Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Worried about niece and new private school activities

262 replies

YellowMarigold · 20/11/2022 15:03

My brother’s daughter, my DN is bright and enjoys sports. She has a younger brother at primary. Sadly her mum passed away with cancer three years ago. At the advice of her primary DN did a test and got a scholarship to a local private school and her fees are almost completely covered by a means tested bursary. Nobody in the family has experience of private schools and there are a few things that don’t sit right with me that worry me.

There is a lot of sport. The sport in the school day is fine but at least once a week she plays a match against another school and is often not back at school until 6.30pm on the coach. It takes her an hour to get home on another coach, then homework and she practices an instrument. Every Saturday she also plays another sport against other schools. If it is an away match she is often gone all day. There is no choice about playing these matches. She has been told it’s part of school. She was encouraged to audition for a school play and got a part. The rehearsals are after school and on weekends so she often finishes late rehearsing and now is rehearsing on Sunday afternoons. She leaves home at 7am every day to get a bus that takes an hour. It isn’t an hour’s journey but the bus collects children from all over so it’s a lot of travel time. There is a lot of homework.

My worries are:
My DN does not seem to have any down time. She and her brother used to come to spend time with my kids at the weekend. She misses us and texts that she is sad she is busy all the time. She has cried on the phone to me several times and always says she didn’t know it would be such a long day and she finds it very hard. She asks me if secondary school is always so hard and I don’t know what to say. I know she is getting amazing chances from an academic point of view but it feels off balance.

My brother makes her food and keeps it warm, they hardly eat as a family. She isn’t doing more than the other kids, this is the standard. These are not optional clubs. Maybe I’m being overprotective because she has already lost her mum at a young age, but is this too much pressure and too much time in school? She has huge rings under her eyes and has difficulty sleeping because she feels stressed about school. Today she text me to ask if she has to go to her rehearsals. I don’t want to interfere but I don’t want to see her suffer and say nothing.

OP posts:
MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 20/11/2022 22:34

I feel like a lot of people praising the superior merits of the C-suite haven't spent a lot of time in a boardroom! C-suite aren't magical hardworking resilient unicorns, forged in the playing fields of our minor prep schools. See also Elon Musk, Frederick Alexander Goodwin and of course our own, dear Alexander Boris de Pfeffel Johnson. Twats to a man, leading boardrooms of twats recruited in their own twatty image.

Noonesperfect · 20/11/2022 22:17

Totally with you rookiemere.

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 22:04

And I suppose another dimension to this is that OP was the closest thing that DNiece has to a maternal figure, and now she hardly gets to see her.

Noonesperfect · 20/11/2022 21:50

caitlinrose

I dont think OP is indulging her niece in her sadness at all, she’s just listening to her and acting as a mother figure to a poor young girl who has lost her mother. It’s alright to point out some of the good points and encourage, but not to the detriment of the child thinking no one is really listening to her and her struggles. Just saying it’s a great opportunity, oh you’re so lucky etc feels a bit like “Oh you’re struggling, but it’s a great opportunity, so just get on with it!” Her niece is reaching out to her aunt, and rightly so her lovely aunt is listening and not trying to glibly sweep it all under the carpet with “Oh she’ll be ok.” Op is trying to ascertain if her niece is really ok or not.

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 21:50

But she's not coping - which is perfectly natural as an 11 year old girl who's struggling to adapt in new circumstances- or she wouldn't be in tears with her auntie, who she doesn't get to see anymore.

It sounds like a punishing schedule, and if that makes me into some beatnik hippie type despite having worked successfully in the corporate world for 30 years, so be it.

I'm not saying the DD should leave, but a bit of sympathy or coping strategies for homework on bus, or a prompt to the DF to pick her up on occasion if it's a late finish, are kindnesses that might help, rather than just saying she wants to toughen up to get a good job.

Justthisonce12 · 20/11/2022 21:39

@edwinbear so that absolutely was not what I said at all that his only route in life is to go down the c suite boardroom office job. To be clear, my point was that in order to be a c suite boardroom type you’re going to need to be able to juggle lots of things within a day and you’re going to need the mental and physical capacity to start early and work hard throughout the evening. If that girl has the capacity to perform at that level, then she should be encouraged. The work life balance shit that’s fed to so many state school children is absolutely unheard of in private schools.
It’s an absolute given that you won’t do very much later on in life because you would’ve delayed gratification earlier on.

piedbeauty · 20/11/2022 21:38

So sport is compulsory but she was 'encouraged' to do rehearsals for the school play, and now she has a part obviously she has to go...

