Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
Twizbe · 21/11/2022 22:15

Shitfather · 21/11/2022 21:56

Sadly, a lot of Muslim women get fucked over by having an Islamic marriage only. I wish the law would change to automatically recognise these as legal marriages, as is the case with Jewish marriages.

I might be wrong but I think the reason they don't is that the ceremony doesn't include the elements that are required by law.

Also I have a feeling it is because when the bride and groom are asked if they enter the marriage they aren't in the same room.

Shitfather · 21/11/2022 21:56

Sadly, a lot of Muslim women get fucked over by having an Islamic marriage only. I wish the law would change to automatically recognise these as legal marriages, as is the case with Jewish marriages.

lifeinthehills · 21/11/2022 21:53

KathyWilliams · 21/11/2022 21:04

@Mumkins42 This is a really good post. I was absolutely influenced by my own upbringing (i.e. mothers stayed at home and looked after the children/house/pets/everything else, and dad went to work). I'm in my early 50s, though, so am probably older than a lot of the women posting here. I still wouldn't swap the time I spent with my children for any salary, though. Funnily, it was my ex husband who wanted us to get married, when I wasn't bothered. Little did either of us realise what a big favour he was doing me.

I'm a little younger but I'm with you. No regrets about the time taken out for my kids at all. If I have to live with lower income going forward because of it, still no regrets.

One thing this thread has really made me do is appreciate what a good man my husband is. I hope my sons will take him as a role model.

GiraffesCauseTrouble · 21/11/2022 21:53

LexMitior · 21/11/2022 21:23

Yes it's legal protection - get married if you want kids. And the comment about a waste of space man who looks after the kids. Well, it is his protection too. Children deserve this kind of protection because without them divorce is straightforward- if you have kids, protect them and get married before you have them.

Umm... there's no divorce without marriage.

I presume you mean that without marriage people splitting up is more straightforward.

Good. Fewer people living in miserable relationships.

Studies show clearly that separated parents does no damage to children, provided it is amicable and that the children are provided for financially.

So let's focus on:
*affordable, universal childcare
*removing sex discrimination in the workplace, directed at mothers in particular
*equalising the roles of men and women at home with men being expected to do 50% of child rearing
*removing the penalties in the tax system for single adult households
*encouraging women to become financially independent and remain so after having children
*enforcing proper CMS payments that equate to 50% of the costs of raising that child. And prison sentences for those who won't comply as with Council tax.

LexMitior · 21/11/2022 21:23

Yes it's legal protection - get married if you want kids. And the comment about a waste of space man who looks after the kids. Well, it is his protection too. Children deserve this kind of protection because without them divorce is straightforward- if you have kids, protect them and get married before you have them.

DarkKarmaIlama · 21/11/2022 21:21

I don’t know a single person in real life who has put themselves in this situation.

DarkShade · 21/11/2022 21:12

I don't think we need a change of laws, I think that we need women to really understand what marriage is: a form of legal protection.

Like many women, I was raised with this really romantic view of marriage. You meet the one! Your soulmate! You wear a beautiful dress and are a princess and it is the best accomplishment of your life!! And like lots of women I called bullshit and wanted no part in it. It actually took MN to make me realise that this picture plays into the hands of men who want to avoid marriage for the legal implications. We should stop romanticising marriage and bring it back to what women of the past understood: marriage is what ensures that the work that you put into the joint family unit doesn't walk out the door with your ex.

KathyWilliams · 21/11/2022 21:04

@Mumkins42 This is a really good post. I was absolutely influenced by my own upbringing (i.e. mothers stayed at home and looked after the children/house/pets/everything else, and dad went to work). I'm in my early 50s, though, so am probably older than a lot of the women posting here. I still wouldn't swap the time I spent with my children for any salary, though. Funnily, it was my ex husband who wanted us to get married, when I wasn't bothered. Little did either of us realise what a big favour he was doing me.

DarkShade · 21/11/2022 21:01

I agree with you OP, I think marriage is the feminist position.

Of course, in a totally misgynistic-free world it would be unnecessay, because women would not automatically be the ones making concessions to their earning potential to have children. Partnering up with a wealthier man without part owning the house and having children is a terrible position to be in. Just get married, it's protection. And if the partnertship starts out equal you just don't know what will happen with children, when relocation and promotion talk starts happening, and so on. If you are making decisions as a unit where the intention is that everyone will benefit from joint decisions, then the decent thing to do is protect both partners by formally building that unit into the law.

Disclaimer: I actually have a child without being married, but I have higher earning potential than DP and am the one who gave up career for childcare (so no guilt about fleecing him).

MolliciousIntent · 21/11/2022 20:54

BesidetheseasideXxx · 21/11/2022 20:51

Both choices are emotional choices. And for the record my six year old is perfectly fine and has never been classed as vulnerable. Done now.

