Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
Bard6817 · 20/11/2022 21:19

There is another side to this conversation…

From a man’s perspective, a 2 year marriage isn’t worth the risk of losing half or more of his estate. When there’s kids involved, it’s even more.

I guess fairness in these financial settlements is a balancing act, but at some point, the risk outweighs the benefit.

Coffeepot72 · 20/11/2022 21:17

I know that love and relationships and not in any way the same as applying for a job, but there is some sense in which not getting married ( it's just a bit of paper ) when there is already inequality in a relationship (i.e. he has a career and her career has been diminished) is akin to keeping someone on a zero hours contract where they have fewer rights and are more vulnerable.

yes!

Topgub · 20/11/2022 21:16

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune

Did they? I mean, my family did. Yours did but on the whole?

Im not so sure. That survey that should a majority of 18 - 34 yos thought mothers shouldn't work was only a few years ago.

I think the sexist conditioning that tells women they shouldn't ever want to leave their kids is much stronger than the keep your independence message

venusandmars · 20/11/2022 21:15

'It's just a bit of paper'

Yes, so is your employment contract. You enter employment with great hope on both sides. You love the job, they appreciate your skills and experience. Maybe you stay together for years, maybe you move on to something else. Amicably.

But, my goodness if things go wrong in the relationship you NEED that employment contract. It sets out what you both agreed and expected from the beginning. It provides a basis for negotiation out of the contract.

I know that love and relationships and not in any way the same as applying for a job, but there is some sense in which not getting married ( it's just a bit of paper ) when there is already inequality in a relationship (i.e. he has a career and her career has been diminished) is akin to keeping someone on a zero hours contract where they have fewer rights and are more vulnerable.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 20/11/2022 21:15

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:35

Then she is phenomenally daft .. unless of course she has unknown private wealth.

This is not a 'marriage ' thread .. marriage is not the be all end all of everything . It's about the appalling lack of legal protection for women who have children with a man who she isnt married/civil partnered to their OH.. and the 'loop hole ' that the lack of contract affords the man...

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split ..'

So for example :
Lived with a woman for 15 years. 3 kids . Not married . Split treaded in EXACTLY the same way as a marriage ..

I disagree!if you want the legal protection of marriage...then get married!

SirMingeALot · 20/11/2022 21:14

Newlifestartingatlast · 20/11/2022 21:03

I’m divorced. It cost us £1400 inc vat. And took 11- weeks (ok can’t do it that quick now since law changed).

Part of reason it was quick and surprisingly painless was because of the framework of the marriage act around “fair settlement”

I view that £1400 a cheap price to pay for the legal and financial protections I got when we split, and for the protection I had during our 30 year marriage.

we both informed ourselves, agreed we’d minimise cost by behaving like grown ups and figuring out what we would do, and went to solicitors only for the things we had to.

on MN divorce board, I go on and on about women not heading straight to “good solicitor “ in an adversarial way but to stop and inform themselves and save time, money and stress by amicable separation- parking the rage till the job is done

But the board is full of tails of spending £13k, £30k etc on divorce. And that’s becuase it’s these people who have got into such difficulty that post the most.

frankly there are stupid and revengeful people trying to split whether married or not. And they post here. Then there are people like me that can’t believe that people cut their noses off to spite their face with such regulatory

Exactly.

The divorce itself is usually the legally straightforward part. It's the kids and joint property that make things difficult and expensive, particularly if one party decides to be a twat. The reality is that if you have children and/or assets with someone, not marrying them isn't protection against being embroiled in protracted and expensive legal proceedings.

RoseLemon · 20/11/2022 21:13

@TulaDoesTheHula I agree

Coffeepot72 · 20/11/2022 21:13

There was a thread a while ago, where the man was prepared to go to the registry office and arrange a civil partnership, but wouldn’t get married. At least this gave his partner financial protection but what she really wanted was a wedding. I just don’t understand men at times.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 21:13

Topgub · 20/11/2022 21:10

@TulaDoesTheHula

Instead of going down this route, we should be teaching women critical thinking skills & giving them the tools & opportunities to be financial independent in their own right.

Yup

Who is "we" ?

Most of my female relatives, friends and acquaintances got this message. Most of the elder women in my family, born anywhere from 1910 to 1950, made a point of always working and having their own stash of money. Some were lorry drivers, laundresses, cleaners, etc. we aren't talking high-flying careers but they managed to fit in some work because they didn't want to be dependent. If women like my grandmothers, born more than 100 years ago, got the message -- why are young women today failing to realize these simple facts?

NadjaCravensworth · 20/11/2022 21:12

Topgub · 20/11/2022 21:02

@sofrustratedbylackofknowledge

*MEN had to pay the childcare from their salaries..

If men were REQUIRED to reduce their hours (and subsequent pension contributions) to care for their children..*

Well why aren't they?

Why do women say oh theres no point me working to pay my salary out in childcare

Why do they reduce their hours without demanding their ohs do the same?

