Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask is there ever an acceptable reason to MN’ers for a man to leave a wife?

104 replies

SavoirFlair · 20/11/2022 16:26

I’m fully prepared to get absolutely flamed for this thread, such is the understandable bias on here from us women.

But I’m wondering - once a man has children with a woman, and something fundamentally goes wrong after time (they don’t evolve together, they fall out of love, the sex ends with little chance of it coming back for one person, they argue to the point of destruction of a loving family environment)

…then is it ever acceptable to MN’ers if a man says “I’m sorry, I can’t do this” and leaves the family?

granted I get there is a crucial part missing here - the man has to have the intent to want to see his family and raise his children, have proper access, want to be a part of their lives and co-parent with respect and understanding .

However I’m often on threads on here where “LTB!” is sounded with regular frequency to the point it’s become cliche here. Does the same count for the “bastards” who have had enough? Can they ever leave?

Some notes for any of the obtuse folk on here who like to pick holes :

  1. This is not a ‘reverse’ (ugh)
  2. I am not a man
  3. Cheating is always wrong. I’m talking about a man leaving without another partner lined up, when a relationship irrevocably breaks down
  4. If this thread takes off and you’re the Daily Mail, I abhor your website which tears down women and encourages them to be catty about body types. Horrible ‘newspaper’
OP posts:
Crankley · 20/11/2022 16:32

Of course a man can leave a marriage if he's unhappy, just the same as a woman. If children are involved, he should continue to contribute both financially and with his time.

I don't really understand why you needed to ask - isn't it obvious?

Lunar270 · 20/11/2022 16:32

Of course there is. Relationships don't always work for whatever reason and it's not always a good idea to stay together for the kids.

One day the man might even take the kids or share parental responsibility 50/50 like they do in Australia. Or even pay their fair share. These are some (not all) of the issues currently.

Tothemoonandbackx · 20/11/2022 16:31

No one, man or woman, should stay in a relationship if it has broken down to the extent that you're just making each other miserable and can't see it continuing.

Bonheurdupasse · 20/11/2022 16:31

Good luck OP, you will be villified!

My DP left because he'd been abused - physically & verbally - for over 10 years, and still he's the bad guy and indeed villified by exw to all and sundry.
(That's despite the fact he does all you say with the kids, plus pays for everything for including her mortgage...).
So unfortunately it's just a reflection of real life...