Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There's too much animosity towards benefit recipients.

363 replies

Threadkillacilla · 20/11/2022 11:36

Any and every flavour of benefit recipient, disabled, pensioner, out of work, low paid, single parent etc etc.
There's a mean and nasty cohort on mumsnet who are vitriolic in their hatred for them all.
What do people want instead of giving people a basic level of existence?
What do they think will happen without benefits?

OP posts:
medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 14:01

@Stripedbag101 but you're saying I don't need pip. So what else would you suggest?

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 14:00

And how am I supposed to do that without evidence in the form of my pip claim? Or my blue badge but oh yeah I need pip to get that. Or what? My consultants have to write letters every time I want to book to go somewhere and they only have 72 hours to do it or I don't go to the concert?

Trivial example but has literally just happened to me.

And it's fucking humiliating having to prove my disability.

I tried not to books free carer ticket too but their system doesn't let you buy disabled and ordinary tickets at the same time so the person you're going with can be beside you so I had to get a carer ticket when I would've paid for it and I don't need a carer anyway.

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 14:00

Whit3Pumpkin84 · 20/11/2022 13:54

Stripedbag101

But you don’t know what she does or where she lives, what her responsibilities are. She shouldn’t be disadvantaged because of her disability.

I absolutely agree. No one should be disadvantaged because of a disability. We should do as much as is reasonably possible to ensure everyone has the same opportunities. I seem to have wandered onto the wrong side of the argument by asking some questions to the lady who earns over £150k a year. She should of course have all the barriers removed where they can possibly be.

Soproudoflionesses · 20/11/2022 14:00

Survey99 · 20/11/2022 12:17

Animosity against the minority who work the system or make their life choices around the tax payer purse is absolutely fine in my book.

Most people are able to differeniate between the two. But there is this phenomenon where discussing those who are an unnecessary burden on that state is seen as slating all those who genuinely receive much needed support. A bit like discussing the faults of a single teacher, dr, nurse, nrp, step parent, MIL etc and they respond like they are one being.

Should have rtft cos things what l was trying to say.

Soproudoflionesses · 20/11/2022 13:59

Badgirlriri · 20/11/2022 11:46

It’s not surprising when there’s so many people who are working full time, struggling and not entitled to any help.

This is a really good point.

And l work with people who claim benefits and some of them, (not all), do milk the system- they can afford to smoke and have lovely holidays whilst simultaneously claiming free school meals etc but other people l know who work full time can't afford such luxuries.

Of course we need to support people who struggle but some of them need to help themselves too.

Do l hate people on benefits? Of course not!

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:58

I want to book tickets for a concert. I can't access any other part of the venue except the accessible areas. If I book an accessible ticket then ticketmaster expect me to prove, within 72 hours, my level of disability.

Do you want to have to do that every time you want to book to go to a concert?

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 13:57

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 13:49

the moral question is different - should tax payers cover this cost or you personally

Which is precisely why benefits aren't decided on moral grounds but grounds of need.

suppose ir goes to heart of why we have benefits - are they are safety net to stop people falling into poverty - if that is the case there is an argument that the very wealthy should not receive them

Then you're going to have to define, and keep defining, what you mean by 'wealthy.' Something I've asked before when we get the rants about 'wealthy pensioners' not 'needing' money how is wealth and need defined? I don't recall receiving a reply. And of course if you decide that people don't 'need' benefits then you're moving to a subjective not an objective criteria based system.

Sorry I was talking about extreme examples - I honestly wasn’t meaning to take benefits away from the majority people and was only entering into a debate.

the poster earning over £150kk said she didn’t need the extra £100, she needed the additional adjustments the benefits brought. I am absolutely supportive of those adjustments for everyone. I was just debating. This is a very emotive subject and one people really should’ve debate clearly.

I meant no offence

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:56

And you know what? This is exactly why I'm real life I never say I claim any benefits.

Because everyone feels they have the right to stick their nose in and judge and say "you don't need it".

I do. It's a gateway benefit.

Fuck this shit.

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 13:55

tillytoodles1 · 20/11/2022 12:36

There was a poster on here during lockdown who thought that the government should temporarily ignore the amount of savings she had so she could claim UC. She had about £90k and didn't want to spend it. She didn't like the idea of spending her own money if she could claim benefits, but she wasn't a scrounger like some benefit claimants!

There was also one who had over £300k equity in their home and was furious at the thought they’d only get an interest free loan to pay the mortgage interest. They thought that the government should pay their entire mortgage for them…and that despite falling on hard times they should get to keep this huge asset instead of considering selling or equity release.

