Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There's too much animosity towards benefit recipients.

363 replies

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 11:36

Any and every flavour of benefit recipient, disabled, pensioner, out of work, low paid, single parent etc etc.
There's a mean and nasty cohort on mumsnet who are vitriolic in their hatred for them all.
What do people want instead of giving people a basic level of existence?
What do they think will happen without benefits?

OP posts:
808Kate1 · 20/11/2022 16:04

@PeloFondo I get that, and I have a friend in the same position as you who takes a 'financially sensible' (for want of a better phrase) approach to not having kids, but I know, like you, it causes her a great deal of pain when people question her about it (and fwiw she would be a wonderful mother, as I'm sure you would be). I didn't mean to come across as belittling you and apologise for that. But there seems to be a wider attitude that 'the poor shouldn't reproduce' and if enough people repeat this mantra and believe it, then who knows when these opinions will creep into policy debates

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/11/2022 16:00

@MarieIVanArkleStinks

Excellent post with which I heartily agree.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 20/11/2022 15:58

Spectre8 · 20/11/2022 11:45

Just as much hatred for people who protest to increase their wages though.

Yes, the site is very anti-union. And despite the professed disdain for certain factions of the right wing on this site, a sizeable proportion of comments and threads it contains certainly reflect those kinds of views.

I've not seen many benefit recipient threads. But people's anger is being focused entirely in the wrong direction. The divide between the obscenely rich and the rest of us is widening by the year. Public sector workers haven't seen a reasonable pay rise in years, and are now having to resort to strike action to secure fair recompense; they've seen their salaries shrink, as they haven't risen anywhere near in proportion to the rising costs of living.

Meanwhile, there's an elite in this country trousering the vast proportion of its wealth. The rest of the country are then left scrapping like crabs in a bucket for the meagre spoils that are left. Attention is diverted from the corrupt actions of the establishment by focusing it on those at the lower end of the wealth spectrum. In the meantime, an overwhelmingly right-wing media are fed incendiary narratives about benefit recipients, immigrants, or any other convenient scapegoat, so that the populace will turn their ire on them rather than where it truly belongs. There's a reason why successive governments keep banging on about tackling immigration, then failing to do so. It suits them to keep the status quo precisely as it is, as it conveniently turns the spotlight of attention away from those who are creaming the profits whilst driving this country through the floor.

Anyone in doubt of this should ask themselves why tax avoidance is perfectly legal whilst benefit fraud is a crime.

RobertaFirmino · 20/11/2022 15:58

But if I posted a new thread and said
"I'm pregnant despite contraception, I can't increase my wages. I'm single, and have no money left at the end of the month, I really want a child but there is no money for one"
What are people likely to say?

The majority of MNers would say 'Don't abort a wanted child' - I would put a tenner on it.

Hobbi · 20/11/2022 15:51

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 15:42

Unwarranted pedantry here, but that's not what the Protestant work ethic is.

Puritan work ethic, then. I wasn't thinking specifically of Weber there, more along the lines that Protestant theology from Luther onwards described worldly work as a benefit to both the individual and society as a whole.

I was just teasing, no insult intended. It's my academic field so I tend to pounce on it. Sorry.

Artygirlghost · 20/11/2022 15:50

''@MxGrinch · Today 15:29
What I don’t get is there are plenty of European countries with much more generous welfare and social housing provisions than the UK and they have nothing like the social stigma that the UK has about welfare payments.''

This.

I lived in France where benefit rates and social housing standards/provision are actually much higher than in the UK and there was no rabid, widespread ''benefit scroungers'' propaganda there.

it is very an English thing.

It is very much part of the class system and Empire obsessions.

But I think it is also about right wing media barons blaming immigrants/ benefit claimants/the EU for everything to distract the public from the general lack of competency of too many Tory governments.

TimBoothseyes · 20/11/2022 15:49

I'd bet a large number of objectors to benefits are also people who received furlough support through lockdown

I wouldn't be too sure of that. There were many posters saying that everybody in receipt of furlough should be made to "work" for it (fruit and veg picking etc), or to pay it back once furlough had ended as we were all being "paid to sit on [our] arses and baking banana bread and enjoying [our] holiday paid for by the taxpayer". It didn't matter that we were also paying tax on our 80% salary or that there was nothing else to do for weeks on end apart from queueing up at supermarkets.

