Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 21:00

*I can wholeheartedly assure you I do not want to get married. Never have, never will. I’m not a raging feminist but marriage has just never appealed.

It’s really odd and a little insulting to assume that ‘deep down’ most women want to walk down the aisle and are in some kind of denial if they say they don’t. Do you honestly think there are no happily unmarried women?

As for financial protection and kids…I have two DC. I bought the house we live in on my own as their dad had no money (and lots of debt). I earn 5x his salary and can manage perfectly fine on my own. I am not marrying him and potentially linking myself to his shambolic financial situation.

Women should be educated to develop financial independence regardless of their marital status.*

Then you MUST BE AWARE that this post does not relate to your situation !!

It is about the thousands of women who are NOT in your fortunate set up.. .

No one with any iota of common sense would think that you need legal protection...

However , back in the real world there are MANY more women in the opposite situation

This thread is about them . Not you .

This is about the many many women living with men who have NEVER offered a legal contract of marriage or civil partnership. Not once have I mentioned 'a wedding' .. 'walking down the aisle' .. this is not about romance ..

It's about women with less earning power than men because they have children that are the responsibility of BOTH .. and yet he continues to further his career .. his pension.. .. his savings .. whilst she sacrifices her career , savings, pension .. and whilst there is recompense via the marriage contract /civil partnership. There is nothing for the unmarried .

OP posts:
1ittlegreen · 20/11/2022 20:56

It seems the crux of all these divorce complaints is not mapping out a pre-nup, having no incentive to work or not having individual wills.

Wtf? Educate yourselves and your dcs, marriage is for romance or to realise a pre-conceived idea. Inheritance tax is a misnomer if there are proper wills in place.

Why does being married change some women into relaxing and letting go of all financial responsibilities?

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 20/11/2022 20:54

Oujiawoowoo · 20/11/2022 20:51

As for financial protection and kids…I have two DC. I bought the house we live in on my own as their dad had no money (and lots of debt). I earn 5x his salary and can manage perfectly fine on my own. I am not marrying him and potentially linking myself to his shambolic financial situation.

Women should be educated to develop financial independence regardless of their marital status.

I agree with you - but you are the exception - very few women earn 5 x more than their DH’s, especially when they are mothers.

I’m unmarried and genuinely don’t know.. is there a difference with who is assumed your next of kin, if you’re married? Eg medical decisions, who makes them for you if you’re out of it? Not even sure if relevant!

I wouldn’t marry without a pre nup (including treatment of assets and childcare in case of separation). I wouldn’t have kids without being married. I want to pre-program it as much as possible, I know it’s not failsafe at all but the more certainty the better

Pleasebeafleabite · 20/11/2022 20:53

Newlifestartingatlast · 20/11/2022 20:44

it is now on curriculum- since 2014
. Martin Lewis, amongst others, had petitioned for it, and was successful.

He’s also wrote and launched the first ever dedicated text book in 2021.

his course is actually available on line to adults too.

I’m not typing this to be argumentative because I think it is a good thing but not every school teaches it. Unfortunately

Oujiawoowoo · 20/11/2022 20:51

As for financial protection and kids…I have two DC. I bought the house we live in on my own as their dad had no money (and lots of debt). I earn 5x his salary and can manage perfectly fine on my own. I am not marrying him and potentially linking myself to his shambolic financial situation.

Women should be educated to develop financial independence regardless of their marital status.

I agree with you - but you are the exception - very few women earn 5 x more than their DH’s, especially when they are mothers.

Newlifestartingatlast · 20/11/2022 20:50

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:35

Then she is phenomenally daft .. unless of course she has unknown private wealth.

This is not a 'marriage ' thread .. marriage is not the be all end all of everything . It's about the appalling lack of legal protection for women who have children with a man who she isnt married/civil partnered to their OH.. and the 'loop hole ' that the lack of contract affords the man...

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split ..'

So for example :
Lived with a woman for 15 years. 3 kids . Not married . Split treaded in EXACTLY the same way as a marriage ..

I don’t know what you think marriage is?
pit is purely a legal and f8ncnaical garment to ensure assets are shared, and both parties have next of kin rights. It also means wealth can be passed between partners on death without inheritance tax. Plus a whole bunch of other legal and financial rights.

The laws are there. We don’t need another set of laws. Just for people to realise that if they won’t sign the legal contract to say they’re in a committed relationship then they can’t expect to be treated in law as committed.

