Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking that meal planning can’t be out of the ordinary?

361 replies

Fono · 21/11/2022 11:30

I’ve always operated a system within my household where I will sit down every Sunday morning and plan all of our meals (lunch and dinner) for the following week and then formulate my shopping list based on everything we need specifically for those meals. This means we have minimal wastage at the end of any given week, prevents over-buying and everyone knows exactly what we are eating and when.

I have a board in our kitchen where I’ll write up the meals for the week and recently every time I’ve had a visitor to the house I’m met with the same shocked reaction about meal planning, like it’s a completely foreign concept.

I’d never previously thought that I did anything out of the ordinary and I’d assumed most households did this? If not, I’m genuinely interested to know what other families do? Imo given the cost of living crisis, meal planning is more important than ever!

OP posts:
DarkMatternix · 21/11/2022 15:52

Improptu "shakshuka" (and now I fancy it!) for example is basically just house staples.

Me too, alas the egg shortage has reached these parts and not a single egg to be had in the supermarket at the weekend

UsingChangeofName · 21/11/2022 15:51

Bit tricky to know which way to vote, as clearly you aren't unreasonable to plan that tightly if it suits you and your family, but equally clearly YABVU to think that most other people are that anal rigid in planning their eating.

I've asked a few people, after hearing of meal planning on MN, and I've never met anyone that does it to that extent.
I think many people - with families particularly - will plan to some extent ("Oh, the Grandparents are coming over on Sunday so we'll have a roast then, and there isn't much time on Tue because of that activity starting so early so that will be a beans on toast night, then I haven't got much time on Friday so I'll double the bolognaise I make on Wed and people can use that as a base with some wraps or pasta or something when we get in). However, recording every single meal for the week without any flexibility sounds a bit more than most people need to do, or find helpful.

DameHelena · 21/11/2022 15:51

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 15:48

It does, doesn't it! I am often undecided until just before meal so having basics is a must. Improptu "shakshuka" (and now I fancy it!) for example is basically just house staples.
Tinned tomato, eggs, bread, onion, garlic, chili. Spice to your heart desire. But it's a lovely throw together without needing shopping for it dish since it's just general cupboard staples.

One thing I have done in the past but must do more regularly is chop and freeze onion, garlic, ginger, lemongrass etc in bulk. Makes such a difference if you don't have to go and buy new, or skin and chop them all, before you start cooking proper.

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 15:48

DameHelena · 21/11/2022 15:42

I think so. I've always had a stock of herbs and spices at home, because obviously you buy quite a big jar or bag compared to how much you use at a time. Then in the pandemic, when you couldn't go shopping much, I started, not bulk-buying exactly, but buying several 4-packs of tomatoes or lots of chickpeas, or jars of anchovies, where I'd previously buy one. I realised it worked really well and I've kept it up. It has made cooking easier and more relaxed.

It does, doesn't it! I am often undecided until just before meal so having basics is a must. Improptu "shakshuka" (and now I fancy it!) for example is basically just house staples.
Tinned tomato, eggs, bread, onion, garlic, chili. Spice to your heart desire. But it's a lovely throw together without needing shopping for it dish since it's just general cupboard staples.

DarkMatternix · 21/11/2022 15:48

I think I've only ever known one family ever plan to the degree you've suggested.

And yes, i do just buy some fresh ingredients each week and then decide what to do with it, minced beef can become burgers, spaghetti bolognese, beef tacos, cottage pie etc. Chicken may end up as fajitas, chicken goujons, curry, stir fry, tagine. Most of these things require the same sort of fresh ingredients, e.g. onion/pepper and other things would either be from the pantry (i.e. tinned tomatoes), from the garden depending on time of year, or from the freezer.

Admittedly, i do end up sometimes googling "alternatives for...." but normally works out ok, e.g. most recently was using some miso paste with water instead of worcestershire sauce in a cottage pie. That sort of thing definitely saves me money over buying exactly what i need for a recipe.

swg1 · 21/11/2022 15:45

I think it helps to have a few base things that your family will always eat as well that use up ingredients.

