Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There's too much animosity towards benefit recipients.

363 replies

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 11:36

Any and every flavour of benefit recipient, disabled, pensioner, out of work, low paid, single parent etc etc.
There's a mean and nasty cohort on mumsnet who are vitriolic in their hatred for them all.
What do people want instead of giving people a basic level of existence?
What do they think will happen without benefits?

OP posts:
AutumnCrow · 20/11/2022 13:08

mamabear715 · 20/11/2022 12:55

@AutumnCrow Do you remember nationalisation the first time?

In 1945-1950? No. My parents and grand-parents do.

Wheretheskyisblue · 20/11/2022 13:01

There is so much vitriol directed at the poorest in society 'playing the system'. Why isn't equal attention paid to the tax avoidance measures of the top 0.5%? Why aren't people fuming that those earning £10m only pay an effective tax rate of 21%? Why aren't people angry that the richest in society avoid paying any inheritance tax?

It is probably becuase the UK media has brainwashed people to blame those less well off than themselves and in doing so redirect their anger away from those who getting the greatest benefits from the system.

Artygirlghost · 20/11/2022 13:00

There is open, self-righteous criticism of people who receive any kind of benefit because it has been encouraged for decades by Tory governments and the right wing press.

People happily gloss over the fact that many people who receive benefits actually work and that the benefit system props up employers who don't want to pay staff a reasonable wage.

I have worked for decades and contributed to the system and I have no issues with the fact that I am now receiving PIP from this year alongside my part-time job income as my long term health condition worsened as I became older.

If not, why exactly do I pay income tax and national insurance contribution every month? I fully expect this to be used to fund a safety net for anyone who needs it.

Most benefits are means-tested and you need to meet specific criteria to receive any kind of support so what exactly is the problem?

Funny how we never talk about the fact that MPs get their food, housing, transport and expenses subsidised by us while they are on a perfectly good wage while a single mum who struggles to make ends meet is demonised...

mamabear715 · 20/11/2022 12:55

@AutumnCrow Do you remember nationalisation the first time?

Pythonese · 20/11/2022 12:54

ThisTimeNext · 20/11/2022 11:44

There is also vitriol for men, cheaters, Other Women, Tory voters, people in their sixties and seventies, heath visitors, landlords, rich people, people who voted for Brexit, MIL's, SIL's, DIL's.

For reasonable and unreasonable reasons!

Totally agree with this.

Shouldershoddy · 20/11/2022 12:52

Badgirlriri · 20/11/2022 11:46

It’s not surprising when there’s so many people who are working full time, struggling and not entitled to any help.

That still doesn't explain the vitriol towards benefit claimers.Have a go at the government not the poor people !Many of the claimant are workers but their greedy bosses underpay them!So basically many benefits are bailing out the employers!

Juniperising · 20/11/2022 12:52

Funny that OP there is also a huge group of people on MN who hate those who earn enough to pay a big amount in tax every month and not claim. They seem fit to insult them for not kissing the feet of people who are claiming it.

As though we should be very grateful, as though we were specially chosen. Top tip we weren't many of us were once on benefits and we sacrifice our life's, choice of having kids and long hours to get where we are to now earn it. Alot of us took years of training and have high university fees also to pay it all back. Goes both ways.

2ManyPjs · 20/11/2022 12:51

But I'm not sure I can blame those who are resentful either.

Agree with this to a slight extent @Topgub BUT there's ignorance and then there's wilful ignorance, and I think too many subscribe to the latter, certainly on MN anyway.

MarshaBradyo · 20/11/2022 12:51

AutumnCrow · 20/11/2022 12:47

Wages need to increase. Housing costs need to decrease.

To enable this we should tax the rich more (and I mean the rich not the middle - the middle need a break tbh) and tax fossil fuel companies, Amazon and the like to the max. And renationalise as much as possible. Starmer dicking about with reforming the upper chamber and identity politics as his priorities makes Mick Lynch look like Clement Attlee.

Well I agree with you on Starmer. Utter headline ludicrous rubbish.

Fossil fuel I reckon is taxed to the max with the double rate and extra WFT and we need them to invest in new energy.

I don’t know the barrier to taxing Amazon etc but interested to hear how it would work in practise.

I would throw in looking at joining the SM too.

AutumnCrow · 20/11/2022 12:49

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 12:41

The system of top ups allows employers to shift the burden of people receiving a living income onto the state. It's not down to the claimants - it's down to a wage culture in which you can work full-time and still be unable to afford the basics.

This is why I favour renationalisation. Privatised employers are taking the piss out of so many workers.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/11/2022 12:47

Topgub · 20/11/2022 12:31

I think it's probably just human nature to resent people who appear to be getting something for nothing. Or those who seem to demand something for nothing.

The minority who play the system and think the state owes them a living don't help.

Theres so much the govt could be doing to help people into work and to improve working conditions and the COL.

They won't though so as things keep getting tighter for everyone except those with the most it's probably only going to get worse

But I'm not sure I can blame those who are resentful either. It's galling that some unemployed people have a bigger disposable income than those who work.

Think this is exactly what I was going to say.

AutumnCrow · 20/11/2022 12:47

MarshaBradyo · 20/11/2022 12:39

Taxes can’t go much higher? Or would you raise them again

Wages I recall a post saying the government don’t gaf about small businesses with the £1 wage and more will go under.

