Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's a whole mental health aftermath to the pandemic which isn't really being addressed

408 replies

crackerscandycanes · 20/11/2022 17:35

Just looking at people I know, people seem to be really struggling at the minute, and of course the cost of living is a big part and all the bad news etc, but I also think that some of it is the aftermath of the pandemic and everything we had to go through being locked indoors for all that time. It seems as if we're not supposed to mention it now or reflect, but I think there's a lot of mental health issues on the back of it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Teatimes2 · 02/12/2022 20:56

MoneyWasJustRestingInMyAccount · 22/11/2022 14:19

I can never forgive anyone who thought it acceptable to force people into solitary confinement for almost three months. Even a couple of weeks would have been too much.

I've noticed people who live alone understand this, there's a look in the eye when it's come up in conversation. Those who were not alone just don't get it.

The worst offender was a horrible bitch who told me I must be a horrible person who wanted people like her to die, just because I was clearly breaking down from the isolation and thought people who live alone should be allowed to buddy up with someone, as they did in New Zealand. She lived with her husband, happy newlyweds. And no one told her to STFU (this was on Facebook), which pains me even more.

I sometimes have flashbacks to the horror of the isolation and feel so worthless that it was considered ok to do that to people like me.

Incredibly they didn't bring in bubbles for single people for eleven weeks. And brought them in at the same time as childcare bubbles, as if basic contact with another human is somehow on the same level as childcare.

It's a crime against humanity, imo. We know the damage solitary confinement can do, there was no excuse. (For those who like to claim it wasn't solitary confinement, the definition of this is 23 or more hours a day alone, and doesn't include contact via screen etc.)

Yes, I live alone, always have and enjoy my own company, but for the first 9 weeks of 2020 lockdown I didn't see anyone and nor was I working so it was just me and the four walls, and I got very down in myself. I had a boyfriend of almost 4 years but he lived in a different city so we didn't see each other. The following year, 2021, in lockdown he dumped me over the phone, but I was able to bubble at that stage and did so with my sister and family. I found it hard to cope with this breakup though and it took me a long time to get over as I couldn't meet with friends.

Like you, I still often suffer flashbacks and still don't feel like my old self really.

MoneyWasJustRestingInMyAccount · 23/11/2022 17:07

orchid220
The fact that something is "artificial" doesn't mean it would have a greater impact on mental health than losing a loved one or being scared for your own life. I think that the threat of death for yourself or family would be far more scary for most people. That's how the human race survives.

Actually, something being "artificial" aka created by humans, does actually mean people are more likely to be traumatised by it. It's a significant risk factor when working out the likelihood of PTSD. It's thought to be due to sort of losing faith and trust in humanity, as oppose to a freak natural disaster (paraphrasing a bit).

I sometimes feel it's a relatively privileged position to hold, that death is the worst thing that could happen. For yourself, at least. I can understand a bit more the fear of a loved one's death.

Crucially, when faced with the potential loss of a loved one, you want to spend as much time with them as possible. Faced with this threat, that many would die, the everyday things didn't seem to matter much any more, and the desire to just be together whilst we still could came sharply into focus. At exactly this moment, we were all separated. Not knowing if you would see each other again.
So actually, the more you feared the death of loved ones, the more awful the separation was likely to be. And some lived out the horrific reality whereby this fear came true and they never got to say goodbye.

Buzzinwithbez · 23/11/2022 12:34

I think that the threat of death for yourself or family would be far more scary for most people. That's how the human race survives.

I was never scared. I know death can come out of the blue as we had a young family member die. For me, one of my concerns was the time together that was lost and the lives half lived in lockdown and fear, should this occur.
How many people regret not seeing and making the most of their time with the friends and relatives that didn't make it to the end of the pandemic.

SirMingeALot · 23/11/2022 11:36

I think that the threat of death for yourself or family would be far more scary for most people.

People make their own value judgements that are dependent on their own circumstances. For the majority, covid represented a very low threat of death, and indeed the state knew this and tried to elevate people's perception of their own risk in order to make them more inclined to observe restrictions. Still, lots of people would still have had an accurate idea of their own risk and how they assessed this against the other risks and benefits they considered relevant. There are plenty of us who knew full well at the time that restrictions were liable to be more detrimental to us than covid itself.

MangyInseam · 23/11/2022 11:09

And also, which was part of my point - there is always a threat of death, and at some point, it is acute. We all face death at one time or another - that is an existential truth.

I do think that our culture is very good at hiding that fact from it's members, rather than helping people learn to live with it in a healthy way. And I think that tendency was actually hugely significant in the western pandemic response.

TheKeatingFive · 23/11/2022 10:43

i'm sure that there have been plenty of laws throughout history that have meant humans are apart from their community for a time

Have there? Preventing an entire population having contact with others outside their immediate household for a significant period of time? Can you give some examples?

