Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cancelled Afterschool Activity

188 replies

CancelledActivity · 21/11/2022 14:54

Hard hat on, I've been on here for years but don't think I've ever braved an AIBU post before.

DD1 is 4 and started school in September. DH and I both work FT, and she goes to an afterschool club everyday. They're the same company as the nursery she went to for years and are thankfully very accommodating. They collect from many schools in the area and run a fleet of cars and do a huge amount of work to make sure everyone is picked up when they need to be.

Once a week DD does football after school - outside company, held at school, advertised through school but paid directly to the company. Afterschool club very nicely put on a car to collect DD and a few others from football, and when the day changed at one week's notice recently they adjusted as well.

It's miserable here today, and we got a text at noon that football was likely cancelled and they would confirm at 1pm.

AIBU to think that two hours notice that DC have to be picked up an hour early is taking the piss? I was embarrassed asking the after school club to make a change to their schedule at such short notice, which thankfully they can do as it would have been difficult for DH or I to make it on time.

Surely an outdoor activity in November needs a contingency plan?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blondeshavemorefun · 24/11/2022 22:58

Sounds stressful

check with childcare that if happens again (and it will esp in winter) that they are happy to pick up early with barely any notice

do they pick up others as usual time so at school regardless

I think dd5 has her her advice so over the terms gym dance crafts cancelled a few times due to poorly teachers

realmsofglory · 23/11/2022 00:07

Ellie1015 · 22/11/2022 09:35

From the football club's point of view are they offering a chance to play football or are the offering childcare?

If it is mainly a football club then if football not possible it wouldn't offer an alternative. School lets are often via council hiring a pitch doesn't necessarily give access to school building.

If it is selling its self as after school care then they should have a back up plan.

plus they are insured to coach football on the football field.It may not cover doing different activities in a different location

EarringsandLipstick · 22/11/2022 23:55

UsingChangeofName · 22/11/2022 23:32

i’d be speaking my mind to the head teacher and/governors. Ultimately responsibility lies with them for these decisions,

..............and we'd know who to blame when this activity wasn't offered again.

Because why would a teacher want to research what is available, check references, etc, and make the booking, then advertise to parents and take the bookings, then be responsible for getting the message out as quickly as they can on the odd occasion it has to be cancelled for legitimate reasons, when this is the response they get to doing all that extra work so the children can have a fun activity available to them, outside of the teacher's contracted hours ? Hmm

It's not a school activity. It's not offered by a teacher after hours. It's a private company. The school only shared the information.

UsingChangeofName · 22/11/2022 23:32

i’d be speaking my mind to the head teacher and/governors. Ultimately responsibility lies with them for these decisions,

..............and we'd know who to blame when this activity wasn't offered again.

Because why would a teacher want to research what is available, check references, etc, and make the booking, then advertise to parents and take the bookings, then be responsible for getting the message out as quickly as they can on the odd occasion it has to be cancelled for legitimate reasons, when this is the response they get to doing all that extra work so the children can have a fun activity available to them, outside of the teacher's contracted hours ? Hmm

Ginseng1 · 22/11/2022 22:58

Am with you as this is a company not a local football club or teacher volunteering. However this happens. It's crap as a working parent primary years stressful you trying to give them opportunities to be out playing football in the fresh air & better at that time than evening when they wrecked! Just appreciate your asc which sounds like you do. They a business too & am sure you pay them enough for the excellent service.

Barbie222 · 22/11/2022 21:50

I'm just wondering if I'm reasonable to be pissed off as a first time parent at school. The notion that every child has pickup options that can change at two hours notice is bizarre and unrealistic to me.

Yes, this is normal, sorry. It's an activity not childcare. Unfortunately your options as a full time working parent OOH during early primary are the after school club (if they will collect from activity), childminder, nanny, or looking for a more flexible position.

Once at secondary school, in my experience, there isn't usually a call home when after school activities are cancelled - children rather than parents are informed.

LolaSmiles · 22/11/2022 21:38

I think afterschool activities providers need to accept that they ARE in fact part of people's childcare arrangements.
Working parents don't get the rest of the afternoon off if it rains!
The responsibility of an after school club doesn't change just because some parents choose to use them in place of properly registered childcare.

It's not the job of the school or after school activity provider to sort out childcare for families who didn't make adequate childcare arrangements.

Plumbear2 · 22/11/2022 17:51

EarringsandLipstick · 22/11/2022 15:02

This is a pickup directly from school so the expectation should be that the parents will not be immediately nearby and available in case of a last-minute cancellation.

