Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 21/11/2022 08:32

BeautifulWar - and for the sake of transparency as far as possible in an anonymous thread. I have never hankered after being a sahm. I would last about a fortnight before being bored witless.
I have had three children all now grown and also helped raise 4 dsc. I have worked full time without any breaks except Mat Leave since my eldest was 6 months old. I am financially secure and whilst raising kids , more financially secure than my DH. This is not about me.

7 years ago my closest friends life imploded . Her partner who she had met at 17 decided in the course of 8 weeks to meet and marry a woman he met on a business trip to Dubai.

They had started at the same economic level. He worked as a photocopy clerk in an investment bank. (Shows how long ago this was) she was a nursery nurse. They moved in together aged 21/22. First baby at 23. She gave up work as he had got promotion as a trainee in the bank.

At the point of implosion he was a senior partner. She had helped that meteoric rise by playing the 'corporate wife' to perfection. Running the home, entertaining clients looking after their joint kids. Their house was worth £750k there were savings of about £100k. There were 5 children . However at the time of this happening only one was left at school. He insisted that marriage was just a piece of paper and 'knew too many people where it had jinxed their relationships' .. I heard him say on numerous occasions. 'We don't need a piece of paper do we babe. ? We're solid. We've got 5 kids . It doesn't get more committed than that. ..

He married his girlfriend quickly because he didn't have to go to the trouble of divorce. He married because his new wife blamed her Catholicism and the fact that her parents would be unhappy if she wasn't married. (Seemed to skip over the bit where you don't have sex before marriage -if you are going to play the religious card)

My dear friend was blindsided. Her entire world crumbled and none of us could believe how little she of that life she was entitled to.

She got ; 8 months of child support until the youngest child left full time non advanced education. At which point she was required to leave the house. He 'gave her' £10k from the savings to rent a property.

7 years later at 63 years old . She works full time in a garden centre and relies on her kids to help her with her rent . She has a 3 bed cottage so kids can come and stay but costs more than the 1 bed entitlement on universal credit.

Her ex DP lives in the family home with his wife. (Who very swiftly produced a baby to secure the situation. ) Something he apparently didn't want - but hey ho we all know how terribly unreliable contraception is these days.

This can't be right. Situations such as this surely require a law change ?

OP posts:
smileandsing · 21/11/2022 08:23

Controversial as it sounds many women choose this. From their own career/work choices, to getting together with someone who earns more, to marrying them, to giving up work or going part time when they have a child. All of it is a choice. Not working due to childcare costs may seem like the only option, but it is often the preferred choice of the mother to do so. The sensible choices would be to earn enough to support yourself in the first place, then maintain that ability to be independent throughout meeting someone, marrying and raising a family.
I wish society would educate young people better regarding life choices, particularly young women. Maybe then women wouldn't be left high and dry when their feckless spouse disappears off

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/11/2022 08:08

That men are more circumspect with regard to their own fertility and rely less on women taking care of contraception

Men should use a condom if they don’t want a baby, but to be honest we can’t pretend it’s equal - ultimately women have a much wider choice of contraceptive methods, that are much more effective, less hassle, last for years and are free. If she then gets pregnant, her body her choice. As it should be.

But the amount of women who still don’t seem to realise, a few kids in, that a quickie can cause pregnancy, amazes me.

Coffeepot72 · 21/11/2022 07:59

Don’t worry OP, the vast majority of us completely get what you’re saying

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 21/11/2022 07:55

BeautifulWar · 21/11/2022 06:36

Why can't women do that? Why such low expectations of women?

Because this list isn't about empowering women, it's about bashing unmarried mothers. Empowering, would be encouraging women not to give up work. Ultimately, this bunch want to stay at home with the babies and be condescending to unmarried women who want the same.

Never mind there are circumstances that don't financially protect even married women.

What complete and utter bollox !
I started this thread. There is not one word of 'bashing' unmarried mothers.

In fact the complete opposite. I have been advocating for a change in the law that financially compensated separating parents - who are not married.

With the hope it provides two outcomes.