Usernamen · 20/11/2022 15:46

Havent read the whole thread, but what I’ve also noticed is how much an increase in benefits (say, in line with inflation…) seems to anger people. As if we should keep benefits low/erode their value just because wages aren’t keeping up with inflation, instead of try to fix the latter. There’s such a scarcity/‘race to the bottom’ mentality in this country, for some reason.

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 15:46

PeloFondo · 20/11/2022 15:36

I'm not saying I know the answer to everything

But if I posted a new thread and said
"I'm pregnant despite contraception, I can't increase my wages. I'm single, and have no money left at the end of the month, I really want a child but there is no money for one"
What are people likely to say?
I don't have a well paid job

What's the sensible answer to that? It's not have a child anyway, you'll find the money because well, there isn't any money to find
It's not always fair or right, and i am an only child as my parents couldn't afford childcare for 2 children

If I were to reply to that thread it'd be a don't worry lass you'll manage because I think we have changed priorities (due to necessity not frivolity) I'm older though and my DC are adult so I see your point.

OP posts:
BrightOrangeRectangles · 20/11/2022 15:45

And people on benefits don't struggle? And none of them work full time either?

Open your blinkers

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 15:42

Unwarranted pedantry here, but that's not what the Protestant work ethic is.

Puritan work ethic, then. I wasn't thinking specifically of Weber there, more along the lines that Protestant theology from Luther onwards described worldly work as a benefit to both the individual and society as a whole.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/11/2022 15:41

I’m swapping between this thread and the one about claimants nervous of taking on extra hours which will destabilise their benefit claims - strangely both threads have moved to the question of having children if you can’t afford them …..

The world is really in a pretty pickle right now, but I am marginally disturbed by the “eugenics by stealth” sneaking in….

PeloFondo · 20/11/2022 15:41

808Kate1 · 20/11/2022 15:37

Let them pick oakum! Let's see how lusty they're feeling after that!

Yes, everyone should be able to have a child @PeloFondo and you're moving into some pretty shitty, dark territory now mate.

I'm genuinely not trying to upset anyone, it's a question I'm asking because well, that's the situation I'm in and I've been in before and had to terminate

After I pay my bills, now with the cost of living increases there isn't any money left over
So I guess my question is HOW would I afford a child? If I can't increase my wages
I'm not saying only the rich should have them but how do people like me afford one then? I can't tighten my belt because there's nothing left to tighten, and as a single person I'm not entitled to any benefits. With a mortgage I don't think I would get enough anyway to fund a child

And when people ask me do I not want children (because I'm at an age when people ask) I tend to laugh and be "no I like my cat/lie ins/partying too much thanks!" because it hurts and it's more embarrassing to say actually I don't have the money

Newcatbrowntail · 20/11/2022 15:39

we should be bashing the employers, who benefit from the system . The government are basically subsidising businesses, by topping up the wages of poorly paid workforce

808Kate1 · 20/11/2022 15:37

Let them pick oakum! Let's see how lusty they're feeling after that!

Yes, everyone should be able to have a child @PeloFondo and you're moving into some pretty shitty, dark territory now mate.

Hobbi · 20/11/2022 15:36

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 15:35

they have nothing like the social stigma that the UK has about welfare payments

Protestant work ethic. The one that demands you go into work when you feel like you're dying. Also (as demonstrated by a few posters on here) an engrained churlishness that some people are getting what they aren't; 'someone's winning something they don't deserve to have and I'm paying for it.'

Unwarranted pedantry here, but that's not what the Protestant work ethic is.

PeloFondo · 20/11/2022 15:36

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 15:30

Ok then no children we can't afford, who does the low skill/pay jobs of the future? Who provides care as we get older? What about those who are carers but also provide second care for older people when they are in ft work?

I'm not saying I know the answer to everything

But if I posted a new thread and said
"I'm pregnant despite contraception, I can't increase my wages. I'm single, and have no money left at the end of the month, I really want a child but there is no money for one"
What are people likely to say?
I don't have a well paid job

What's the sensible answer to that? It's not have a child anyway, you'll find the money because well, there isn't any money to find
It's not always fair or right, and i am an only child as my parents couldn't afford childcare for 2 children

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 15:35

they have nothing like the social stigma that the UK has about welfare payments

Protestant work ethic. The one that demands you go into work when you feel like you're dying. Also (as demonstrated by a few posters on here) an engrained churlishness that some people are getting what they aren't; 'someone's winning something they don't deserve to have and I'm paying for it.'

Hobbi · 20/11/2022 15:35

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 15:30

Ok then no children we can't afford, who does the low skill/pay jobs of the future? Who provides care as we get older? What about those who are carers but also provide second care for older people when they are in ft work?

