Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There's too much animosity towards benefit recipients.

363 replies

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 11:36

Any and every flavour of benefit recipient, disabled, pensioner, out of work, low paid, single parent etc etc.
There's a mean and nasty cohort on mumsnet who are vitriolic in their hatred for them all.
What do people want instead of giving people a basic level of existence?
What do they think will happen without benefits?

OP posts:
AnElegantChaos · 20/11/2022 13:44

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 13:28

but financially you don’t need them surely?

you are financially able to cover the additional costs imposed by your disability.

the moral question is different - should tax payers cover this cost or you personally.

so if a billionaire had a disability, the tax payer would give him or her additional money help cover the additional costs.

I suppose ir goes to heart of why we have benefits - are they are safety net to stop people falling into poverty - if that is the case there is an argument that the very wealthy should not receive them.

but just a debate point - not something to be honest I necessarily think!

Sorry but this actually comes across as crass ableism. Who are you to decide or even question her disability needs? The idea that disabled people need to prove and justify their disability requirements (in this case to a random MN'er) is gross.

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 13:42

Whit3Pumpkin84 · 20/11/2022 13:39

You can’t means test PIP otherwise you’d get people just over and beyond really struggling with disability and not accessing needs which would cost the state a whole lot more through NHS costs and people not working. Disabilities are sooooo expensive.

My husband and I both work. Our DD’s disabilities cost us £££ and every penny of her PIP. I often lose wages then there is petrol, car costs, food, heating, counselling … All hugely impacted by her disabilities. It’s eye watering.

Sorry I was only talking about the extremely wealth - the lady earning over £150,000, the billionaire.

my point was very badly made and I certainly accept that disabilities impose a lot of additional costs on families.

just debating - not judging or decreeing.

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 13:41

Livpool · 20/11/2022 13:40

Very!

That poster sounds unhinged though

I'm a bit surprised there aren't more like that. There seems to be plenty when it's skating someone claiming.

OP posts:
ItchySnoof · 20/11/2022 13:41

As long as the government can keep saying "Look at all these benefit scroungers not working, spending YOUR money on fags and booze, while you, the poor squeezed middle, can't get any help" and the middle earners keep believing it the attitude towards helping the poorest in the UK will never change.

Livpool · 20/11/2022 13:40

Teresa777 · 20/11/2022 13:35

@Livpool Yup, it's a bit eugenicsy isn't it.

Very!

That poster sounds unhinged though

Whit3Pumpkin84 · 20/11/2022 13:39

You can’t means test PIP otherwise you’d get people just over and beyond really struggling with disability and not accessing needs which would cost the state a whole lot more through NHS costs and people not working. Disabilities are sooooo expensive.

My husband and I both work. Our DD’s disabilities cost us £££ and every penny of her PIP. I often lose wages then there is petrol, car costs, food, heating, counselling … All hugely impacted by her disabilities. It’s eye watering.

Teresa777 · 20/11/2022 13:35

@Livpool Yup, it's a bit eugenicsy isn't it.

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 13:35

mrsm43s · 20/11/2022 12:00

The problem is that often, for set periods of time, people on benefits have more disposable income than families where both parents work. The working family actually do have more, but it's more for locked in future benefits rather than money in their pocket today. For example, a couple each earning £30k working full time, paying a £1500 month mortgage, paying out full time childcare for 2 children will have less disposable income than the equivalent,non working family on benefits who have their rent paid in full and no need for childcare. But the working family is buying a house, paying into pension, keeping their skills relevant, furthering their career etc, and will in 10 years time be in a far better position than the non working family. The "family" stage of a working families life will be the hardest, tightest time for them, whereas the "family" stage of a non working families life will likely be the most flush period for them because, rightly, benefits are set up to ensure that children don't go without just because their parents don't or can't work. But it can be hard to work so hard and have nothing left, and see non working families seemingly having so much more. I would have loved to spend more time with my children rather than working, but it was unaffordable for me, as I had a mortgage to pay. I resented families who were at home with their children and had more disposable income than me. Now 20 years down the line, I'm so, so much better off because I kept working, paid off the mortgage, have a fully funded pension etc. I'm pretty comfortable, whilst the families who have remained on benefits post their children growing up are living fairly basic existences.

