Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking that meal planning can’t be out of the ordinary?

361 replies

Fono · 21/11/2022 11:30

I’ve always operated a system within my household where I will sit down every Sunday morning and plan all of our meals (lunch and dinner) for the following week and then formulate my shopping list based on everything we need specifically for those meals. This means we have minimal wastage at the end of any given week, prevents over-buying and everyone knows exactly what we are eating and when.

I have a board in our kitchen where I’ll write up the meals for the week and recently every time I’ve had a visitor to the house I’m met with the same shocked reaction about meal planning, like it’s a completely foreign concept.

I’d never previously thought that I did anything out of the ordinary and I’d assumed most households did this? If not, I’m genuinely interested to know what other families do? Imo given the cost of living crisis, meal planning is more important than ever!

OP posts:
FormerCarer · 21/11/2022 15:04

What I really can't understand is why busy families don't all do an online shop (unless they are going to Aldi/Lidl as it is cheaper but they don't deliver). I can't believe the number of busy women (and it usually women) who waste time going to the supermarket!

I do the very occasional online shop but I much prefer to shop in person. I like to pick my own fruit and vegetables so that they're fresh and ripe. I like seeing what new products they have and you don't get yellow stickered items online. I love a bargain especially as it allows me to try items that I'd normally be reluctant to pay full price for. Plus sometimes seeing a random ingredient inspires me.

APurpleSquirrel · 21/11/2022 15:03

I don't do an online shop because I hate not being able to choose the food I want - whether it's fruit/veg or meat etc. we had to do an online shop a couple of times during lockdown due to positive Covid tests & found we got food a day off from its use by date which was absolutely pointless! Normally I'd pick the ones from the back which had near a week on them.
Plus I think it will depend on location - how close you live to a large supermarket, if you commute etc. I work from home & live semi rurally so don't pass any shops on the school run & have no commute. So I go to the supermarket once a week for the main food shop, & possibly once or twice more if we need something specific from another.

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 15:03

Actually I meal plan. Christmas food. Because I have 2 traditional dinners. Is that meal planning even.

DameHelena · 21/11/2022 15:02

mrsm43s · 21/11/2022 14:43

But I genuinely don't understand how, without a plan, you can possibly buy the right ingredients.

You wouldn't put fresh coriander in a fish pie, or fresh parsley in a curry, or fresh dill in a taco. So unless you know whether you're cooking curry or fish pie or Mexican, how do you know which fresh herbs to buy? If you buy them all to keep your options open there's wastage, if you buy none, you food will not taste so good. So without a plan how do you know which to buy?

Some dishes work best with waxy potatoes, some with floury potatoes. How do you know which to buy without a plan? If you buy both, then there's likely to be wastage. If you just buy one, you're likely to end up with less good results in many dishes. So which do you buy?

I genuinely don't get how you can get it right without a plan. Not necessarily a formal written plan, but at the very minimum a loose in your head plan of what you're planning to cook with the food you're buying, and making sure you buy the right combinations to make the dishes you're intending to cook.

Well, I don't get too hung up on whether I should use waxy potatoes or floury ones, for starters.
But you're looking at it the wrong way round. I don't think 'I must cook Mexican tonight – oh shit, I haven't got any coriander!' I look in the veg box and store cupboard and think, 'I've got peppers, onions and some black beans. That sounds a bit Mexican' and look up some recipes. Or if there's lots of root veg and it's a miserable day like today, I'll think of a veg curry, knowing that I've always got rice and the right spices in the cupboard, and whoever is passing the shops on the way home can get some naan breads.

gogohmm · 21/11/2022 15:00

@mast0650

I like the supermarket Blush

I go at least 4 times a week. I find planning stressful whereas I can calculate what I need easier at shorter intervals.

