Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
RobertaFirmino · 21/11/2022 00:05

a biological imperative written deep into every living being

It isn't in EVERY living being - certainly wasn't in me! There are also many people who are sexually attracted to members of the same sex - people who they cannot reproduce with.

I've read about plenty of situations where a female non-human primate has given birth and just walked away from the baby.

I think socialisation has a lot to do with it.

OriginalUsername2 · 21/11/2022 00:02

For me, didn’t know any better. Wasn’t taught any better. Didn’t see any better around me.

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 20/11/2022 23:56

Aintnosupermum · 20/11/2022 23:46

I have two disabled children. My third is also lovely and needs help as has dyslexia.

It’s been extremely challenging to keep my career but I’ve done it. I was under immense pressure to stop. I ignored him and worked at a small loss which I hid from him. Absolutely ridiculous but now my youngest is 6 and Xenia was totally correct with her advice. You need to have your own career and your income needs to be sufficient to support your children with zero monies from the other parent.

I now make more than the top income tax bracket in the UK and this enables me to provide for my 3 children. He pays nothing and division of assets was not equal with the children getting 30% of his business, I got two properties which is less than 20% of the combined net worth. I have a full time nanny, two cars (one for nanny), 3 sets of school fees, a cleaner/housekeeper 3x a week, my children get the therapy they need and attend extra curricular activities including tutoring and sports (Iron(wo)man training). It’s massively liberating to not have to go to court and fight him for what our children deserve given our family wealth. I’ll face that later when the children are older. He is really focused on building his business. I’ll let him do that and he can give me half in 10 years.

Think long and hard about who benefits from mummy staying home. It’s rarely mummy or the child who benefits. Two disabled children later, I bought good childcare to take my children to activities after school (much of it therapy) and worked my ass off. I’m so so so happy I followed this path.

Your username…is a lie?!? You’re most definitely a superwoman!!

Circe7 · 20/11/2022 23:50

@millymollymoomoo
I think there’s a bit of truth in this. Clearly some SAHMs have sacrificed a career but actually if you have a decent career yourself it’s not so common to give it up entirely to be a SAHM. I’m a solicitor- most female solicitors come back after having children because it pays enough to be worthwhile. They are more likely to work part time or give up on partnership etc. but they still have a career to fall back on if need be. And most women who have a career to be sacrificed can understand the risk in doing so. I went part time and worked for a more family friendly firm after children - I was well aware that this damaged my earning potential but the time with my children was important. I could have hired a nanny and pursued partnership if I’d wanted to.

If you have a job which pays £25k and you give it up because childcare is expensive / you’d like to spend time with children while they’re young/ you didn’t like the job much anyway and your husband earns 3 x what you do, I don’t really see it as being inherently unfair if you aren’t entitled to 50% of your partner’s assets if you split, particularly where you have never agreed that between yourselves. The SAHM has been enabled to pursue a lifestyle she may well have wanted while the couple were together and she may never have had her ex’s earning potential anyway.

I think it would be good for everyone to understand that marriage is a financial contract and all that entails so that they can make informed decisions (and Uk divorce law is very favourable to the lower earner relative to other jurisdictions) but I don’t see that the legal implications of marriage should be forced on people who haven’t opted into that.

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 23:50

MrsMiddleMother · 20/11/2022 23:40

Honestly I agree. Out of 4 sisters I'm the only one married with children who were planned. Contraception used incorrectly or not at all with men they knew would never marry them or be good fathers.

That doesn't make you a better person, the sad fact is there isn't an unlimited supply of wealthy good men. Wealthy good men have a lot of choice in the dating relationship scene. They can wait for a long time if they want , women can't do that. At least your sisters have DC who are presumably loved. MN talks like the are scores of wealthy eligible men out there.

I was lucky and met my DH at a young age others aren't.

PurpleButterflyWings · 20/11/2022 23:46

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune

Producing another human should be undertaken only in the most optimal circumstances, after careful thought and preparation. It's absurd to consider that a big ask in 2022.

Are you actually serious right now?! 😂 ....... do tell us all........ what optimal circumstances should a woman have a baby???????? Go on. Enlighten us all!!!

