Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many more women are going to find themselves in this situation ?

387 replies

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 20/11/2022 18:47

Thread borne by the sheer amount of posts this week alone, of women who have moved in with wealthier men . Men who own houses solely in their name.. and women who have children with them without a contract of marriage or civil partnership..

The relationship breaks down and the woman is either not working or massively economically disadvantaged compared with their partners .

Made even worst by the courts bias towards shared care rendering CM almost negligible...

Why are women putting themselves in this situation. ?

Marriage has a lot of patriarchal connotations which are 'no go' for some women... but now we have civil partnerships why would you not go for this option .. ? Or is it the man refusing to commit ?

Also really concerned about the massive number of contraception failures . So many women taking the pill finding themselves pregnant and deciding to continue the pregnancy with no legal protection ..is the pill /implant failing ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
katepilar · 26/06/2023 09:17

Not sure if I understood this right but what is the difference between a marriage and a civil partnership?

peaceandove · 23/11/2022 10:32

Penguinsaregreat · 22/11/2022 17:49

Oh yes I know men who have strung their long term partners along with the ‘I don’t believe in marriage’ only to meet someone else and marry the new partner very quickly. Usually in lavish ceremonies with all the bells and whistles.

Yes, I have sadly seen this happen a few times in our social circle. Typically, the long term female partner is too soft, has issued ultimatums (and not followed through), and ended up feeling helpless because there's no hope of the wedding/marriage she desperately wants.

The bloke then meets a woman with some fire in her belly, who stands up for what she wants and will leave if she doesn't get it. Voila, the man is happy to marry her.

I was with DH for 11 years and he was still apparently undecided about whether he wanted to marry me Hmm So, I decided for us both - I left him, bought my own house and had a fling with a bloke 10 years younger than me. DH was stunned & horrified and couldn't propose to me fast enough. I turned him down. I finally accepted his 3rd proposal and we were married 4 months later. Still very happily married 21 years later.

Generally speaking, people treat you how you allow them to treat you.

PyongyangKipperbang · 22/11/2022 22:42

Justthisonce12 · 22/11/2022 18:06

I personally witnessed 3 of these in our social circle. There’s a book you can buy called why men marry bitches, honestly it’s well worth a read. Slight spoiler, the women arent bitches, they are just women who assert themselves.

Havent read that one but I highly recommend Why Men Love Bitches. Its basically about how the nice girl gets all she asks for which is nothing as she doesnt want to appear demanding. The bitch knows what she wants, demands it and will walk away when she doesnt get it. What she demands above all else is respect.

Justthisonce12 · 22/11/2022 18:06

Penguinsaregreat · 22/11/2022 17:49

Oh yes I know men who have strung their long term partners along with the ‘I don’t believe in marriage’ only to meet someone else and marry the new partner very quickly. Usually in lavish ceremonies with all the bells and whistles.

I personally witnessed 3 of these in our social circle. There’s a book you can buy called why men marry bitches, honestly it’s well worth a read. Slight spoiler, the women arent bitches, they are just women who assert themselves.

SirMingeALot · 22/11/2022 18:01

Penguinsaregreat · 22/11/2022 17:49

Oh yes I know men who have strung their long term partners along with the ‘I don’t believe in marriage’ only to meet someone else and marry the new partner very quickly. Usually in lavish ceremonies with all the bells and whistles.

Mmmm, very much a thing unfortunately.

Penguinsaregreat · 22/11/2022 17:49

Oh yes I know men who have strung their long term partners along with the ‘I don’t believe in marriage’ only to meet someone else and marry the new partner very quickly. Usually in lavish ceremonies with all the bells and whistles.

Penguinsaregreat · 22/11/2022 17:43

I agree op.
If you don’t want the patriarchal side of marriage , and let’s face it being ‘given away’ etc is, then do a statutory ceremony where you enter together, say the legal parts and have an a contract of marriage at the end.
I have warned dd about the pitfalls of having a child outside of marriage and advised her never to give a child a surname which is not her own. She has no intention of having a child unless she is married. If you don’t have a partner then sperm donation is the way to go. Seek out good quality genes and no from the start that you will be a single parent. I have complete respect for women who do this.