Nonworking families on benefits don’t have a higher disposable income. They just are not encouraged to save any of their disposable income because they’re penalised if they do. So while you may have £300 left over a month after bills and save £200 of it, they’ll have £150 left over a month if they are lucky and are likely spend it. You’re seeing that you’re spending £100 a month on extras and they’re spending £150 a month on extras.

They’re also more likely to be struggling with substandard housing and so this £150 a month they spend is often to attempt to improve living conditions that their LL refuses to correct or they fear telling the LL about because they don’t want to be revenge evicted for “complaining.” So it’ll be DIY things.

We all saw the poor 2yo who died from mould in his home. 1 in 10 social housing and 1 in 5 private rented housing currently do not meet the basic minimum living standards to be habitable. I know others struggling with mould and they literally are using all their disposable money replacing clothes, bedding and such due to it being destroyed by the mould. To an outsider looking in it looks like gosh benefits Suzy is always buying new clothes and she gets new bedding four times a year! Wow, how come she’s got more to spend on that than I do?

Nonworking families on benefits also on average have higher energy bills because of the above rate of substandard housing plus housing that is ok but not at all energy efficient. Poor insulation. Windows and doors rotting out of their frames. Ancient gas boilers and dodgy electrics. Among these nonworking families are millions who are caring for disabled family members who have equipment that is expensive to run but necessary to survive. I read an article about a poor mum with a daughter who requires essentially life support at home and her electric bill is £17k/Yr. Yet the government help to the disabled for COL energy crisis is the lowest of all the help they are doing, a mere £150 a year….for this mum that means 3 days of her daughter not dying.

Livpool · 20/11/2022 13:33

Teresa777 · 20/11/2022 12:04

People need to live within their means so if you can afford no children don't have them, can only afford one (us) have one etc

Blimey.

I know!

PP must think only the wealthy should breed. Perhaps they think poverty can be inherited

Talapia · 20/11/2022 13:32

ThisTimeNext · 20/11/2022 11:44

There is also vitriol for men, cheaters, Other Women, Tory voters, people in their sixties and seventies, heath visitors, landlords, rich people, people who voted for Brexit, MIL's, SIL's, DIL's.

For reasonable and unreasonable reasons!

You've said it very well.

There does seem to be some really selfish, mean spirited people on here who just want to stamp on posters and be unkind.

AutumnCrow · 20/11/2022 13:32

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:24

I get PIP. And no other benefits. But that's a benefit. They're a gateway for me to other assistance that I need and can't get any other way.

Yes, PIP is really the only guaranteed way to acquire a Blue Badge in most local authority areas, for example.

You can send in consultants' letters etc - but scoring 8+ points on 'Mobility - Moving Around' guarantees it relatively quickly.

Livpool · 20/11/2022 13:31

Badgirlriri · 20/11/2022 11:46

It’s not surprising when there’s so many people who are working full time, struggling and not entitled to any help.

So what does that have to do with people who do receive benefits?!

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:29

I need a blue badge. I can't get that without claiming pip.

If anyone wants my disabilities for £100 a month they're welcome to them.

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 13:28

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:22

@Stripedbag101 yes. They're disability related.

but financially you don’t need them surely?

you are financially able to cover the additional costs imposed by your disability.

the moral question is different - should tax payers cover this cost or you personally.

so if a billionaire had a disability, the tax payer would give him or her additional money help cover the additional costs.

I suppose ir goes to heart of why we have benefits - are they are safety net to stop people falling into poverty - if that is the case there is an argument that the very wealthy should not receive them.

but just a debate point - not something to be honest I necessarily think!

Danikm151 · 20/11/2022 13:28

I work full time on a £25k salary. I get £850 UC and child benefit of £21.50 a week.
If I didn’t need childcare help I would still get nearly £300 UC.

I pay almost £400 in tax and NI each month.

A lot of people who benefit bash don’t realise they might actually be eligible to claim UC depending on their circumstances.

