Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There's too much animosity towards benefit recipients.

363 replies

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 11:36

Any and every flavour of benefit recipient, disabled, pensioner, out of work, low paid, single parent etc etc.
There's a mean and nasty cohort on mumsnet who are vitriolic in their hatred for them all.
What do people want instead of giving people a basic level of existence?
What do they think will happen without benefits?

OP posts:
Asher33 · 20/11/2022 18:45

actualnamechange · 20/11/2022 18:43

I'm in Scotland and have a 10 year ADP award of enhanced for both elements. Common sense seems to have been applied and it states that my disabilities are not likely to change in the short term so a 10 year review is appropriate.

The DWP could learn a lot from how Scotland is proceeding with their new system.

10 years is also the longest you get under PIP

actualnamechange · 20/11/2022 18:43

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/11/2022 18:36

This is the thing though - people with conditions that will never change or improve and need extra support are treated to regular reviews for PIP regardless, which is stressful for the claimant and generates costly bureaucracy.

As I recall, under the old DLA system there could be lifetime awards that recognised that bar some cheap and effective scientific breakthrough they would always need that extra support.

As reported, by service users, the PIP system is hardly fit for purpose. It fails to provide the support it promised and ties up assessors, claimants and tribunals in processes that ultimately cost more money on top of back payments etc.

Of all the benefits to “bash” ( not that I think any should be) PIP is absolutely the wrong target. IMHO.

I'm in Scotland and have a 10 year ADP award of enhanced for both elements. Common sense seems to have been applied and it states that my disabilities are not likely to change in the short term so a 10 year review is appropriate.

The DWP could learn a lot from how Scotland is proceeding with their new system.

TimBoothseyes · 20/11/2022 18:39

Especially with artificial limbs, new eye implants…you could be sitting at home unaware of something that could help and your GP being too overworked to flag you up now that some treatment is possible.

It's pretty obvious if some has an artificial limb, what could a consultant possibly say that would help?

bjjgirl · 20/11/2022 18:39

I think it also is effected by the people who pay so much into a system they can not access and then assume the reason for this is it is being used up by those on benefits.

For example if you go to any a and e a large portion of people will be those there due to substance misuse. This in itself is a complex area but easily interpreted as self inflicted.

A small proportion of society uses up a large proportion of public resources, the police, fire, ambulance etc. the majority of people who live chaotic / dysfunctional lives are on benefits but there is a reason they are this way and it is usually due to the society that benefits from them being that way. Again a complex issue but it's just easier to point the finger and blame

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/11/2022 18:36

This is the thing though - people with conditions that will never change or improve and need extra support are treated to regular reviews for PIP regardless, which is stressful for the claimant and generates costly bureaucracy.

As I recall, under the old DLA system there could be lifetime awards that recognised that bar some cheap and effective scientific breakthrough they would always need that extra support.

As reported, by service users, the PIP system is hardly fit for purpose. It fails to provide the support it promised and ties up assessors, claimants and tribunals in processes that ultimately cost more money on top of back payments etc.

Of all the benefits to “bash” ( not that I think any should be) PIP is absolutely the wrong target. IMHO.

Ted27 · 20/11/2022 18:34

@Onnabugeisha

I think you are conflating disability with ill health. My 18 year old is fit as a fiddle. Hasnt been near a doctor in years. He gets PIP.

actualnamechange · 20/11/2022 18:30

Often you are refused PIP if you only have a GP treating you.

A lot of disabled people don't even have that.

Asher33 · 20/11/2022 18:29

Given the current backlogs, it's going to be impractical for every person disability benefits to be under a consultant.

Cuppasoupmonster · 20/11/2022 18:28

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 16:53

Not if the wage increase is where it's needed - at the lower end. Wages do not need to rise across the board - there are plenty of people who have more than enough already and won't suffer if their wages stagnate.

