Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking that meal planning can’t be out of the ordinary?

361 replies

Fono · 21/11/2022 11:30

I’ve always operated a system within my household where I will sit down every Sunday morning and plan all of our meals (lunch and dinner) for the following week and then formulate my shopping list based on everything we need specifically for those meals. This means we have minimal wastage at the end of any given week, prevents over-buying and everyone knows exactly what we are eating and when.

I have a board in our kitchen where I’ll write up the meals for the week and recently every time I’ve had a visitor to the house I’m met with the same shocked reaction about meal planning, like it’s a completely foreign concept.

I’d never previously thought that I did anything out of the ordinary and I’d assumed most households did this? If not, I’m genuinely interested to know what other families do? Imo given the cost of living crisis, meal planning is more important than ever!

OP posts:
ILoveCats89 · 22/11/2022 23:45

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 23:36

Good news! You can freeze them 😁
Also Napolina makes small cans but it is cheaoer to buy full size and freeze the rest.

Wouldn't even have thought of freezing them. Usually use half and throw away the rest

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 23:36

ILoveCats89 · 22/11/2022 23:21

The only food we waste is kidney beans for chilli as a whole tin is too much and they don't do smaller tins. I guess I plan to some extent as each week why buy bolognese sauce mince and spaghetti (dont put veg in it as DSS wouldn’t eat it)

Good news! You can freeze them 😁
Also Napolina makes small cans but it is cheaoer to buy full size and freeze the rest.

UsingChangeofName · 22/11/2022 23:23

I'm not sure why so many planners seem to think people who don't have a rigid meal plan written out then waste food Confused

I very rarely throw away any food at all.
But everyone writes on the list when they see something is running low - so we've always got staples like tinned toms, pasta, onions, cheese etc, then I go to the meat / fish section and look what looks appealing / has a long enough date / on a good week what is on special offer / sometimes something catches my eye and I think we've not had it for a while.
That is the basis of the meals, then I go and buy the veg to suit the protein that is there which is why I can't understand why so many supermarkets have the veg first
Often I will buy something like some chicken breast or a packet of mince, without knowing which of several regular dishes we will make with it that week, but I know there are a few options without needing to buy any ingredients that are peculiar to that dish.
Obviously nobody goes and buys random ingredients as someone said earlier like on Masterchef, but I have no idea on a Monday what dish whoever is cooking on Thursday might make with that mince.
But rest assured no food gets thrown away.
The person who mentioned celery - if I have celery left and it's crunch has gone, I chop it up small, put it in the freezer, then add it to various slow cooker meals to fill them out a bit / sneak a bit of hidden veg in. I wouldn't have to start hunting down a specific celery dish - same with the cauliflower mentioned. Chop, freeze, use when you want to.

ILoveCats89 · 22/11/2022 23:21

The only food we waste is kidney beans for chilli as a whole tin is too much and they don't do smaller tins. I guess I plan to some extent as each week why buy bolognese sauce mince and spaghetti (dont put veg in it as DSS wouldn’t eat it)

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 22:19

I wonder if we are from same country @katepilar
As well grew up on some random white potato so don't care for types and spent childhood picking tons of mushrooms I don't eat.
By any chance. Is it normal to go "borrow" onions from fields around villages where you are from?😂

I also grew up with "if you like it savour it, I don't remember what's in it." Type of dishes which were never the same twice😂

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 22:15

katepilar · 22/11/2022 21:13

Without much own experience I know that freezing herbs can be also done in ice cubes, with water. Also freezig them first spread out on a tray before putting them into a bag or container should avoid chopped herbs getting stuck into one big ball that is sometimes hard to break up.

Alternative is also drying teh herbs if they would go to waste otherwise.

Also most herbs last longer if stored in a glass of water in the fridge.

All this is great to freeze spread on a tray and then move into the bag if it's a full bag worth.
I even have a dehydrator now because it was too much for freezing😂
You can freeze chickpea as well if you have left over. Defrosts quickly after.

