Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 22:21

Thank you everyone .. this has actually been a very interesting discussion with some very thoughtful posts . and blessed with a minimum of performance agro by the usual kb warriors . Which must be some kind of record for AIBU ..

My take from it (and others will probably feel differently) is that women need to up their bar with whom they are prepared to have children with.. if he won't commit contractually then don't screw yourself committing to child birth and rearing .

(Marriage /cp is just a piece of paper . but one with some very important words written on it . )

That 'having a baby with a man who is financially better placed' is a poor choice without a legal contract (currently marriage or CP) ...that there is an educational package available for schools - but it's not mandatory.

Perhaps that is the essential that needs to be changed .. (along in my opinion ) for changes to the division of assets on separation to include any couples who have a joint child . (that will be an interesting legal conundrum for a married man who fathers a child whilst having an affair ... I haven't thought that through yet in my utopian fantasy of fairness to children of unmarried couples ..)

OP posts:
StClare101 · 20/11/2022 22:19

There are multiple threads a week of women who can’t leave or who have been left in the shit because they haven’t protected themselves financially. It’s depressing.

LolaSmiles · 20/11/2022 22:15

My personal opinion is because society teaches ‘all you need is love’.

While I do think you should love someone in a long term relationship, we are taught everything will work out as long as there’s love and that we ‘just know’ when it’s forever
Agree with this.

Love's all well and good but it's worth establishing your views on big financial matters, how financial/domestic load should be shared, what expectations are regarding working and child raising, retirement and other boring topics before ploughing into a relationship where you're incompatible on major areas.

lifeinthehills · 20/11/2022 22:13

Bretonstrip · 20/11/2022 19:31

I’d go as far as to include married women who don’t work in this post tbh

The “oh he’s not like that”, the “he loves his kids“ posters; the “he wouldn’t do that to me” posters

Yes he would
Yes they do
Yes he can

So what if you get the house in the divorce? How you planning on paying your bills the next month when you’ve got 50/50 and he ain’t paying you a penny anymore….

lot of women out there who need to give their heads a wobble

and YES I was one of them!

I agree. It worked out for me but I have also been one of them and have made sure I've told my daughters that while I have no regrets and was fortunate, I left myself in a very vulnerable position. Women should always be in a position to leave, if they feel they need to.

IneedanewTV · 20/11/2022 22:11

Notanevillamdlord · 20/11/2022 21:42

I have ds's and I have advised them not to marry unless their partner have the same amount of assets as them.

We all know that marriage, or rather divorce, favours the poorer partner. I've also told my ds's to be fully in control of when they want a child and to be responsible for their own contraception and not rely on the woman.

I am married and my dh and I had similar amounts of assets when we married.

Good advice.

1ittlegreen · 20/11/2022 22:10

*ofcourseshecan

That's pretty insightful, we are both from Bermuda and fellow Bermudians will have worked out by now who we are.

BUT we have been together 20 years so I don't think we fit your run of the mill £1 mumsnet women you seem to be referring to.

We are pretty equal tho so it prolly wouldn't play out like that irl.

Chill people only here - any fleecing tends to stem from inequality and relationships that were doomed from the get go.

bravelittletiger · 20/11/2022 22:08

I agree with you. It's very hard for me to understand because I would just never let it happen (personality and job being reasons why I'm not the sort of person to let it happen). I was a pain in the arse to my DH making sure he was going to propose because I knew I wanted kids and then when I wanted kids it was basically get with the programme or I'm off and now that I'm cutting my hours and he's a high earner I'm planning to put something in writing in place and have been very clear that our resources now need to be pooled 100%.

FlyingPandas · 20/11/2022 22:07

Coffeepot72 · 20/11/2022 21:59

I'm guessing WC women need IVF a lot less then MC women because they reproduce younger.

I wonder why WC women have children earlier? Do WC men commit earlier?

I suspect it's because it's the norm for those from middle class families to go to university, to develop a career, to want to spend 5-10 years minimum working in that career before thinking about children. So as a very rough guide many of those don't even start thinking about a family till they reach their early 30s.

Very different for those from poorer/WC backgrounds for whom it is far more the norm to have DC in their late teens or early twenties. Nothing to do with men committing, more that it's just considered normal in their social circle, and they are more likely to think in terms of hand-to-mouth jobs rather than professional careers (huge generalisation of course but true for so many) and don't see the benefit in waiting.

Topgub · 20/11/2022 22:01

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune

Wtf?

Coffeepot72 · 20/11/2022 21:59

I'm guessing WC women need IVF a lot less then MC women because they reproduce younger.

I wonder why WC women have children earlier? Do WC men commit earlier?

whumpthereitis · 20/11/2022 21:56

Women aren’t children that need protecting from bad decisions they choose to make. If the security of marriage is important to you, then get married. If a man doesn’t want to marry you then leave him. It may not be what you want to do, but that doesn’t negate your agency.

Someone can making a bad choice does not mean they were manipulated into doing so, or that they’re not ultimately responsible for their own actions.

Justthisonce12 · 20/11/2022 21:55

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 21:49

Which is pretty reprehensible. To mate with some low unreliable specimen and then figure the taxpayers can pick up the tab "if" something goes awry.

But then we’re falling down the Incel rabbit hole. They only want to breed with what they consider to be high value women. Presumably that’s good looking healthy intelligent I suppose is a bonus but not necessarily.