So they make sure that someone can - relative, minder, after-school - whatever is needed for each family.

It's simply splitting hairs to say that because the parent might not be there at drop off, different rules apply.

The final, repeated how-many-times-now point, is that the activity is not childcare, and if a parent chooses that option, they have to take the attendant risk of cancellation & plan for it.

Exactly this.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/11/2022 15:02

This is a pickup directly from school so the expectation should be that the parents will not be immediately nearby and available in case of a last-minute cancellation.

So they make sure that someone can - relative, minder, after-school - whatever is needed for each family.

It's simply splitting hairs to say that because the parent might not be there at drop off, different rules apply.

The final, repeated how-many-times-now point, is that the activity is not childcare, and if a parent chooses that option, they have to take the attendant risk of cancellation & plan for it.

georgarina · 22/11/2022 13:26

EarringsandLipstick · 21/11/2022 20:49

If parents expect their kids to be occupied at X time, they will need more notice on cancellation.

But that's not true of any other activity - if your DC has music lessons on Saturday or tennis on Sunday, you would not expect an alternative arrangement to be made if the activity could not go ahead.

There's lots of challenges around working + childcare. But this isn't one that's fair to blame either the provider or the school for

That's different because in those examples someone drops the kids off themselves. This is a pickup directly from school so the expectation should be that the parents will not be immediately nearby and available in case of a last-minute cancellation.

Plumbear2 · 22/11/2022 12:44

The parents are the back up plan. Your child is still in school now, school is not child care it's education. Sporting clubs are not childcare they provide an activity. School can call you anytime if a child is illor has an accident, they do not have to give notice because ultimately it is your responsibility. You do have to get your head round that fact.

Ellie1015 · 22/11/2022 09:35

From the football club's point of view are they offering a chance to play football or are the offering childcare?

If it is mainly a football club then if football not possible it wouldn't offer an alternative. School lets are often via council hiring a pitch doesn't necessarily give access to school building.

If it is selling its self as after school care then they should have a back up plan.

DangerousAlchemy · 22/11/2022 08:51

FancyANewID · 21/11/2022 18:42

If you're going to collect thirty four year olds, accept payment for doing so and not allow parents to attend - why don't we as parents have enough power as consumers to say actually, that is childcare as well as football

Lol. Good luck with the next 12 years or so of school and clubs and activities with that attitide op.

Outdoor activities are always at risk of cancellation due to poor weather. No, the football/rugby/netball/whatever coach doesn't usually plan a nice afternoon of colouring instead to turn the extra curricular sport into generic childcare. 🤦🏻‍♀️😂

Exactly this! My DS after school football training is cancelled on the day/after school fairly often- parents don't get an email or alert & the kid just has to make their own way home/ring parents when school finishes to try & get a lift (Secondary school age). I know this is slightly different as the football coach is also a teacher so he is volunteering his time but that's the way all after school clubs are run ime. What if your DD injured herself playing football? These things can easily happen playing sports on wet & muddy fields. The football coaches aren't babysitters - they are there to coach football & nothing else. It's not up to them to come up with different indoor activities if the sport can't be played due to bad weather! I'd suggest you find a football activity that's held at weekends - but be aware you might need to stay & watch when the kids are only 4 years old. You can't always drop & run with these kind of sporting activities.

Plumbear2 · 22/11/2022 08:42

Redebs · 22/11/2022 07:48

I think afterschool activities providers need to accept that they ARE in fact part of people's childcare arrangements. Working parents don't get the rest of the afternoon off if it rains!
There needs to be a Plan B in case of bad weather and indoor facilities are available in most schools.

But that's not the clubs responsibility. If they require that care they need to look elsewhere. Asking them to provide care aswell will up the price for everyone. If the need care then pay for it elsewhere and leave the club to do what it was designed for.

MountainChalet · 22/11/2022 08:31

Before I enrolled my ds in his afterschool soccer I was made aware that it will be done outdoors since there's no hall available. I still went ahead because I can collect him at 3pm instead of 4pm. I wouldn't have signed for it if I couldn't.

needabreak5 · 22/11/2022 08:28

this is really tricky, as external activity clubs do get cancelled a lot (I have 2 young primary DC and need full time wraparound too). Ours is easier as the school are very accommodating and will just put them straight into the normal after school childcare provision if the club is cancelled and we can’t collect (parents need to pay on the day if they haven’t already booked it). However it’s on site and run by the school, and they adjust staff numbers supervising last minute to take into account the number of kids there. The flexible wraparound is the main reason we chose the school!