Just because someone claims benefits doesn’t mean they’re a “dole dosser”. I pay plenty of tax and NI each month.
I think when they called it “working tax credit” that helped take some stigma away but the simplification of UC just makes some people think free money and start on the benefit bashing.

XenoBitch · 20/11/2022 13:27

An end to the current housing system for benefit claimants make it so housing benefit only pays for HMO style accommodation. Everyone deserve a roof over their heads but they should be funding it

So whole families should be shunted into HBO, with potential addicts? What about people that have adaptions for their disabilities? Or a single parent who has shared custody?
Why on earth should someone who currently lives in a 1 bed flat be moved into a HBO? If you are single person on UC with no kids, and housing benefit is removed, they they have a whole £74 a week to live off of. Do you think they would have any sort of life after the rent is taken from that?
Why do you think that would be acceptable?

No ability to claim out of work benefits it should be funded through an insurance scheme to which you pay into from day one of working. Make work scheme mandatory for those without paid employment (litter picking, street cleaning, factory work etc) to provide an income limited to the current level of benefits

Some people never make it into the workplace. What happens to them?
We have had work schemes before. It was basically slavery. Why not give the people litter picking a proper wage?

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:24

I get PIP. And no other benefits. But that's a benefit. They're a gateway for me to other assistance that I need and can't get any other way.

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:22

@Stripedbag101 yes. They're disability related.

ilovesooty · 20/11/2022 13:22

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 13:20

That’s interesting. Given your earn over £150,000 do you believe you need the benefits you receive?

not being goody, just trying to understand. I am sore you can see how someone earning say £30k would find this odd.

Benefits such as PIP aren't means tested so it's not necessarily odd.

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 13:20

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:17

I get benefits. I also work and I'm a top rate tax payer.

That’s interesting. Given your earn over £150,000 do you believe you need the benefits you receive?

not being goody, just trying to understand. I am sore you can see how someone earning say £30k would find this odd.

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 13:20

Badgirlriri · 20/11/2022 11:46

It’s not surprising when there’s so many people who are working full time, struggling and not entitled to any help.

True, but instead of applying critical thinking and realising, hang on, if I’m struggling and I’m above the earnings threshold for help, then everyone getting help is struggling worse than I am. This should create compassion, not jealousy.

Sadly there are a lot of myths about benefits recipients like they have more money than a FT worker and so on.

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:17

I get benefits. I also work and I'm a top rate tax payer.

Iwonder08 · 20/11/2022 13:15

People don't tend to begrudge less fortunate, but lazy and entitled. I see fairly regular posts here where OP asks if she should just quit her job and start relying solely on benefits because she will be better off.
People with disabilities, illnesses, short term difficulties should receive benefits and it should be easier for them to do so. Unless there is a long term health condition benefits shouldnt be a permanent solution

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 13:11

Juniperising · 20/11/2022 12:52

Funny that OP there is also a huge group of people on MN who hate those who earn enough to pay a big amount in tax every month and not claim. They seem fit to insult them for not kissing the feet of people who are claiming it.

As though we should be very grateful, as though we were specially chosen. Top tip we weren't many of us were once on benefits and we sacrifice our life's, choice of having kids and long hours to get where we are to now earn it. Alot of us took years of training and have high university fees also to pay it all back. Goes both ways.

Maybe you're right and I've missed it. I'm far from a high earner, I work for crapita who are one of the real villains imo and earn just enough to not need any benefit but maybe it's easier for me to imagine dropping a rung and being in need. Most people in need have paid their tax as they should but people associate any benefits to the shirker minority, yet we don't associate all wealthy ppeople with the ones evading tax. In fact it's applauded to minimise tax obligations.

OP posts:
Topgub · 20/11/2022 13:09

@Wheretheskyisblue

It is possible to be annoyed at both

Wealth inequality is a far bigger issue than fraudulent benefits claims

There is a huge amount of expectation for what the state should provide in terms of support that isn't actually being provided because the state isn't taking enough tax to pay for it

Are people entitled to be pissed off that some people seem to think the state should fund their lifestyle? When it's their tax paying for it?