  1. Children from cohabiting families are not less well off - because one of the parents have refused to offer the legal commitment when the mother made the commitment to childbirth and child rearing .
  1. That men are more circumspect with regard to their own fertility and rely less on women taking care of contraception. If it's going to cost them a large percentage of their assets then perhaps they will be bothered to wear a condom or get the snip .

I would also want to empower ALL young people with knowledge of the CURRENT legal position. Mostly so that young women understand that shacking up with a man and having kids with marriage. Is a decision that needs to be made from a financial view point with all the facts.

OP posts:
Januarcelebration · 21/11/2022 07:44

BeautifulWar · 21/11/2022 06:36

Why can't women do that? Why such low expectations of women?

Because this list isn't about empowering women, it's about bashing unmarried mothers. Empowering, would be encouraging women not to give up work. Ultimately, this bunch want to stay at home with the babies and be condescending to unmarried women who want the same.

Never mind there are circumstances that don't financially protect even married women.

What bunch? I was married and have always worked. Apart from mat leave, I have always worked full time. I do think women should retain their own careers. However, many simply don’t want to. They want to be at home but do not look at the potential negative impact on them. And often simply don’t believe that would happen to them. Married women should still look at the potential impact as well.

If you are going to give up work, or take a hit to your career to bring up children you are better off being married in the vast majority of cases. Even when there is no assets. Just incase the main wage earner dies.

No one claimed married women are absolutely fine and completely protected in all circumstance. All women should always be aware of their financial position and the risks. Everyone should.

It’s not about the morality of being an unmarried mother. That’s not the discussion at all.

Coffeepot72 · 21/11/2022 07:44

Oh here we go again! Didn't think it would be long before this drivel was trotted out. 'Single women are much happier than married women' is a myth created by single women to make other single women feel better.

I know about 9 or 10 single women (over 25) and they're nearly all pretty miserable half the time. Always broke, struggling financially, no-one to help when they're sick, and always feel a bit left out at big social events where most people are in couples. And at LEAST half of them are ALWAYS going on dates, desperate to find a man!

I was single at that age and confirm it was grim for all the reasons above. All my friends were settling down, some already having their first baby, the film of the year was ‘Four Weddings and a Funeral’ (showing my age here) and I was on/off dating the man who became my first husband. By the time I was 30 he was still embarrassingly commitment-shy and looking back it was a dark period in my life.

christmaspudding43 · 21/11/2022 07:41

PurpleButterflyWings · 20/11/2022 19:43

This. ^ Rightly or wrongly, I actually inwardly cringe at women who've been with a man for 10 or 15 years or more - and especially if they've got one or two or more kids with him - and they're not married. They try and peddle this 'neither of us wants to get married, it's what we both want' bollux, but I know deep down probably 9 out of 10 women want to get married. I think they just try and convince themselves that they don't. But it's because HE doesn't want to in most cases.

I've got a close female relative aged 30 now who's been with the same bloke for 11 years since the age of 19. She kind of wanted to get married for the first three or four years, but he was just right against it. It was 'you'd best find someone else if you want marriage because it's not for me.' She loved him (still does) and didn't want to split, so she settled for this. Then she kept saying, 'I'm never getting married, no way, not ever. Patriarchy, patriarchy, not changing my maiden name, blah, blah, blah, blah. Not being owned by a man etc etc etc!' For about 4 or 5 years she said this!

A couple of years ago, after nine years together, he finally proposed, God knows why he suddenly changed his mind. Nobody has asked. But she was in tears with absolute joy because he asked her to marry him. The wedding is next June.

So it seems all along she did want to get married, but she tried to convince everybody else she didn't. I believe this is the case for a lot of women because why would a woman NOT want to get married? It brings lots more security, and proves the man is committed. And no WAY would I have children with a man without being married.

As I say, deep down I think most women want to get married - not only for the fact they've got security, and it shows commitment from him, but it also feels awkward when virtually every woman you know - sisters, nieces, cousins, friends, work colleagues, neighbours etc etc, are getting married, and YOU are always the bridesmaid, or just a guest.