If my oven is on I usually use the bottom shelf for a rice pudding. I always always have pudding rice in and it's great for using up extra milk. My kids love it.

Or if I have bread on the turn and eggs to use up I make a bread and jam pudding (like bread and butter but my kids dislike dried fruit).

If I'm kneedeep in eggs (my friends have chickens) then I usually have a few baking mixes I pick up cheap and allow the kids to use them with minimal supervision to make cake.

DameHelena · 21/11/2022 15:42

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 15:37

I do wonder if that difference in here is as well about stocking up. Like some people don't have herbs, spices and basics generally at home it seems so it's a different style of shopping to someone who has lots of basics.
Again, no one is wrong, just different styles of shopping and stocking up.
I could get the mlst ridiculous Chopped (fun show) basket and still manage to make meals out of it, because I have so strong base stock levels, anything can find flavour and texture friends.

I think so. I've always had a stock of herbs and spices at home, because obviously you buy quite a big jar or bag compared to how much you use at a time. Then in the pandemic, when you couldn't go shopping much, I started, not bulk-buying exactly, but buying several 4-packs of tomatoes or lots of chickpeas, or jars of anchovies, where I'd previously buy one. I realised it worked really well and I've kept it up. It has made cooking easier and more relaxed.

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 15:37

DameHelena · 21/11/2022 15:30

Well, I don't feel like I need always to offer an exhaustive list of ingredients and accoutrements. No one in my house is going to kick off if I serve something involving black beans and peppers that omits sour cream or fresh chillis, or a curry that in the recipe has lentils but in my version has chick peas woe betide their arse if they do
Things like limes and avocado I always have in. And I buy those trays of fresh chillis and freeze them. Maybe the difference from a lot of people on here is that we live in a busy neighbourhood with lots of corner shops/greengrocers/supermarkets, and we all walk to and from work, or work from home, so it's trivial for one of us to pop to a shop or to go in on our way home from somewhere. I or someone else can always get fresh coriander, or lime pickle if we've run out, or e.g. sausages if I've got corn on the cob and tomatoes in and decide to roast them and add meat.

I think you're defining 'meal planning' loosely, which is fine; but what this thread is really talking about (the OP anyway) is planning in the way she does it, with a pre-planned shopping list and a board. People like me aren't saying we either shop for every meal from a standing start, or throw together arbitrary things just because we've got them in the house. We're just saying we don't do one shop and plan in advance exactly what we'll cook from it.

I do wonder if that difference in here is as well about stocking up. Like some people don't have herbs, spices and basics generally at home it seems so it's a different style of shopping to someone who has lots of basics.
Again, no one is wrong, just different styles of shopping and stocking up.
I could get the mlst ridiculous Chopped (fun show) basket and still manage to make meals out of it, because I have so strong base stock levels, anything can find flavour and texture friends.

swg1 · 21/11/2022 15:36

kitchenplans · 21/11/2022 15:19

See I get the bit about looking at what you have and saying "I've got peppers, onions and black beans - basis for Mexican." But I don't understand how you could have co-incidetally, without any thought or planning, just happened to have also bought fresh coriander, fresh chilli, a fresh lime, sour cream, avocado etc. So either lots of the essential ingredients are missing, or some sort of planning process is going on when you shop, albeit a loose, informal one.

I don't actually think the non planners cook shite (although surely there will be a subset who just do basics and convenience food). I think its more likely that most people put more effort into planning their meals and their shopping than they acknowledge.

For example, seeing a delicious looking aubergine and buying courgette/pepper/red onion etc to go with it thinking "I could cooking a nice mediterranean vegetable dish with that lot" is a loose form of planning. As is thinking "I fancy pasta this week, I'll make sure I pick up parmesan/pecorino, fresh lemon, fresh tomatoes, fresh basil etc".

If you're not putting any thought at all into what you're likely to cook and just chucking random stuff in the trolley then its inevitable that there will be food waste, poorly made dishes or the need for top up shops. I don't think many people do that though. They plan loosely in their head as they shop. It may not be rigid, it may not be written down, but it's still a plan.

