Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cancelled Afterschool Activity

188 replies

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 14:54

Hard hat on, I've been on here for years but don't think I've ever braved an AIBU post before.

DD1 is 4 and started school in September. DH and I both work FT, and she goes to an afterschool club everyday. They're the same company as the nursery she went to for years and are thankfully very accommodating. They collect from many schools in the area and run a fleet of cars and do a huge amount of work to make sure everyone is picked up when they need to be.

Once a week DD does football after school - outside company, held at school, advertised through school but paid directly to the company. Afterschool club very nicely put on a car to collect DD and a few others from football, and when the day changed at one week's notice recently they adjusted as well.

It's miserable here today, and we got a text at noon that football was likely cancelled and they would confirm at 1pm.

AIBU to think that two hours notice that DC have to be picked up an hour early is taking the piss? I was embarrassed asking the after school club to make a change to their schedule at such short notice, which thankfully they can do as it would have been difficult for DH or I to make it on time.

Surely an outdoor activity in November needs a contingency plan?

OP posts:
Redebs · 22/11/2022 07:48

I think afterschool activities providers need to accept that they ARE in fact part of people's childcare arrangements. Working parents don't get the rest of the afternoon off if it rains!
There needs to be a Plan B in case of bad weather and indoor facilities are available in most schools.

sheepdogdelight · 22/11/2022 07:48

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 15:45

Ok, seems IABU.

It's going to be a long ten years isn't it.

Sadly, I think this is what most posters are telling you. Yes, it would be nice for the football club to have a back up plan, but that's probably beyond what the organiser wants to do. It would actually be nice for schools/child activities in general to be more focused around making things easier for parents (not just working ones) but if your child is going to state school, you just have to accept that capacity to do this is lower priority.

In 10 years' time you will probably look back and be grateful that you had 2 hours notice. I've had notification of clubs not running after they were meant to have started. School sports days they will tend to leave until the last minute to decide that actually the grass is too slippery. And my personal favourite - DC's junior school which used to take half the year group on a trip on one day, and the other half on another day, but they didn't tell you which half your child was in until the evening before.

I'd suggest adopting a "go with the flow" attitude or you will be driven mad on a regular basis :)

Guitarbar · 22/11/2022 07:48

It's basically shit if you work and have children of school age. I feel for you, its not always easy to be able to escape work early or arrange alternative childcare with 2 hours notice. You'd think they'd have a contingency plan with the school, it's ridiculous they can't use a classroom, even if to watch something or go through tactics or whatever just for one week. As you say in winter surely it's expected the weather will be crap.

toomuchlaundry · 22/11/2022 07:45

What are the terms and conditions of the club?

LolaSmiles · 22/11/2022 07:22

WHY aren't these clubs childcare though? They're collecting 30 four year olds from their teachers and then an hour later they are collected by after school
Because childcare is provided by registered childcare providers and a club isn't.
Clubs ran by staff can, and are, changed because it's not actually a teacher's job to run after school clubs.
Clubs ran by outside companies can, and are, changed based on whatever the business requirements are (so in the case of bad weather they can be cancelled).

If parents want childcare, they need to sort childcare.

Purple52 · 22/11/2022 07:16

YANBU.
school led clubs are like the hoaky-coaky.
however if I’ve paid an external provider I expect some sort of delivery!
are you getting a refund or an extra date added in to what you’ve paid for?
or are you expected to fund the cancellation too?!

i’d be speaking my mind to the head teacher and/governors. Ultimately responsibility lies with them for these decisions, who uses the school facilities (who they are RENTED to for income) & what activities are advertised to children & parents.

LightUpTheWoods · 22/11/2022 07:15

That said, these things happen, but I would not think much of a provider who repeatedly cancelled at short notice

Don't ever get involved in cricket then!
50% of DS's were cancelled for heavy rain or heatwave last season. Matches are cancelled for rain every season, albeit not usually quite so many.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/11/2022 07:10

you are paying for both as the organisers of any activity for children where parents are not present are in loco parentis.