I think that the threat of death for yourself or family

The problem with this statement is that the threat of death was actually very low for a majority of the population

orchid220 · 23/11/2022 10:40

MangyInseam · 22/11/2022 23:01

I'm not sure these are the same kind of thing.

Losing people, fear of becoming ill - I would broadly put those under "fear of death" and the repercussions of death. In some sense the most horrible reality of human life, but also completely ubiquitous and inevitable for us all. We will all experience the trauma of having loved ones die, of becoming ill and dying ourselves, of not being able to control disease and sickness and the degradation of our bodies, and we must all somehow come to terms with it. The pandemic really did nothing to change that.

Having laws or regulations passed completely artificially, supposedly for the good of ourselves and others, that remove us from the human community - that is abnormal, and destructive of the integrity of the human community. That is not nature playing out as it does, that is people doing something to us.

i'm sure that there have been plenty of laws throughout history that have meant humans are apart from their community for a time. The fact that something is "artificial" doesn't mean it would have a greater impact on mental health than losing a loved one or being scared for your own life. I think that the threat of death for yourself or family would be far more scary for most people. That's how the human race survives.

SirMingeALot · 23/11/2022 09:51

Just to clarify, when I say never done that was a confusing word choice because there were some provisions for single person households later on. I mean it never happened in the initial period.

1dayatatime · 23/11/2022 09:36

@SirMingeALot

"It seems too obvious to have been overlooked, doesn't it"

+++

I absolutely don't think it was overlooked. I just think that anyone who pointed it out in the early days would have been shut down and criticised as uncaring, Covid denier, anti vaxx etc. Everyone else (as is often the case in authoritarian regimes) then learnt to keep their mouths shut if they wanted to get on / keep their jobs.

SirMingeALot · 23/11/2022 09:35

EmmaAgain22 · 23/11/2022 09:00

Exactly.

It's a weird one as well, because I don't think it necessarily falls into things we knew were going to have awful consequences but the government decided those people's interests would have to be sacrificed in the name of reducing contacts and controlling the spread. Eg domestic violence victims, schoolchildren, workers and preschool children when childcare was withdrawn etc.

But it would've been entirely possible within the parameters of the lockdown we had to include at least some provision for those living alone, even if it were only some minor sop like you can meet one person outside only for exercise. Yet it was never done.

EmmaAgain22 · 23/11/2022 09:02

Mangy agree with your 23:01 post.

EmmaAgain22 · 23/11/2022 09:00

SirMingeALot · 22/11/2022 16:14

It seems too obvious to have been overlooked, doesn't it?

Exactly.

JenniferBooth · 22/11/2022 23:10

Good post at 23.01 @MangyInseam

MangyInseam · 22/11/2022 23:02

MrsDooDaa · 22/11/2022 19:15

The problem was at the time covid became the only risk to life to be avoided at any cost. Anyone trying to highlight other viewpoints were labelled as murderers.

It's worrying that some people still think like this.

I know that herein my part of Canada, people in the medical system who tried to argue for looking at the longer term results of the covid measures - say for cancer - were ultimately ignored and even removed from the discussion.

MangyInseam · 22/11/2022 23:01

ArabellaScott · 22/11/2022 14:45

Sorry to hear you were traumatised, Money.

Just as you've been traumatised by isolation, others were traumatised by being forced to work with inadequate PPE etc, or by losing loved ones. Everyone's trauma is different and it's all affecting people in different ways.

I'm not sure these are the same kind of thing.

Losing people, fear of becoming ill - I would broadly put those under "fear of death" and the repercussions of death. In some sense the most horrible reality of human life, but also completely ubiquitous and inevitable for us all. We will all experience the trauma of having loved ones die, of becoming ill and dying ourselves, of not being able to control disease and sickness and the degradation of our bodies, and we must all somehow come to terms with it. The pandemic really did nothing to change that.

Having laws or regulations passed completely artificially, supposedly for the good of ourselves and others, that remove us from the human community - that is abnormal, and destructive of the integrity of the human community. That is not nature playing out as it does, that is people doing something to us.

MrsDooDaa · 22/11/2022 19:15

The problem was at the time covid became the only risk to life to be avoided at any cost. Anyone trying to highlight other viewpoints were labelled as murderers.

It's worrying that some people still think like this.

SirMingeALot · 22/11/2022 16:14

MoneyWasJustRestingInMyAccount · 22/11/2022 15:46

Yes if course, and I don't mean to dismiss anyone else's trauma.

