Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Worried about niece and new private school activities

262 replies

YellowMarigold · 20/11/2022 15:03

My brother’s daughter, my DN is bright and enjoys sports. She has a younger brother at primary. Sadly her mum passed away with cancer three years ago. At the advice of her primary DN did a test and got a scholarship to a local private school and her fees are almost completely covered by a means tested bursary. Nobody in the family has experience of private schools and there are a few things that don’t sit right with me that worry me.

There is a lot of sport. The sport in the school day is fine but at least once a week she plays a match against another school and is often not back at school until 6.30pm on the coach. It takes her an hour to get home on another coach, then homework and she practices an instrument. Every Saturday she also plays another sport against other schools. If it is an away match she is often gone all day. There is no choice about playing these matches. She has been told it’s part of school. She was encouraged to audition for a school play and got a part. The rehearsals are after school and on weekends so she often finishes late rehearsing and now is rehearsing on Sunday afternoons. She leaves home at 7am every day to get a bus that takes an hour. It isn’t an hour’s journey but the bus collects children from all over so it’s a lot of travel time. There is a lot of homework.

My worries are:
My DN does not seem to have any down time. She and her brother used to come to spend time with my kids at the weekend. She misses us and texts that she is sad she is busy all the time. She has cried on the phone to me several times and always says she didn’t know it would be such a long day and she finds it very hard. She asks me if secondary school is always so hard and I don’t know what to say. I know she is getting amazing chances from an academic point of view but it feels off balance.

My brother makes her food and keeps it warm, they hardly eat as a family. She isn’t doing more than the other kids, this is the standard. These are not optional clubs. Maybe I’m being overprotective because she has already lost her mum at a young age, but is this too much pressure and too much time in school? She has huge rings under her eyes and has difficulty sleeping because she feels stressed about school. Today she text me to ask if she has to go to her rehearsals. I don’t want to interfere but I don’t want to see her suffer and say nothing.

OP posts:
mycatisannoying · 20/11/2022 17:56

She will get used to it, harsh as that sounds Flowers

geraniumsandsunshine · 20/11/2022 17:54

Going against the grain it's great she's in a good school and keeping busy. I think this is one less worry for her dad and if she is enjoying herself, fits in and has friends then that's perfect

ShandaLear · 20/11/2022 17:53

Kids are much more resilient than you imagine and soon get used to more intensive routines as they settle in. At 12 years old my DD was doing a full school day plus another 22 hours of gymnastics over 6 days every week. I hope you’re supporting and encouraging her, rather than telling her how awful it must be for her. Even state school kids do lots of activities such as football - practice on a Tuesday night, play on a Saturday morning, or swimming - 2 hours every morning from 5am, or martial arts - 3 nights a week. They are perfectly capable of achieving with full timetables. Things change as they develop so make sure you help her make the most of her opportunities.

Tulipomania · 20/11/2022 17:52

As PPs have said, this is pretty normal for a private school - my DS's went to a similar one.

They had to get the bus to school which left at 7 and they got back at 6 in the evening, one also had sports matches at weekends, with other late nights for training.

They did not sign up for drama (which annoyed me!) but one was quite good at music, played in the orchestra which meant more late nights.

It is tiring when they first start and have to get used to everything. But they are both now adults and formed the most amazing long-lasting friendships - my 24 year old still regularly sees his old friends from school.

Your niece can drop the drama next term, it will likely also be different sport and she may not get chosen for the team, it will get better. If the bus journey takes too long is there an option for a parent to take her? Although mine would never have agreed to that as they enjoyed the bus banter!

You sound like a very thoughtful and caring aunt - I would reassure your niece that it will get easier as she goes along, she can do less activivites next term, but if she is really fed up she should speak to her tutor or house-master/mistress.

Pipsquiggle · 20/11/2022 17:48

Is it a boarding school?

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 17:44

"In all honesty, this isn't your business, but if your niece feels she's overwhelmed at present, I would hope she she uses this experience to learn not to over-commit herself in future."

This seems very harsh, Dniece is only 11 and has no DM to discuss these things with and is perhaps worried she will be letting her DF down by admitting she has found things hard.

OP you could maybe say to your DF that you miss seeing her and see if that prompts any discussion. Also with your Dniece remind her that the play will be over at end of term - hopefully that's the case - and she doesn't need to sign up for everything. Also encourage her to try and do most of her homework on the bus/coach as sounds like that's where she is spending most time.