I do do a big shop most weekends that dp pays for, I buy longer life products, household stuff etc but that's usually Lidl, it's literally 2 mins in the car away, we usually walk takes 5-6 mins

ComtesseDeSpair · 21/11/2022 14:58

I also think it’s entirely subjective to your family’s needs whether it’s necessarily more efficient to have a rigid meal plan. Say you’ve planned a roast chicken dinner for Tuesday, risotto with the leftover chicken and vegetables from Tuesday for Wednesday, and quick omelettes for Thursday because you know you’re going to be late home. But then on Tuesday your last meeting at work badly overruns and you don’t get home until 8pm. You can’t roast your chicken because then you wouldn’t eat before 10pm; which means Wednesday’s dinner plans are also out of kilter because there won’t be any leftover roast chicken and vegetables for the risotto, so you now need to think up something else. And you also can’t use the chicken on Thursday because you already know you needed to plan for something quick and easy.

This would happen to us every single week. If all carefully thought out dinners were chalked up on a board in the kitchen we’d constantly be doing the culinary equivalent of wearing Sunday’s “day of the week” underwear on a Tuesday!

mast0650 · 21/11/2022 14:57

I don't think it is extraordinary, but I suspect the majority of people I know don't meal plan.

I planned pretty carefully up until very recently when both my kids went to Uni. I had an Ocado delivery at the same time every week, and therefore every week on the night before I would check my cupboards and fridge, sketch out meals for the week, and do the shopping. Meals might move around, but I'd have a rough idea what we would have when, taking into account how much time I would have, who would be around, and eating stuff that wouldn't last well first.

Since the kids left, I've switched to a weekly veg box which is a bit unpredictable, plus a fortnightly Ocado shop. I'm enjoying experimenting a bit more, and eating more vegetarian food, without the kids turning their noses up and wanting spag bol! It's working well, but meal planning worked better before I think.

What I really can't understand is why busy families don't all do an online shop (unless they are going to Aldi/Lidl as it is cheaper but they don't deliver). I can't believe the number of busy women (and it usually women) who waste time going to the supermarket!

gogohmm · 21/11/2022 14:57

I shop every couple of days to reduce food waste - means nothing goes off in the fridge and I can adapt to changing schedules. Also if we unexpected have leftovers I can utilise them eg I have pork from yesterday and it may do one or two meals depending on who is here for dinner

KirstenBlest · 21/11/2022 14:57

@FivePotatoes , I was thinking of something like pasta in a ready-made sauce, and thought yuk.
The difference, I imagine, is that I will have cooked up a huge batch of it, so only cook once. When I make a curry, there are basic ingredients that I would need to have in, and there are lots of ingredients like spices that are in the store cupboard.

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 14:57

mrsm43s · 21/11/2022 14:43

But I genuinely don't understand how, without a plan, you can possibly buy the right ingredients.

You wouldn't put fresh coriander in a fish pie, or fresh parsley in a curry, or fresh dill in a taco. So unless you know whether you're cooking curry or fish pie or Mexican, how do you know which fresh herbs to buy? If you buy them all to keep your options open there's wastage, if you buy none, you food will not taste so good. So without a plan how do you know which to buy?

Some dishes work best with waxy potatoes, some with floury potatoes. How do you know which to buy without a plan? If you buy both, then there's likely to be wastage. If you just buy one, you're likely to end up with less good results in many dishes. So which do you buy?

I genuinely don't get how you can get it right without a plan. Not necessarily a formal written plan, but at the very minimum a loose in your head plan of what you're planning to cook with the food you're buying, and making sure you buy the right combinations to make the dishes you're intending to cook.

But I just don't understaaaaand.
Right ingredients for what?
You cook based on ingredients you have. Not based on recipe.

I also don't buy fresh herbs. I have my own. If I get some and they don't get used they get chopped into freezer. I have full cupboard of spices and dried herbs. I have stock of basics like tinned tomatoes, dry pulses, etc. Some are just good improvisation chefs, some are good following recipes, it is as simple as that.