Ok let’s say that happens, the government can only legislate to change the minimum wage. So only the lower earners. They can’t control what private companies choose to pay their staff as long as it isn’t below that. How is it enforceable?

Whit3Pumpkin84 · 20/11/2022 18:28

I’d rather consultants were left to treat patients not spend hours assessing PIP that others can do for them.

XenoBitch · 20/11/2022 18:28

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 18:21

You would have had one at some point. At least a paediatrician as a child. Then see one now and then…new advances are made all the time…why not have a consultant that checks on you every few years? Especially with artificial limbs, new eye implants…you could be sitting at home unaware of something that could help and your GP being too overworked to flag you up now that some treatment is possible.

I know a lady in her 60s that has Albinism. She is registered blind as a result. It is a genetic disorder, and there is no treatment or reason for her to have a consultant. She just plods on through life as she knows no different.
She is still absolutely entiled to PIP.

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 18:27

Which would you rather have
1 consultant assigned to you or
1 private contractor assessor + 1 DWP decision maker?

The first option is actually cheaper to the taxpayer than the second…..of course lots of DWP staff will lose their jobs but we need doctors more than we need paper pushing decision makers and idiot assessors who get bonuses for every claimant they give zero points to.

Onlyforcake · 20/11/2022 18:26

Daily Fail fans. Liars. Wind up merchants. Arseholes. Unfortunately they keep remembering to suck in oxygen between their random hate posts. You've got to remember these maggots are probably faking functioning normality and friendliness out there in real life, they probably park on double yellows though Wink

Asher33 · 20/11/2022 18:25

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 18:21

You would have had one at some point. At least a paediatrician as a child. Then see one now and then…new advances are made all the time…why not have a consultant that checks on you every few years? Especially with artificial limbs, new eye implants…you could be sitting at home unaware of something that could help and your GP being too overworked to flag you up now that some treatment is possible.

Oh how I wish this was true! Diagnosed with Autism and just left to it.

Some of us have conditions that will never change. Why would we need to see a consultant?

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 18:21

XenoBitch · 20/11/2022 18:12

Every disabled person who needs benefits should have a consultant, too many are tossed on the rubbish heap and left with no medical support

Not every one with a disability needs a consultant.

If you have been partially sighted from birth, for example, why would you have a consultant? Why would you have a consultant if you are missing limbs?

You would have had one at some point. At least a paediatrician as a child. Then see one now and then…new advances are made all the time…why not have a consultant that checks on you every few years? Especially with artificial limbs, new eye implants…you could be sitting at home unaware of something that could help and your GP being too overworked to flag you up now that some treatment is possible.

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 18:19

Asher33 · 20/11/2022 18:16

Not all of us need consultants. I was discharged from audiology because nothing can be done. What would be the point of being under them? Yes, my hearing impairments are disabling. But there's no treatment.

But they could have signed off on a disability for that says no treatment, no recovery for you before discharging you….and then you would get PIP or whatever related to that disability automatically.

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 18:17

Whit3Pumpkin84 · 20/11/2022 18:11

Um why do all disabled people need a consultant? My Dd doesn’t need to see a consultant for one of her conditions. It can’t be treated.

Some people are on a 2 year waiting list to see consultants. Do they not get PIP either?

That’s just it, we don’t have enough consultants in the NHS. Meanwhile hundreds of millions are being wasted by DWP on something that any consultant should be able to sign off on. There wouldn’t be a conflict of interest, just like of a doctor starts selling opiate prescriptions, they’d get barred for life and put in prison. Do the same if a doctor signs disability forms for money.

Often you are refused PIP if you only have a GP treating you. Especially if it is a mental health disorder. And honestly, even if a consultant only sees you once to sign your form after a GP referral that’s ok too. I just don’t think the government would give GPS the power for this as they complain enough about GPS “abusing” sick notes for short term sickness.