I think you're thinking of most people as being more exact in recipes than they are!

I don't remember the last time I bought fresh herbs - they're incredibly expensive and don't last so I only do it when they're reduced. I have a few growing in the garden that I'll wander out to pick and otherwise it's dry/jarred/make do without. Chilli is jarred or there's chilli powder. I've only got fresh tomatoes in if they're reduced/in my veg box/the kids asked for them but I always have tinned tomatoes in. Sour cream and guac come in bottles - yes not as good but cheaper and they keep. If I don't have a red onion in I'll use an onion - maybe not as good but I always have onions.

I'm not badly off but frankly I cannot afford to buy exact fresh ingredients for every recipe. So we have a good store-cupboard in of basics and those are used as my building blocks to fill in the fresh ingredients I do have. There's a few fall-backs that I use constantly so those I do always try to keep in, either fresh or in the freezer - dried pasta, cream, grated cheese (mozzarella and cheddar), fresh mozzarella, bacon, bread, onions, broccoli or cauli, milk, bananas, eggs, potatoes, chicken thighs - those are our necessities that I will use over and over again. Everything else I use if I have it, make do if I don't.

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 15:33

I don't get why people don't get that someone plans and someone doesn't.
It is that fucking simple, no one is superior and any of the two can cook nice meals. Same with people who follow recipes and people who like to generally improvise.
🙄

"BuT Do YoU hAvE tHe RiGhT PotAtO" i have a potato, that is quite enough🤷🏻

Phrenologistsfinger · 21/11/2022 15:33

It’s a fun game, what do you need to use up that day and how can you make it into a tasty meal? I rarely use recipes anyway as I’m confident with flavours and improvisation (exDP was a chef).

SleeplessInEngland · 21/11/2022 15:31

Recently started meal planning and wish I'd done it ages ago. I find thinking of what to eat every single evening genuinely wearisome.

DameHelena · 21/11/2022 15:30

kitchenplans · 21/11/2022 15:19

See I get the bit about looking at what you have and saying "I've got peppers, onions and black beans - basis for Mexican." But I don't understand how you could have co-incidetally, without any thought or planning, just happened to have also bought fresh coriander, fresh chilli, a fresh lime, sour cream, avocado etc. So either lots of the essential ingredients are missing, or some sort of planning process is going on when you shop, albeit a loose, informal one.

I don't actually think the non planners cook shite (although surely there will be a subset who just do basics and convenience food). I think its more likely that most people put more effort into planning their meals and their shopping than they acknowledge.

For example, seeing a delicious looking aubergine and buying courgette/pepper/red onion etc to go with it thinking "I could cooking a nice mediterranean vegetable dish with that lot" is a loose form of planning. As is thinking "I fancy pasta this week, I'll make sure I pick up parmesan/pecorino, fresh lemon, fresh tomatoes, fresh basil etc".

If you're not putting any thought at all into what you're likely to cook and just chucking random stuff in the trolley then its inevitable that there will be food waste, poorly made dishes or the need for top up shops. I don't think many people do that though. They plan loosely in their head as they shop. It may not be rigid, it may not be written down, but it's still a plan.

Well, I don't feel like I need always to offer an exhaustive list of ingredients and accoutrements. No one in my house is going to kick off if I serve something involving black beans and peppers that omits sour cream or fresh chillis, or a curry that in the recipe has lentils but in my version has chick peas woe betide their arse if they do
Things like limes and avocado I always have in. And I buy those trays of fresh chillis and freeze them. Maybe the difference from a lot of people on here is that we live in a busy neighbourhood with lots of corner shops/greengrocers/supermarkets, and we all walk to and from work, or work from home, so it's trivial for one of us to pop to a shop or to go in on our way home from somewhere. I or someone else can always get fresh coriander, or lime pickle if we've run out, or e.g. sausages if I've got corn on the cob and tomatoes in and decide to roast them and add meat.