Your db needs to speak to the school. Say how tired his dd is, that she's loving the experience but scared of losing her bursary, so what extra-curricular clubs does she HAVE to do? Then he can set her mind at rest.

edwinbear · 20/11/2022 21:08

@Justthisonce12 DS manages a heavy (private school) academic work load plus a heavy sports training schedule. At 13, he’s unusual to still be competing at a high level, across a very broad range of sports - athletics (sprints, middle distance and long lump), cross country, swimming & rugby. Most kids have specialised in one or two by now. He’s a master at managing his time and commitments, but no way will he be going into a boardroom!

He’ll end up either in pro sport - probably not as a sportsman, (as so few ‘make it’) but almost certainly, coaching, refereeing, whatever else sports careers can entail (I’m a banker so not my area of expertise). If not, I can see him in the forces, police, possibly a pilot, or something similarly active. But I think it’s a bit narrow minded to just think of c suite as the natural career path for bright, well rounded kids? Don’t get me wrong, when we started down the private school route, we were thinking medicine, law, accountancy, banking. But I’ve come to realise he’d absolutely detest those sorts of jobs. I’ve no doubt he’ll be successful in whatever he chooses - he just won’t choose an office based role.

XingMing · 20/11/2022 20:40

Ended up working in A&E is so rude. That's the fast fast lane of routine medical practice, where all the new acute treatments are tried out, and for scientific research purposes, where detailed notes need to be recorded accurately. Because a conscientious record could be the key to seeing something important. Outside of a warzone, A&E is the closest thing to the front line and the most likely place for a nurse or surgeon to have to improvise a quick fix to "hold" your relative safe and stable while working out the best clinical treatment.

2bazookas · 20/11/2022 20:00

Our children enjoyed their long bus commute to school; it was a very sociable part of school life. (40 mins each way, passengers aged 5 to 18, girls and boys).
With a very early start, I made sure mine were up and ready in good time
(no late rush) and fuelled by a really good breakfast. They were always ravenous when they arrived back home. At this time of year they left and arrived home pretty much in the dark.

She's had a big upheaval , is new to everything and has only been there a short time. Keep listening and comforting. When the newness/strangeness wears off she may settle. Lots of sport improves sleep, health and resilience.

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 20/11/2022 19:55

Justthisonce12 · 20/11/2022 19:29

No, not at all what I’m suggesting is that the type of person who is able to manage long days with lots of multiple activities is the type of person who will end up in C suite roles, hopefully. Or they might end up being a nurse.
but the opposite of that, a child that won’t work life balance and wouldn’t commute for an opportunity. I wouldn’t go the extra mile for sport or extra curricular activities, even though they might enjoy them because that would be too much for them Will absolutely not end up in the boardroom. And nor the operating theatre or A&E either.
I actually went to a state comprehensive and it’s really interesting because you could see you at the age of 12 who was going to end up in precisely those kind of roles, who had the guts for the Glory.

What a load of old rot. From someone who 'ended up' in A&E.

PlentyO · 20/11/2022 19:43

Tbh 830 to 3pm (which my kids do in state school) is not enough and definitely doesn't stretch them. I'd rather they had longer days

mondaytosunday · 20/11/2022 19:38

Its NOT normal to be compulsory. My son did sports - for school and outside. So yes every Saturday was taken up with school sport, every Sunday with his outside of school sport, plus one practice a week. He played an instrument too but drama was optional, even when he did GCSE drama.
My daughter did not care for competitive sport nor drama. So she did not sign up for those activities.
Between me and my husband's kids i have experience of six private schools and none of the activities were compulsory other than in my sons year when they needed most boys to make up a team - even then some didn't participate. I'd have your brother check.
As it's a need based bursary it's very unlikely she would be compelled to participate - if she had a sport or music or drama scholarship then she would.

Justthisonce12 · 20/11/2022 19:29

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 19:09

@bakerstreetbus74 What I'm trying to say - probably very badly- is that some posters on this thread clearly think that a private education with long school days means their DCs are much more suited for a board level high paying role. I was just trying to point out that nurses work long hours too, but I think some people put a lot of importance on high paying careers.

No, not at all what I’m suggesting is that the type of person who is able to manage long days with lots of multiple activities is the type of person who will end up in C suite roles, hopefully. Or they might end up being a nurse.
but the opposite of that, a child that won’t work life balance and wouldn’t commute for an opportunity. I wouldn’t go the extra mile for sport or extra curricular activities, even though they might enjoy them because that would be too much for them Will absolutely not end up in the boardroom. And nor the operating theatre or A&E either.
I actually went to a state comprehensive and it’s really interesting because you could see you at the age of 12 who was going to end up in precisely those kind of roles, who had the guts for the Glory.