When every woman has a ring on her finger - it's heart-breaking for a woman who's with a man who refuses to get married. I wouldn't stay with a man if he wouldn't get married. I just wouldn't.

To be honest, if a man has more money than the woman he is with, and has more assets, and is very solvent, they often won't get married. Many well-off men won't get married if they have nothing to gain from it.

@PurpleButterflyWings I know you've said most not all, and especially those with children so I do acknowledge you're trying not to make a sweeping generalisation... but please, don't cringe on my behalf, don't feel awkward on my behalf and be assured that I am not heart broken. I am happily unmarried, secure in my decision and now my friends' marriages are starting to sadly end even less convinced by marriage as an emotional concept, or one that I should feel heart broken not to have experienced.

As a legal concept, yes, I understand completely and particularly where children are involved but since I'm child free and the higher earner, don't pity me anymore than you pity anyone else happy with their life choices!

Coffeepot72 · 21/11/2022 07:33

I think its one of the things that maybe the old days had right. The only thing that women have that men want is access to our genitals. Deny that and guess what, they were up the aisle and away from the reception as fast as they could arrange it.

Now they get it all with no committment. Sex on date three (later and she is frigid, throw her back. Earlier and she is a slag, shag her then throw her back). Kids where she does the wife work without any wife rights. And if he is really lucky, half of the bills and mortgage paid too.

Trading virginity for security isnt romantic, but is a hell of a better deal for us. The sexual revolution did nothing for women but devalue us in the eyes of men.

Yes! You have phrased this better than I could and it’s so true. In my grandmother’s day, the perks of marriage only came with marriage.

(However the wedding industry is thriving so let’s not tar all men with the same brush)!

BeautifulWar · 21/11/2022 06:36

Why can't women do that? Why such low expectations of women?

Because this list isn't about empowering women, it's about bashing unmarried mothers. Empowering, would be encouraging women not to give up work. Ultimately, this bunch want to stay at home with the babies and be condescending to unmarried women who want the same.

Never mind there are circumstances that don't financially protect even married women.

KimberleyClark · 21/11/2022 06:03

I think many women want a baby so much that they’ll overlook red flags in a relationship in order to have one. And then they’ll have more kids with the same man even though they already know he’s a shit dad.

Aintnosupermum · 21/11/2022 05:28

Truth be told, dearly beloved, as I call him, earned 10x or more some years than me. I made damn sure I knew where all the money was. It wasn’t an accident that I became an accountant.

I don’t like that prenuptial agreements aren’t recognized in the UK. Mine came in very handy when getting divorced as all assets brought into the marriage were listed along with their valuation.

DubiousGiraffe · 21/11/2022 03:51

Aintnosupermum · 20/11/2022 23:46

I have two disabled children. My third is also lovely and needs help as has dyslexia.

It’s been extremely challenging to keep my career but I’ve done it. I was under immense pressure to stop. I ignored him and worked at a small loss which I hid from him. Absolutely ridiculous but now my youngest is 6 and Xenia was totally correct with her advice. You need to have your own career and your income needs to be sufficient to support your children with zero monies from the other parent.

I now make more than the top income tax bracket in the UK and this enables me to provide for my 3 children. He pays nothing and division of assets was not equal with the children getting 30% of his business, I got two properties which is less than 20% of the combined net worth. I have a full time nanny, two cars (one for nanny), 3 sets of school fees, a cleaner/housekeeper 3x a week, my children get the therapy they need and attend extra curricular activities including tutoring and sports (Iron(wo)man training). It’s massively liberating to not have to go to court and fight him for what our children deserve given our family wealth. I’ll face that later when the children are older. He is really focused on building his business. I’ll let him do that and he can give me half in 10 years.

Think long and hard about who benefits from mummy staying home. It’s rarely mummy or the child who benefits. Two disabled children later, I bought good childcare to take my children to activities after school (much of it therapy) and worked my ass off. I’m so so so happy I followed this path.

As someone trying to continue a career as a lone parent with two disabled DC, this is so inspiring to read. Thank you for sharing this. You are amazing.