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 21:55

I'm guessing WC women need IVF a lot less then MC women because they reproduce younger.

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 21:53

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 21:49

Which is pretty reprehensible. To mate with some low unreliable specimen and then figure the taxpayers can pick up the tab "if" something goes awry.

WC have a right to reproduce it's not reserved for the rich. WC also do very important jobs care work etc. Society would fall apart without people doing MW jobs.

SandyY2K · 20/11/2022 21:52

Well I'm in my 50s, and I knew not to rely on a man, I knew to build my career. So it's not an age thing

Same here.

I think women also do what they saw their mothers and women in their extended family do.

My daughters see that I got married first, that I worked as did their Aunties/Grandma so that's the norm for them.

If they see the older females living with men, no marriage, not working/SAHM forever... then that becomes their norm.

TomTraubertsBlues · 20/11/2022 21:51

mackthepony · 20/11/2022 20:27

I know a couple who live in a house worth around 3 million. They have 3 kids. She doesn't work and doesn't want to. He works. They are not married.

What if they split?

She's utterly fucked

I know a few couples in similar situations, always the women in vulnerable situations

She would just as fucked if the house was worth £250k though.

I agree that people need to protect themselves. It's particularly pertinent for women as they tend to be the ones leaving work, going part time, giving up occupational pensions etc. I don't know what the answer is though, because nobody believes that their DP will screw them over. Perceived romance seems to trump practicalities.

Newlifestartingatlast · 20/11/2022 21:51

Pleasebeafleabite · 20/11/2022 20:53

I’m not typing this to be argumentative because I think it is a good thing but not every school teaches it. Unfortunately

Oh
i thought that’s what a national curriculum is for?
silly me 🙄

I guess as a parent then I’d get hold of the course and put my kids through it myself then

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/11/2022 21:49

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 21:29

The marriage thing only benefits middle class women who have no intention of going back to work SAHM. A penniless working class woman married to a WC man renting is better off never marrying. She can easily leave the relationship and claim benefits if things go wrong.

Which is pretty reprehensible. To mate with some low unreliable specimen and then figure the taxpayers can pick up the tab "if" something goes awry.

KickAssAngel · 20/11/2022 21:48

It's a nice idea that both parents can be financially independent, but actually very difficult to achieve. A child with health concerns, even relatively minor, can cost a patent their job. Travel, childcare, not getting the first choice of school, an elderly parent, more than 2 children, children from a previous relationship ... Any one of those things can make it impossible to work full time.

The answer is to ensure that part time work is reliable so that people in those jobs have some security, and ANY person who becomes a parent is responsible for decent financial support until the child is 18, and enforce that, as many other countries do, very effectively. Affordable long tem housing would also be great.

BobbitWorm · 20/11/2022 21:43

I grew up watching my mother rely on one seemingly terrible man after another. We were moved about, pillar to post, spent years in temporary accommodation. She has nothing now but another terrible man makes all of the still terrible decisions. Despite her constantly telling us what a fierce, intelligent feminist she is.

It made me absolutely determined to be as independent as possible. I was a teenage mum, but I have pulled together some sort of career and have always been the breadwinner. It's boring, it isn't what I want to do. But it pays.

When my husband and I bought our home, I only agreed to borrow what we could afford to repay on one salary, so should he fuck up/leave/lose his job/die I would be okay
and actually if I did any of those things, so would he.

I never had security growing up. I never knew a great male or female provider. I see other women who are so vulnerable and I get frustrated at them. Which is entirely shitty and unreasonable of me, and is a clear manifestation of my own demons.

Notanevillamdlord · 20/11/2022 21:42

I have ds's and I have advised them not to marry unless their partner have the same amount of assets as them.

We all know that marriage, or rather divorce, favours the poorer partner. I've also told my ds's to be fully in control of when they want a child and to be responsible for their own contraception and not rely on the woman.

I am married and my dh and I had similar amounts of assets when we married.

BeautifulWar · 20/11/2022 21:42

The problems occur when women don't work for years.

I think MN often inflates the safety net of marriage. Yes, there may well be more protection than being unmarried but there are plenty of ways men can get out of paying enough. There are also other situations to take into account too that don't involve men being shits - relying solely on another person is a very precarious place to be.

SirMingeALot · 20/11/2022 21:40

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 21:38

They got rid of the widowed parents allowance it's now a breavement support payment which is much less. It's now 9000 for death of a spouse not a life changing amount and they will lose their benefits.

They did indeed get rid of it, but what remains is still more generous for a married bereaved partner. The lump sum wouldn't lose them benefits either.

Nobody said it was life changing, but the fact that it exists makes your claim about penniless working class women wrong.

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 21:39

Many men will waste her fertile years
indeed, best time to have a baby from a health point of view is probably 19-25 ish, but that can be a huge disadvantage in other respects
also you want a big fit athletic man with good genes, desperate Dan jawline and all that.....but that can be a huge disadvantage in other respects.
if I was young and wanted children I think I'd be on the prowl to get myself knocked up by an alpha.....but I'd make damn sure he didnt know anything about the resultant child

Peedoffo · 20/11/2022 21:38

SirMingeALot · 20/11/2022 21:35

Not true.

Being married gives access to a greater range of bereavement benefits and the penniless working class woman is, if widowed, more likely to need these than the woman with more money.

They got rid of the widowed parents allowance it's now a breavement support payment which is much less. It's now 9000 for death of a spouse not a life changing amount and they will lose their benefits.