Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 20/11/2022 19:50

It makes me wince, not in embarrassment or anything like that but just the exposure and risk these people have.

Know someone (call her Friend A) who was in a relationship with someone for five years, engaged to them, she delayed the wedding to fit into the dress, they had a kid…but not married, he walked away and cheated and she has spent SIX YEARS trying to get any financial support from him, while he wants 50/50 access but hides huge amounts of cash (has his own very successful business).

Same with very sweet friends at school, who thought their boyfriends would be long term and when found they were pregnant they were left with no support from many of their families, no money, just judgement :( now they’re ok but only from their sheer tenacity and friends helping. But Friend A made the same mistake in her 30s… she just assumed she was in a safe place in her life.

Thing is, could happen to any of us at any time. But you wouldn’t spend so much time in business with another person without some formalities, and the same is true of our personal lives - especially when children and their security and happiness is involved. Why risk your and their futures for anything??? Makes me want to scream!

RoseAndGeranium · 20/11/2022 19:50

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 20/11/2022 19:02

I was with you until the "courts going for shared care so no maintenance" bit. If the dad is willing to do 50/50 he absolutely should and the mum can then work and support herself and her share of the kids. Spousal maintenance is vanishingly rare anyway, as it should be as we move on from the generation where women routinely gave up all work for 20+ years.

This is fine in theory. In practice the mother will often have taken some steps back in her career already because of maternity leaves, time out caring for young children etc., so when she re-enters the workforce her earning power will be substantially below that of her wealthier ex. If she wants to support herself she’ll have to work full time and pay for childcare after school and during school holidays (on her days with the children). That will be a much bigger financial hit proportionally than her ex will experience doing the same.

Greennetting · 20/11/2022 19:49

To many women are invested in the romance of a proposal and therefore are left hanging around waiting for when a man gets round to it

I went into my relationship as an equal party, therefore I wasn't about to hand all the power to the man and let him set the pace of the relationship solely. Instead we had mature adult discussions about whether we were ready to get engaged the same way we did about whether we were ready to buy a house etc

Not as romantic no, but much more equal. I even got DH an engagement present when he got me a ring because I thought it wasn't fair he got nothing.

But what I see a lot of is women hanging on waiting for their partners to propose. One of my colleagues is currently trying for a baby. They've had conversations about that, but she won't broach the topic of marriage because she wants it to come from him because its more romantic. He is a higher earner who is self employed and travels a lot and will not expect to pick up childcare (and already doesn't pick up housework). She is walking into a situation that could become problematic because romance is more important than practicality.

Years of films and TV shows and books have fed into this myth that the perfect proposal is so important. but its not, at all.

Georgeskitchen · 20/11/2022 19:48

A staggering amount of people seem to think marriage is "just a piece of paper"
No it isnt

honeylulu · 20/11/2022 19:46

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split

This is OK in principle but how does it work if the father has children with a wife and new partner(s)? The point of marriage/ civil partnership is that it is opt in, not opt out. I can't see how it would work the other way.

PurpleButterflyWings · 20/11/2022 19:43

Twizbe · 20/11/2022 19:06

I was watching location location location this week and the couple on there... the mad was openly laughing about the fact that they'd had a kid, we're buying a house, but he had no plans to propose. The woman was clearly hanging on in hopes it would come.

This. ^ Rightly or wrongly, I actually inwardly cringe at women who've been with a man for 10 or 15 years or more - and especially if they've got one or two or more kids with him - and they're not married. They try and peddle this 'neither of us wants to get married, it's what we both want' bollux, but I know deep down probably 9 out of 10 women want to get married. I think they just try and convince themselves that they don't. But it's because HE doesn't want to in most cases.

I've got a close female relative aged 30 now who's been with the same bloke for 11 years since the age of 19. She kind of wanted to get married for the first three or four years, but he was just right against it. It was 'you'd best find someone else if you want marriage because it's not for me.' She loved him (still does) and didn't want to split, so she settled for this. Then she kept saying, 'I'm never getting married, no way, not ever. Patriarchy, patriarchy, not changing my maiden name, blah, blah, blah, blah. Not being owned by a man etc etc etc!' For about 4 or 5 years she said this!

A couple of years ago, after nine years together, he finally proposed, God knows why he suddenly changed his mind. Nobody has asked. But she was in tears with absolute joy because he asked her to marry him. The wedding is next June.