My freezer and cupboards are like hoarder's flat. Full to burst of random stuff😂

katepilar · 22/11/2022 22:03

mrsm43s · 21/11/2022 14:22

All these no plan/think up the recipe on the day people, how do you know if you need waxy potatoes or floury potatoes?, button mushrooms, shitake mushrooms or chestnut mushrooms,? white onions, red onions or green onions? fresh coriander or fresh basil or fresh parsley or fresh dill?, Fresh ginger or fresh chillis? feta cheese or marscapone or pecorino or strong cheddar?, or lime juice/zest or lemon juice/zest or orange juice/zest?

I just can't fathom how, without some plan (be in written on in your head) how someone could happen to come up with exactly the right ingredients without either wastage or having ingredients missing.

I understand that you could think - "I'll do Mexican - I'll make sure I buy a lime and fresh coriander. fresh red chilli, avocado etc" etc - and if you had taco shells, tortillas, spices, black beans, tinned toms etc in the cupboard, a selection of meat in the freezer and a good selection of veg you could finalise the exact dish later - but to me that is planning Mexican and buying certain ingredients accordingly. Albeit that it's a loose plan and in your head.

Just randomly shoving stuff in your trolley with no vague idea of what you are likely to make with it is surely going to lead to either wastage, substandard meals with compromise ingredients or extra shops to pick up top ups once you've decided on the meal. And if you have got an idea of what to make and so shop accordingly and buy the correct ingredients for that, then that's a plan!

Thank you for the interesting insight. I have never understood all these posts about mealplanning and /not/ having the right ingrediences.

I dont care about type of potatoes. They werent even a thing when I was growing up. I buy them at a farmers market where they arent coded anyway. The only time to looks for potato type is when getting a big sack of potatoes for the winter, in that case they need to be the type suitable for storage.

I am not a mushroom person so dont care about those. But generally in my home country mushrooms are something you go to and pick in the woods rather they buy in the shops eventhough you can get all the "supermarket" type of mushrooms as well.

Onions - again, I dont care about type of onions. Just have onions, lots of onions that go into any meal.

I think the difference is that when you are cooking you have a fixed idea what a certain meals consists of and need exactly that to cook it. Which is fine but I wouldnt do that for everyday cooking. Everyday cooking is more of a lets see what I've got and what can I do with it that I feel like eating at that moment. I dont often cook following a recipe and if I do I would look up several versions of the thing and then create my own version anyway.

Also I wouldnt pop to the shops if I was missing an ingredient that wasnt absolutely necessary for the meal even when I have several shops on my doorstep /I would if I started baking only to find out I dont have eggs for example/.

katepilar · 22/11/2022 21:13

DameHelena · 21/11/2022 15:57

Hadn't thought about roasting and freezing garlic! That's genius.
On a similar subject, is it possible to freeze fresh herbs and for them to come out nice enough to use as fresh? They're probably the major wasted item in my house; the corner shops near me sell them in such big bunches I don't have a hope of using them all before they go off, and I've failed miserably at growing my own.
Sorry, derail I know.

Without much own experience I know that freezing herbs can be also done in ice cubes, with water. Also freezig them first spread out on a tray before putting them into a bag or container should avoid chopped herbs getting stuck into one big ball that is sometimes hard to break up.

Alternative is also drying teh herbs if they would go to waste otherwise.

Also most herbs last longer if stored in a glass of water in the fridge.

Oblomov22 · 22/11/2022 21:12

Not as rigidly as you.

Start by Looking in freezer and see 3 or 4 things we could use. Write list of any thing we need to make said meals (say steak pie in freezer, thus need new pots and 3 veg). And then might see something in store. Beef stir fry. Or, Say 2 x loins of pork marinate in 5 spice and soy, ginger, garlic and honey, so buy pittas to make meal. Always buy the same stuff for lunches; chicken satay, cooked bacon to make BLT, bananas and grapes. Same list each week.

Still gets boring and monotonous.
Find people who don't meal plan at all a bit odd. But some are just adventurous and go to supermarket every day!

bloodyeverlastinghell · 22/11/2022 21:00

I think most people don't necessarily have it on a board. I meal plan loosely, about five nights a week we eat the same foods. Home made pizza, bolognaise, home made burgers, a roast of some description at the weekend and fish. Veg depends on what I can get from community garden/ whats on offer at Tesco or Aldi. Other two nights are yellow sticker surprise / if there isn't good reduced stuff we get something bought in a previous haul out the freezer. Or a batch cooked meal etc.

