Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
EhLov · 21/11/2022 18:05

EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 17:51

Yes, I am. And yes, general "you" should be. But the reality is not everyone is. And if you are relying on your partner's income to support a career break, or maternity leave, or whatever, then you need to have the fall back of marriage.

But again, it's also handy for death or illness, not just divorce. So sensible in many ways, legally.

Sorry, I should’ve said ‘one’ not ‘you’ but yes you get what I mean.

I agree with the pooling, it usually allows for a nicer life for all. But just don’t rely.

And surely if you want a career break, you need to save for / fund that career break. How is that the man’s job to fund your break?

I remember being on ML on SMP from all 3 of mine, in early 20s.
Never asked a penny from the dad, though we are a happy and committed couple. It just wouldn’t occur to me to ask him for money. That’s his money. I just budgeted well and then worked HARD to climb in my career. It’s just so much safer.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/11/2022 18:02

@EndlessRain

There is merit in pooling resources and working towards a common goal. I would not say marriage is inherently bad. You have partnerships in business for the same reason.

Of course and a good and equally balanced marriage is life enhancing and enriching, both financially and emotionally.

But marriage as a financial end in itself, targeting a man in order to get him to support you in order to remain at home with your children (which is a model I have seen advocated on here and hinted at on this thread) is a recipe for alienation, resentment and dishonesty on both sides.

Justthisonce12 · 21/11/2022 18:00

@Thepeopleversuswork women’s Lib. Seemed to mark end women supporting each other and for us to start competing in yet another area of life. And the patriarchy would probably combust If we all started pulling in the same direction.

cherish123 · 21/11/2022 17:55

Bizarre. When would you not work or severely reduce your income if you were not married. It's very risky. It's not always the man who doesn't want to commit, though. Marriage isn't for everyone. There are benefits of both.

EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 17:53

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/11/2022 17:48

@KathyWilliams

it is absolutely an insurance policy against not working.

sure and if you’re not planning to work it’s essential.

I would argue that being financially independent in the first place and negating the need for such insurance is a much better option to buying an insurance policy which includes tolerating loads of shit from another human being who are legally shackled to and having to go through a lengthy, expensive and painful legal process to extricate yourself from.

There is merit in pooling resources and working towards a common goal. I would not say marriage is inherently bad. You have partnerships in business for the same reason.

EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 17:51

EhLov · 21/11/2022 17:49

who is not financially independent to marry from a legal perspective.

I don’t get this. Surely you should just be financially independent? You’re a grown adult.

Yes, I am. And yes, general "you" should be. But the reality is not everyone is. And if you are relying on your partner's income to support a career break, or maternity leave, or whatever, then you need to have the fall back of marriage.

But again, it's also handy for death or illness, not just divorce. So sensible in many ways, legally.

EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 17:50

EhLov · 21/11/2022 17:47

Marriage is an insurance policy against not working.

It’s so romantic.

Also I think about what example I want to set my daughters.

Do I want them to know I spend dad’s money because we’re married, so I can.

Or do I want them to see me hustling my own money?

Always the latter. They need to see a woman who earns well. IMO.

I don't think there is anything wrong about showing you are a team or unit. Financially or otherwise. That is what a partnership is, joining together and working together towards a joint goal (in this case the family). I also think it's fine to talk about marriage and commitment as a sign of love. That, and teaching the value of financial independence are not mutually exclusive.

EhLov · 21/11/2022 17:49

who is not financially independent to marry from a legal perspective.

I don’t get this. Surely you should just be financially independent? You’re a grown adult.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/11/2022 17:48

@KathyWilliams

it is absolutely an insurance policy against not working.

sure and if you’re not planning to work it’s essential.

I would argue that being financially independent in the first place and negating the need for such insurance is a much better option to buying an insurance policy which includes tolerating loads of shit from another human being who are legally shackled to and having to go through a lengthy, expensive and painful legal process to extricate yourself from.

EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 17:47

Marriage is a legal tool to confer rights between the parties. Whether or not it is in your interest to do so of course depends on your position at the outset. I would advise any woman having children with a man and who is not financially independent to marry from a legal perspective. Not just for divorce but also for death. It's the prudent thing to do. It comes with pros and cons of course, like most arrangements.

But other than that, I am not sure why there is this holy grail of marriage, that we should trade the rights to our body and sexual liberation for.

EhLov · 21/11/2022 17:47

Marriage is an insurance policy against not working.

It’s so romantic.

Also I think about what example I want to set my daughters.

Do I want them to know I spend dad’s money because we’re married, so I can.

Or do I want them to see me hustling my own money?

Always the latter. They need to see a woman who earns well. IMO.