I see nice stirfry veg, I buy stirfry veg. Is it going to be used in noodle stir-fry or in rice dish? Maybe made into some kind of spring roll? With fosh or chicken? Who knows. But they will be eaten.

Dill is rank anyway😂

FivePotatoes · 21/11/2022 14:57

kitchenplans · 21/11/2022 14:52

Well mine has crisp, fresh coriander on the top rather than soggy frozen coriander for a start!

You got me there Grin However, I spent my Saturday hiking in the Peak District with friends, rather than the morning meal planning on a special whiteboard and then the afternoon in a supermarket Wink

Suprima · 21/11/2022 14:55

KirstenBlest · 21/11/2022 14:45

@BosaNova , but if you don't meal plan, don't you end up eating whatever you can put together, or end up going shopping again or ordering a takeaway?
Nipping to the corner shop or supermarket usually means you spend more than intended, and takeaways tend to be expensive and unhealthy.

As people have posted- having a good selection of meat in, veggies, a well packed store cupboard and things like fresh chillis and lemon means you can throw infinite things together.

I don’t meal plan. I know I can make at least 10 different things at dinner time. I’m a good cook.

I’ve seen pasta spoken about a lot on here. I don’t need to purposely buy meatballs, pasta sauce and a sachet of hard cheese. Based on what’s in my cupboards I could make:

spaghetti with lemon zest, capers, olive oil
spaghetti with a tomato sauce and meatballs with defrosted mince
spaghetti with sardines and chilli
Use defrosted mince to make normal spag bol
carbonara
cacio e pepe
puttanesca from cupboard stuff

I don’t know why so many people on this thread are acting like we are stirring fresh coriander, prawns and mango together and shoving it in a weird fish pie because that’s what we’ve got in…

kitchenplans · 21/11/2022 14:52

FivePotatoes · 21/11/2022 14:51

if you don't meal plan, don't you end up eating whatever you can put together

Well yes, and it's always delicious and nourishing. I don't understand what's wrong with that? What's the difference between my made-from-scratch curry that I didn't plan and your made-from-scratch curry that you did plan?

Well mine has crisp, fresh coriander on the top rather than soggy frozen coriander for a start!

Icannoteven · 21/11/2022 14:51

We meal plan but not to the same extent as you do, that sounds a bit extreme. How do you cope when something unexpected happens e.g someone is home from school I'll and needs lunch or you have a medical appt and don't have time to cook?

We just make sure we have enough meals for 7 days (veg/sides are interchangeable) and a selection of lunch type things /snacks that everyone likes. Then we decide which meal to cook based on use by dates/ energy levels/ time/ what we feel like that day.

We still wind up by takeaways and wasting food tho 😬

My parents didn't need to meal an growing up because they had plenty of storage space for food - we have a tiny freezer and lack of cupboard space.

FivePotatoes · 21/11/2022 14:51

if you don't meal plan, don't you end up eating whatever you can put together

Well yes, and it's always delicious and nourishing. I don't understand what's wrong with that? What's the difference between my made-from-scratch curry that I didn't plan and your made-from-scratch curry that you did plan?

fruitsaladsweets · 21/11/2022 14:49

I think it's obvious that meal planning is going to be more efficient, in terms of less waste and less time spent thinking about food.

Doesn't mean it's the right thing for everyone. Some people don't like to plan everything in such detail, some like to be more creative on the spur of the moment, it might involve nipping out to the shop on the day for something you don't have in, but some people prefer that as and when approach.

Basically everyone's different and it's all fine 😅

medicatedgift · 21/11/2022 14:48

I rarely use fresh herbs, I use dried because I don't have capability to grow fresh beyond a pot of basil on the kitchen windowsill.

Surely that's not unusual?

Sage396 · 21/11/2022 14:48

We plan, and keep a list of the meals on the fridge. On the weeks we end up not planning for whatever reason, our meals get really unhealthy, or we end up ordering takeaway.

