Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 21/11/2022 13:59

behave? Because it's 'tradition?'
Not tradition but wanting to pick and choose what suits from tradition and feminism.

Equality in opportunities and pay but at the sane time, to be able to choose not to work or only few hours yet enjoy the financial benefits as if they work.

They want to be a main carer to the children because that brings rewards, but share 50% of the not so much fun tasks associated with being a parent.

They want financial security but without earning the money yet having the exact same right to it. However, they want to be able to leave and have all the rights over the children.

Not all of course, but some have mindsets that are very entitled.

vivainsomnia · 21/11/2022 13:51

To me I think it's pretty simple, unless you're already a higher earner earning significantly more than your husband, it's very likely that when you have children, your earning potential and career progression will decrease or slow down and he will earn more than you
Why very likely? Many many mothers keep earning more after having children. I was on £17k when I got pregnant with my first, £55k when she left school.

Why demeaning mums and their ability to be good mums and progress in their career? It can be done, if you want it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/11/2022 13:44

@PurpleButterflyWings

Oh here we go again! Didn't think it would be long before this drivel was trotted out. 'Single women are much happier than married women' is a myth created by single women to make other single women feel better. It's absolute horseshit and a ludicrous and laughable generalisation that all single women are happier than married women.

Lots to unpick here but just to start:

This claim about single women being happier than married women comes from a misreading of some data from the American Time Use Study in 2019. It's not complete drivel but you're right that its been over-extrapolated. But there is some longitudinal data that backs up the idea that overall marriage benefits men more than women.

But you're missing the broader point. You're right that a lot of single women feel they would be happier married. That doesn't necessarily mean they actually would be happier married. It's a snapshot of attitudes at a time in their lives when they are constantly bombarded with societal pressure that tells them the only worthwhile goal in their lives is to be married with children. A lot of women in their late 20s and early 30s are unhappily single. Many of those same women, 15 years on, wish they were single again because marriage has abjectly failed to live up to their expectations.

But also more significantly, even if, as a woman, you are happier married, you should still protect yourself financially. Marriage is often treated (both on MN and in RL) as an end financial goal for women. The assumption is that all you have to do to secure your financial security is to get married. Of course if you're going to stop work then this is good advice. But it only tells half the story. If you already have financial autonomy, then you are in a much stronger position, both married or single.

A lot of women assume that if the are married they will be OK in the event of divorce "because I'll get half his assets". Well, maybe you will. But you'll also have to maintain that house after having been out of the workforce for many years. It's not as simple as that.

There's nothing wrong with being married and in many cases its financially advantageous to women to get married. But it shouldn't be the be all and end all of a woman's economic ambition.

LexMitior · 21/11/2022 13:36

There are a lot of women in poverty once they get past retirement age, more so than men.

The state pension is not going to cover a nice life. If you have been at home with children then won't even get the full amount.

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/11/2022 13:33

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 21/11/2022 13:31

Women should contribute to a private pension the moment they start working - don't rely on the state pension, or your husband's. You need your own for a comfortable retirement

And save really, really hard into that pension, because last week there were posters suggesting that if you have a private pension you should be deprived of the state one.

So we should slog away for 50 years and hardly see our kids just so we end up with a mediocre pension at the end of it? What a depressing life

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 21/11/2022 13:31

Women should contribute to a private pension the moment they start working - don't rely on the state pension, or your husband's. You need your own for a comfortable retirement

And save really, really hard into that pension, because last week there were posters suggesting that if you have a private pension you should be deprived of the state one.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 21/11/2022 13:29

I'm all for minding my own business when it comes to other women's decisions about their home and family set-up, and am uninterested in their opinions or judgement of mine. This stance would seem to be consistent with the attitude that it's their lives, and if they want to make poor decisions, on their heads be it.

Women are no more incapable of sorting out their own financial security than men are of operating a washing machine and ironing their own shirts. I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who have more common sense than to leave these things to chance.

Our backward culture also has a lot to answer for with the idea that women should sit pretty and wait for a 'proposal', thereby allowing men to make the major decisions regarding the future structure of both their lives. Why adhere to this backward view of how women should behave? Because it's 'tradition?' IMO passivity does no one any favours and isn't a good model for any relationship. I didn't want to run my adult life on this basis, so didn't. There's a clear choice.

EhLov · 21/11/2022 13:27

Many people are struggling even on two incomes.

Oh totally, like he does need to earn too 😂

Sorry I was unclear. Yeah no family can survive on one income these days! Over half of whatever you both pull in goes on rent anyway 🙄

strivingtosucceed · 21/11/2022 13:25

EhLov · 21/11/2022 13:24

He could beat you, leave, cheat, become seriously ill or die, you need to protect yourself.