Aintnosupermum · 20/11/2022 23:46

I have two disabled children. My third is also lovely and needs help as has dyslexia.

It’s been extremely challenging to keep my career but I’ve done it. I was under immense pressure to stop. I ignored him and worked at a small loss which I hid from him. Absolutely ridiculous but now my youngest is 6 and Xenia was totally correct with her advice. You need to have your own career and your income needs to be sufficient to support your children with zero monies from the other parent.

I now make more than the top income tax bracket in the UK and this enables me to provide for my 3 children. He pays nothing and division of assets was not equal with the children getting 30% of his business, I got two properties which is less than 20% of the combined net worth. I have a full time nanny, two cars (one for nanny), 3 sets of school fees, a cleaner/housekeeper 3x a week, my children get the therapy they need and attend extra curricular activities including tutoring and sports (Iron(wo)man training). It’s massively liberating to not have to go to court and fight him for what our children deserve given our family wealth. I’ll face that later when the children are older. He is really focused on building his business. I’ll let him do that and he can give me half in 10 years.

Think long and hard about who benefits from mummy staying home. It’s rarely mummy or the child who benefits. Two disabled children later, I bought good childcare to take my children to activities after school (much of it therapy) and worked my ass off. I’m so so so happy I followed this path.

PurpleButterflyWings · 20/11/2022 23:44

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 23:30

We need a new paradigm in which childfree living isn't seen as second-best. Don't surveys show that single, childfree women report far higher levels of happiness than do married and childed women?

As a species we've reliably been able to control our fertility for 100 years. We need to stop educating young women to believe that reproducing is the only path to a fulfilling life. Yes, the childfree may miss out on some special moments but so do the childed. And having children under miserable circumstances is really unfair to the additional human beings who are being often thoughtlessly created, because of "broodyism" or trying to fill an emotional void in the mother-to-be.

Producing another human should be undertaken only in the most optimal circumstances, after careful thought and preparation. It's absurd to consider that a big ask in 2022.

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune

Oh here we go again! Didn't think it would be long before this drivel was trotted out. 'Single women are much happier than married women' is a myth created by single women to make other single women feel better. It's absolute horseshit and a ludicrous and laughable generalisation that all single women are happier than married women.

I know about 9 or 10 single women (over 25) and they're nearly all pretty miserable half the time. Always broke, struggling financially, no-one to help when they're sick, and always feel a bit left out at big social events where most people are in couples. And at LEAST half of them are ALWAYS going on dates, desperate to find a man!

Great for you if you're happy as a pig in shite as a 'singleton' but you're kidding yourself if you believe every single woman is much happier than every married woman. Many single women are only tolerating it until the right man comes along ... Why on earth do you think there are so many millions of women on dating apps?!

At the end of the day, no-one really wants to spend the rest of their life alone. Bit different if they have BEEN married, and have been widowed, or divorced after 30-odd years or something. But to have NEVER been married? No. Most women don't want that life. No matter how much you try to convince yourself otherwise. As I say, the 'single women are happier than married women' bullshit was created by single women to make themselves feel better. I mean if you have to say something like this to try to convince yourself............... well............. Wink

PyongyangKipperbang · 20/11/2022 23:44

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 23:40

It's a biological urge to reproduce for a lot of women. How many do you see heartbroken because they cannot get pregnant even after spending 1000s. Yes in an ideal world but I don't think the vast majority of humans are ever going to stop wanting to reproduce.

I agree that is is a biological imperative written deep into every living being.
Its why mummy turtle buries hundreds of eggs knowing that most of her babies will get eaten before the make it to 24 hours old. Its why mummy antelope has her baby knowing that chances are it will get gobbled up by a cheetah.

Logic can't stop hormones.

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 23:40

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 23:30

We need a new paradigm in which childfree living isn't seen as second-best. Don't surveys show that single, childfree women report far higher levels of happiness than do married and childed women?

As a species we've reliably been able to control our fertility for 100 years. We need to stop educating young women to believe that reproducing is the only path to a fulfilling life. Yes, the childfree may miss out on some special moments but so do the childed. And having children under miserable circumstances is really unfair to the additional human beings who are being often thoughtlessly created, because of "broodyism" or trying to fill an emotional void in the mother-to-be.