That's still not childcare!

Childcare is a specific arrangement, with a contract & certain conditions, that differs from an activity.

I would not think much of a provider who repeatedly cancelled at short notice.

Don't be silly! If it's an outdoor activity & it's rained off, that's the nature of the activity. My kids play sports; occasionally a pitch is unplayable; training or a match will be called off.

Ladyvgc · 22/11/2022 07:08

Think you just need to get used to it tbh! Things get cancelled and plans change. School is not childcare - it’s education. There will be times when school is unexpectedly closed or shuts early and you, the parent, need to plan for that! Or your child will be ill and either can’t go in or need picking up early. You and your husband need to speak with your employers and have your contingency plan in place!

Mummieslncorporated · 22/11/2022 07:02

I'm not sure how you expect them to have more notice to give? Things happen sometimes.

I once took my kids to school to be met by a teacher outside saying the school was closed because the heating was broken. I had no time to make a contingency plan. It's just one of those things that life throws at you sometimes, and you just have to figure out how to deal with it.

balalake · 22/11/2022 06:56

Depending on where you are, I think the weather was such that a decision could have been made earlier. Assuming you believe a weather forecast to be accurate.

H007 · 22/11/2022 06:27

YABU they do have a contingency plan the plan is in the case of bad weather to inform parents that football may be cancelled and confirm by 1pm, I expect in the rare cases where a situation changes and children are unable to be collected the school would look after them I.e. sat in the office twiddleling their thumbs.

You wait till it snows and the school closes there is even less notice for that.

I don’t think it’s the assumption that there is always someone to collect child. I think these decisions are made after a lot of consideration and with the child’s interest at the centre. There probably is an assumption that all employers understand that there is a need for parents to sometimes pick up their children because of illness, weather, accident etc.

MavisChunch29 · 22/11/2022 06:23

Newsflash: the two are not the same thing. You pay for football session not a childcare service

Newsflash: you are paying for both as the organisers of any activity for children where parents are not present are in loco parentis. Paying through the nose often too.

That said, these things happen, but I would not think much of a provider who repeatedly cancelled at short notice.

Mediocrates · 22/11/2022 06:16

I understand your frustrations. I wonder though if maybe you’re expecting the club to have put a plan in place for inclement weather which, as you say, is entirely predictable in November, while you haven’t also planned for the same predictable outcome?

RedToothBrush · 21/11/2022 21:37

Plumbear2 · 21/11/2022 15:28

This is because it's an activity not childcare. I would always make sure I was around in case an activity was cancelled.

This.

Football was cancelled due to the weather.

But really you want a babysitter not a football activity.

Newsflash: the two are not the same thing. You pay for football session not a childcare service.

ZiriForEver · 21/11/2022 21:30

titchy · 21/11/2022 21:04

Look you're clearly thinking the football club is killing two birds with one stone - minding your kid and providing an activity, and that therefore they should fulfil the requirements of looking after kids in any way shape or form regardless of conditions. But it's a football club, and most parents probably send their kids to play football. If they can't play because it's raining, they're not interested in having the kids sat in the hall colouring in. They send them there to play football outside on a muddy field.

Just book your kid in between the 2.00 and 3.00 slot. If she goes to football, then the ASC has one less kid to look after. If footballs cancelled your have childcare sorted. Job done.

The issue is handover. ASC is picking children up, normally after school, on Monday after football.
It is technically paid for the time (flat fee), but they might not be always flexible with pick up time on a very short notice.

If the football was providing backup activity in the classroom in the past (for those who prefered backup over simple cancellation), it is easy to see, why the change to just cancelling is hard for OP.

It sounds that several children are in this situation, so maybe it will be worth finding some solution (maybe even on the football's side) so those children would be able to keep both.