DubiousGiraffe · 21/11/2022 03:32

Aintnosupermum · 20/11/2022 23:09

@sofrustratedbylackofknowledge

where I live, my ex husband is going to have a shock. Child support is up to 10% of your gross income per child regardless of the marital status of the parents when the child was born. What determines the amount of child support is contact, behavior during the relationship (infidelity means the other adult gets more), length of relationship, each parents earnings and if you are married. We have 3 children. As he is hiding income in his business, they take the income of the business attributed to his ownership. I asked for 3% of his income. He told me it’s a ridiculous amount. Well, let’s see how 30% feels darling.

Child support in the UK has always shocked me. It’s child abuse not to pay. It should come out of income at source and be taxed as income of the parent paid, who invariably is lower income. I think 10% of income per child is reasonable for child support. Non payment should result in jail.

Absolutely agree with this. This is one of the main things that needs to change in the UK. Even the US manages to enforce decentish child maintenance properly. The very idea that it's ok for someone to pay a few hundred pounds per month towards raising a child is absolutely disgusting, and that many get away with paying far less or nothing is a stain on our society.

I hope you get your 30%. Would love to know which country it is if you are happy to PM to share! I take a keen interest in these kinds of international differences as it adds more weight to the argument to get things changed here.

DubiousGiraffe · 21/11/2022 03:28

The vast VAST majority of women are not, never have been, and never WILL be on 5 times their husband's salary as you allegedly are. And as for buying a house on your own as you claim you have done........ Bully for you!!!!! MOST women could never buy a house in a million years on their own. What an utterly ridiculous post. Most ludicrous on this thread!

Rather than having a go at that poster, perhaps you should question why you find it so astonishing that a woman could be the far higher earner. Do you react like this to posts where women say they are a SAHM or earn peanuts part time and their husband is a high earner? I doubt it. It's not totally incomprehensible that some women make sensible choices and study/ work to secure lucrative careers and financial independence, which offers more protection than a marriage would. This is what we should be emphasising to young women.

DubiousGiraffe · 21/11/2022 03:21

EhLov · 20/11/2022 22:41

But why would you need to be married to secure yourself financially? Why can’t each party just have their own money?

Split the house, if owned, by who paid what. And woman ensure she has her own good income, assets, investments, pension etc.

Isn’t the idea of marriage really disempowering in the sense that it provides for the woman, VIA the man.
Rather than empowering her to earn her own money and thus not need his?

Why would you want your ex’s money?
Wouldn’t you rather have made your own while with him, than SAHP and have to then ask for some of his?

Personally when I got pregnant (very early 20s) I was insulted at family asking if he ‘would marry me now’.
Like I needed his money 🤪 I make my own.

I agree completely. We'd be far better off campaigning for universal cheap childcare provision like most European countries have, enforcing closure of the gender pay gap, and encouraging women to be financially independent and maintain a career, and demand that a man does 50% of child rearing.

DubiousGiraffe · 21/11/2022 03:18

...the division of assets on separation to include any couples who have a joint child . (that will be an interesting legal conundrum for a married man who fathers a child whilst having an affair ... I haven't thought that through yet in my utopian fantasy of fairness to children of unmarried couples ..)

A very good point and another reason it's completely unworkable.

Say a woman is married and has children and her husband cheats and the affair partner becomes pregnant. Effectively your rule (because in a marriage all assets are joint) means that the married woman has not only been humiliated and betrayed but is now required to give up a share of her assets to the scumbag who fucked her husband?

That would somewhat undermine your assertion that marriage provides people with protection!

John1988 · 21/11/2022 03:18

Soothsayer1 · 21/11/2022 00:23

Why on earth do you think there are so many millions of women on dating apps?!
isn't it quite a lot more men than women though?☝

90% of dating apps are men.