Producing another human should be undertaken only in the most optimal circumstances, after careful thought and preparation. It's absurd to consider that a big ask in 2022.

It's a biological urge to reproduce for a lot of women. How many do you see heartbroken because they cannot get pregnant even after spending 1000s. Yes in an ideal world but I don't think the vast majority of humans are ever going to stop wanting to reproduce.

MrsMiddleMother · 20/11/2022 23:40

Honestly I agree. Out of 4 sisters I'm the only one married with children who were planned. Contraception used incorrectly or not at all with men they knew would never marry them or be good fathers.

Soreztee · 20/11/2022 23:38

*Onefootinthegroove · Today 21:29
It's not just financially.

My cousin was with her DP for 17 years & 3 DC when he had a bleed on the brain. He was obviously seriously ill and she was astonished to realise that she wasn't legally his next of kin, his sister was as his parents had already died.*

next of kin is not a legal entity in the UK so neither your cousin OR his sister had a right to make decisions. In non-emergency situations you can name whoever you like a ‘next of kin’. In emergency situations Medics normally take a pragmatic view on who needs to know what. Most decisions would be medically driven anyway and medics can talk to more than one person. It’s a fallacy that inflates the benefits of marriage to state otherwise.

PyongyangKipperbang · 20/11/2022 23:37

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 23:21

The only thing that women have that men want is access to our genitals
true but beyond that they want heirs dont they?

Yes but like I said, they are now able to get that without any of the cost of committment of marriage. They can get the heir and spare, safe in the knowledge that it will cost them nothing more than the pittance CMS demands, and often not even that as we all know how easy it is to avoid paying CS.

So why would they put their financial eggs into one marital basket when they can literally get it all for nothing?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 23:32

PyongyangKipperbang · 20/11/2022 23:16

I think its one of the things that maybe the old days had right. The only thing that women have that men want is access to our genitals. Deny that and guess what, they were up the aisle and away from the reception as fast as they could arrange it.

Now they get it all with no committment. Sex on date three (later and she is frigid, throw her back. Earlier and she is a slag, shag her then throw her back). Kids where she does the wife work without any wife rights. And if he is really lucky, half of the bills and mortgage paid too.

Trading virginity for security isnt romantic, but is a hell of a better deal for us. The sexual revolution did nothing for women but devalue us in the eyes of men.

I am not a prude about sexuality but I do think it's a pity that the stigma of out-of-wedlock childbearing has been obliterated.

It was never about sex, it was because "the village" knew that an unmarried mother was likely to become a burden on the village, and that her offspring would too. Expecting people to be partnered before adding new members to the community is not unreasonable, for the children's sake and the sake of the community. Willy-nilly reproduction benefits no one.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 23:30

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 23:00

I think some women just want to be mother's and that's the goal. How many women do you see on here saying it's too late they are infertile? Yes things might be imperfect but they have DC. Many men especially now will string women along especially MC men.
I don't blame some women for the choices they make , if I had to choose between marriage or no DC I'd choose DC.
There's a limited time to have DC you can get married up until death. I think the key is maintaining financial independence if that means having fewer DC just one or two then that's what you need to do.

We need a new paradigm in which childfree living isn't seen as second-best. Don't surveys show that single, childfree women report far higher levels of happiness than do married and childed women?

As a species we've reliably been able to control our fertility for 100 years. We need to stop educating young women to believe that reproducing is the only path to a fulfilling life. Yes, the childfree may miss out on some special moments but so do the childed. And having children under miserable circumstances is really unfair to the additional human beings who are being often thoughtlessly created, because of "broodyism" or trying to fill an emotional void in the mother-to-be.

Producing another human should be undertaken only in the most optimal circumstances, after careful thought and preparation. It's absurd to consider that a big ask in 2022.

herecomestheaeroplane · 20/11/2022 23:23

DashboardConfessional · 20/11/2022 18:58

Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Honestly? Yes, usually. They often buy the ring and then do nothing. In the situation you're talking about they're the ones who stand to lose out.