How high would you go and how would you control inflation and protect businesses? Or maybe not do the latter, which is fine but has an impact on employment and revenue.

Wages need to increase. Housing costs need to decrease.

To enable this we should tax the rich more (and I mean the rich not the middle - the middle need a break tbh) and tax fossil fuel companies, Amazon and the like to the max. And renationalise as much as possible. Starmer dicking about with reforming the upper chamber and identity politics as his priorities makes Mick Lynch look like Clement Attlee.

Ted27 · 20/11/2022 12:43

@daffodilandtulip

no we don’t all know someone who ‘takes the piss’.

The few people I know claiming any sort of benefit are in need, those who got PIP had to provide shed loads of evidence.
I sat with my neighbour while she had her phone assesment - it was one of the most demeaning and humiliating things I have ever witnessed. She still had to go to tribunal to get it, assisted by CAB and the Law Centre.

Alacarde · 20/11/2022 12:41

The system of top ups allows employers to shift the burden of people receiving a living income onto the state. It's not down to the claimants - it's down to a wage culture in which you can work full-time and still be unable to afford the basics.

AutumnCrow · 20/11/2022 12:40

I don't think it helps that we talk about 'benefit entitlement'. 'Entitled' now has a double meaning: it can mean eligible, or it can mean grabby.

I think 'benefit eligibility' would be less adversarial.

MarshaBradyo · 20/11/2022 12:39

AutumnCrow · 20/11/2022 12:36

Increase wages, @MarshaBradyo?

Or taxes. Amazingly, the Tory government has gone for the latter.

Taxes can’t go much higher? Or would you raise them again

Wages I recall a post saying the government don’t gaf about small businesses with the £1 wage and more will go under.

How high would you go and how would you control inflation and protect businesses? Or maybe not do the latter, which is fine but has an impact on employment and revenue.

BigScreen · 20/11/2022 12:37

@Grumpybutfunny I work full time. 56k. I'm also a single mum who is disabled (Multiple Sclerosis). I've been very lucky that I didn't relapse until I was in my 40's and therefore had an established career who made some very helpful reasonable adjustments.

Imagine if I first relapsed at 20. I'd have a much lower chance of getting a role in the first place and also not a role I'd have an interest in actually doing.

Oh and I get the higher rate of PIP / free car.

tillytoodles1 · 20/11/2022 12:36

There was a poster on here during lockdown who thought that the government should temporarily ignore the amount of savings she had so she could claim UC. She had about £90k and didn't want to spend it. She didn't like the idea of spending her own money if she could claim benefits, but she wasn't a scrounger like some benefit claimants!

AutumnCrow · 20/11/2022 12:36

Increase wages, @MarshaBradyo?

Or taxes. Amazingly, the Tory government has gone for the latter.

MarshaBradyo · 20/11/2022 12:33

I don’t really know much about benefits system to comment on individuals but this stood out to me on another thread

  1. Reductions in indirect taxes and increased benefits-in-kind, largely in response to the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, drove the proportion of individuals receiving more in benefits than they paid in taxes increased from 47.5% to 54.2% in FYE 2021

Seems high. Of course the pandemic was why which makes sense. But how does it compare to other countries and how would you make it lower if not

Not easy to deal with but I’d not like to see it go higher still

daffodilandtulip · 20/11/2022 12:32

With anything, there's a "bad apple spoils the lot". We all know of a person/family who takes the piss, gets a "free" new build, car, always splashing the cash. In turn it makes you cynical towards the rest, even without meaning to.

Topgub · 20/11/2022 12:31

I think it's probably just human nature to resent people who appear to be getting something for nothing. Or those who seem to demand something for nothing.

The minority who play the system and think the state owes them a living don't help.

Theres so much the govt could be doing to help people into work and to improve working conditions and the COL.

They won't though so as things keep getting tighter for everyone except those with the most it's probably only going to get worse

But I'm not sure I can blame those who are resentful either. It's galling that some unemployed people have a bigger disposable income than those who work.

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 12:31

The benefit system was introduced as a safety net to ensure those unable to work didn’t starve and children always had a roof, food and education.

i think any decent society wants the most vulnerable to be safe, fed and healthy.

the benefits bashing is fuelled by headlines about how much families on benefits can receive. The recent story for example of the family on £7k benefits a month. This was never how the benefit system was intended to operate and it makes tax payers feel taken advantage of. This is likely an outlier - but people start to think that it is reality of the system.

mamabear715 · 20/11/2022 12:29

There's no easy answer, is there? I guess successive Govts have tried to get it right, but just like posties / rail employees / nurses etc at the mo, it's a merry go round, a balancing act..
I'm retired now but my kids are on benefits (ND, on PIP & ESA) & I just think that my DH, my Dad, grandads etc paid enough in over the years.. obviously I'd prefer if they were working, but it is what it is.
We have never been out of the UK, no car etc, so I'm not beating myself up!

Blossomtoes · 20/11/2022 12:28

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 20/11/2022 12:11

An end to the current housing system for benefit claimants make it so housing benefit only pays for HMO style accommodation. Everyone deserve a roof over their heads but they should be funding it.

Sounds very workhousey.

It does. And it’s what some of them want.

Swipe left for the next trending thread