I'm happy for your good luck. As you frequently see on here, many many many women are not so lucky and they and their children suffer for it.

BesidetheseasideXxx · 21/11/2022 20:51

MolliciousIntent · 21/11/2022 20:35

It's just common sense though, isn't it? You can make the emotional choice but you need to be aware that there's a risk that you're not acting in the best interests of yourself or your child. You can continue with a pregnancy without any legal protection but you should be aware that doing so makes you, and more importantly your child, incredibly vulnerable. It's not a smart thing to do unless you're independently financially secure and will be long term. People don't like to admit that though, as you've shown.

Both choices are emotional choices. And for the record my six year old is perfectly fine and has never been classed as vulnerable. Done now.

MolliciousIntent · 21/11/2022 20:35

BesidetheseasideXxx · 21/11/2022 20:18

So unless the father of the child proposes people with unplanned pregnancies should always have abortions? I don't understand how anyone thinks they've got the right to state what women should do in this situation. There is no right or wrong choice.

It's just common sense though, isn't it? You can make the emotional choice but you need to be aware that there's a risk that you're not acting in the best interests of yourself or your child. You can continue with a pregnancy without any legal protection but you should be aware that doing so makes you, and more importantly your child, incredibly vulnerable. It's not a smart thing to do unless you're independently financially secure and will be long term. People don't like to admit that though, as you've shown.

BesidetheseasideXxx · 21/11/2022 20:18

MolliciousIntent · 21/11/2022 19:29

OP wasn't implying that people in your situation shouldn't continue the pregnancy, they were saying that people in your situation shouldn't continue the pregnancy without legal protection. which is absolutely true.

So unless the father of the child proposes people with unplanned pregnancies should always have abortions? I don't understand how anyone thinks they've got the right to state what women should do in this situation. There is no right or wrong choice.

MrsPetty · 21/11/2022 19:39

I think it’s a really valid question. My exH wasn’t keen to get married but he did want a family. The idea of having DCs with a man who wasn’t willing to commit didn’t swing with me! He seen having children as a commitment enough. If I hadn’t insisted that we married first, I would have
been in exactly the situation that you describe. I became a sahm at his behest … I lost ten years of my career progression and income. To have walked back into a job at the same level post divorce would have been impossible!

MolliciousIntent · 21/11/2022 19:29

BesidetheseasideXxx · 21/11/2022 19:11

I got pregnant on the pill unmarried. YABU to imply that I shouldn't have continued with the pregnancy in these circumstances. Being pro choice also includes respecting women who don't choose abortion.

I was on microgynon and taking a seven day break in between pill packets. A gp told me a few years later that they have now changed the guidance on this as most women getting pregnant on this pill were getting pregnant on thier breaks and now a four day break is recommended instead.

OP wasn't implying that people in your situation shouldn't continue the pregnancy, they were saying that people in your situation shouldn't continue the pregnancy without legal protection. which is absolutely true.

BesidetheseasideXxx · 21/11/2022 19:11

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

I got pregnant on the pill unmarried. YABU to imply that I shouldn't have continued with the pregnancy in these circumstances. Being pro choice also includes respecting women who don't choose abortion.

I was on microgynon and taking a seven day break in between pill packets. A gp told me a few years later that they have now changed the guidance on this as most women getting pregnant on this pill were getting pregnant on thier breaks and now a four day break is recommended instead.

Cleopatra67 · 21/11/2022 19:09

@PurpleButterflyWings and @Coffeepot72 - wow! Such backward views. Do you really believe that women don’t want sex too? People have been having pre marital sex since the dawn of man. I wouldn’t want to marry someone because it’s the only way they could have sex with me. You must all be hanging out with some real Neanderthals if you believe this nonsense.

Cleopatra67 · 21/11/2022 19:05

Coffeepot72 · 21/11/2022 15:40

I agree that women's liberation has been an own goal in some areas - remember when we woke up and realised that 'having it all' basically means 'doing it all' ??

That’s not the fault of feminism, it’s the fault of a still unequal society. What’s the alternative? Forced housewifery and needing a man to countersign your mortgage application?

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 21/11/2022 18:45

Greennetting · 20/11/2022 19:49

To many women are invested in the romance of a proposal and therefore are left hanging around waiting for when a man gets round to it

I went into my relationship as an equal party, therefore I wasn't about to hand all the power to the man and let him set the pace of the relationship solely. Instead we had mature adult discussions about whether we were ready to get engaged the same way we did about whether we were ready to buy a house etc

Not as romantic no, but much more equal. I even got DH an engagement present when he got me a ring because I thought it wasn't fair he got nothing.