I'll have you know my hubby bought me a ring at the tender age of 15 and we have been in marital bliss for the last 2 years. And a second baby on the way - yeah, I know - biological clock to consider. And my man still pines for me every minute of every day. Wishing the same for you queens! x

millymollymoomoo · 20/11/2022 23:21

I hate this mn notion that women are disadvantaged all the time
lets face it most women who become sahm and ‘sacrifice careers’ never actually had one to begin with, at least not one they would buy them houses and nice lifestyle.
so rather than being disadvantaged by having children are actually advantaged by it in the case of divorce ( especially if higher earner husband) walking away with assets they’d never have been able to accumulate
you do t have to stop work when you have a child, nor work part time etc. yet do many threads here is like, oh but I can’t work as I have to do school run ( even though there is wrap around care etc)

if women want legal protection they should marry
we don’t need any other laws or silly notion of giving 50% of assets even for a ons that results in s child!
if a man wont marry ( and I’ll certainly be advising my ds not to!) then dont have children unless you’re prepared to work and pay your own way ! ( which you should anyway )

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 23:21

The only thing that women have that men want is access to our genitals
true but beyond that they want heirs dont they?

EhLov · 20/11/2022 23:21

And why should we assume that we have to pass childcare over to strangers however we’ll qualified?

Because… (wo)man gotta eat!

How else you gonna make your money, seriously?

You have babies you still gotta work, man. Who’s gonna buy all your stuff? Your man!? That’s so deliriously dangerous to rely on someone else for a penny.

Also, the idea of splitting assets / property etc via marriage has to be a generational one.
Like, we’re generation rent. We have naff all to split 😂

The only thing we have is our income and we won’t be giving that up for a man to find it easier to make his.

All the mums I know make more than their men. Why would we want to marry them 🤷‍♀️ We’re good. We have our own money thank you.

Lopilo · 20/11/2022 23:20

Justthisonce12 · 20/11/2022 21:26

@Lopilo aren’t women genetically programmed to breed with the best quality of male they can get their hands on. This is what I feel its gone, really badly wrong over the last few years these inferior specimens are going round Impregnating women that are completely out of their league.
Why ? Why is there such desperation on some women’s part to have a baby with literally anyone.

@Justthisonce12 I’m not sure that nature and modern women agree on what makes the best quality male. Nature would probably think someone like Genghis Khan was a perfect specimen to breed with, but I don’t think he would be a reliable husband!

Greennetting · 20/11/2022 23:18

plusk · 20/11/2022 23:12

The women talking about implants /pills/coil failing are usually lying.

How is a woman who gets pregnant whilst she has a coil lying?

Around 8 out of 1000 women with a coil get pregnant every year. That's not lying, it's statistics.

On top of that the coil can slip out of place in 2-10 of.women. Yes you should be checking the strings, but its still not lying.

PyongyangKipperbang · 20/11/2022 23:16

I think its one of the things that maybe the old days had right. The only thing that women have that men want is access to our genitals. Deny that and guess what, they were up the aisle and away from the reception as fast as they could arrange it.

Now they get it all with no committment. Sex on date three (later and she is frigid, throw her back. Earlier and she is a slag, shag her then throw her back). Kids where she does the wife work without any wife rights. And if he is really lucky, half of the bills and mortgage paid too.

Trading virginity for security isnt romantic, but is a hell of a better deal for us. The sexual revolution did nothing for women but devalue us in the eyes of men.

Allsnotwell · 20/11/2022 23:13

It isn’t as simple to make your own money unless employers value mothers!
And why should we assume that we have to pass childcare over to strangers however we’ll qualified?
A father should want to protect his family.
Men should be taught the value of his children and not screwing the mother over!

plusk · 20/11/2022 23:12

The women talking about implants /pills/coil failing are usually lying.

Greennetting · 20/11/2022 23:10

EhLov · 20/11/2022 23:04

Or just… have / make your own money?

Up until you have a child with disabilities and one of you needs to give up work and deserves to be financially protected by the other parent

37% of children with disabilities have a parent who has had to give up work
36% have a parents who has had to reduce their hours

9% of children are disabled.