Asher33 · 20/11/2022 18:16

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 18:03

Every disabled person who needs benefits should have a consultant, too many are tossed on the rubbish heap and left with no medical support.

The pressure on the NHS would be less because the hundreds of millions DWP is giving away to private contractors would go to the NHS to hire more consultants who would only need to fill out a simple form. As it is the NHS is having to write LONG reports and letters to DWP to support every PIP claim, and then again for ever ESA WCA. It would be less work, plus funds for more doctors.

Not all of us need consultants. I was discharged from audiology because nothing can be done. What would be the point of being under them? Yes, my hearing impairments are disabling. But there's no treatment.

XenoBitch · 20/11/2022 18:12

Every disabled person who needs benefits should have a consultant, too many are tossed on the rubbish heap and left with no medical support

Not every one with a disability needs a consultant.

If you have been partially sighted from birth, for example, why would you have a consultant? Why would you have a consultant if you are missing limbs?

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 18:12

Babyroobs · 20/11/2022 17:57

Agree even Gp's don't have time to write supporting letters for people trying to claim PIP so I very much doubt hospital consultants would get involved. ESA highest rates is pretty automatic for people undergoing certain types of treatment like Chemotherapy or Radiotherapy.

My consultants all wrote full reports to DWP for my PIP. Spine surgery consultant, neurologist, neuro-rehabilitation specialist, and a brain injury specialist psychologist.

It would have been much easier if any one of them could have coordinated with the others (they do anyway) to fill out a single form and sign it for disability benefits.

Instead there’s this huge monster of a labyrinth that DWP has set up that costs far too much, takes to long and comes to the wrong decision far too often.

Whit3Pumpkin84 · 20/11/2022 18:11

Um why do all disabled people need a consultant? My Dd doesn’t need to see a consultant for one of her conditions. It can’t be treated.

Some people are on a 2 year waiting list to see consultants. Do they not get PIP either?

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 18:10

I don't know if it should be nhs or dwp making the decision. I'd worry the conflict of interests would sway them in their decision.
we could have an independent body, not some contracted in private sector who make impartial decisions without targets or performance incentives.

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 18:03

actualnamechange · 20/11/2022 17:52

I think the whole disability benefit determination should be given to the NHS consultants. If they sign off, you get PIP, ESA and all that automatically. The consultant can set a review date if recovery or worsening is likely, or true lifetime awards if recovery is impossible.

And for disabled people who don't see a consultant?

I think the pressure on the NHS is vast enough just now without adding more.

Something disabled people could benefit from is some method of acknowledgement that doesn't involve a PIP claim.

Every disabled person who needs benefits should have a consultant, too many are tossed on the rubbish heap and left with no medical support.

The pressure on the NHS would be less because the hundreds of millions DWP is giving away to private contractors would go to the NHS to hire more consultants who would only need to fill out a simple form. As it is the NHS is having to write LONG reports and letters to DWP to support every PIP claim, and then again for ever ESA WCA. It would be less work, plus funds for more doctors.

Babyroobs · 20/11/2022 17:57

actualnamechange · 20/11/2022 17:52

I think the whole disability benefit determination should be given to the NHS consultants. If they sign off, you get PIP, ESA and all that automatically. The consultant can set a review date if recovery or worsening is likely, or true lifetime awards if recovery is impossible.

And for disabled people who don't see a consultant?

I think the pressure on the NHS is vast enough just now without adding more.

Something disabled people could benefit from is some method of acknowledgement that doesn't involve a PIP claim.

Agree even Gp's don't have time to write supporting letters for people trying to claim PIP so I very much doubt hospital consultants would get involved. ESA highest rates is pretty automatic for people undergoing certain types of treatment like Chemotherapy or Radiotherapy.

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 17:56

I agree @actualnamechange

Fwiw I'm chuffed off with jobs etc asking if you're "registered disabled". That's what I was asked about to get accommodations and adjustments.

Other than PIP, there is no register of disabled people.