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 20/11/2022 17:44

I attended a private primary for a year that sounds very similar. Really sporty/extra curricular, long days. It was a boarding school too and geared very much towards the boarders I think who didn't have family to get back to in the evenings/at weekends.
My parents spoke with the staff and just refused to have me away too much at the weekend. I missed out on being on the sports teams etc but obviously still played daily. I'm so grateful to them.
Participation may be 'very much expected' but it's not as mandatory as it's made out. DN will be unable to negotiate this for herself so her parents/relatives should step in.
You can start with a term with a less hectic timetable and once that's established it will probably be easier to carry it on as you/your DN wishes.
It's a school, not prison. Parents have a say.

Wishihadanalgorithm · 20/11/2022 17:43

OP, it may be that the school isn’t right for your DN or, that in time, she will grow to love it. I work in an indie and it isn’t as intense as what you describe although I know many can be like this. I think at the moment I’d be concerned about how your DN is coping with the onset of puberty without her mum. It is such a tricky time for girls without their mums (I know form my own experience).

There is a wonderful charity called Winston’s Wish that helps children who have experienced a bereavement. I’d be looking at their website for ideas for how school can support your DN.

Helenloveslee4eva · 20/11/2022 17:42

Secondary school ? That’s very normal.
my kids were mostly musical not sporty but that’s the level of commitment they had at that age.
thry are now fully functioning adults

flowerycurtain · 20/11/2022 17:41

Firstly what a lovely Auntie you are to be so caring.

I do think the level of sports/activities is normal for private secondary. This will be the hardest longest term though. Did she get two weeks off in October? When to they finish for Xmas? Mine finish on the 9th December.

Having said that there's not many kids that achieve academically plus sport plus music plus drama. There are one or two exceptions to that but most do some sport and 1 instrument or no sport and two instruments plus drama. I don't think there would be any shame in giving up the play.

maranella · 20/11/2022 17:36

Your niece chooses to play a musical instrument and auditioned to be in a play - it's not surprising that she has to practice and she got a part in the play. The sports commitments are normal (I have lots of experience with private schools).

She may have over-committed herself (this can happen if a DC doesn't fully consider the time commitment of the various things they sign up for), but I notice that it's YOU who is concerned, not the girl herself or her DF.

In all honesty, this isn't your business, but if your niece feels she's overwhelmed at present, I would hope she she uses this experience to learn not to over-commit herself in future.

The bottom line is this - she will have many, many opportunities at a private school to get involved in all kinds of things and the key is to prioritise what she loves and wants to pursue long-term. If she's in Y7 or 8 though, she's still discovering where her passions lie.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 20/11/2022 17:32

Totally normal. Yes, it’s a huge change. Yes, she will be utterly exhausted. It gets better.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 20/11/2022 17:30

Does the school offer boarding? If sounds like it does which would explain the longer days.

I work in a boarding school so can offer some perspective on that:

  1. all year 7s are tired, dark evenings, new school, higher expectations etc…. Not just independents
  2. is there an option of staying later and her dad picking her up? Which would give time to do prep at school?
  3. could she board some nights? Removing the commute can really help
  4. speak to her tutor /house parent (if boarding) and explain your concerns - they most likely want to help
  5. it might not be the right school for her - and that is ok, she isn’t letting anyone down or wasting a great opportunity, it isn’t the right fit.
  6. no, not everyone flew somewhere on holiday, there will be a full mix of very rich to full bursary. Even with no bursary a lot of parents a making sacrifices to attend the school.
PurpleParrotfish · 20/11/2022 17:28

I’m surprised at the agreement that this is normal for private schools. At my private secondary in the 80s/90s, sports teams etc were voluntary, and we had a long lunch break with activities like orchestra practice, choir, clubs run by sixth form students for first years. I was home by about 4.15 every day with plenty of time for homework and music practice.
I would have absolutely loathed having no free time in the week and having to spend all Saturday at sports matches!

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 17:26

It sounds like her distance from school is making it unsustainable.
Two hours of travel every day - including Saturdays - is too much when you factor in evenings sports etc.
Would the journey be less by car? Can her DF at least pick her up on the evenings she has sport, rather than her having to get the bus ?

YesitsJacqueline · 20/11/2022 17:26

I think it sounds hard but in years to come she will appreciate the incredible opportunity she's been given and hopefully this will give her a great start in life
Also sounds like you have a lovely relationship with her

YellowMarigold · 20/11/2022 17:21

Sport on Saturday is definitely compulsory. She has a letter that was sent to all parents saying they have to facilitate it and it’s part of school. Same for evening sport.