Elf25 · 22/11/2022 17:41

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 21/11/2022 08:32

BeautifulWar - and for the sake of transparency as far as possible in an anonymous thread. I have never hankered after being a sahm. I would last about a fortnight before being bored witless.
I have had three children all now grown and also helped raise 4 dsc. I have worked full time without any breaks except Mat Leave since my eldest was 6 months old. I am financially secure and whilst raising kids , more financially secure than my DH. This is not about me.

7 years ago my closest friends life imploded . Her partner who she had met at 17 decided in the course of 8 weeks to meet and marry a woman he met on a business trip to Dubai.

They had started at the same economic level. He worked as a photocopy clerk in an investment bank. (Shows how long ago this was) she was a nursery nurse. They moved in together aged 21/22. First baby at 23. She gave up work as he had got promotion as a trainee in the bank.

At the point of implosion he was a senior partner. She had helped that meteoric rise by playing the 'corporate wife' to perfection. Running the home, entertaining clients looking after their joint kids. Their house was worth £750k there were savings of about £100k. There were 5 children . However at the time of this happening only one was left at school. He insisted that marriage was just a piece of paper and 'knew too many people where it had jinxed their relationships' .. I heard him say on numerous occasions. 'We don't need a piece of paper do we babe. ? We're solid. We've got 5 kids . It doesn't get more committed than that. ..

He married his girlfriend quickly because he didn't have to go to the trouble of divorce. He married because his new wife blamed her Catholicism and the fact that her parents would be unhappy if she wasn't married. (Seemed to skip over the bit where you don't have sex before marriage -if you are going to play the religious card)

My dear friend was blindsided. Her entire world crumbled and none of us could believe how little she of that life she was entitled to.

She got ; 8 months of child support until the youngest child left full time non advanced education. At which point she was required to leave the house. He 'gave her' £10k from the savings to rent a property.

7 years later at 63 years old . She works full time in a garden centre and relies on her kids to help her with her rent . She has a 3 bed cottage so kids can come and stay but costs more than the 1 bed entitlement on universal credit.

Her ex DP lives in the family home with his wife. (Who very swiftly produced a baby to secure the situation. ) Something he apparently didn't want - but hey ho we all know how terribly unreliable contraception is these days.

This can't be right. Situations such as this surely require a law change ?

@sofrustratedbylackofknowledge what do you suggest should the curriculum and change in law look like?

I ended up writing this long post, internet failed and lost it all 😂.

In my view it should teach fairness, responsibility and independence and it should be aimed at both, the female and the male part of population.

I was more elaborate in my vanished post but in my view basically the curriculum should be, just because you raise the children you had with someone don’t expect to be entitled to half of their wealth. Equally, if someone decides to fully commit their life to raising children don’t worry that you are going to automatically have to give away 50% of all of your wealth to them.

LexMitior · 22/11/2022 14:01

I don't think it worth women being a wife... without the actual status in law. If you do "wife work" without marriage then you don't build joint assets. Girls should know that.

No marriage no kids

Don't ever give up work

Have your own pension

If a man can't agree to these basics then don't do it. You would be setting yourself up for hard work, an uncomfortable retirement, dependency but no recourse in law.

If you have girls, tell them that.

Aintnosupermum · 22/11/2022 13:28

My issue with the current system in the UK is that mothers who are in a good marriage often do not have the option to be a SAHM. It is a valid choice and my children would have really benefited from me being home with them during the first 5 years. I wasn’t in a good marriage therefore it wasn’t an option for me. The tax rules in the UK are extremely unfair. Childcare needs a complete overhaul. The ratios are ridiculous and it’s not about subsidies but about proper tax breaks for anyone who is working.