NoodleQueen84 · 22/11/2022 08:17

Yes, YABU. They provide an activity not childcare. If you want childcare, pay for a childminder or use the school afterschool tea club.

funtycucker · 22/11/2022 08:16

GristleToesAndWhine · 22/11/2022 08:12

If two parents are expected to work to afford to run a household, then the whole school and holiday system needs a shake up to allow that to happen.

This. It's not this specific's club's fault (imo) - they can only do what they can do. But there needs to be universally available good, safe, reliable, affordable care from 8am till 6pm if parents are going to be expected to hold down 2 x full time jobs.

IMO this means employers stepping up a bit as well. Or a single, average wage needs to be enough to live on.

But it isn't the responsibility of a school to provide childcare outside of core education hours. Yes it's a nice to have if they do provide wrap around care, but that's all it is. It's not mandatory. I don't see how the school holidays could be reformed when teachers aren't contracted or paid for the holidays.

GristleToesAndWhine · 22/11/2022 08:12

If two parents are expected to work to afford to run a household, then the whole school and holiday system needs a shake up to allow that to happen.

This. It's not this specific's club's fault (imo) - they can only do what they can do. But there needs to be universally available good, safe, reliable, affordable care from 8am till 6pm if parents are going to be expected to hold down 2 x full time jobs.

IMO this means employers stepping up a bit as well. Or a single, average wage needs to be enough to live on.

Saniner1 · 22/11/2022 08:05

I think the OP and other posters need to take into account who are running after school clubs. A larger more professional company is one thing, but round here after school
clubs are run by parent volunteers helped by senior school pupils wanting to gain coaching experience. That or they are one man band instructors looking to make a small amount of extra income (and I mean small) and they run the classes because they are committed to sports development. No one is making a fortune from these classes and they are not childcare.

I‘ve helped / volunteered with after school
clubs and other evening clubs and community groups for a number of years. The other side of the coin is that the behaviour of some parents is shocking tbh. Late payment / non payment, not telling you when kids won’t turn up, not collecting kids on time (regularly rather than one offs). And that’s before we get to those parents who think their kid is a sporting superstar and who also know much more about the sport than the coaches, so little Jimmy / Jemima should be in xyz position and how dare they not be in the starting line up for the next match. Add in those parents who won’t accept that their kids are anything less than perfect behaviour wise. I’ll be honest, I’m amazed anyone still wants to run after school clubs or Scouts, Guides etc.

OP is correct that contingency needs to be in place and that rain in November isn’t unpredictable. So the onus is on OP to check / be prepared and to have that contingency thought out in case, which she had with the ASC.

Being a working parent with small kids is hard, but the responsibility for managing and coordinating and preparing contingencies for after school activities lies with the parents, not anyone else. It’s pretty entitled to expect others to do that for you, especially if they are volunteering or a small scale business coach.

Schools are there to educate your kids. After school activities are hobbies. Neither are childcare.

QueenoftheFarts · 22/11/2022 07:59

I run an afterschool club. The contingency plan is your job. We aren't childcare, we are a sporting activity and sometimes, for unavoidable reasons (usually something to do with the school, like they have comandeered our space for something else), we have to cancel.

Sennelier1 · 22/11/2022 07:58

I think you want to be very gratefull for the care your child already gets at school with afterschool minding and being shuttled around etc. You are in a luxury situation as it is.

Crazydoglady1980 · 22/11/2022 07:55

The issue is that sports clubs and child care providers have very different rules and guidance to follow. The sports club may not be working at the level required to offer childcare, such as of stead registered and staff CRB checked and therefore they can’t offer this, and have to send the children home when they can’t offer the service advertised

itsgettingweird · 22/11/2022 07:52

I would expect an activity you paid for to have contingency plans for something as obvious as inclement weather.

My ds is a swimmer. Sometimes that gets cancelled for reasons outside control (chlorine etc) but you can't plan around that!

If I paid for him to remain at school for an hour every week I'd expect that he remain at school for that hour every week.

I'd also expect the school to be more accommodating to an outside company they are charging to use their facilities - for their own pupils to access after school.

LaGioconda · 22/11/2022 07:49

The issue really lies with the school and its refusal to allow the club to carry on using a classroom in the event of bad weather. It's a bit silly that they're still using the covid excuse and perhaps you could talk to the head about rethinking this.