OP posts:
Mirabai · 20/11/2022 17:18

YellowMarigold · 20/11/2022 17:05

Thanks for all the comments and questions. A lot of the questions I don’t know the answers to as she is not my DC. This school was suggested by the primary and it sounded like a great opportunity. I’m not sure of other options but my DB will have looked into options. Sports are definitely compulsory in her year. Everyone is banded into teams by ability. There are lots of teams which is why matches seem to take a long time. She definitely has a very big bursary. I’m not sure exactly what but almost all her fees.

Sport will be compulsory yes, but it may not be compulsory on Saturday.

If it is compulsory on Saturday she may still be able to get out of it given that she plays an instrument (unless she learns in school).

If it is compulsory, she can’t get out of it, and all the students are away all Saturday, then the school may not be that academic. Academic schools have more flexibility on sports. If it’s not so academic, there will be less pressure on work.

Eleusa · 20/11/2022 17:13

Sounds quite normal. If she’s unhappy, I’d suggest your DB speaks to the school to understand whether these activities are genuinely compulsory- teachers are always keen to tell pupils they have to do X or Y but actually (subject to the terms of the bursary- don’t know anything about this) what they mean is you have to do matches after school if you want a place on the team- it’s not actually Compton the strict sense.

He needs to help her understand what actually is compulsory and whether she can do it. If not he can speak to the school to explain the situation.

Jenny3412 · 20/11/2022 17:09

I teach at a top private school, but would not choose it for my kids. I think it’s worthwhile looking at time management and sorting this out with her tutor at school. Great opportunity does not equal happy home life, though the longer hours may allow her father to work more. She sounds truly lovely, keep listening to her concerns and look at time management. Sorting this out with her tutor is the best advice. It’s not meant to be a hamster wheel, she has to enjoy it as well.

Wallaw · 20/11/2022 17:06

@YellowMarigold

Have sent you a pm

YellowMarigold · 20/11/2022 17:05

Thanks for all the comments and questions. A lot of the questions I don’t know the answers to as she is not my DC. This school was suggested by the primary and it sounded like a great opportunity. I’m not sure of other options but my DB will have looked into options. Sports are definitely compulsory in her year. Everyone is banded into teams by ability. There are lots of teams which is why matches seem to take a long time. She definitely has a very big bursary. I’m not sure exactly what but almost all her fees.

OP posts:
YouSoundLovely · 20/11/2022 17:04

There's an emphasis in a lot of these replies on the fantastic opportunities, on a schedule like this being a (the only?) route to 'success', etc. (even the implication that there's no other way to get to C-level - which in itself is an extremely narrow and reductive definition of success). I think I want to strike a slightly different note in wondering if an 'opportunity' is really an opportunity if the person 'taking' it is experiencing it as an exhausting chore. I think the one-sided emphasis on compulsory 'extra-curricular' (not really extra- if it's compulsory) sports would worry me a bit - it may be the case that this little girl would really like to do the play, and/or her instrument, so she's joined in, but it's just too much along with the rest of it. The comment she made about potentially 'losing everything' if she doesn't keep up would really worry me, especially given her history - I'm surprised nobody else has picked up on that.

OP, yes, I would speak to your brother. She's a young child who's vulnerable by reason of her early loss. If I were him I would be wanting to find out what additional activities the school could be flexible about and what it regards as non-negotiable. Their attitude towards her struggles would tell me quite a lot about whether it was the right environment for her long-term.

PixellatedPixie · 20/11/2022 17:03

In my area the girls only secondaries don’t tend to do sports on Saturdays unless you voluntarily sign up for the A / B team in a sport. Some of the co-ed schools do have compulsory sports on Saturday mornings from Year 9 but by then the kids are used to it.

Coasterfan · 20/11/2022 17:02

My DS did year 7 at a school that sounds similar, he was out 7 til 7 every day and had no choice about Saturday sport if he was chosen. He had a complete breakdown over the summer as he was utterly exhausted and he begged me not to make him go back. I think your concerns are justified.

However DD is at a different private school 15 mins from home, we leave at 8.15 and I collect her at 4.30, she does no extracurricular stuff so it does depend on the school, they are not all like this. Her school is single sex so they wouldn’t have DS.

DS is now being homeschooled while we wait for a state school place. The impact on his mental health was devastating and that to me outweighed any benefits of a private education.