I do keep a stocked store cupboard especially at this time of year. At some point I will get snowed in and when it happens I need to be able to drink coffee/ wine.

sadiewt · 22/11/2022 20:58

Some meal planning seems normal. 'Operating a system' of weekly family council to determine the meals seems over engineered!
Maybe you come across as very controlled so visitors are tittering about the meal plan?

katepilar · 22/11/2022 20:52

kitchenplans · 21/11/2022 15:19

See I get the bit about looking at what you have and saying "I've got peppers, onions and black beans - basis for Mexican." But I don't understand how you could have co-incidetally, without any thought or planning, just happened to have also bought fresh coriander, fresh chilli, a fresh lime, sour cream, avocado etc. So either lots of the essential ingredients are missing, or some sort of planning process is going on when you shop, albeit a loose, informal one.

I don't actually think the non planners cook shite (although surely there will be a subset who just do basics and convenience food). I think its more likely that most people put more effort into planning their meals and their shopping than they acknowledge.

For example, seeing a delicious looking aubergine and buying courgette/pepper/red onion etc to go with it thinking "I could cooking a nice mediterranean vegetable dish with that lot" is a loose form of planning. As is thinking "I fancy pasta this week, I'll make sure I pick up parmesan/pecorino, fresh lemon, fresh tomatoes, fresh basil etc".

If you're not putting any thought at all into what you're likely to cook and just chucking random stuff in the trolley then its inevitable that there will be food waste, poorly made dishes or the need for top up shops. I don't think many people do that though. They plan loosely in their head as they shop. It may not be rigid, it may not be written down, but it's still a plan.

No, I would hardly ever do the thinking while shopping what you describe with the aubergine. I just randomly buy the vegetables and then decide when looking at it at home to do what you describe a mediterranean vegetable dish. Also I wouldnt usually think about buying a specific cheese for a pasta dish. Lemons and tomatoes are considered a staple, basil - if I dont have the whole plant in a pot at home - is also bought and used randomly.
I buy the vegetable at the farmers market which generally leads you a bit as they have what's in season, unlike a supermarket.

BosaNova · 22/11/2022 20:39

Also if you have fresh cut herbs from shop, keep them in a bit of water in a fridge. My parsley is like day 5 (because my garden one is sleeping) and it's like new. Basil outside of fridge is on day 12. It has flowers now

WeepingSomnambulist · 22/11/2022 20:39

Blowyourowntrumpet · 22/11/2022 20:22

I've never done meal planning. I did try once and gave up after two days. How do you know what you'll fancy for dinner next Thursday? I don't understand it..

It's not always about what you'll fancy. It's about budgeting for all the meals each person needs each week, which means careful selection of ingredients to minimise wasted money on half used items.

Ideatcakeforbreakfast · 22/11/2022 20:37

I so meal plan and have done since my son was little. It's makes the week a lot easier when I'm working and it probably saves money as well as saving waste. My MIL doesn't meal plan and is so indecisive it's painful. I suggested she meal plans as she works shifts now so it would make things easier. My partner also 'jokingly' sent her a link to a meal planner - apparently she doesn't need it as she isn't 'disorganised'.

Blowyourowntrumpet · 22/11/2022 20:22

I've never done meal planning. I did try once and gave up after two days. How do you know what you'll fancy for dinner next Thursday? I don't understand it..

JaceLancs · 22/11/2022 20:07

We meal plan but it’s mainly how many nights in or out and number of lunches
then choose say 5 meals but they can be on any night so not planned rigidly
plan is also round what needs eating up or gas been in freezer longest

katepilar · 22/11/2022 20:01

JudgementalCentipede · 21/11/2022 11:59

I don't understand people who don't meal plan - do you just buy a load of random 'ingredients' and then try to come.up with recipes that use what you've got? Or do you live mainly off 'convenience' foods that you just throw in the oven eg. pizza? It must be stressful!

I am the other way round, I dont get the "you need to meal plan to avoid waste or to have all the ingrediences".