Drfosters · 20/11/2022 19:29

I’ll be honest that sounds like my kid’s lives. My daughter leaves for school 6.30 most mornings to do an hour of sport before school and often had after school matches and satursdays. My son plays football 5 days a week. They also play instruments. But they love it. They can’t play enough sport honestly. I don’t think they would do it if not and I’d be the first to tell them to stop if they didn’t enjoy it. So what is is doing is pretty normal for schools like the one she attends. However, If your niece honestly isn’t enjoying it then she needs to rein it in. It is rare anyone is forced to do it. My kids live for sport but plenty of others don’t and the schools let them choose something else. It should be about fun and finding the right balance

bakerstreetbus74 · 20/11/2022 19:24

class nurse in me got a bit prickly!

bakerstreetbus74 · 20/11/2022 19:23

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 19:09

@bakerstreetbus74 What I'm trying to say - probably very badly- is that some posters on this thread clearly think that a private education with long school days means their DCs are much more suited for a board level high paying role. I was just trying to point out that nurses work long hours too, but I think some people put a lot of importance on high paying careers.

Thank you for that clarity. The working class nurse in me got a bit prickly!

saraclara · 20/11/2022 19:16

...C-level - which in itself is an extremely narrow and reductive definition of success

You're telling me. The post that led to the question, boggled my mind. I'd never heard of C Suite either, and it certainly wouldn't be the kind of success I'd actively promote to my offspring.

alwayscheery · 20/11/2022 19:10

Your DN is very lucky to have such a Caring Auntie.
Sounds quite normal for private school.
I always enjoy the match teas as parents and grandparents we have always been invited to attend. Could you look out for the matches being played at schools near you or the home matches and pick your dn up after the match? Can Dad do a pick up one night too and maybe spectate at the weekend occasionally.

I agree about helping with time management and life skills. Poor child sounds exhausted.

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 19:09

@bakerstreetbus74 What I'm trying to say - probably very badly- is that some posters on this thread clearly think that a private education with long school days means their DCs are much more suited for a board level high paying role. I was just trying to point out that nurses work long hours too, but I think some people put a lot of importance on high paying careers.

XingMing · 20/11/2022 19:09

It is a very tough transition from state primary to private secondary, especially on a presumably competitive bursary scheme, and your niece will not be alone in feeling shattered. Next term it will be the play, and another sport, and more music.

We took a similar course, and after a year, it was clear that DS did not have the stamina for Y10, plus three mandatory twilight sessions every week. So he did y10/11 locally in state comprehensive-- where he learned almost nothing academically, but a huge amount about other people's lives and his privilege.

His GCSE results were achieved entirely on the teaching strength of prep school and Y9 in private, and were nothing to brag about. But it was the travel distance that killed us. We chose a brilliant school but it was too distant (50 miles away), and DS was then a shrimp. So we got it wrong, but we could not have afforded a full boarding private school either. Nearly a decade later, we occasionally wonder what we could have done better.

bakerstreetbus74 · 20/11/2022 19:07

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 18:51

It's amusing all these DPs thinking that these long hours make their DCs ideal for roles in the corporate world - nurses do long shifts too, so perhaps private school is an ideal preparation for a nursing career.

Honestly DS goes to a private school and it's certainly not as intensive as this - I'd be horrified if it was. But then I would have been unlikely to let him go to a school with an hours commute each way - no matter how good it was.

I've worked with many a nurse who was privately educated. Not sure where you are coming from with your comment. Are nurses only allowed to be from the state education system? Genuinely perplexed...

Mirabai · 20/11/2022 19:05

Is an hour a commute? It’s roughly how long it takes to get anywhere in London.

Most people I know did an hour to school. There were a few who lived nearby. There’s no doubt that less travel time leaves more time for prep and practice, but I’d much rather go to a really good school that took a while to get to than a crap one just because it was local.

Greytea · 20/11/2022 19:01

One of my DC went to private school
and it was nothing like this. No after-school or Saturday sports. No music practice etc at school. Mine did play an instrument but it was out of school and she didn’t play it in school. Mine did do drama for GCSE and there was a play and rehearsals for that. Otherwise, no. No excessively long hours.

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 18:51

It's amusing all these DPs thinking that these long hours make their DCs ideal for roles in the corporate world - nurses do long shifts too, so perhaps private school is an ideal preparation for a nursing career.

Honestly DS goes to a private school and it's certainly not as intensive as this - I'd be horrified if it was. But then I would have been unlikely to let him go to a school with an hours commute each way - no matter how good it was.

Swipe left for the next trending thread