KathyWilliams · 21/11/2022 17:42

Marriage is an insurance policy against not working. It shouldn’t be a financial goal in its own right and I can’t see any other reasons to bother with it

I do and don't agree with this. I think it can give children more stability - but leaving that aside, it is absolutely an insurance policy against not working. After my divorce (clean break - ex paid no child support/spousal support), I was able to continue to be a SAHM precisely because I had been married and ended up with a large share of significant marital assets. If I hadn't been married, I'd have been completely stuffed.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/11/2022 17:33

She now feels marriage was the single worst decision she ever made.

Same for me. I would caution my DD against marrying unless she planned to stop working for any length of time (which I wouldn’t advise unless it was essential for reasons of health).

I was lucky not to lose my home as a result of having been married and I would be £70k better off if I hadn’t got divorced.

Marriage is an insurance policy against not working. It shouldn’t be a financial goal in its own right and I can’t see any other reasons to bother with it.

ItsaMetalBand · 21/11/2022 17:25

MN terrifies me into working my ass off on a FT basis.

Me too. I started reading on here when I was TTC - unmarried and many of the clichés on this thread applied. While I did see the issues of being a SAHM from my own mother with a financially controlling husband, MN was the modern reminder that men really don't change all that much.

So I thought - either I could quit this relationship of 8 years and find someone who would instantly marry me, or stay and ensure that I stayed independent enough to be ok if marriage never happened. I chose the latter.

Now, he's the best hands on dad I know but even so, there was often this assumption that I'd have to sort something out if childcare fell through or take time off for a sick DC so I pushed from day one that we took turns and were equal partners in every respect.

Then marriage actually didn't matter once I was financially stable for myself. That even if he did turn out to be a shithead, I'd be ok with DS if needs be. We did get married eventually - I was the one not bothering to organise a wedding but no, I've not settled into complacency. I'll continue to work FT, progress and continue to get pay rises and ensure that I earn because you just don't know what life might throw at our family and the ability to have a good well paying career that you can negotiate flexibility for home life is really important.

GiraffesCauseTrouble · 21/11/2022 17:07

She now feels marriage was the single worst decision she ever made.

It was the same for me. Worst financial decision I ever made.

ZoeCM · 21/11/2022 16:57

Testina · 21/11/2022 16:16

Nothing like a bit of anecdata, but every person I know who has had an “accidental” pregnancy, it’s been nothing of the sort.

  • one friend years later admitted it was deliberate lying about taking the pill
  • one decided breastfeeding would protect her, but knew full well that was a risk
  • one family member was adamant they were on the pill and much later admitted they’d gone to the GP for the pill during a two week wait when they turned out to already be pregnant
  • just plain old taking a risk after a one night stand

There are more. Even just incorrect use has been done in the full knowledge it was incorrect and taking a risk.

Yes. I don't believe contraception failure is as common as MN insists it is. I think a lot of women have partners who are dragging their feet about commitment, and they think to themselves, "Well, I'm not getting any younger, lying about a few pills isn't a crime, I'm doing him a favour really, he'll love the baby once it's here..."

Eastie77Returns · 21/11/2022 16:50

Oujiawoowoo · 20/11/2022 20:51

As for financial protection and kids…I have two DC. I bought the house we live in on my own as their dad had no money (and lots of debt). I earn 5x his salary and can manage perfectly fine on my own. I am not marrying him and potentially linking myself to his shambolic financial situation.

Women should be educated to develop financial independence regardless of their marital status.

I agree with you - but you are the exception - very few women earn 5 x more than their DH’s, especially when they are mothers.

Admittedly 5x salary is unusual but it isn’t as rare as you might think for women to significantly out earn their partners/husbands. I have several friends in this situation. One met her ‘D’P when she earned six figures and owned a couple of properties. He worked part time and lived in a house share. They married, had DC and he decided he didn’t want to work at all, preferring to focus on a hobby that brought in virtually no income. Fast forward a few years and several affairs (his) later and she wants to divorce him but is worried about losing her assets and also sharing childcare with an utterly irresponsible and useless dad who will be in a position to claim maintenance from her. She now feels marriage was the single worst decision she ever made.

Its not always in a woman’s best interest.

I also agree with a PP that it is frankly depressing that women are encouraged to cajole reluctant partners down the aisle just so they can get protected financially. Many of these men become resentful, cheating husbands and the misery that plays out in these sham marriages is there for all to see on MN’s Relationships board every day. I don’t know if the financial safety net marriage allegedly confers is worth the stress, abuse and humiliation many women go through. Also, many married men manage to manipulate the system to avoid paying maintenance and hide assets etc.

Neanov · 21/11/2022 16:43

I agree OP. For me it was lack of guidance and I had no idea how motherhood can change your world and it quickly can turn south if you don't have your child/children to a decent man.