Exactly. So you need to make sure that your income won’t drop by a penny, whether he stays or goes.

I.e you need to earn your own, and not rely on his. Married or not.

I mean, that was the second point in my epistle.

EhLov · 21/11/2022 13:24

He could beat you, leave, cheat, become seriously ill or die, you need to protect yourself.

Exactly. So you need to make sure that your income won’t drop by a penny, whether he stays or goes.

I.e you need to earn your own, and not rely on his. Married or not.

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/11/2022 13:21

strivingtosucceed · 21/11/2022 13:20

Anyone who's ever had a relationship end knows that you can't force a partner to do anything. He could beat you, leave, cheat, become seriously ill or die, you need to protect yourself. Also, not all women can get good enough jobs to support the whole family. Many people are struggling even on two incomes.

Not according to MN, women are forced to do all sorts by malign males on here.

strivingtosucceed · 21/11/2022 13:20

EhLov · 21/11/2022 13:10

it's very likely that when you have children, your earning potential and career progression will decrease or slow

Surely only if you let it? Why not make sure you just… earn well?

Make sure he does childcare to accommodate your career.
Make sure you don’t leave the labour market.
Keep your money.
Don’t get married.

Surely that’s far preferable to having to ask a man for some of his money (or marriage to access it)?

Anyone who's ever had a relationship end knows that you can't force a partner to do anything. He could beat you, leave, cheat, become seriously ill or die, you need to protect yourself. Also, not all women can get good enough jobs to support the whole family. Many people are struggling even on two incomes.

LexMitior · 21/11/2022 13:19

It's about thinking how you will live your whole life, not just your child bearing years.

We are living longer and longer. Women should contribute to a private pension the moment they start working - don't rely on the state pension, or your husband's. You need your own for a comfortable retirement.

EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 13:13

EhLov · 21/11/2022 13:10

it's very likely that when you have children, your earning potential and career progression will decrease or slow

Surely only if you let it? Why not make sure you just… earn well?

Make sure he does childcare to accommodate your career.
Make sure you don’t leave the labour market.
Keep your money.
Don’t get married.

Surely that’s far preferable to having to ask a man for some of his money (or marriage to access it)?

Marriage isn't just convenient for entitlement in divorce, but also in sickness and death. So while I agree with all these things, legally marriage is a sensible idea. And, in reality, women do earn less than men (gender gap is not a myth).

But yes, one of the reasons I work (out of many) is to protect my financial independence.

EhLov · 21/11/2022 13:10

it's very likely that when you have children, your earning potential and career progression will decrease or slow

Surely only if you let it? Why not make sure you just… earn well?

Make sure he does childcare to accommodate your career.
Make sure you don’t leave the labour market.
Keep your money.
Don’t get married.

Surely that’s far preferable to having to ask a man for some of his money (or marriage to access it)?

strivingtosucceed · 21/11/2022 13:07

To me I think it's pretty simple, unless you're already a higher earner earning significantly more than your husband, it's very likely that when you have children, your earning potential and career progression will decrease or slow down and he will earn more than you. Obviously it's possible to catch up, but the likelihood of that decreases the more children you have and the more part-time you go.

To protect yourself in this situation, it's imperative you marry, so you have access to the assets built up in the case of divorce. It's also important you continue working in some capacity to keep your work experience current in the event you suddenly have to start working again.

If you are not in the above situation, all it means is you need to consider the benefits and disbenefits of working/marrying and see if it works for you. There is no advice that will apply to everyone, but for many or even most women, it will work for them.

Something i'll also mention here, I think more women should insist on their partners sharing custody more equally. I see so many women who have 75% or more of their kids' time which restricts their working capacity and puts htem in hardship. Yes, you want to see your kids, but I really do think it sets them back a lot.

vivainsomnia · 21/11/2022 13:03

Actual fucking WOW! Shock The jealousy and bitterness is strong on THIS one!!
Haha, the good old 'you must be jealous' when you dare bring up what many think but won't admit!

No jealousy on my part at all in any way. I've been with someone but not marry and that was the best decision I could have made. I'm now married but totally self sufficient financially. Actually a trait that attracted my OH who got done by his ex who left for another man taking half.

We're both pleased to be able to depend as much on ourselves as eachother. I would gate being financially dependent on a man, especially now the kids are grown up, and would hate having to support someone just because they never wanted to work or go back to work

So jealous? Most certainly not 😀Not sure the opposite can be said, reading all the posts from women who seem to have grown to hate their husband or partner and miserable but won't leave because of the lifestyle they want that they can only have staying with someone they despise a bit more every year. No, I wouldn't trade for a million year!

