Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There's too much animosity towards benefit recipients.

363 replies

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 11:36

Any and every flavour of benefit recipient, disabled, pensioner, out of work, low paid, single parent etc etc.
There's a mean and nasty cohort on mumsnet who are vitriolic in their hatred for them all.
What do people want instead of giving people a basic level of existence?
What do they think will happen without benefits?

OP posts:
medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 19:43

Xpost with @ChristmasisRuined

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 19:42

@CulturePigeon so disabled people who are so disabled they cannot work should live a miserable life?

ChristmasisRuined · 20/11/2022 19:42

ThisTimeNext · 20/11/2022 19:41

@ChristmasisRuined - that's not what she said. (Even you'd like it to have been)

Yes, yes it is. Try reading the post again.

ChristmasisRuined · 20/11/2022 19:41

ThisTimeNext · 20/11/2022 19:39

@CulturePigeon - you expressed that very well. I agree.

You agree that people with disabilities so severe that they're unable to work, don't deserve ANY luxuries or any kind of nice lifestyle? Simply because they do not work? Wow. Tory beliefs personified in one simple statement

ThisTimeNext · 20/11/2022 19:41

@ChristmasisRuined - that's not what she said. (Even you'd like it to have been)

ThisTimeNext · 20/11/2022 19:39

@CulturePigeon - you expressed that very well. I agree.

ChristmasisRuined · 20/11/2022 19:39

CulturePigeon · 20/11/2022 19:35

OP I deliberately haven't read any responses on here because I suspect they'll send my blood pressure sky high!

To answer your question: I believe in welfare provision - to protect people who've fallen on hard times through bad luck, ill health etc etc. I want people to have a home, food, warmth (and healthcare of course). I want to make that absolutely clear. Where I part company from some of the more righteous MNetters is that I don't think benefits payments could or should provide a lifestyle that's equal to that of people in full-time work. To be clear: clothes, but not designer labels. Food, but not luxury items; and not the very latest in phones/tablets/devices for example. And certainly not beauty treatments - they're a luxury that I (who have never claimed but always worked ) have never been able to afford/justify. So it's right that benefits should be carefully assessed and yes, this might mean it's not always dead easy to get them.

I don't think reasonable people (and it's pointless to consider crazies here) begrudge valid claimants I certainly don't. But we all know of examples of fraud or people who try it on and it's galling when their lifestyle is more affluent than people who are working. I get really tired of the argument often trotted out on MN (and I bet it's already appeared above...) that while some people/businesses evade tax we can't criticise benefit fraudsters. Oh yes, we can. Two wrongs never made a right - and these things shouldn't be conflated. Once you start going down that road, you lose all logic and respect. Some crook somewhere has stolen £5 million, so it's OK for me to shoplift. Er, no it's not.

Fraudulent claimants absorb money which could go to deserving people and also, quite reasonably, alienate hard-working people whose taxes are paying those benefits. So it's not a victimless crime.

Excuse you?! So you don't feel that people with disabilities through NO fault of their own, should have any kind of decent lifestyle?!?!?!

Clearly a red hot Tory

ChristmasisRuined · 20/11/2022 19:37

Ponesta · 20/11/2022 19:29

I don't think anyone grudges benefits to people who genuinely need them. Clearly there are people on here who do and it's distressing to see the anxiety discussions like this cause. But it's disingenuous to say that everyone claiming benefits is in the same position. There are people claiming benefits who don't need to. That's the issue, and if that can be resolved then the pot for those who need them will be bigger. As it should be, those genuinely in need deserve more.

Absolutely and the blame lies with them. Not just for claiming fraudulently but also for tainting society's views of disabled people and those of us who claim benefits.

Disabled benefits now being part of Universal Credit hasn't helped. Now we're all lumped together as one 'entity' so it's just "I'm on Universal Credit" which 99.9% of people presume this means you're simply unemployed. So we have to immediately follow this with "But the disabled element rather than the unemployed element" Whereas before it was just "I receive Incapacity Benefit (which then became ESA)" which is pretty self explanatory.

CulturePigeon · 20/11/2022 19:35

OP I deliberately haven't read any responses on here because I suspect they'll send my blood pressure sky high!

