Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There's too much animosity towards benefit recipients.

363 replies

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 11:36

Any and every flavour of benefit recipient, disabled, pensioner, out of work, low paid, single parent etc etc.
There's a mean and nasty cohort on mumsnet who are vitriolic in their hatred for them all.
What do people want instead of giving people a basic level of existence?
What do they think will happen without benefits?

OP posts:
SavingKitten · 20/11/2022 12:27

Georgeskitchen · 20/11/2022 12:23

Setting apart those with disabilities or disabled children who are unable to work, and don't forget many disabled people can and do work, OAPs, who many on MN seem to despise, despite the fact that most have worked for 40/50years without things that would have seemed luxuries back then, but people take for granted nowadays, not working at all and claiming handouts seems to be a lifestyle choice for many, along with producing hordes of children and complaining to the papers because the council refuses to provide a 6 bedroom council house.
Pretty sure many of these people would quickly find employment if they were told the British taxpayer would no longe feed and clothe them. They could try doing what many parents did (and still do)
Dad goes out to work through the day. Mum goes out to work evenings when dad come home.
My parents did it and I did it too
Back in the days before wage top ups and free childcare.
That is reason people are pissed off with benefits claimants. There is a big difference between can't work and won't work!!
Pass me my arse now please 🥵

Back in the days before wage top ups and free childcare.

Were can I find this free childcare please? Also what happens when dad has buggered off and mum already works full time, but can’t also work evenings because she has children and thought when she was planning them that the other human creating them would do and pay his fair share?

Also do you no the majority of people on benefits already work?

Georgeskitchen · 20/11/2022 12:23

Setting apart those with disabilities or disabled children who are unable to work, and don't forget many disabled people can and do work, OAPs, who many on MN seem to despise, despite the fact that most have worked for 40/50years without things that would have seemed luxuries back then, but people take for granted nowadays, not working at all and claiming handouts seems to be a lifestyle choice for many, along with producing hordes of children and complaining to the papers because the council refuses to provide a 6 bedroom council house.
Pretty sure many of these people would quickly find employment if they were told the British taxpayer would no longe feed and clothe them. They could try doing what many parents did (and still do)
Dad goes out to work through the day. Mum goes out to work evenings when dad come home.
My parents did it and I did it too
Back in the days before wage top ups and free childcare.
That is reason people are pissed off with benefits claimants. There is a big difference between can't work and won't work!!
Pass me my arse now please 🥵

Hellopello · 20/11/2022 12:22

Make work scheme mandatory for those without paid employment (litter picking, street cleaning, factory work etc) to provide an income limited to the current level of benefits.

  • bringing back punishment for being poor History about the Poorhouses has surely taught us that this is devastating to communities locking them in a cycle of poverty
lipstickwoman · 20/11/2022 12:22

I agree, however there's the same for anyone who happens to own a property, have a pension or dare to be retired.

TimBoothseyes · 20/11/2022 12:22

It's the irony of posters say stuff like "well I work and have DC's and I don't receive benefits" that makes me chuckle. If you're earning under a certain amount and you have children, then you do receive at least 1benefit.

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 12:20

I think just about everyone agrees about the tiny minority who are gaming the system @Survey99 but have a read of some recent threads. Genuine claimants who need and are entitled to use the system I happily pay tax towards. It's brutal.

OP posts:
Whit3Pumpkin84 · 20/11/2022 12:19

Grumpybutfunny

You do realise many people with disabilities work. You can be awarded PIP and work.

I do think the squeezed middle vitriol is just as unhelpful.

SavingKitten · 20/11/2022 12:18

Grumpybutfunny · 20/11/2022 12:02

It's not hatred it's a pure discussion of how we a) finance the welfare state and b) what extent we want to to provide. I'm very much in favour of health, education, security and defence taking precedent over the welfare state as I believe all but the most disabled can and should work in some capacity to fund not only our current lives but also our retirement.

I would love it if the state pension was limit to rises that reflect the rise in wages only with a mandate that we all pay into a private scheme from day one.

Appropriate work found and ring fenced from those with disabilities to enable them to engage in society and earn a living. The wages for this should be linked to a person ability to work, with even says 2-3hour a week providing a minimum income equivalent to current benefits. This would likely to be more costly than the current system but I believe it is worth while.