PurpleButterflyWings · 21/11/2022 12:50

@Peedoffo

Many women now out earn their partners. My best friend won't get married her DM has given her a 400k house.

🙄

This post isn't even worthy of a response tbh. But I'll bite. Many women DON'T out-earn their partners, only on mumsnet do the majority of working women earn more than their partners. And as for your 'friend' being given a £400K house. Words fail me. This will not happen to 99.9999999% of women - ever!

And as a pp said, imagine if a man refused to get married because he wanted to protect his assets and the equity on his house! Some posters on here would be frothing at the gills!

@vivainsomnia

Too many women want their cake and eat it. They want to be SAHM or work PT, hours of their choosing whilst enjoying a perfect work life balance whilst still enjoying all the money that offers.

Actual fucking WOW! Shock The jealousy and bitterness is strong on THIS one!!!

I mean GOD FORBID that some women want to have children and work shock horror part time! So they can have a good work/life balance. Are you actually kidding me right now?! Confused

You're seem so bitter, and are clearly jealous of part time working mums, and stay-at-home-mums ... Your entire posts screams bitterness and jealousy. NOT a good look!

EhLov · 21/11/2022 12:41

Women also need to take account of their financial future - pension, employment after children leave home or go to school.

Thats put it well, Lex.

It’s less an issue of Marry or Don’t Marry, and more an issue of Earn or Don’t Earn.

In my opinion, being a grown adult without your own dollar is just too disempowering.

LexMitior · 21/11/2022 11:49

Women also need to take account of their financial future - pension, employment after children leave home or go to school.

There will be a lot of women heading for poverty based on being at home and not returning to work or going part time.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 21/11/2022 11:43

*I know you've said most not all, and especially those with children so I do acknowledge you're trying not to make a sweeping generalisation... but please, don't cringe on my behalf, don't feel awkward on my behalf and be assured that I am not heart broken. I am happily unmarried, secure in my decision and now my friends' marriages are starting to sadly end even less convinced by marriage as an emotional concept, or one that I should feel heart broken not to have experienced.

As a legal concept, yes, I understand completely and particularly where children are involved but since I'm child free and the higher earner, don't pity me anymore than you pity anyone else happy with their life choices!*

This this this. And I speak as someone who has experienced this wonderful thing called marriage that we're all supposed to long for and have NO intention of falling for that one again.

Crazycrazylady · 21/11/2022 11:35

Honestly I think of all of this is a red herring. I wouldn't get married to my partner if I had far more assets than him or had inherited family home etc. I would know that he could potentially leave me In a couple of years for some one else and take half my parents home with him. I don't blame men for feeling that way too.
The issue isn't really about marriage, it's about woman being the ones who often choose to give up their careers/work to stay at home and mind their kids. It leaves that partner in such a vulnerable state if the relationship breaks down .

vivainsomnia · 21/11/2022 11:34

They're wrong about it all. Men are laughing at them
Talk about utter rubbish! I'm glad I didn't have to marry to enjoy sex. I glad I could pick to marry a man I'm sexually compatible with.

I chose to start a career before having kids and to continue to work FT so not to make me vulnerable. Turned out to be the best decision when we separated.

I had many days of dreaming of being a SAHM. What an easier life it would have been, but I wasn't prepared to trade easier for more vulnerable.

Too many women want their cake and eat it. They want to be SAHM or work PT, hours of their choosing whilst enjoying a perfect work life balance whilst still enjoying all the money that offers, but then to be able to continue as much of that lifestyle as possible after separation or divorce.

Ultimately, no one wants to be in a vulnerable position nor want to be shafted. Women want financial security and feel they ate therefore owed marriage that protects them. Men want to protect themselves so that if their SAHM wives, enjoying spending the money he brings in, decides when it suits her to take her bags and the kids, they don't find themselves losing most of their financial comfort in addition to his family.

Peedoffo · 21/11/2022 11:28

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/11/2022 11:07

Ok, but what would you say if the sexes were reversed? If he wouldn’t marry her to protect his equity?

He's not having having to take extended leave from work, he's having standard paternity leave so his earning power won't be affected. My friend is taking maternity leave and will be primary carer for the new DC. If he was the primary carer for the DC I would say it's cruel and she should marry him.

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/11/2022 11:07

Peedoffo · 21/11/2022 10:58

Many women now out earn their partners. My best friend won't get married her DM has given her a 400k house. She wants to keep the equity she's having a baby but no interest in marrying because it wouldn't financially benefit her. It's this sexist trope that women have no money so need to marry a wealthy man for financial security.

Ok, but what would you say if the sexes were reversed? If he wouldn’t marry her to protect his equity?