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 20/11/2022 20:49

There’s a lot of smaller property where unless it’s violence, the police did not bother following up on stuff he’d taken. Unless she could prove he was neglectful (and she was late to report financial and other abuse) then the courts werent bothered about how he was constantly messing around their DC and when he was supposed to provide care.

So for example he claimed she’d gifted him a lot of stuff that wasn’t true. Plus lots of money committed to home improvements from one account, and already spent on future holidays, and based on their shared earnings their DC was being signed up to nurseries (her ex then pulled all funding and claimed poverty). She was trying to unwind a long term relationship (or at least exit it with what she was rightfully entitled to, her own stuff!) and he was hugely difficult at every stage, no incentive for him to participate like an adult.. he just wanted to go off with his new girlfriends, hide money, and punish my friend when he was stressed.

SirMingeALot · 20/11/2022 20:48

It’s not the dark ages, women are perfectly capable of understanding finance and taking actions to protect their future financial position. And do that every day. They just don’t post about it on MN

The demographics of MN being what they are, the cohort of unmarried women who fully understand the consequences of their decision and who've been able to adequately protect themselves are if anything liable to be overrepresented on here.

Oujiawoowoo · 20/11/2022 20:46

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:35

Then she is phenomenally daft .. unless of course she has unknown private wealth.

This is not a 'marriage ' thread .. marriage is not the be all end all of everything . It's about the appalling lack of legal protection for women who have children with a man who she isnt married/civil partnered to their OH.. and the 'loop hole ' that the lack of contract affords the man...

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split ..'

So for example :
Lived with a woman for 15 years. 3 kids . Not married . Split treaded in EXACTLY the same way as a marriage ..

The problem is proving this in a court of law. Marriage is essentially a contract with a date, signatures and proof of commitment to the relationship. How do you prove you have lived together 15 years in a committed relationship? A marriage certificate is a catch-all fail safe agreement. Lots of men would be lying through their teeth and trying to wriggle out of admitting they were in a long term commuted relationship when it’s (what they see as) their money on the line.

i was one of those blinkered women who had dcs and gave up work whilst partner earned the money and had the house in his name - we weren’t married for a very long time due to his reluctance to actually commit to it. Luckily (after years of being unmarried) once I sat him down and explained all the ways in which this left me and the dcs in a very vulnerable position (largely thanks to knowledge I soaked up from MN) he realised he was being out of order and we married. But I would say the main reason why women get into this situation is ignorance, pure and simple. Many people still believe there is such a thing as common law marriage. I remember my dm being really shocked when I told her I’d be entitled to a bit of child maintenance at best (and if he deigned to pay it) if we broke up before being married. She thought the law protected women who had children with a man as do lots of people.

Educate your dd’s! Girls (and boys) should be taught this in school IMO.

Newlifestartingatlast · 20/11/2022 20:44

Pleasebeafleabite · 20/11/2022 20:16

Selection bias.

If you believe MN you’d think that every single married couple had family money in joint bank accounts when in reality it’s around 20%

I absolutely agree with you that the UK should do more to teach finance in schools, including how to safeguard your own income and assets.

I find it astonishing that trigonometry and learning about various sky fairies is more important but there we go

it is now on curriculum- since 2014
. Martin Lewis, amongst others, had petitioned for it, and was successful.

He’s also wrote and launched the first ever dedicated text book in 2021.

his course is actually available on line to adults too.

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 20:41

If men were REQUIRED to reduce their hours (and subsequent pension contributions) to care for their children
they'd all be having the snip!
men expect to be able to leave women to do the menial tasks, the reason they agree to have children is to advertise to other men that they have the ability to capture & enslave a woman, it's a way of advertising thier status, they don't expect to have to lower themselves and do women's work.

Eastie77Returns · 20/11/2022 20:41

PurpleButterflyWings · 20/11/2022 19:43

This. ^ Rightly or wrongly, I actually inwardly cringe at women who've been with a man for 10 or 15 years or more - and especially if they've got one or two or more kids with him - and they're not married. They try and peddle this 'neither of us wants to get married, it's what we both want' bollux, but I know deep down probably 9 out of 10 women want to get married. I think they just try and convince themselves that they don't. But it's because HE doesn't want to in most cases.