I don't think the importance of marriage is pushed enough... I read a thread some time ago and women was upset shouting it's not the vikings time.

Marriage is important though. This trend of having multiple kids to shit fathers needs to stop too!

I learnt the lesson the hard way I stuck to my 1 child! But I would love another.

vivainsomnia · 21/11/2022 16:22

I didn't say you'll earn less, I said it's likely that if you hadn't had your daughter, you'd either be on more than £55k or you'd have gotten there much quicker AND it's very probable that your husband still earns more than you
No, not really. I actually was offered another promotion but didn't take it. My children were already older teenagers. I just didn't want it.

I wouldn't have progressed quicker without them and no, my husband earns slightly less.

So many assumptions made to justify one's choice. I wanted a career for myself and my financial independence. I also wanted a great relationship with my kids and managed both as have most of my friends and colleagues.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/11/2022 16:22

@MarieIVanArkleStinks

Nor do I ever remember seeing that infuriating phrase 'having it all' applied to men.
The expectation of a family and a career is something men have always taken for granted. A work-life balance with both partners working and sharing parenting and domestic labour is hardly an egregious demand.
The phrase is also meaningless. We learn from a very young age that nobody can have absolutely everything they want.

Thank you. I loathe this "women can't have it all" narrative. It's just (yet) another way of putting women back in their box.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/11/2022 16:21

@Justthisonce12

I also think a hell of a lot of men do not want to be fathers.
and indeed, for one reason or another should not be fathers, and if only we could educate our young people to spot the signs in both yourself and others.

I don't disagree with you that a lot of men don't want to be fathers and probably shouldn't. I certainly think a much large proportion of men than we will admit are basically not that interested in marriage and children.

But the logic here is warped; people on this thread (not necessarily you) seem to be arguing that the solution to this is to make sure women use sex as a bargaining chip to get married to wealthy men in order to live off their income.

If so many men are inadequate fathers, the idea that trapping them into marriage and forcing them to provide for women more or less in perpetuity is nonsense. Surely it's far better to educate girls and young women to provide for themselves as far as they possibly can and use marriage (only if its absolutely essential) as an insurance policy for when they can't work. Rather than holding marriage up as the Holy Grail of financial achievement.

That's not consistent with your argument that women's lib hasn't helped women. Surely with shit, feckless and lazy fathers we need more women's lib, not less?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 21/11/2022 16:19

Coffeepot72 · 21/11/2022 15:40

I agree that women's liberation has been an own goal in some areas - remember when we woke up and realised that 'having it all' basically means 'doing it all' ??

No.

Nor do I ever remember seeing that infuriating phrase 'having it all' applied to men.

The expectation of a family and a career is something men have always taken for granted. A work-life balance with both partners working and sharing parenting and domestic labour is hardly an egregious demand.

The phrase is also meaningless. We learn from a very young age that nobody can have absolutely everything they want.

Testina · 21/11/2022 16:16

Nothing like a bit of anecdata, but every person I know who has had an “accidental” pregnancy, it’s been nothing of the sort.

  • one friend years later admitted it was deliberate lying about taking the pill
  • one decided breastfeeding would protect her, but knew full well that was a risk
  • one family member was adamant they were on the pill and much later admitted they’d gone to the GP for the pill during a two week wait when they turned out to already be pregnant
  • just plain old taking a risk after a one night stand

There are more. Even just incorrect use has been done in the full knowledge it was incorrect and taking a risk.

strivingtosucceed · 21/11/2022 16:06

vivainsomnia · 21/11/2022 13:51

To me I think it's pretty simple, unless you're already a higher earner earning significantly more than your husband, it's very likely that when you have children, your earning potential and career progression will decrease or slow down and he will earn more than you
Why very likely? Many many mothers keep earning more after having children. I was on £17k when I got pregnant with my first, £55k when she left school.

Why demeaning mums and their ability to be good mums and progress in their career? It can be done, if you want it.

I didn't say you'll earn less, I said it's likely that if you hadn't had your daughter, you'd either be on more than £55k or you'd have gotten there much quicker AND it's very probable that your husband still earns more than you.

Justthisonce12 · 21/11/2022 15:54

@Thepeopleversuswork im certain theres some middle ground.

I also think a hell of a lot of men do not want to be fathers.

and indeed, for one reason or another should not be fathers, and if only we could educate our young people to spot the signs in both yourself and others.

I have a 30-year-old colleague who has two beautiful, healthy daughters and would like a vasectomy, the NHS will not sanction it on the basis that he’s too young, and he might change his mind. Can you imagine the reaction an 20-year-old might receive.