Aintnosupermum · 21/11/2022 02:50

@Backstreetsbackalrightdadada

love your username. I’m no superwoman. Something changed in me when my eldest was born and I knew I had to provide for her. I had a heart attack when she was delivered and I was in for a week after. It didn’t help that I was 3000 miles from family and my godmother drove down when things went south. I was an absolute mess but there was my husband telling me he was so tired at 2am in the morning after I’d been through a 22 hour labor, a heart attack and still had to figure out how to feed this beautiful baby girl. The nurse was scathing. I had the start of post partum depression and the same nurse made sure the psychiatrist came immediately for an evaluation. I’m forever thankful for that 30mins he spent with me.

I knew my marriage wasn’t going to last and took the necessary steps to get qualified as an accountant and went to work for big 4 in the most heavily regulated and tough industry groups. I then took on consulting projects as auditors were cheaper so used during the summer. It was so tough and for a short while I went part time so I could do an intense summer of therapy with my son (2nd child). It was a disaster for my career.

I had joined big 4 firm when I was 7 months pregnant with my son. I interviewed at 5 months pregnant. His big sister was 13/14 months old at that point. On my first day, I had to fly to the onboarding center for 2 days. My exhusband left the house at 4am and I didn’t have childcare. I had to call them and lie that my car to the airport hadn’t picked me up and I missed my flight. Luckily the partner who hired me was a woman who was divorced with 3 children and saw what was going on. She let me start from the local office. But yeah, I was married to a selfish prick. Of course he was successful and it was a problem that I had successes of my own. I just kept it from him because I knew he would sabotage.

DubiousGiraffe · 21/11/2022 02:14

honeylulu · 20/11/2022 19:46

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split

This is OK in principle but how does it work if the father has children with a wife and new partner(s)? The point of marriage/ civil partnership is that it is opt in, not opt out. I can't see how it would work the other way.

Hahaa well, perhaps it would discourage people from having children with multiple partners.

It's not a good idea though because adults should get to choose whether they enter into such a life-changing contract, not have it presumed in law. The solution is better financial education so that people make more informed choices.

How long would you have to live with someone before you're legally entitled to their money and assets? Where do you draw the line? A presumption of an implicit marriage contract would be a cocklodgers' and scammers' charter.

DubiousGiraffe · 21/11/2022 02:10

I believe this is the case for a lot of women because why would a woman NOT want to get married?

What a sexist comment. Plenty of women don't want to and it isn't always in their financial interests to do so either. Getting married was the most disastrous financial decision I ever made.

TulaDoesTheHula · 21/11/2022 01:10

Greennetting · 20/11/2022 23:10

Up until you have a child with disabilities and one of you needs to give up work and deserves to be financially protected by the other parent

37% of children with disabilities have a parent who has had to give up work
36% have a parents who has had to reduce their hours

9% of children are disabled.

Yes but in cases like that, an unmarried partner can go to court & bring a claim for extra financial provision under Schedule 1 of the Children Act 1989 so there are already protections in place even when unmarried.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/11/2022 01:09

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 23:50

That doesn't make you a better person, the sad fact is there isn't an unlimited supply of wealthy good men. Wealthy good men have a lot of choice in the dating relationship scene. They can wait for a long time if they want , women can't do that. At least your sisters have DC who are presumably loved. MN talks like the are scores of wealthy eligible men out there.

I was lucky and met my DH at a young age others aren't.

I think it does make her a better person, by far.

Saying "Oh well I can't seem to meet anyone decent so I'll have offspring by some shit loser anyway" is just immoral and reprehensible. Find something productive to do with one's life, rather than create another dire and dysfunctional situation to perpetuate society's ills.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/11/2022 01:07

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 23:40

It's a biological urge to reproduce for a lot of women. How many do you see heartbroken because they cannot get pregnant even after spending 1000s. Yes in an ideal world but I don't think the vast majority of humans are ever going to stop wanting to reproduce.

We have a lot of biological urges that we suppress. And frankly there is a lot of psychosocial conditioning that fuels these urges. Maybe if we opened girls' eyes earlier to other options, and the big wide world out there, more of them would respect themselves too much to be impregnanted by losers or men who don't respect them.

Soothsayer1 · 21/11/2022 00:23

Why on earth do you think there are so many millions of women on dating apps?!
isn't it quite a lot more men than women though?☝