The children of the rich will step up to the plate and provide intimate care for the elderly, work on checkouts and clean toilets. Obviously. Of course, the low wages will prevent them from avoiding forced sterilisation so some sort of robotic workforce will have to be designed for the dwindling population, solely consisting of the deserving rich.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/11/2022 15:32

It’s interesting isn’t it? I mean, being deemed worthy of employment is apparently a source of pride, higher self esteem and admiration from the wider community - even if your job is shit, exploitative, undermines your family life and mental health, has no security or long term prospects, it’s still better than the stigma of “being on benefits”.

Yet a huge number doing just this still have to have government support. Because the capitalist system is broken in its current form.

Whether you earn your money from blood sweat and tears, or receive it due to often inbuilt systemic disadvantage from the state, it goes back into the economy.

Those with the least pay the most and cannot build up their assets, those with assets just see them grow.

Capitalism as we know it is the worlds shittest pyramid scheme and it’s dependent on the least well off continually pouring every penny back into the system.

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 15:30

Ok then no children we can't afford, who does the low skill/pay jobs of the future? Who provides care as we get older? What about those who are carers but also provide second care for older people when they are in ft work?

OP posts:
MxGrinch · 20/11/2022 15:29

What I don’t get is there are plenty of European countries with much more generous welfare and social housing provisions than the UK and they have nothing like the social stigma that the UK has about welfare payments.

i have a relative living in France and she can easily afford to be a SAHM due to the generous family allowances. Similar in Austria I think. Also I read about every young person being allocated social housing in I think Holland or Denmark. Germany has much higher pay rates than the UK as well.

Its disgusting classism propaganda for the hard of thinking.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 15:27

Hobbi · 20/11/2022 15:24

Duh! The workhouse will have separate sex dormitories. That will cut down the effects of the peasant's well-documented feral lust. If that doesn't work, sterilisation is the only answer.

Eighteen hours on the treadmill and they'll be too tired for anything.

PeloFondo · 20/11/2022 15:25

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 15:21

Could @PeloFondo enlighten us as to this 'bulletproof contraception'? because I was under the impression the only contraception that's 100% is abstinence.

Right so everyone should be able to have a child, even if they can't afford one? Confused
That's what's bemusing me
If I decide to have a baby, who pays for the child? Not me, because I have no spare money

My contraception was the pill and a condom which both failed so I HAD to terminate. It was either that or continue with the pregnancy and give the baby up for adoption. I can't get my tubes tied on the NHS and can't afford private so i now have a coil and use condoms

Not about benefits or giving children back you already have

I guess my point is do people really think "we have a fiver left at the end of the month, we can't increase our earnings but we will have a child anyway?" Because surely people take this into consideration when they choose to only have 1, or 2 children. So it's a consideration when you choose to have a child in the first place?

ToWhitToWhoo · 20/11/2022 15:25

Appropriate work found and ring fenced from those with disabilities to enable them to engage in society and earn a living. The wages for this should be linked to a person ability to work, with even says 2-3hour a week providing a minimum income equivalent to current benefits. This would likely to be more costly than the current system but I believe it is worth while.

Not all disabled people can work even to a limited extent, and often the problem isn't the hours involved, but the physical and mental demands of most jobs. But yes, in the past there were sheltered workshops that provided these sorts of opportunities for many disabled people who could not have been employed in the open market. Most of these were cut under 'austerity'. It would be a good thing to have more such programmes again.

No ability to claim out of work benefits it should be funded through an insurance scheme to which you pay into from day one of working

What about those who were not employed from the beginning?

Make work scheme mandatory for those without paid employment (litter picking, street cleaning, factory work etc) to provide an income limited to the current level of benefits.

Apart from all other considerations, what do you think this will do to the wages of existing street cleaners, factory workers, etc.? If a job needs to be done, employ people to do it and pay them an appropriate wage. Don't treat it as a sort of 'community service' punishment for people who commit the 'crime' of being unemployed.

And many benefit claimants are not unemployed, but are already doing such jobs, and having low pay topped up.

People need to live within their means so if you can afford no children don't have them, can only afford one (us) have one etc

OK, but this is already happening to a large extent: families are far smaller now than in the past. And when people cannot afford to care properly for the number of children that they have, often they could afford them until an unexpected crisis occurred. In the last 15 years, there have been at least three unexpected crises of a sort that had not occurred for many years beforehand so could not have been readily predicted: the 2008 banking crisis, Covid, and the current cost-of-living crisis.