But what I see a lot of is women hanging on waiting for their partners to propose. One of my colleagues is currently trying for a baby. They've had conversations about that, but she won't broach the topic of marriage because she wants it to come from him because its more romantic. He is a higher earner who is self employed and travels a lot and will not expect to pick up childcare (and already doesn't pick up housework). She is walking into a situation that could become problematic because romance is more important than practicality.

Years of films and TV shows and books have fed into this myth that the perfect proposal is so important. but its not, at all.

This. So much this. I have friends who are APPALLED I knew what my ring looked like, what it cost (I refused to have an expensive one and set a budget for us to save for, as we had very little money). I knew a proposal was coming, it was at home, nothing fancy. But we had decided together we were ready for that step.

I often tell my friends who are complaining that their husbands/partners haven't done something or got a gesture wrong that if they want something from them, tell them what you want. Communicate. Sounds cliche but it's key to a solid, healthy relationship. If I don't tell my husband I want something or I'm upset, how will he know!?

Invisablewoman · 21/11/2022 18:41

Eastie77Returns · 20/11/2022 20:41

I can wholeheartedly assure you I do not want to get married. Never have, never will. I’m not a raging feminist but marriage has just never appealed.

It’s really odd and a little insulting to assume that ‘deep down’ most women want to walk down the aisle and are in some kind of denial if they say they don’t. Do you honestly think there are no happily unmarried women?

As for financial protection and kids…I have two DC. I bought the house we live in on my own as their dad had no money (and lots of debt). I earn 5x his salary and can manage perfectly fine on my own. I am not marrying him and potentially linking myself to his shambolic financial situation.

Women should be educated to develop financial independence regardless of their marital status.

This^^

Mumkins42 · 21/11/2022 18:38

I was well educated, incredibly independent and self sufficient financially but also very naive in relationships and naive about the world. Alot of the pickles we get ourselves in can be down to ones upbringing, their role models and what they were taught, not taught. I was never taught any of this or talked about any of this and I learnt the hard way, the long way and now call myself very independent and self sufficient, but also wise now - it was only through the experience as you describe that I got there. Thanks s situation would never happen to me again ever because of what I learnt the hard way.

As a parent, I would be sure to convey the importance of these things to my children. Always be self sufficient, even in a partnership, you never know what may happen. Women are not generally positively encouraged to think this way, this is part of the problem passed down from generations.

KathyWilliams · 21/11/2022 18:29

EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 17:53

There is merit in pooling resources and working towards a common goal. I would not say marriage is inherently bad. You have partnerships in business for the same reason.

I'm actually all in favour of marriage for every possible reason (including my religion), and am very much in favour of pooling all resources and sharing a common goal. As it happens, I needed the financial protection too. It would be the same, really, if I were to go into business with someone: I'd want a contract with all our legal rights and responsibilities set out, including what would happen in the event of our going our separate ways. You hope you don't need it, but it makes everything so much easier if you do.

EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 18:26

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/11/2022 18:02

@EndlessRain

There is merit in pooling resources and working towards a common goal. I would not say marriage is inherently bad. You have partnerships in business for the same reason.

Of course and a good and equally balanced marriage is life enhancing and enriching, both financially and emotionally.

But marriage as a financial end in itself, targeting a man in order to get him to support you in order to remain at home with your children (which is a model I have seen advocated on here and hinted at on this thread) is a recipe for alienation, resentment and dishonesty on both sides.

Oh yes, I agree with that. I would NEVER encourage my children (genders aside) to marry with the aim for living of another person.

Iliketosmile · 21/11/2022 18:24

All you need to do is joint own your house and set up a mirror will where everything transfers to the surviving partner. Unless half your house is worth over the death tax level (£600k I think) you'll be fine. Or if they run off with their secretary I guess.

QueenOfHiraeth · 21/11/2022 18:20

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/11/2022 18:02

@EndlessRain

There is merit in pooling resources and working towards a common goal. I would not say marriage is inherently bad. You have partnerships in business for the same reason.

Of course and a good and equally balanced marriage is life enhancing and enriching, both financially and emotionally.

But marriage as a financial end in itself, targeting a man in order to get him to support you in order to remain at home with your children (which is a model I have seen advocated on here and hinted at on this thread) is a recipe for alienation, resentment and dishonesty on both sides.

I was about to raise this that men can be disadvantaged in some ways too.
A dear male friend, probably some undiagnosed ASD, high functioning, extremely clever but rather naive and crap at relationships, had a whirlwind romance with a woman he met at work and married her. He had a high-earning successful career and assets before they met. It did not end well
She moved on and is now divorcing her third husband, having never worked full time but having claimed assets, pensions, etc from all of three
Sadly this seems to be a career choice for some women