To answer your question: I believe in welfare provision - to protect people who've fallen on hard times through bad luck, ill health etc etc. I want people to have a home, food, warmth (and healthcare of course). I want to make that absolutely clear. Where I part company from some of the more righteous MNetters is that I don't think benefits payments could or should provide a lifestyle that's equal to that of people in full-time work. To be clear: clothes, but not designer labels. Food, but not luxury items; and not the very latest in phones/tablets/devices for example. And certainly not beauty treatments - they're a luxury that I (who have never claimed but always worked ) have never been able to afford/justify. So it's right that benefits should be carefully assessed and yes, this might mean it's not always dead easy to get them.

I don't think reasonable people (and it's pointless to consider crazies here) begrudge valid claimants I certainly don't. But we all know of examples of fraud or people who try it on and it's galling when their lifestyle is more affluent than people who are working. I get really tired of the argument often trotted out on MN (and I bet it's already appeared above...) that while some people/businesses evade tax we can't criticise benefit fraudsters. Oh yes, we can. Two wrongs never made a right - and these things shouldn't be conflated. Once you start going down that road, you lose all logic and respect. Some crook somewhere has stolen £5 million, so it's OK for me to shoplift. Er, no it's not.

Fraudulent claimants absorb money which could go to deserving people and also, quite reasonably, alienate hard-working people whose taxes are paying those benefits. So it's not a victimless crime.

ChristmasisRuined · 20/11/2022 19:30

@bloodyplanes Disabled people are exempt from road tax. Yes insurance is included but many other leases have this as well. Such as Peugeot's Just Add Fuel amongst others.

Ponesta · 20/11/2022 19:29

I don't think anyone grudges benefits to people who genuinely need them. Clearly there are people on here who do and it's distressing to see the anxiety discussions like this cause. But it's disingenuous to say that everyone claiming benefits is in the same position. There are people claiming benefits who don't need to. That's the issue, and if that can be resolved then the pot for those who need them will be bigger. As it should be, those genuinely in need deserve more.

Asher33 · 20/11/2022 19:27

bloodyplanes · 20/11/2022 19:25

Its not really the same as any other lease though is it? You don't have to pay road tax or insurance with mot ability. Not that i begrudge someone who genuinely needs to use the scheme!

You don't pay road tax if you have your own car and receive higher mobility DLA or enhanced mobility PIP. You can get half price road tax with standard mobility PIP.

bloodyplanes · 20/11/2022 19:25

ChristmasisRuined · 20/11/2022 19:22

*Correction, £258 every 4 weeks is currently what it costs to have a Motability car after the upfront payment. That's £3,354 a year and the leases are for 3 years, so that's £10,062+£3/4,000 paid by the claimant to drive that 'very expensive Audi'

Whilst yes, the money comes from the DWP, it's no different than using your PIP to go and sign up to a regular lease elsewhere. It is honestly about time this bitterness & jealousy of Motability users, stopped as it's completely unfounded

Its not really the same as any other lease though is it? You don't have to pay road tax or insurance with mot ability. Not that i begrudge someone who genuinely needs to use the scheme!

ChristmasisRuined · 20/11/2022 19:22

*Correction, £258 every 4 weeks is currently what it costs to have a Motability car after the upfront payment. That's £3,354 a year and the leases are for 3 years, so that's £10,062+£3/4,000 paid by the claimant to drive that 'very expensive Audi'

Whilst yes, the money comes from the DWP, it's no different than using your PIP to go and sign up to a regular lease elsewhere. It is honestly about time this bitterness & jealousy of Motability users, stopped as it's completely unfounded

Lanneederniere · 20/11/2022 19:18

In my previous job, I legally defended individuals accused of benefit fraud, and obviously had access to prosecution documentation.

I do not recognise the version of events presented by @DWPComplianceOfficer .

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 20/11/2022 19:16

The benefits system is flawed and needs a massive overhaul.

bloodyplanes · 20/11/2022 19:13

@DWPComplianceOfficer im not bashing genuine claimants but people who claim money they are not entitled to to get out of having to earn a living and if you work for the DWP you will know that there are plenty of those! If you class a phone call telling someone they have been reported for benefit fraud, asking them a few questions to which they are hardly going to answer truthfully if they are committing fraud as " following up a report" then yes you do!

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 19:13

I am only ever going to get worse in terms of my physical disabilities. My autism and adhd will never go away.

I am due review in February and I'm terrified they'll take my pip away which means I won't get my blue badge which means I'll be fucked.