An end to the current housing system for benefit claimants make it so housing benefit only pays for HMO style accommodation. Everyone deserve a roof over their heads but they should be funding it.

No ability to claim out of work benefits it should be funded through an insurance scheme to which you pay into from day one of working. Make work scheme mandatory for those without paid employment (litter picking, street cleaning, factory work etc) to provide an income limited to the current level of benefits.

People need to live within their means so if you can afford no children don't have them, can only afford one (us) have one etc

So what do you do with people who work in factories, litter pickers etc in order to make way for unemployed people in your forced labour? Make them redundant and then force them into unpaid labour? Also what about those who work full time but are still eligible for benefits because they are so poorly paid, but also essential like health care workers?

Nospringchix · 20/11/2022 12:18

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 12:06

What happens if you fall Ill @Grumpybutfunny we have insurance through the welfare state but in your scenario what would happen?

Yes, this. An illness or accident can happen to anyone, leading to the need to claim benefits. Some people don't seem to think it could ever happen to them though.

Survey99 · 20/11/2022 12:17

Animosity against the minority who work the system or make their life choices around the tax payer purse is absolutely fine in my book.

Most people are able to differeniate between the two. But there is this phenomenon where discussing those who are an unnecessary burden on that state is seen as slating all those who genuinely receive much needed support. A bit like discussing the faults of a single teacher, dr, nurse, nrp, step parent, MIL etc and they respond like they are one being.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 12:13

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 20/11/2022 12:11

An end to the current housing system for benefit claimants make it so housing benefit only pays for HMO style accommodation. Everyone deserve a roof over their heads but they should be funding it.

Sounds very workhousey.

Some posters would be creaming themselves at the thought of workhouses being opened. They never stop to think that one day they might be the ones needing help.

Peteryougit · 20/11/2022 12:11

Badgirlriri · 20/11/2022 11:46

It’s not surprising when there’s so many people who are working full time, struggling and not entitled to any help.

I’ve said this on here before , but a huge number of people who claim benefits are also working full time.

The jobs just don’t pay enough to live in some places.

My dh was one of them - “good” job but for a Local authority, so wages are crap. I worked nights in a carehome (3 nights, 36 hours) - so crap pay as well but at least I was at home in the day to save on childcare (no sleep almost killed me though).

But we were in London. Rent for a tiny, damp dump was crazy, almost 2k a month. We claimed top up housing benefit like most people we knew, or we wouldn’t have been able to live.

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 20/11/2022 12:11

An end to the current housing system for benefit claimants make it so housing benefit only pays for HMO style accommodation. Everyone deserve a roof over their heads but they should be funding it.

Sounds very workhousey.

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 12:10

There's something going on @AutumnCrow on another thread someone said they'd rather kill themselves than have two kids with disability, in a thread about benefit for kids with disability.
Mind. Blown.

OP posts:
Ted27 · 20/11/2022 12:10

@Grumpybutfunny

do you know anyone with a disability?

2ManyPjs · 20/11/2022 12:07

Make work scheme mandatory for those without paid employment (litter picking, street cleaning, factory work etc)

WTF!? Why stop there - bring back slavery!

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 12:06

What happens if you fall Ill @Grumpybutfunny we have insurance through the welfare state but in your scenario what would happen?

OP posts:
AutumnCrow · 20/11/2022 12:05

The posts (usually in couched language) directed towards disability benefit recipients are particularly awful

Absolutely, @Teresa777. There is a sub-set of posters that appear regularly on MN specifically to deter MNers from claiming PIP. One even pretended to work for the DWP, saying things to posters like, 'you'll never get PIP, there's point you claiming, no you won't qualify ...'

It was utter bollocks and I managed to get MNHQ to agree to delete the thread.

These posters seem to come here either as out-and-out trolls; or as arseholes with a political agenda. The DWP are currently testing the waters around a number potential benefit cuts and changes, and of course political flying monkeys from policy units are going to come to MN to play games around how to best float ideas in the wider media.

Some threads end up as if it's just policy trolls left on them ranting at each other and into the void.