I also find it really helpful for making sure I don't have too much food accumulating in the freezer or cupboards, as we base the majority of our meals on what's already in the house. I don't care how other people manage their lives but I'm definitely stressed out at the thought of how some of my friends approach meals, e.g. literally deciding what's for the dinner as they walk into the kitchen go make something, or going to the shops every day of the week.

FivePotatoes · 21/11/2022 14:48

You wouldn't put fresh coriander in a fish pie, or fresh parsley in a curry, or fresh dill in a taco. So unless you know whether you're cooking curry or fish pie or Mexican, how do you know which fresh herbs to buy?

I chop up all my fresh herbs and freeze them, and then I always have coriander to hand if I fancy a curry. Same for parsley, dill, basil, mint, chillies, garlic, ginger, etc. It can all be frozen.

fruitsaladsweets · 21/11/2022 14:47

@mrsm43s Maybe they use more dried herbs? Not everyone uses fresh herbs. Maybe they are a bit more creative and thrown together combinations that are a bit unusual.

I don't think it's impossible, my friend does it and she is an amazing cook. But it would be too much stress for me - I prefer to meal plan.

FormerCarer · 21/11/2022 14:46

but if you don't meal plan, don't you end up eating whatever you can put together,

What's wrong with just putting something together?

FivePotatoes · 21/11/2022 14:45

People on this thread who keep posting I just can't understand how people manage without meal planning, there have been loads of us explaining how we manage. What's so hard to understand? Or are you just not reading our posts?

KirstenBlest · 21/11/2022 14:45

@BosaNova , but if you don't meal plan, don't you end up eating whatever you can put together, or end up going shopping again or ordering a takeaway?
Nipping to the corner shop or supermarket usually means you spend more than intended, and takeaways tend to be expensive and unhealthy.

APurpleSquirrel · 21/11/2022 14:44

I've been meal planning since I was a Uni student & we needed to make our budget stretch.
I plan the dinners for the full week based on what activities are happening that day (after school clubs/meetings etc). I try not to have the same protein or carb two days in a row; quick meals for days we don't have much time, etc.
DH usually does the cooking now, & we have two freezers, large fridge & stocked cupboards.
We tend to freeze most meats, bread etc on day of purchase as this reduces waste.
We have flexibility in the menu; if we don't fancy x we change it to y; if we decide to eat out/takeaway etc we move the meal to the next day, or usually as the meat is frozen it can shift to the following week. Veg doesn't go off quickly, & gets used in pasta sauce etc, fruit gets used in cakes/jam/smoothies if past it's best.
I don't rigidly plan breakfast/lunch, but make sure we have our regular options in.
It's certainly less stressful for us to have a plan - which is in the back of my shopping list & is pinned on the fridge.

mrsm43s · 21/11/2022 14:43

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 14:27

People need to stop implying that everyone who doesn't plan cooks shite food and wastes a lot...

It shouldn't be that hard to comprehend, people can still shop just enough and cook nice food even if they didn't spend hours planning it before shop. Same like it's not hard to comprehend some people prefer or need to do that planning. 🙄
Some of us are even such magical creatures who shop once a week only as well.

But I genuinely don't understand how, without a plan, you can possibly buy the right ingredients.

You wouldn't put fresh coriander in a fish pie, or fresh parsley in a curry, or fresh dill in a taco. So unless you know whether you're cooking curry or fish pie or Mexican, how do you know which fresh herbs to buy? If you buy them all to keep your options open there's wastage, if you buy none, you food will not taste so good. So without a plan how do you know which to buy?

Some dishes work best with waxy potatoes, some with floury potatoes. How do you know which to buy without a plan? If you buy both, then there's likely to be wastage. If you just buy one, you're likely to end up with less good results in many dishes. So which do you buy?

I genuinely don't get how you can get it right without a plan. Not necessarily a formal written plan, but at the very minimum a loose in your head plan of what you're planning to cook with the food you're buying, and making sure you buy the right combinations to make the dishes you're intending to cook.