So it seems all along she did want to get married, but she tried to convince everybody else she didn't. I believe this is the case for a lot of women because why would a woman NOT want to get married? It brings lots more security, and proves the man is committed. And no WAY would I have children with a man without being married.

As I say, deep down I think most women want to get married - not only for the fact they've got security, and it shows commitment from him, but it also feels awkward when virtually every woman you know - sisters, nieces, cousins, friends, work colleagues, neighbours etc etc, are getting married, and YOU are always the bridesmaid, or just a guest.

When every woman has a ring on her finger - it's heart-breaking for a woman who's with a man who refuses to get married. I wouldn't stay with a man if he wouldn't get married. I just wouldn't.

To be honest, if a man has more money than the woman he is with, and has more assets, and is very solvent, they often won't get married. Many well-off men won't get married if they have nothing to gain from it.

Pleasebeafleabite · 20/11/2022 19:41

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:35

Then she is phenomenally daft .. unless of course she has unknown private wealth.

This is not a 'marriage ' thread .. marriage is not the be all end all of everything . It's about the appalling lack of legal protection for women who have children with a man who she isnt married/civil partnered to their OH.. and the 'loop hole ' that the lack of contract affords the man...

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split ..'

So for example :
Lived with a woman for 15 years. 3 kids . Not married . Split treaded in EXACTLY the same way as a marriage ..

You’re overstepping OP if you think that those who have chosen not to get married should have the court decide who gets what when they split.

Half of all marriages fail and there is no joy involved in splitting assets. Far better to have an agreement in the first place which sets out the terms. All perfectly possible without getting married and a far more legally binding

It’s not the dark ages, women are perfectly capable of understanding finance and taking actions to protect their future financial position. And do that every day. They just don’t post about it on MN

drpet49 · 20/11/2022 19:40

These women make a choice to do that. I’ve got no sympathy for them when it goes tits up.

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:40

We need a MN campaign !

Child with another half ? His /her assets are up for the split settlement .. based on child care... ?

OP posts:
RJnomore1 · 20/11/2022 19:36

Even if you get married never let your career suffer in relation to his - seen it too many times in friends, she drops part time to collect kids so he doesn’t get hassled at work, 10/15/20 years later it falls apart, she can’t afford to buy him out, home relationship and way of life all gone in one swoop.

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:35

Zanatdy · 20/11/2022 19:25

I think some women just don’t even consider some things. I said to my best friend that she should get married (engaged over 10yrs, I don’t think she actually wants to marry him but that’s another story, her head would be turned easily) as if they split she’s done years of part time and her DP has had to pay minimal childcare and build up a nice pension for herself. She hadn’t even actually considered this and I could see the cogs turning as the realisation dawned on her. He wants to get married though, it’s her who has stalled all these years.

Then she is phenomenally daft .. unless of course she has unknown private wealth.

This is not a 'marriage ' thread .. marriage is not the be all end all of everything . It's about the appalling lack of legal protection for women who have children with a man who she isnt married/civil partnered to their OH.. and the 'loop hole ' that the lack of contract affords the man...

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split ..'

So for example :
Lived with a woman for 15 years. 3 kids . Not married . Split treaded in EXACTLY the same way as a marriage ..

OP posts:
drunkinthebackofthecar · 20/11/2022 19:34

I find it’s almost impossible to talk to women in these situations about these things as well. My sister in law and an ex-colleague/friend have gotten into this exact situation over the last few years - my SIL had a baby with her boyfriend in a house they co-own but his family provided the deposit for, and she’s now gone very part time in a job that was already low paying and didn’t have much career progression. Her boyfriend brings in almost all their money, baby has his name. I tried to talk to her about pensions/national insurance contributions/baby having both names/not giving up so much work and she just was so awkward and side-stepping I gave up. They don’t even have will’s, which my husband has talked to them about loads - if her boyfriend was to die tomorrow she’d get nothing!

What shocks me is a lot of the women who end up in these situations are clever, switched on and feminist women who just seem to lose their common sense, and then I think maybe are embarrassed so it becomes worse? I don’t know. It worries me a lot.

Bretonstrip · 20/11/2022 19:31

I’d go as far as to include married women who don’t work in this post tbh

The “oh he’s not like that”, the “he loves his kids“ posters; the “he wouldn’t do that to me” posters

Yes he would
Yes they do
Yes he can

So what if you get the house in the divorce? How you planning on paying your bills the next month when you’ve got 50/50 and he ain’t paying you a penny anymore….

lot of women out there who need to give their heads a wobble

and YES I was one of them!