I've got a close female relative aged 30 now who's been with the same bloke for 11 years since the age of 19. She kind of wanted to get married for the first three or four years, but he was just right against it. It was 'you'd best find someone else if you want marriage because it's not for me.' She loved him (still does) and didn't want to split, so she settled for this. Then she kept saying, 'I'm never getting married, no way, not ever. Patriarchy, patriarchy, not changing my maiden name, blah, blah, blah, blah. Not being owned by a man etc etc etc!' For about 4 or 5 years she said this!

A couple of years ago, after nine years together, he finally proposed, God knows why he suddenly changed his mind. Nobody has asked. But she was in tears with absolute joy because he asked her to marry him. The wedding is next June.

So it seems all along she did want to get married, but she tried to convince everybody else she didn't. I believe this is the case for a lot of women because why would a woman NOT want to get married? It brings lots more security, and proves the man is committed. And no WAY would I have children with a man without being married.

As I say, deep down I think most women want to get married - not only for the fact they've got security, and it shows commitment from him, but it also feels awkward when virtually every woman you know - sisters, nieces, cousins, friends, work colleagues, neighbours etc etc, are getting married, and YOU are always the bridesmaid, or just a guest.

When every woman has a ring on her finger - it's heart-breaking for a woman who's with a man who refuses to get married. I wouldn't stay with a man if he wouldn't get married. I just wouldn't.

To be honest, if a man has more money than the woman he is with, and has more assets, and is very solvent, they often won't get married. Many well-off men won't get married if they have nothing to gain from it.

I can wholeheartedly assure you I do not want to get married. Never have, never will. I’m not a raging feminist but marriage has just never appealed.

It’s really odd and a little insulting to assume that ‘deep down’ most women want to walk down the aisle and are in some kind of denial if they say they don’t. Do you honestly think there are no happily unmarried women?

As for financial protection and kids…I have two DC. I bought the house we live in on my own as their dad had no money (and lots of debt). I earn 5x his salary and can manage perfectly fine on my own. I am not marrying him and potentially linking myself to his shambolic financial situation.

Women should be educated to develop financial independence regardless of their marital status.

Pleasebeafleabite · 20/11/2022 20:38

He sounds grim. I’m sorry for your friend. Surely better though to have had legally enforceable arrangements in place that would kick in rather than the position on divorce which is ultimately down to the courts if the parties can’t agree.

For example, a declaration of trust can set out exactly what happens to the house when the couple split. How it is valued, how you can buy out the other party and under what timescales.

Again, all about education as you have to know about the protections that you can put in place and that it’s reasonable to ask for them

Mummy2mybear · 20/11/2022 20:35

ButterflyLeg · 20/11/2022 20:31

This! I find it weird that people are shocked at how stupid the vast majority of people are.

👏 THIS

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 20:34

Pleasebeafleabite
... is this a MN first ? We concur. !

So many take these threads as a
Knock against 'unmarried mothers' as though the poster has some moral stance . I really don't

My stance is against men that exploit women because the law is on their side . !!

If MEN had to pay the childcare from their salaries..

If men were REQUIRED to reduce their hours (and subsequent pension contributions) to care for their children..

Perhaps they would be less willing to make children ? Perhaps they would be more careful with their fertility.. ? They don't care at the moment because the emotional and financial cost is all on the woman if it all goes tits up ..

And PERHAPS there would be a bit more scientific research into the male contraceptive !!

Can you imagine it ?
If you have a child with a woman and your assets are up for grabs .. and yet there is a male contraception a kin to the pill .... I bet your bottom dollar the 99% effective rate - that appears to be about 60% on MN ... would plummet .

OP posts:
Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 20/11/2022 20:34

1ittlegreen · 20/11/2022 20:28

Don't know how to reply without including the whole message on the app so apologies.

My dp wouldn't leave as such, we wouldn't need to negotiate child maintenence because we respect each other. If one decided they wanted out it wouldn't be an ordeal, it would simply be one of us moving out and taking over 50% of duties and payments with regards to ds.

It's hard to explain, we both have wills and life insurance and luckily are both comfortable financially but it would never be about the childcare onus falling on me because I'm a woman.

We run a business together also and have a joint account plus our own current and savings account.

We love each other fiercely which I have seen in very few married couples I know.

We also had a big party about 5 years ago which all our close friends and family were invited to, it cost a fortune and I'm guessing was much like a wedding.

I swear down all my married friends are miserable af and always, ALWAYS wary for some reason.

great that you have a will!! Most don’t 🙄In your business make sure you’re named as shareholder AND director in the company registers and filings (or equivalent positions, if a different entity type). Talk about teaching to suck eggs :) wish I had a business!