I do believe the OP is correct that when the curriculum covers relationships, marriage should be explained in full. Wifework should be talked about because it happens to women all the time. The boys and girls should be divided when this is discussed because it’s a different conversation that is needed.

girlswillbegirls · 22/11/2022 13:00

@KathyWilliams
Answering your last post: yes, you would swap "the time you spent with your children" being SAHM for many years, if you had the misfortune of so many women affecting their husbands: illness, including MH, redundancy, unexpected partner's addictions to alcohol, DH swapping wife you for a younger model etc. All these happening to friends who were shocked it was happening to them. And once they saw themselves in that situation (I count 3 friends), they really regretted spending all the time with the kids while losing their earning potential and security. This thread is about that. Women need to stop ignoring reality.
I would never give up my career and tell my DDs (and DS) to never do so. Its a no brainer.

peaceandove · 22/11/2022 11:07

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/11/2022 08:13

Yup. And all the guff about "soul mates" and finding "the one"
Too much Mills and Boon, not enough common sense.

Absolutely. The way people think about marriage in our society is disastrous. The awful Disney miasma of hearts and flowers, the competition to rush down the aisle. The obsession with engagement rings. It’s responsible for so much poor advice, wrong motivations and bad decision making. Particularly by women who have the most to lose.

We need to educate our children properly about what this means.

Exactly. Far too many people (and it's usually the woman) become obsessed with the wedding, completely ignoring whether the actual marriage will be a success or not.

Yet another example of the hard of thinking focusing on what they want e.g. to be centre of attention for the day, glitzy dress, huge engagement ring, swanky venue, every last twitch & sniffle captured on social meeja. Instead of focusing on what they need e.g. financial security, a respectful & supportive partner, a marriage that genuinely enhances their life etc.

user1472151176 · 22/11/2022 10:43

I think finance is something that should be addressed to boys and girls in schools. Budgeting, mortgage, pensions, savings, credit cards etc. I think this sort of information is important for children to learn and not every child has parents or guardians who can or will advise and teach this information.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 22/11/2022 09:42

Shitfather · 21/11/2022 21:56

Sadly, a lot of Muslim women get fucked over by having an Islamic marriage only. I wish the law would change to automatically recognise these as legal marriages, as is the case with Jewish marriages.

Unfortunately this will probably not occur for any religion which advocates or legitimatises polygamy, which is not the case with Judaism or Christianity (however, I know for Christianity and think for Judaism ) that the ceremony includes ‘registration’, that is a state sanction and recording of the marriage. So we are back to the point of marriage being a legal entity within the legal system of the country.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 22/11/2022 09:16

sofrustratedbylackofknowledge · 21/11/2022 08:32

BeautifulWar - and for the sake of transparency as far as possible in an anonymous thread. I have never hankered after being a sahm. I would last about a fortnight before being bored witless.
I have had three children all now grown and also helped raise 4 dsc. I have worked full time without any breaks except Mat Leave since my eldest was 6 months old. I am financially secure and whilst raising kids , more financially secure than my DH. This is not about me.

7 years ago my closest friends life imploded . Her partner who she had met at 17 decided in the course of 8 weeks to meet and marry a woman he met on a business trip to Dubai.

They had started at the same economic level. He worked as a photocopy clerk in an investment bank. (Shows how long ago this was) she was a nursery nurse. They moved in together aged 21/22. First baby at 23. She gave up work as he had got promotion as a trainee in the bank.

At the point of implosion he was a senior partner. She had helped that meteoric rise by playing the 'corporate wife' to perfection. Running the home, entertaining clients looking after their joint kids. Their house was worth £750k there were savings of about £100k. There were 5 children . However at the time of this happening only one was left at school. He insisted that marriage was just a piece of paper and 'knew too many people where it had jinxed their relationships' .. I heard him say on numerous occasions. 'We don't need a piece of paper do we babe. ? We're solid. We've got 5 kids . It doesn't get more committed than that. ..

He married his girlfriend quickly because he didn't have to go to the trouble of divorce. He married because his new wife blamed her Catholicism and the fact that her parents would be unhappy if she wasn't married. (Seemed to skip over the bit where you don't have sex before marriage -if you are going to play the religious card)

My dear friend was blindsided. Her entire world crumbled and none of us could believe how little she of that life she was entitled to.

She got ; 8 months of child support until the youngest child left full time non advanced education. At which point she was required to leave the house. He 'gave her' £10k from the savings to rent a property.