Because women think they should, because they want to, because they're told by the father "oh you stay home it's better if you do it", because other women sneer at mums going out to work, (as well as those that sneer at those staying home ofc), because the man says I earn more, it's not worth you working.... so many reasons

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 21:10

ChesterDrawz · 20/11/2022 21:05

Of the women I know (friends, family, acquaintances) in this position it's almost always because they simply don't want to work and that takes precedence over whether it's a bad idea to get into the situation in the first place.

Yeah. For all the "I was forced to SACRIFICE MY CAREER!" lamentations, there are quite a few out there who don't like working, don't want to work and are happy to take the risk.

I don't like working and don't want to work either, but at nearly 60 I still do, because I don't want to be at anyone's mercy. Can't imagine what it feels like to be 35, 45, 55 and have the guy walk away with his assets, leaving her impoverished and with the prospect of trying to get into the workforce and work till she drops.

Topgub · 20/11/2022 21:10

@TulaDoesTheHula

Instead of going down this route, we should be teaching women critical thinking skills & giving them the tools & opportunities to be financial independent in their own right.

Yup

BadNomad · 20/11/2022 21:10

Women who want children are on a countdown. Many choose to have them in insecure relationships, rather than risk never having them, then just hope for the best.

TulaDoesTheHula · 20/11/2022 21:09

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:35

Then she is phenomenally daft .. unless of course she has unknown private wealth.

This is not a 'marriage ' thread .. marriage is not the be all end all of everything . It's about the appalling lack of legal protection for women who have children with a man who she isnt married/civil partnered to their OH.. and the 'loop hole ' that the lack of contract affords the man...

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split ..'

So for example :
Lived with a woman for 15 years. 3 kids . Not married . Split treaded in EXACTLY the same way as a marriage ..

NO NO NO, suggestions like this really boil my blood.

Protection is there in the form of marriage & people can opt in if they wish - as it should be. Women have full control of their reproduction systems in this country & they can choose whether to have children without the benefit of marriage.

I’m by far the higher earner in my relationship which is exactly why I’ve chosen NOT to get to married, why should I lose my protection because some women make bad decisions & CHOOSE not to use protections already in place for them? Not getting married is my only financial protection & you’re advocating taking that away because other women are blinkered & prioritise “love”. Why the hell should I automatically be opted into a system that could completely financially screw me over? It should always be opt in.

As well as screwing over higher earning women, your suggestion will also disadvantage children from first marriages. Say a women divorces & gets a decent financial settlement to support her & her children from that marriage but then she subsequently has another child with another man, that man would then have access to her all her assets which should be her children’s security.

I’ll probably get roasted for this but I think you’re deluded if you think most women don’t know what they’re doing & that they’re they’re putting themselves in a vulnerable position; I think most do know but choose to push on anyway in the hope that the man will change & the baby will somehow keep him. I also don’t believe a lot of contraception failures are as accidental as some women will have you believe either.

Instead of going down this route, we should be teaching women critical thinking skills & giving them the tools & opportunities to be financial independent in their own right.

1ittlegreen · 20/11/2022 21:09

That sounds great. I think.

I reckon these days marriage isn't for life. It's until you find someone better or see a bad side to your husband/wife.

If you don't bother you won't need a fair settlement, what's yours is yours, what's theirs is theirs, what you have between you still belongs to the both of you and you work it out like adults.

Coffeepot72 · 20/11/2022 21:08

As I say, deep down I think most women want to get married - not only for the fact they've got security, and it shows commitment from him, but it also feels awkward when virtually every woman you know - sisters, nieces, cousins, friends, work colleagues, neighbours etc etc, are getting married, and YOU are always the bridesmaid, or just a guest.

When every woman has a ring on her finger - it's heart-breaking for a woman who's with a man who refuses to get married. I wouldn't stay with a man if he wouldn't get married. I just wouldn't.

God yes, this was me at one point. It was also very humiliating. But I was very clear - no wedding, no baby. And I was very diligent with contraception I also had a friend in the same position, but she’d already had her partner’s baby and had given away her bargaining chips.

To be honest, if a man has more money than the woman he is with, and has more assets, and is very solvent, they often won't get married. Many well-off men won't get married if they have nothing to gain from it.

But this has only been the case in recent decades, when women have been prepared to have children without being married. 50 years ago, if a rich man (or any man for that matter) wanted a live-in partner and children, then marriage had to come first.

NadjaCravensworth · 20/11/2022 21:08

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 19:35

Then she is phenomenally daft .. unless of course she has unknown private wealth.

This is not a 'marriage ' thread .. marriage is not the be all end all of everything . It's about the appalling lack of legal protection for women who have children with a man who she isnt married/civil partnered to their OH.. and the 'loop hole ' that the lack of contract affords the man...

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split ..'

So for example :
Lived with a woman for 15 years. 3 kids . Not married . Split treaded in EXACTLY the same way as a marriage ..

Personally I would like to see a change in the law which makes 'the father/mother/partner to a birth have his/her assets assessable in a split ..'

So for example :
Lived with a woman for 15 years. 3 kids . Not married . Split treaded in EXACTLY the same way as a marriage ..

That would be awful. You should not be sleepwalking into a contract.

