posts:
FaazoHuyzeoSix · 21/11/2022 20:20

Sorry I think yabu.
You said yourself that this isn't exactly unexpected. Rain happens in November. The organisation are not promising childcare come rain or shine, they are offering a football club, with no obligation to join it. Having a reliable wet weather backup would massively increase the costs and make it unviable. It's on you to ask what the rain contingency plan is and either work with it or don't use the club. You are responsible for deciding which after school options work for your family.

ZiriForEver · 21/11/2022 20:19

So is the football presented as year round or seasonal activity?
It is only November now, how would they deal with the winter? Cancel every week till spring, because who could have expected rain, snow, and cold?

honeylulu · 21/11/2022 20:15

@UsingChangeofName

No it isn't childcare per se but it's secondary function is indeed thus for working parents. Like school '"isn't childcare" but if I looked for a term time nursery or childminder for my 8 year old there would be NO provision because children are being cared for at school by default.

It's cool, I get it. But it's not viable to send my kids when we're both at work full time. I am a bit hmmmm when I get the emails from head teacher griping about the risk that the providers might cancel the clubs because there aren't enough pupils to run them profitably. Well, no shit Sherlock. If they aren't doubling up as reliable childcare working parents won't sign up their kids and they won't get the desired numbers It's hardly rocket science .

Pinkflipflop85 · 21/11/2022 20:12

It isn't an example of a broken childcare system.

It is a hobby. An optional club.

But you don't want to listen to that fact.

UsingChangeofName · 21/11/2022 20:05

because I think it's just another example of our broken childcare system and the way working parents aren't supported,

But, as posters have been trying to point out to you for 5 pages now, this isn't childcare. It is a hobby club. In the same way that you might take your child to a sports club on a Saturday morning, or, when they get older, to Beavers or Anchor Boys or something at 6pm. If it doesn't fit in with what you can arrange, then you can't do it. It's a bit frustrating, but hardly the end of the world. As I have already said, once they get older and you've got to know others with similar age dc, plus the dc themselves are a bit older and more comfortable spending an hour here and there with other people's parents, then you work with other parents to help each other out in these circumstances.
4 is really very young to be doing something like this, so if you can't work it with your other commitments, it doesn't matter if he doesn't do it.

honeylulu · 21/11/2022 19:58

@SkylightSkylight

@honeylulu why can't you bok after school club & if the sport activity is cancelled he goes to ASC?

To be fair son only went to hobby club when I was on mat leave so it wasn't an issue but if I'd booked both it would have cost £12 for hobby club and £18 for after school club so paying twice. (Cost of living, anyone? )Also after school club was very heavily subscribed and had a waiting list so it would have made me very unpopular to have booked/hogged a space that I probably wasn't going to use and a dinner would be prepared that would end up in the bin so the club staff would end up blacklisting us 😂
Until covid we did have an after school nanny 2 evenings a week - she would drop off and pick up from cubs etc. It majorly messed her around if it got cancelled (cubs very rarely cancelled to be fair) as she'd plan the schedule to accommodate my son, my toddler and her own two children. If it happened too often I'm sure she would have given notice pronto. When you have good reliable childcare you can't risk taking the mick. If she'd resigned my whole career would have been up shit creek.

It just meant the flaky hobby clubs were untenable once i was back at work.

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 19:22

Btw - I had one short conversation with the man who owns the football company, and I won't be contacting the school. I'm venting on here because I think it's just another example of our broken childcare system and the way working parents aren't supported, and as someone above has noted these activities and the like haven't moved with the times to account for working parents with no family support.

No real person is feeling the lash of my tongue, I'm posting here while I cuddle a sick toddler (who goes to the equally amazing nursery associated with the amazing after school club).

OP posts:
Testina · 21/11/2022 19:22

It’s an activity club, not a childcare provision.
“Surely an outdoor activity in November needs a contingency plan?”
The contingency planning is on your side, and it’s you!
These activity clubs are often franchised and self employed leaders with small teams - can get cancelled for their sickness, for example.

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 19:19

Jeweleyedjudy · 21/11/2022 19:18

Ye gods, I expect you are one of those people who believe that teachers are glorified childminders who are there for your convenience while you work.

I would love you to point out where you think my posts say this as nothing could be further from the truth.

OP posts:
SkylightSkylight · 21/11/2022 19:18

honeylulu · 21/11/2022 18:18

Same at our children's school. My son was really keen to do some of the hobby clubs so when I was on maternity with youngest I signed him up for a couple which he loved. But there were lots of last minute cancellations and they never ran for the full term. Luckily I was only round the corner but if I'd been in the office in London I'd have been stuffed not to mention very distracted!

I get it, they aren't "childcare" but they do have a secondary childcare function because primary age kids can't just go home on their own when club is cancelled. Just not workable for parents with jobs if they aren't reliable. Conversely the off site after school club (did pick up, dinner and care until 6pm) never let us down once, whatever the weather. Once I was back at work no more after school clubs.

Now the head teacher keeps sending round emails bleating about how poorly attended the hobby clubs are and if they don't get more numbers they will be cancelled. Well yes because they are only viable for kids who have a SAHP.

@honeylulu why can't you bok after school club & if the sport activity is cancelled he goes to ASC?

Jeweleyedjudy · 21/11/2022 19:18

Ye gods, I expect you are one of those people who believe that teachers are glorified childminders who are there for your convenience while you work.

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 19:18

I do. Every week I pay the football and the after school club to collect from 2pm but they collect at 3pm. Frankly if they charged me extra for the inconvenience of a different time of pickup I'd happily pay it. As others have noted, we're very lucky with them and they are indeed worth their weight in gold.

I feel like a dick messing them around when their schedule is a logistical nightmare.

OP posts:
titchy · 21/11/2022 19:15

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 19:10

He isn't refunding and I'm not making an issue out of that, it's a small local business and I don't care about the few pounds.

Then pay for the ASC as well then as money clearly isn't an issue!

EarringsandLipstick · 21/11/2022 19:15

I actually think OP is really lucky that her after school club will accommodate other after school activities and do the pick ups an hour later.

She is.

I've had many childcare combinations over the years. None really worked. When I used an ASC, they were utterly inflexible. I kind of understood, but one activity was literally around the corner from them, finishing at the same time they were collecting a group from the hall beside where my DC was doing a different activity. They said no, and so DC couldn't do it.

I also used child minders and some didn't drive; they couldn't hang around to collect 1 DC who was staying on to do an activity, while waiting with the other 2.

It's crap but that's the way it is.

Occasionally I see families who strike gold with amenable & flexible childminders. Like gold dust & paid accordingly! Thank goodness mine are more or less beyond that stage, nearly.

UsingChangeofName · 21/11/2022 19:12

if you can’t handle last minute changes like this sack off the after school activities and just do the one after school club. Sounds like a load of faff anyway and I’m sure a 4 yo doesn’t get that much out of it especially after a long day of school
take her to little kickers or diddikicks on a weekend

This
If you are both at work and don't have a mate or a grandparent who can pick up and transport dc places at short notice occasionally, and you don't have the flexibility over your diary some working parents do and you don't work at home like some parents do, then it might make sense for you to just stick to the OoS Care for now. A 4 yr old is hardly missing out if they don't go to this football. Start after school enrichment activities when they get into Junior school and you have built up a bit of a network of mates who would happily take your dc home with their ds in the event of an unexpected pick up like this.