I think the thing that really gets to me about it is that it was so very easily avoided. It wouldn't have required organisation, or planning, or sourcing materials. All it would have taken was for someone in one of the meetings to say "Hold on - what about people living alone?" and to give out the statement that they could join another household. The fact the the precedent of New Zealand's lockdown existed, and that it took eleven weeks to allow this fundamental human contact, makes me think someone did point it out, and it was decided we simply didn't matter.

It seems too obvious to have been overlooked, doesn't it?

MoneyWasJustRestingInMyAccount · 22/11/2022 15:46

ArabellaScott · 22/11/2022 14:45

Sorry to hear you were traumatised, Money.

Just as you've been traumatised by isolation, others were traumatised by being forced to work with inadequate PPE etc, or by losing loved ones. Everyone's trauma is different and it's all affecting people in different ways.

Yes if course, and I don't mean to dismiss anyone else's trauma.

I think the thing that really gets to me about it is that it was so very easily avoided. It wouldn't have required organisation, or planning, or sourcing materials. All it would have taken was for someone in one of the meetings to say "Hold on - what about people living alone?" and to give out the statement that they could join another household. The fact the the precedent of New Zealand's lockdown existed, and that it took eleven weeks to allow this fundamental human contact, makes me think someone did point it out, and it was decided we simply didn't matter.

TimBoothseyes · 22/11/2022 15:07

Incredibly they didn't bring in bubbles for single people for eleven weeks. And brought them in at the same time as childcare bubbles, as if basic contact with another human is somehow on the same level as childcare.

That was the 1 rule I broke with no fucks given. The expectation that an 83 year old should be left to grieve a woman who had been his world, alone, was beyond cruel. I didn't care want anybody thought about me, my dad deserved better than that.

You're spot on, there was no excuse,* *I wish you well @MoneyWasJustRestingInMyAccount I can only imagine how it must have been for you and so many others in the same situation.

SirMingeALot · 22/11/2022 14:49

Incredibly they didn't bring in bubbles for single people for eleven weeks. And brought them in at the same time as childcare bubbles, as if basic contact with another human is somehow on the same level as childcare.

Both omissions endangered the people on the wrong end of them: very young children not being supervised properly is a danger. I had a friend who ticked both boxes but was entitled to see nobody as she attempted to balance full time work with sole care of her toddler. Horrific.

And these both fall into the category of things we knew full fucking well were going to cause problems in March 2020, but the people who were going to be at risk didn't matter enough to address them. I can quite see why you are still angry. It's entirely justified.

ArabellaScott · 22/11/2022 14:45

Sorry to hear you were traumatised, Money.

Just as you've been traumatised by isolation, others were traumatised by being forced to work with inadequate PPE etc, or by losing loved ones. Everyone's trauma is different and it's all affecting people in different ways.

MoneyWasJustRestingInMyAccount · 22/11/2022 14:19

I can never forgive anyone who thought it acceptable to force people into solitary confinement for almost three months. Even a couple of weeks would have been too much.

I've noticed people who live alone understand this, there's a look in the eye when it's come up in conversation. Those who were not alone just don't get it.

The worst offender was a horrible bitch who told me I must be a horrible person who wanted people like her to die, just because I was clearly breaking down from the isolation and thought people who live alone should be allowed to buddy up with someone, as they did in New Zealand. She lived with her husband, happy newlyweds. And no one told her to STFU (this was on Facebook), which pains me even more.

I sometimes have flashbacks to the horror of the isolation and feel so worthless that it was considered ok to do that to people like me.

Incredibly they didn't bring in bubbles for single people for eleven weeks. And brought them in at the same time as childcare bubbles, as if basic contact with another human is somehow on the same level as childcare.

It's a crime against humanity, imo. We know the damage solitary confinement can do, there was no excuse. (For those who like to claim it wasn't solitary confinement, the definition of this is 23 or more hours a day alone, and doesn't include contact via screen etc.)

TheKeatingFive · 22/11/2022 11:57

I don't think global 'agreement' is the way forward. Countries did well by playing to their individual strengths. But lots of analysis of the benefit and harms of each measure to guide decision making in the future.

For example, the harms of closing schools were very significant. We know that now. If that's ever on the table again, we would need to be 100% sure that the benefits are worth it and baked into the decision would need to be the support measures to mitigate the affects to any degree we can.

SirMingeALot · 22/11/2022 11:40

SleeplessInEngland · 22/11/2022 11:36

Really they need a global pandemic commission so nations agree future measures bilaterally. One of the more absurd dimensions of lockdown was the conflicting travel restrictions, and clearly an island like britain is almost completely dependent on outside supply chains which were massively hampered.

Of course, that could just be another diplomatic shithow.

My worry would be that wealthier countries who have the infrastructure in place to make lockdown at least theoretically possible would use their power to try and impose measures that the poorest couldn't execute or afford.

But you're right about the travel restrictions, and the UK's inability to function without incredibly integrated outside supply chains.