Our women need to be taught not to rely on a man, so many times here we tell of our stories to educate our fellow posters - the problem is,they don't come here for help until they are aready in the shit.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 21:08

Others might be fully aware that their relationship has more red flags than a Liverpool match but are convinced that a baby will change his mind.

This always baffles me because there's nothing like a baby to strain a relationship, and in my experience most men could take or leave fatherhood; they go along to get along or cede to family pressure, but they aren't going to fall in love with family life, quite the reverse. Not a gamble I'd take.

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 21:07

*Newlifestartingatlast
*
The laws are there. We don’t need another set of laws. Just for people to realise that if they won’t sign the legal contract to say they’re in a committed relationship then they can’t expect to be treated in law as committed.

Yes I absolutely agree and this is very well put.
However so many women persuade themselves that he IS committed... because he's 'happy about the baby' .. it's a very cheap line... cheap in all senses of the word.

OP posts:
ChesterDrawz · 20/11/2022 21:05

Of the women I know (friends, family, acquaintances) in this position it's almost always because they simply don't want to work and that takes precedence over whether it's a bad idea to get into the situation in the first place.

Boulshired · 20/11/2022 21:04

I’m not married but have many of the securities already in place. for those who I know are in a vulnerable position it generally began because the male partner is older, and the woman is moving into his established life. He’s on the housing market, already further down the career path. The risks of being a SAHP and part time without a share of the asset from the time together is often ignored with the here and now benefits.

Newlifestartingatlast · 20/11/2022 21:03

1ittlegreen · 20/11/2022 20:04

This sounds like a post from many married people.

Divorce sounds utterly shit and expensive.

I've been with DP 20 years and we have a ds. So many weddings we have been to served no purpose, half our friends are divorcing. I'd say that's about 10 couples. It's so hard for them.

If we broke up, our bank accounts would remain the same, our dc would see us both equally and our house would sell 50/50.

I can only imagine the people complaining are people who haven't been in an equal relationship and therefore don't have the same assets.

Don't you worry about the unmarried, we are fine!

I'd deffo worry if I had a faith and got married before god. That seems like a major life fuck up to me 🤷🏼‍♂️

I’m divorced. It cost us £1400 inc vat. And took 11- weeks (ok can’t do it that quick now since law changed).

Part of reason it was quick and surprisingly painless was because of the framework of the marriage act around “fair settlement”

I view that £1400 a cheap price to pay for the legal and financial protections I got when we split, and for the protection I had during our 30 year marriage.

we both informed ourselves, agreed we’d minimise cost by behaving like grown ups and figuring out what we would do, and went to solicitors only for the things we had to.

on MN divorce board, I go on and on about women not heading straight to “good solicitor “ in an adversarial way but to stop and inform themselves and save time, money and stress by amicable separation- parking the rage till the job is done

But the board is full of tails of spending £13k, £30k etc on divorce. And that’s becuase it’s these people who have got into such difficulty that post the most.

frankly there are stupid and revengeful people trying to split whether married or not. And they post here. Then there are people like me that can’t believe that people cut their noses off to spite their face with such regulatory

Topgub · 20/11/2022 21:02

@sofrustratedbylackofknowledge

*MEN had to pay the childcare from their salaries..

If men were REQUIRED to reduce their hours (and subsequent pension contributions) to care for their children..*

Well why aren't they?

Why do women say oh theres no point me working to pay my salary out in childcare

Why do they reduce their hours without demanding their ohs do the same?

NadjaCravensworth · 20/11/2022 21:02

Zanatdy · 20/11/2022 19:26

The contraception failures are women who are too embarrassed to say they’ve planned a baby in this position

Are you talking from experience?

I'm sure some are planned, but there will be plenty of others that were not planned

DozyFox · 20/11/2022 21:00

I've noticed a few things...

Firstly, I agree with @PurpleButterflyWings about women denying they want to get married when really they do. I think women, especially younger women, are made to feel silly or even crazy for wanting marriage after being together for a few years. The amount of women I hear that seem to fall over themselves to insist how much they don't want to get married is ridiculous - it's this idea of not wanting to "scare a man away".

Secondly, I think the whole 'gold digger' thing is used against women. If a woman said "I want to get married so I'm entitled to X from my high earning partner if we split" she'd be called all sorts. So women have to make sure their motives are pure and 'good', meanwhile men avoid marriage specifically and explicitly to minimise their financial risk.

Thirdly is about the contraception thing also mentioned on this thread. I think many women are lulled into a false sense of security. The vast majority of my friends have been on the pill since they were 13-15, either for period pains, acne or irregular periods, and they've been on it ever since. They don't even think about it anymore, and so when they are prescribed things like antibiotics that affect the pill, they don't even think to ask about how their contraception will be affected. So if the doctor doesn't bring it up, they just continue none the wiser. This all isn't helped by men who insist that they can't possibly wear condoms.

I've also seen people get accused on here of being akin to abstinence-only educators because they've talked about how young men and women need to understand that the pill is not foolproof and they ought to wear condoms too if they feel strongly about not getting pregnant. I think it's really irresponsible to give the impression that as long as the woman takes the pill everything will be hunky dory and no one needs to worry.