I think you're defining 'meal planning' loosely, which is fine; but what this thread is really talking about (the OP anyway) is planning in the way she does it, with a pre-planned shopping list and a board. People like me aren't saying we either shop for every meal from a standing start, or throw together arbitrary things just because we've got them in the house. We're just saying we don't do one shop and plan in advance exactly what we'll cook from it.

Phrenologistsfinger · 21/11/2022 15:29

ChristmasCakeAndStilton · 21/11/2022 12:29

Why does not mean planning mean it needs to be convince food?
I can cook. I can look at ingredients and turn them in to something. I rarely use a recipie, unless we are trying something new, or I'm baking.

This!

lentil stew, indian veg curry, chickpeas in veg pasta sauce, chilli bean todu and rice,, cashew and tempeh stir fry, tofu thai curry, veg sausages, kale & mash or veg and bean fajitas all can be whipped up within 20-30 mins based on what I have in the fridge, freezer and pantry. No recipe needed, always plenty of veg and protein. No need to use convenience foods, why would there be?

swg1 · 21/11/2022 15:26

ComtesseDeSpair · 21/11/2022 14:58

I also think it’s entirely subjective to your family’s needs whether it’s necessarily more efficient to have a rigid meal plan. Say you’ve planned a roast chicken dinner for Tuesday, risotto with the leftover chicken and vegetables from Tuesday for Wednesday, and quick omelettes for Thursday because you know you’re going to be late home. But then on Tuesday your last meeting at work badly overruns and you don’t get home until 8pm. You can’t roast your chicken because then you wouldn’t eat before 10pm; which means Wednesday’s dinner plans are also out of kilter because there won’t be any leftover roast chicken and vegetables for the risotto, so you now need to think up something else. And you also can’t use the chicken on Thursday because you already know you needed to plan for something quick and easy.

This would happen to us every single week. If all carefully thought out dinners were chalked up on a board in the kitchen we’d constantly be doing the culinary equivalent of wearing Sunday’s “day of the week” underwear on a Tuesday!

I assume this is why the "old style" way of doing things is roast dinner on a Sunday when you could assume everyone would be home because the world shut down and then leftovers from it through the week.

Friday123 · 21/11/2022 15:20

I don't meal plan because I don't know what I'll want to eat on a given day. I'm unlikely to bother cooking something I'm not in the mood to eat. I have staples (rice, noodles, pasta, chips, veggie meats, various beans, nuts, spices, frozen veg etc) and just rummage around in the cupboards/freezer/fridge until I decide what I want. If there's something nice reduced in the supermarket I'll plan a meal around that.

kitchenplans · 21/11/2022 15:19

DameHelena · 21/11/2022 15:02

Well, I don't get too hung up on whether I should use waxy potatoes or floury ones, for starters.
But you're looking at it the wrong way round. I don't think 'I must cook Mexican tonight – oh shit, I haven't got any coriander!' I look in the veg box and store cupboard and think, 'I've got peppers, onions and some black beans. That sounds a bit Mexican' and look up some recipes. Or if there's lots of root veg and it's a miserable day like today, I'll think of a veg curry, knowing that I've always got rice and the right spices in the cupboard, and whoever is passing the shops on the way home can get some naan breads.

See I get the bit about looking at what you have and saying "I've got peppers, onions and black beans - basis for Mexican." But I don't understand how you could have co-incidetally, without any thought or planning, just happened to have also bought fresh coriander, fresh chilli, a fresh lime, sour cream, avocado etc. So either lots of the essential ingredients are missing, or some sort of planning process is going on when you shop, albeit a loose, informal one.

I don't actually think the non planners cook shite (although surely there will be a subset who just do basics and convenience food). I think its more likely that most people put more effort into planning their meals and their shopping than they acknowledge.

For example, seeing a delicious looking aubergine and buying courgette/pepper/red onion etc to go with it thinking "I could cooking a nice mediterranean vegetable dish with that lot" is a loose form of planning. As is thinking "I fancy pasta this week, I'll make sure I pick up parmesan/pecorino, fresh lemon, fresh tomatoes, fresh basil etc".