The system in our family is that you buy stuff and than cook with what you've got. Most ingrediences are simply always in the cupboards or fridge.

MasterBeth · 22/11/2022 19:59

kitchenplans · 21/11/2022 15:19

See I get the bit about looking at what you have and saying "I've got peppers, onions and black beans - basis for Mexican." But I don't understand how you could have co-incidetally, without any thought or planning, just happened to have also bought fresh coriander, fresh chilli, a fresh lime, sour cream, avocado etc. So either lots of the essential ingredients are missing, or some sort of planning process is going on when you shop, albeit a loose, informal one.

I don't actually think the non planners cook shite (although surely there will be a subset who just do basics and convenience food). I think its more likely that most people put more effort into planning their meals and their shopping than they acknowledge.

For example, seeing a delicious looking aubergine and buying courgette/pepper/red onion etc to go with it thinking "I could cooking a nice mediterranean vegetable dish with that lot" is a loose form of planning. As is thinking "I fancy pasta this week, I'll make sure I pick up parmesan/pecorino, fresh lemon, fresh tomatoes, fresh basil etc".

If you're not putting any thought at all into what you're likely to cook and just chucking random stuff in the trolley then its inevitable that there will be food waste, poorly made dishes or the need for top up shops. I don't think many people do that though. They plan loosely in their head as they shop. It may not be rigid, it may not be written down, but it's still a plan.

Don’t you have a fridge? If I buy a fresh chilli, it’s good for a couple of weeks. Fresh herbs in pots grow on the windowsill. Floury potatoes? Keep for weeks. Parmesan? What do think is going to happen to it if you don’t use it?

DigbyLongcock · 22/11/2022 19:54

I haven't voted as I think it's a personality thing. I have never done meal planning as I wait until I'm on my way home at 5.30 then have a dither in Tesco about what to have for supper. However, there's never any wastage, as I just buy fresh stuff on the day, and use it. I don't follow recipes as they are tiresome - I make it up as I go along.

MasterBeth · 22/11/2022 19:52

Don’t meal plan. Buy fresh food at the weekend. Cook and eat it during the week. Top up staples when they get low. Have less choice of what to cook and eat by Friday so maybe have to be more inventive.

Couldn’t start thinking about what I might want for tea in three or four days time!

Mummadeze · 22/11/2022 19:40

I go to the supermarket every day and spend a fortune. I often get takeaways too because I find myself too tired to cook. I am going to research how this works. I need to follow someone else’s meal plan to be honest. But I can’t afford how I live at the moment. Really going to try harder.

LololaLo2012 · 22/11/2022 19:34

My mum just buys stuff. Like each week same without checked what she has in or if they are going out! It stresses me out when I go to there’s and I’m like what are you eating tonight and she laughs! She constantly takes the piss that I have a meal plan for the week, she’s actually quite rude about it tbh.

I plan the meals not the nights. After I get home with the shopping just have a mental check about what’s going out of date first- normally the fish/prawns and if I’m planning on something sausages or a veggie meal that can be later in the week . Always pick up a frozen pizza for the night when you just can’t be arsed!

I think it just makes life easier with work and kids knowing that you have x amount of meals in the fridge ready to be cooked.

AsIfIWish · 22/11/2022 16:16

I think if I cooked, I would have a rough idea of what we would eat that week, with a few batch-cooked meals in the freezer and some extra bits like grains and veg on hand. As it is, my DH cooks all the evening meals (his choice, and I'm not a fan of cooking) and i think he used to do the above, but now we live literally next door to a supermarket, he often cooks different things spontaneously as he can use the shop as an extra pantry almost. But it's a pretty expensive one and I think I might try and encourage more meal planning to a point to try and keep our costs down a bit.

I don't think it's weird to meal plan, although nowadays I only know one person who actually writes it all down in advance (my sister).

CombatBarbie · 22/11/2022 12:41

Been doing it for years, we have a Mon to. Sun chalkboard in kitchen with the meals and appts for that week.

I actually don't know how I'd shop if I didn't have a meal planner as I'd be constantly be between aisles to get xyz that will go with the chicken breasts, meat etc. Even that makes my anxiety churn.

Swipe left for the next trending thread