Suemademedoit · 21/11/2022 21:23

Think about WHY you chose to put your DD in football one day per week OP. Probably it was because she enjoys it, she might get better at it, she might learn something new.

The second two things are NOT childcare. They’re teaching, which is above and beyond childcare which is feeding, keeping safe, keeping entertained. There’s no education involved.

The football club isn’t childcare. You’re dumbing down what they do.

That said, the world is increasingly populated by a two-working-parent model and childcare options haven’t evolved much. There’s more reliance on after school clubs but there’s not enough for everyone. And it’s not affordable to everyone but that’s a different matter.

titchy · 21/11/2022 21:04

Look you're clearly thinking the football club is killing two birds with one stone - minding your kid and providing an activity, and that therefore they should fulfil the requirements of looking after kids in any way shape or form regardless of conditions. But it's a football club, and most parents probably send their kids to play football. If they can't play because it's raining, they're not interested in having the kids sat in the hall colouring in. They send them there to play football outside on a muddy field.

Just book your kid in between the 2.00 and 3.00 slot. If she goes to football, then the ASC has one less kid to look after. If footballs cancelled your have childcare sorted. Job done.

Dixiechickonhols · 21/11/2022 21:01

Have you asked school why the change? Is it just Covid hangover or did an external club leave classroom in a mess or not pay room hire. Perhaps there’s been a change in policy about schools renting out rooms eg having to book by term not rent as and when needed meaning it’s not affordable by football club. Hire of school classrooms tends to be expensive around here (we were looking at alternative venue for an activity club as church hall is expensive but school wasn’t an option)

titchy · 21/11/2022 20:58

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 20:41

I don't pay the ASC to cover the football. They collect at 3pm after football and we collect from them at 5:30.

Well then that's what you need to do Confused

honeylulu · 21/11/2022 20:54

@EarringsandLipstick
But that's just the way it is - booking DC into the activity comes with that risk

Yes that's why we no longer book the clubs. Then the clubs whinge that numbers are too low to justify the cost of running them. 🙄

LightUpTheWoods · 21/11/2022 20:53

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 21/11/2022 15:29

I would have liked the football company to have a plan in place with the school for inclement weather

You said yourself they can't use a classroom or the hall. What do you expect them to actually do? They aren't a babysitting service. I'm sure parents would have also complained if their DC got a bit wet and muddy injured due to the unsafe playing conditions

Maybe their plan is to cancel the activity? As pp, it's not childcare.

TBH, if you're child is going to play outdoor sports, you're going to have to get used to short notice cancellations.

EarringsandLipstick · 21/11/2022 20:53

@CancelledActivity

I can agree that if a room used to be available then it's a bit frustrating that it isn't still.

But (and I think I'm running out of ways to say it!) there's no requirement for an activity (run exactly the same as any other activity offered for DC) should be expected to make contingency plans like this.

I know this affects you because you work; but a SAHP could similarly be affected if they had made a specific alternate plan based on this activity. It's inherent in the situation that^^ sometimes things get cancelled & parents (working / stay at home) have to adjust. Challenging but it's parenting.

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 20:49

EarringsandLipstick · 21/11/2022 20:47

But that's just the way it is - booking DC into the activity comes with that risk.

The activity couldn't know that rain would make the pitch unplayable. And they're not required to provide an alternative activity.

But WHY is that the risk? It happens in school, feet away from the classrooms. No, they couldn't know in advance that it would rain today but entirely predictable that not every Monday would be dry. And, again, the school used to allow them use an indoor space, presumably for exactly this reason - a very simple solution to a predictable problem.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 21/11/2022 20:49

If parents expect their kids to be occupied at X time, they will need more notice on cancellation.

But that's not true of any other activity - if your DC has music lessons on Saturday or tennis on Sunday, you would not expect an alternative arrangement to be made if the activity could not go ahead.

There's lots of challenges around working + childcare. But this isn't one that's fair to blame either the provider or the school for