For anyone married… make sure you have a will too, your DP could inherit if you die and spend on a new partner rather than help your kids. Think of the eventualities and talk to a solicitor.

Newlifestartingatlast · 20/11/2022 20:34

heliosunburg · 20/11/2022 19:15

What do you hope to get out of this post? Is this about advising people or...?

Having a discussion? Getting other views? Having a chat?

JohnStuartMill · 20/11/2022 20:33

Many of the poster on this thread say it all:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4681684-lets-play-a-game-age-salary-sector

ButterflyLeg · 20/11/2022 20:31

MolliciousIntent · 20/11/2022 19:55

Honestly, an awful lot of people just aren't that bright.

This! I find it weird that people are shocked at how stupid the vast majority of people are.

mackthepony · 20/11/2022 20:30

What a PP said. Marriage is a legal contract. Romance is a new concept and all women should follow their head, not their heart.

We've been screwed over way too long with this shit

GeorgiaGirl52 · 20/11/2022 20:30

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 20/11/2022 19:02

I was with you until the "courts going for shared care so no maintenance" bit. If the dad is willing to do 50/50 he absolutely should and the mum can then work and support herself and her share of the kids. Spousal maintenance is vanishingly rare anyway, as it should be as we move on from the generation where women routinely gave up all work for 20+ years.

The man has higher income, keeps the family home, gets a new girlfriend or a nanny or moves in grandma to do childcare.
The woman takes her personal possessions and has to find a start-up job and a rental situation that she can afford. Often with no room for the kids so they don't visit overnight, and not in the same school catchment area so transport is a problem. Gradually the children spend less time with mom because their friends and rooms and afterschool activities are with dad.
When the kids hit teenage years they start to refuse to stay with mom, and then the percentage of custody change means mom pays child support to dad -- mom pays the price for being a SAHM with less pension, less property, less time with kids and more child support.

TulaDoesTheHula · 20/11/2022 20:29

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:23

Yes !!! and 1000 x this !!

My agenda is to get this situation into schools .

Knowledge really IS power.. so many myths about 'common law wives' .. or complete lack of knowledge.

No this is really dangerous & could cause more harm then good because governments / legislation change & laws evolve. We can teach someone something at 15 but by the time it’s applicable to them 10 - 20+ years down the line, that information could no longer be accurate. People could be left with a false sense of security or miss out on ways to protect themselves.

Knowledge is definitely power so it’s more important to teach them about independence, critical thinking, research skills etc.

1ittlegreen · 20/11/2022 20:28

Don't know how to reply without including the whole message on the app so apologies.

My dp wouldn't leave as such, we wouldn't need to negotiate child maintenence because we respect each other. If one decided they wanted out it wouldn't be an ordeal, it would simply be one of us moving out and taking over 50% of duties and payments with regards to ds.

It's hard to explain, we both have wills and life insurance and luckily are both comfortable financially but it would never be about the childcare onus falling on me because I'm a woman.

We run a business together also and have a joint account plus our own current and savings account.

We love each other fiercely which I have seen in very few married couples I know.

We also had a big party about 5 years ago which all our close friends and family were invited to, it cost a fortune and I'm guessing was much like a wedding.

I swear down all my married friends are miserable af and always, ALWAYS wary for some reason.

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 20/11/2022 20:28

Pleasebeafleabite · 20/11/2022 20:24

A divorce would’ve been a whole lot messier. She was the one wanting the assets/child support from him. Go to the divorce boards and it’s women chasing down the men.

The child support agreement lasts a maximum of 12 months and then you’re into CSA if the other party reneges

I’ve never heard of a enforceable childcare agreement in the UK. If this is new perhaps one of the family solicitors on the site can confirm

Oh messier but she’d have some
leverage… she wasn’t wanting to mess him around, just literally get his final answer on child access and get some child support, get some of her property back from him (can’t tell you the specifics but he is VILE and messed her around completely, intensely, for years… just abusive when all had been great for years). Instead of the admittedly awful divorce process, there was no process and he’s been able to mess her around for so long, and the DC is pretty aware of it. Awful!!

mackthepony · 20/11/2022 20:27

I know a couple who live in a house worth around 3 million. They have 3 kids. She doesn't work and doesn't want to. He works. They are not married.

What if they split?

She's utterly fucked

I know a few couples in similar situations, always the women in vulnerable situations