ChristmasisRuined · 20/11/2022 19:12

anyhopehere · 20/11/2022 18:47

Unfortunately I have a friend who is 'unable' to work and gets disability benefits.
However said friend also will stop taking their meds in the 3 weeks lead up to their reassessments meaning by the time they get to them they are much much worse then they are when all is controlled on said meds.
This friend worked in an office job however said they are unable to sit/stand to do this anymore however can go for days out to London etc, do gardening, baking, crafting.
I do care for this friend but she clearly cheats the system. Is she better off for it... no she gets the same as a person on minimum wage but there is no reason she cannot sit at a desk to work as she was doing before, especially with WFH. She also gets a mobility car (not that it is adapted in anyway) which happens to be a very expensive Audi with lots of optional extras such as heated seats, parking cameras, full leather interior etc.

So yes there are those who get away with cheating the system and it is frustrating for those who are raring the same/similar amounts but I don't know how this can be improved

Excuse me, how exactly do you know that she is unable to sit at a desk???? Many severe disabilities are invisible - mine included! I am in agony constantly and some days I can go out for the day. The next day however, I can’t even stand for more than a moment.
I too have a 'very expensive Audi' on Motability. What you fail to realise, is that these higher end cars still cost the same as any other lease! The Audis on Motability (especially automatics) cost £3-4,000 upfront and like all Motability cars, you pay £275 every 4 weeks so they are NOT free!!!!!!!

You sound bitter, judgmental & jealous. You are definitely no friend.....

DWPComplianceOfficer · 20/11/2022 19:07

bloodyplanes · 20/11/2022 14:12

@Asher33 i have! Nothing has been done because DWP don't have the capacity to follow up every single report! One family i have worked with ( mother and two teenage dc) are raking in £1500 a month in PIP alone, then add to that universal credit, child benefit, disability premiums etc! Its astonishing!

Name change obviously.

As a person who works for DWP in counter fraud... @bloodyplanes you are wrong.

DWP follow up all reports of benefit fraud, unfortunately a lot of our time is taken up by malicious reporting by petty neighbours, relatives, and ex partners.

Stop bashing claimants many of whom are on the bones of their arses and trying their best to survive, let alone have the energy or motivation to thrive.

Choconut · 20/11/2022 18:55

BIL is on disability he has a condition that means he is only ever going to get worse, is almost bed bound and will eventually die from it. I don't know if it's still the case now but he used to still have to be assessed to make sure he qualified for benefits every so often. It was absolutely ridiculous.

ChristmasisRuined · 20/11/2022 18:50

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 11:36

Any and every flavour of benefit recipient, disabled, pensioner, out of work, low paid, single parent etc etc.
There's a mean and nasty cohort on mumsnet who are vitriolic in their hatred for them all.
What do people want instead of giving people a basic level of existence?
What do they think will happen without benefits?

THIS! ⬆️ As a disabled, widowed parent who is forced to rely on benefits after previously having a career and a (fully working) family previous to my DH's death, I have noticed it immensely. The middle classes will coyly deny it and try gaslight you into believing you're imagining it and therefore it's you that's in the wrong, but you're 100% correct OP and it genuinely hurts & saddens me often

anyhopehere · 20/11/2022 18:47

Unfortunately I have a friend who is 'unable' to work and gets disability benefits.
However said friend also will stop taking their meds in the 3 weeks lead up to their reassessments meaning by the time they get to them they are much much worse then they are when all is controlled on said meds.
This friend worked in an office job however said they are unable to sit/stand to do this anymore however can go for days out to London etc, do gardening, baking, crafting.
I do care for this friend but she clearly cheats the system. Is she better off for it... no she gets the same as a person on minimum wage but there is no reason she cannot sit at a desk to work as she was doing before, especially with WFH. She also gets a mobility car (not that it is adapted in anyway) which happens to be a very expensive Audi with lots of optional extras such as heated seats, parking cameras, full leather interior etc.

So yes there are those who get away with cheating the system and it is frustrating for those who are raring the same/similar amounts but I don't know how this can be improved

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/11/2022 18:47

@actualnamechange

That sounds eminently sensible and reasonable, and I’m relieved for you.

Yes it does sound as though the DWP could learn from this.

actualnamechange · 20/11/2022 18:46

10 years is also the longest you get under PIP

It's rare to get that though, comparatively.

I didn't have a 10 year PIP award.