DashboardConfessional · 20/11/2022 19:27

The fact is that an unmarried couple where one owns the property aren't recognised as having any sort of "contract". Because they don't. In law, they may as well be housemates who have fallen out, then one has left and is demanding some of the house.

Januarcelebration · 20/11/2022 19:27

roarfeckingroarr · 20/11/2022 19:20

I can see both sides. I'm the higher earner and own the house plus others in my name early. I won't marry - too many cock lodger men like the one in the other thread where the woman works 80 hours and he does v little at home.

I am the same, will not marry. but I am always upfront and honest and I wouldn’t support someone giving up their income, with a promise of always looking after them.

I wouldn’t make Dps situation worse for my benefit and mislead him that I would take care of him. Dp knows my stance and is happy with it.

Zanatdy · 20/11/2022 19:26

The contraception failures are women who are too embarrassed to say they’ve planned a baby in this position

Zanatdy · 20/11/2022 19:25

I think some women just don’t even consider some things. I said to my best friend that she should get married (engaged over 10yrs, I don’t think she actually wants to marry him but that’s another story, her head would be turned easily) as if they split she’s done years of part time and her DP has had to pay minimal childcare and build up a nice pension for herself. She hadn’t even actually considered this and I could see the cogs turning as the realisation dawned on her. He wants to get married though, it’s her who has stalled all these years.

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:23

heliosunburg · 20/11/2022 19:15

What do you hope to get out of this post? Is this about advising people or...?

Yes !!! and 1000 x this !!

My agenda is to get this situation into schools .

Knowledge really IS power.. so many myths about 'common law wives' .. or complete lack of knowledge.

OP posts:
Januarcelebration · 20/11/2022 19:22

My personal opinion is because society teaches ‘all you need is love’.

While I do think you should love someone in a long term relationship, we are taught everything will work out as long as there’s love and that we ‘just know’ when it’s forever.

People are in love and swept off their feet. So they forge forward ignoring the huge red flags. Ignoring the vulnerable position they are putting themselves in, because they believe the love will always be like that. They don’t believe a partner will never just fall out of love and treat them differently. That’s not the Happy ever after they have led to believe is true.

Then there’s also the ‘marriage is a just a piece of paper lie’ that so many people peddle.

honeylulu · 20/11/2022 19:22

I agree. I know a lot of women with children who don't work or work part time but consider they are cool/modern/independent for not being married. That's all lovely if their partner sticks around but if it isn't then they're fucked without independent wealth/income. He should pay maintenance for the kids but they'll see fuck all else. 50% equity (if you're on the deeds) but his savings, investments, pensions, forget it.

RandomMusings7 · 20/11/2022 19:21

So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

I'm very suspicious of the sheer amount of contraception failures on mumsnet. I think most of them are users being reckless or engineering happy little accidents.

roarfeckingroarr · 20/11/2022 19:20

I can see both sides. I'm the higher earner and own the house plus others in my name early. I won't marry - too many cock lodger men like the one in the other thread where the woman works 80 hours and he does v little at home.

Waterfalls39 · 20/11/2022 19:18

I think the trouble with MN is that people don't tend to post about good relationships, only bad ones so there's a skewed perception that all men are shits. Yes, some are but there are a lot of decent ones out there too.

Luredbyapomegranate · 20/11/2022 19:18

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 20/11/2022 19:02

I was with you until the "courts going for shared care so no maintenance" bit. If the dad is willing to do 50/50 he absolutely should and the mum can then work and support herself and her share of the kids. Spousal maintenance is vanishingly rare anyway, as it should be as we move on from the generation where women routinely gave up all work for 20+ years.

I think the point the OP is making is about women who have not been working because they’ve been looking after the kids. If their ex goes for 50/50 then it can be incredibly hard for them to keep their financial end up, with no recent work experience.

As 50/50 becomes more common I think the finances around it need to be revised anyway, so both parents can find their financial feet and the children aren’t disadvantaged while they do.

RefuseTheLies · 20/11/2022 19:18

Twizbe · 20/11/2022 19:06

I was watching location location location this week and the couple on there... the mad was openly laughing about the fact that they'd had a kid, we're buying a house, but he had no plans to propose. The woman was clearly hanging on in hopes it would come.

I saw that. I had massive second hand embarrassment for her.