If you're not putting any thought at all into what you're likely to cook and just chucking random stuff in the trolley then its inevitable that there will be food waste, poorly made dishes or the need for top up shops. I don't think many people do that though. They plan loosely in their head as they shop. It may not be rigid, it may not be written down, but it's still a plan.

notacooldad · 21/11/2022 15:15

Just do this every week and you'll never need to do a supermarket shop ever again.
Actually, you could be on to something there!

This week is looking equally chaotic, and it's only Monday!

Diedre44 · 21/11/2022 15:13

I can't meal plan for shit. I have tried and tried and tried. 3 adults, freezer full of food and it's spag bol, nacho chilli, toad in the hole, chicken curry.
I've been trying all year to empty my freezer and I just keep filling it back up. I could feed the street with the food in there. It's a childhood trauma response that I really struggle with I must have plenty of everything - just incase. I don't stockpile so much as just need to have 2 of most things. I do feel guilty given current cost of living crisis and people using food banks. I'm working my way through my baking cupboard atm to use up as much of it as possible, aiming to get to just having to replace items as and when they are needed and then I'll get to my tin/pasta cupboards. Might share pictures for reference...
I am terrible, I know.

Goldenbear · 21/11/2022 15:13

Online shopping is so longwinded and I don't want someone to tie me down with delivery slots. It just doesn't suit my way of thinking. Depends what's on at work as well, I mightt need to throw myself in to something and mostly I'm terrible in these scenarios, dinner slips my mind until the DC ask if they will be fed any time soon! My DC would faint with surprise if I had plans on fridges!

SleeplessInEngland · 21/11/2022 15:08

notacooldad · 21/11/2022 15:04

Actually some weeks I meal plan I end up wasting more food than I save.

Two weeks ago I planned Sunday to Saturday's meal for the week with no meal plan on the Wednesday as I was working late and DH was going to have tea with DS.

What actually happened was on Sunday Ds and gf turned up unexpectedly and took us out for tea.

Monday Dh didn't feel great and couldn't face eating. I went out with my friend to the cinema ( unplanned)

Tuesday I was asked if I could work late instead of Wednesday so I did that. Wednesday DH had already made arrangements to go out as I was supposed to be working so I invited my friend round and we just had dips, breadsticks and ncie things
Thursday Dh came home after having a bad day and said the infamous words 'pub! now!' so we went out to a nice country pub and had a meal there.
Friday Dh suggested we go away for the weekend so we went to Dumfries until Sunday.

So not one meal from the plan!

Just do this every week and you'll never need to do a supermarket shop ever again.

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 15:07

That should have said 90% of my regular weekly shopping

BosaNova · 21/11/2022 15:06

Online shop often doesn't work for me because 90% of my shopping is fresh. It's great though when I need to stock up on non perishables!
Tried ordering fresh as well but wasn't as happy with it as when I pick it myself.

notacooldad · 21/11/2022 15:04

Actually some weeks I meal plan I end up wasting more food than I save.

Two weeks ago I planned Sunday to Saturday's meal for the week with no meal plan on the Wednesday as I was working late and DH was going to have tea with DS.

What actually happened was on Sunday Ds and gf turned up unexpectedly and took us out for tea.

Monday Dh didn't feel great and couldn't face eating. I went out with my friend to the cinema ( unplanned)

Tuesday I was asked if I could work late instead of Wednesday so I did that. Wednesday DH had already made arrangements to go out as I was supposed to be working so I invited my friend round and we just had dips, breadsticks and ncie things
Thursday Dh came home after having a bad day and said the infamous words 'pub! now!' so we went out to a nice country pub and had a meal there.
Friday Dh suggested we go away for the weekend so we went to Dumfries until Sunday.

So not one meal from the plan!

medicatedgift · 21/11/2022 15:04

Friday night I hadn't been shopping and I couldn't be arsed. I usually get take away but I couldn't even be bothered to do that. I had a look in the fridge and wasn't inspired so went to the freezer and cupboards, googled the ingredients I'd found, got a bbc good food recipe that was close enough but I adapted slightly - cooked and ate it. Leftovers in the freezer.

How is that some sort of sad way to be? I don't get it?