Teresa777 · 20/11/2022 12:04

People need to live within their means so if you can afford no children don't have them, can only afford one (us) have one etc

Blimey.

Grumpybutfunny · 20/11/2022 12:02

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 11:36

Any and every flavour of benefit recipient, disabled, pensioner, out of work, low paid, single parent etc etc.
There's a mean and nasty cohort on mumsnet who are vitriolic in their hatred for them all.
What do people want instead of giving people a basic level of existence?
What do they think will happen without benefits?

It's not hatred it's a pure discussion of how we a) finance the welfare state and b) what extent we want to to provide. I'm very much in favour of health, education, security and defence taking precedent over the welfare state as I believe all but the most disabled can and should work in some capacity to fund not only our current lives but also our retirement.

I would love it if the state pension was limit to rises that reflect the rise in wages only with a mandate that we all pay into a private scheme from day one.

Appropriate work found and ring fenced from those with disabilities to enable them to engage in society and earn a living. The wages for this should be linked to a person ability to work, with even says 2-3hour a week providing a minimum income equivalent to current benefits. This would likely to be more costly than the current system but I believe it is worth while.

An end to the current housing system for benefit claimants make it so housing benefit only pays for HMO style accommodation. Everyone deserve a roof over their heads but they should be funding it.

No ability to claim out of work benefits it should be funded through an insurance scheme to which you pay into from day one of working. Make work scheme mandatory for those without paid employment (litter picking, street cleaning, factory work etc) to provide an income limited to the current level of benefits.

People need to live within their means so if you can afford no children don't have them, can only afford one (us) have one etc

Teresa777 · 20/11/2022 12:02

@Itchintobestitchin Yes, exactly.

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 20/11/2022 12:02

Teresa777 · 20/11/2022 11:47

Yes, often disguised as 'just asking questions' and 'why should I work my fingers to the bone' etc etc.

The posts (usually in couched language) directed towards disability benefit recipients are particularly awful. And the venom spat at pensioners - there's a vile thread going on just now about the squeezed middle, and their sheer ignorance about basic economics and economic history is as brazen as their ageism. And they're all playing straight into the Tory's hands.

Throw in a 'free' motability car to really get them frothing. Why we are entitled to lease one escapes them though.

Interesting how none of the posters going on about a cushy life on benefits ever give up work to experience the 'lifestyle' for themselves.

mrsm43s · 20/11/2022 12:00

The problem is that often, for set periods of time, people on benefits have more disposable income than families where both parents work. The working family actually do have more, but it's more for locked in future benefits rather than money in their pocket today. For example, a couple each earning £30k working full time, paying a £1500 month mortgage, paying out full time childcare for 2 children will have less disposable income than the equivalent,non working family on benefits who have their rent paid in full and no need for childcare. But the working family is buying a house, paying into pension, keeping their skills relevant, furthering their career etc, and will in 10 years time be in a far better position than the non working family. The "family" stage of a working families life will be the hardest, tightest time for them, whereas the "family" stage of a non working families life will likely be the most flush period for them because, rightly, benefits are set up to ensure that children don't go without just because their parents don't or can't work. But it can be hard to work so hard and have nothing left, and see non working families seemingly having so much more. I would have loved to spend more time with my children rather than working, but it was unaffordable for me, as I had a mortgage to pay. I resented families who were at home with their children and had more disposable income than me. Now 20 years down the line, I'm so, so much better off because I kept working, paid off the mortgage, have a fully funded pension etc. I'm pretty comfortable, whilst the families who have remained on benefits post their children growing up are living fairly basic existences.

Itchintobestitchin · 20/11/2022 12:00

Badgirlriri · 20/11/2022 11:46

It’s not surprising when there’s so many people who are working full time, struggling and not entitled to any help.

Perhaps the people who are working full time and struggling should realise it's the fault of the government and the employers, not of the benefit claimants.

The anger is being directed at the wrong people.

Trulyweird1 · 20/11/2022 11:52

Underhisi · 20/11/2022 11:51

"What do they think will happen without benefits?"

They don't care and they think it will never be them.

Absolutely this. And I hope it never happens to people too, but life happens.