7 years later at 63 years old . She works full time in a garden centre and relies on her kids to help her with her rent . She has a 3 bed cottage so kids can come and stay but costs more than the 1 bed entitlement on universal credit.

Her ex DP lives in the family home with his wife. (Who very swiftly produced a baby to secure the situation. ) Something he apparently didn't want - but hey ho we all know how terribly unreliable contraception is these days.

This can't be right. Situations such as this surely require a law change ?

But the legal protections exist. Your friend could have refused to have a baby until they were married ( and there was reliable contraception available entirely free, I know , because I’m even older than you and I had it, unmarried, from the age of eighteen. Shagged a lot, never got pregnant).

She could have refused to play the ‘wife’ until she was the wife; yes, it would have caused big ructions, but not as big as when he decided that actually marriage was really attractive, just not to her. Sometimes you have to fight your corner.

Maybe what we have to do is to try to raise girls to say ‘no’ again. No, I’m not having our baby until we are married, that is, a legally recognised family unit. Why should the ‘law’ have to take the responsibility of protecting people against their own foolishness?

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/11/2022 08:13

Yup. And all the guff about "soul mates" and finding "the one"
Too much Mills and Boon, not enough common sense.

Absolutely. The way people think about marriage in our society is disastrous. The awful Disney miasma of hearts and flowers, the competition to rush down the aisle. The obsession with engagement rings. It’s responsible for so much poor advice, wrong motivations and bad decision making. Particularly by women who have the most to lose.

We need to educate our children properly about what this means.

Twizbe · 22/11/2022 08:06

@Shitfather oh I know about that and it's terrible that these women who believe they are married find themselves not so legally.

I believe a lot of work has gone on within the community to spread this message. I know friends of mine have been unable to book their Islamic ceremony without either a booked date for their civil wedding or their marriage certificate.

I was just saying that I think the reason the ceremony hasn't been included in the law is because the traditional format of it does not include the requirements under British law.

Shitfather · 22/11/2022 07:49

Twizbe · 21/11/2022 22:15

I might be wrong but I think the reason they don't is that the ceremony doesn't include the elements that are required by law.

Also I have a feeling it is because when the bride and groom are asked if they enter the marriage they aren't in the same room.

Yes, you are right. They don’t necessarily include the elements of a civil wedding, but it would be trivial, e.g., if imams were given powers. Bride and groom don’t necessarily have to be in separate rooms.

A man can divorce a woman by saying the word 3 times. That is it. A woman needs to seek permission and jump through hoops for one. There are cases where women have been thrown out of their homes overnight. Many will be of a demographic where they don’t understand the implications of an Islamic marriage without a legal one.

Allsnotwell · 22/11/2022 07:44

The focus shouldn't be on teaching young women how to obtain a share of men's assets. Teach them how to become financially secure in their own right instead

I want my daughters to be financially stable of their own accord and not rely on a partner - howver having children unbalances this relationship.
Having 3 children I gave up work because it wasn’t financially viable or practical.

I am grateful I had the opportunity to raise my own children.

My career has suffered, my husbands career exploded financially and we do ok.

Is that right? Probably not!

Januarcelebration · 22/11/2022 06:17

GiraffesAreTheBestDancers · 22/11/2022 01:36

So much misogyny here.

Women need men to look after them
Women can't earn more than men
Women can't support themselves
Women have to do most of the childcare
Women should sell themselves: a hole in return for a piece of paper. Just one without the Queen/ King's head on it, because then apparently it's respectable.

We need women to stand up and demand to be equal members of society with their own assets and incomes equivalent to men's. And teach young girls to expect to provide for themselves, and both partners to provide equally for the children in time and money. Then this whole issue is shown to be the irrelevancy that it is.

The focus shouldn't be on teaching young women how to obtain a share of men's assets. Teach them how to become financially secure in their own right instead.

I agree in part. The problem is that a lot of women (and men) still want one parent at home full time. A lot of people talk about how they couldn’t possible afford to work full time, but more often than not it’s because they want to. I think women should maintain their own careers, but it’s not going to happen for every woman. And there’s a small percentage who don’t have a choice due to their childrens needs/caring responsibilities.

Aside from banning sahp not sure how anyone outside the family can stop that.

If a person wants their partner to give up work to look after joint kids, then I think marrying them is the least someone could do.

And no one is teaching girls to take half a man’s assets. If you are married they are joint assets. Same when women are high earners and marry. They are joint. If you want someone to give up work to raise your joint children, but also won’t give them security and bet your financial future on it as well, you are not a good partner or person.

I won’t marry dp because I have more in assets. I have 2 kids. We are not having more. But if I wanted another child and expected dp to stay at home, I would marry him. I wouldn’t expect him to give so much up with no security.

GiraffesAreTheBestDancers · 22/11/2022 01:36

So much misogyny here.

Women need men to look after them
Women can't earn more than men
Women can't support themselves
Women have to do most of the childcare
Women should sell themselves: a hole in return for a piece of paper. Just one without the Queen/ King's head on it, because then apparently it's respectable.

We need women to stand up and demand to be equal members of society with their own assets and incomes equivalent to men's. And teach young girls to expect to provide for themselves, and both partners to provide equally for the children in time and money. Then this whole issue is shown to be the irrelevancy that it is.

The focus shouldn't be on teaching young women how to obtain a share of men's assets. Teach them how to become financially secure in their own right instead.

MassiveSaladWithChristmasTrimmings · 22/11/2022 00:46

If you want to be married, then don't have a baby with a man who marry you-forget engagement-marriage is the key word,

If he knows you want to be married and he won't-doesn't matter what reason he gives-then he sees you as the bottle of sauce in the tombola, not the bottle of champagne. You are just the trial run, so that he can say to his future wife-I've never met anyone I wanted to marry until you-all the rest were just less than a wet fart.

If he loved you and wanted to be with you for ever then most men hotfoot it to the registry office.

If you're the one who doesn't want to get married, then crack on if you don't need his money or time to support the child.

entropynow · 21/11/2022 23:56

Januarcelebration · 20/11/2022 19:22

My personal opinion is because society teaches ‘all you need is love’.

While I do think you should love someone in a long term relationship, we are taught everything will work out as long as there’s love and that we ‘just know’ when it’s forever.

People are in love and swept off their feet. So they forge forward ignoring the huge red flags. Ignoring the vulnerable position they are putting themselves in, because they believe the love will always be like that. They don’t believe a partner will never just fall out of love and treat them differently. That’s not the Happy ever after they have led to believe is true.

Then there’s also the ‘marriage is a just a piece of paper lie’ that so many people peddle.

Yup. And all the guff about "soul mates" and finding "the one"
Too much Mills and Boon, not enough common sense.

wohmum · 21/11/2022 23:42

DarkShade · 21/11/2022 21:12

I don't think we need a change of laws, I think that we need women to really understand what marriage is: a form of legal protection.

Like many women, I was raised with this really romantic view of marriage. You meet the one! Your soulmate! You wear a beautiful dress and are a princess and it is the best accomplishment of your life!! And like lots of women I called bullshit and wanted no part in it. It actually took MN to make me realise that this picture plays into the hands of men who want to avoid marriage for the legal implications. We should stop romanticising marriage and bring it back to what women of the past understood: marriage is what ensures that the work that you put into the joint family unit doesn't walk out the door with your ex.

This.
Both parties need to realise the risks and implications of their decisions ESPECIALLY if there is inequality in earnings or assets

my partner and I have recently done a civil partnership. Together 30 years, 2 kids in their early twenties. Very equal in earnings / assets . We absolutely should have done it sooner but thankfully we are both decent people and i honestly believe neither of us would have screwed the other over.
I never wanted the big public display that a marriage presented (yes , I know it didn’t need to be so public) so a 20 minute civil partnership agreement protected both us us

this gives the same protection and is a very viable alternative for any partnership where one might not want a ‘marriage’.

LexMitior · 21/11/2022 22:29

@GiraffesCauseTrouble - I'm divorced and agreed! But get married to protect the children you have.

The rest is up to you