XenoBitch · 20/11/2022 13:55

YANBU

There seems to be a lot of benefit bashing on MN lately. It makes for a depressing read. I am on benefits, and already feel like a burden. Then you see posters on here saying people on benefits are a drain, should live in poverty, should be forced to "work" full time for £74 a week etc.
A lot of it comes across as foot stamping tbh. "What about ME?" when the CoL payments are being given out. The payments are not rewards for working hard ffs.
If the benefit system was more tightly controlled/ less "generous", do all these people moaning about it genuinely thing that they would be better off as a result? Forcing others to live in misery wont put £s in your pocket.

Whit3Pumpkin84 · 20/11/2022 13:54

Stripedbag101

But you don’t know what she does or where she lives, what her responsibilities are. She shouldn’t be disadvantaged because of her disability.

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 13:53

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:50

@Stripedbag101 it's not about purely whether or not I can afford the costs associated with my disabilities.

First, I can't get a blue badge without claiming pip. I need a blue badge or I would never leave my house.

Second, I am able to use the pip claim to assist in reasonable adjustments to enable me to work to earn my salary.

Third, if I want to book tickets to go places, I can't access accessible tickets without proving my disabilities via some means and the only one I've found that works across the board is my pip claim.

I am clearly wrong, and I accept that.

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:52

If I hadn't got pip I wouldn't have been able to retrain and qualify in my job. I wouldn't have got DSA that gave me the support I needed to do my degree.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 13:52

I would love it if the state pension was limit to rises that reflect the rise in wages only with a mandate that we all pay into a private scheme from day one

I bet you would. And FYI, we are 'all paying into a scheme' it's called NI. What's the safety net if this 'private scheme' goes tits up or people can't afford it?

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 13:51

@Georgeskitchen
Back in the days before wage top ups

Oh, back in the days when real earnings were enough to live modestly on. Not the depressed wages that are at the lowest point in real terms they have been in 20yrs!

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:51

I use my pip claim for example to get an adjustment from work that enables me to go to appointments without using leave.

It also got me a special chair and gets accommodations made when I travel to the office.

TimBoothseyes · 20/11/2022 13:50

No ability to claim out of work benefits it should be funded through an insurance scheme to which you pay into from day one of working. Make work scheme mandatory for those without paid employment (litter picking, street cleaning, factory work etc) to provide an income limited to the current level of benefits

So what happens to those of us who are y'know employed to do those jobs (factory work in my case), if the unemployed are expected to do it in order to obtain their benefits? Go on have a little think and then you, too, will see the absurdity of your "plan"

medicatedgift · 20/11/2022 13:50

@Stripedbag101 it's not about purely whether or not I can afford the costs associated with my disabilities.

First, I can't get a blue badge without claiming pip. I need a blue badge or I would never leave my house.

Second, I am able to use the pip claim to assist in reasonable adjustments to enable me to work to earn my salary.

Third, if I want to book tickets to go places, I can't access accessible tickets without proving my disabilities via some means and the only one I've found that works across the board is my pip claim.

Grantanow · 20/11/2022 13:49

The Tories stir up hatred of benefit recipients. There are far less benefit frauds than tax avoidance frauds and the sums are usually trivial in comparison to the sums lost to the taxpayer's through off shore schemes, tax shelters, nondom status, etc. Of course there's always the occasional individual bad benefit apple but there is a whole tax avoidance industry at work. The Tories don't want us to look too hard at that.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 13:49

the moral question is different - should tax payers cover this cost or you personally

Which is precisely why benefits aren't decided on moral grounds but grounds of need.

suppose ir goes to heart of why we have benefits - are they are safety net to stop people falling into poverty - if that is the case there is an argument that the very wealthy should not receive them

Then you're going to have to define, and keep defining, what you mean by 'wealthy.' Something I've asked before when we get the rants about 'wealthy pensioners' not 'needing' money how is wealth and need defined? I don't recall receiving a reply. And of course if you decide that people don't 'need' benefits then you're moving to a subjective not an objective criteria based system.

Asher33 · 20/11/2022 13:49

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 13:42

Sorry I was only talking about the extremely wealth - the lady earning over £150,000, the billionaire.

my point was very badly made and I certainly accept that disabilities impose a lot of additional costs on families.

just debating - not judging or decreeing.

It's not just the money. If you need a blue badge, you're then going to have to waste GP time for a letter and possibly be assessed before you can get one

Flowersonthewall6 · 20/11/2022 13:48

I have no issues with the benefits system other than the 1% who abuse it but most people who get benefits need this to be in place otherwise I would dread think the situation.

I have always noticed people don’t have an issue with benefits if it’s spend on rent / bills / basic foods. It’s when anyone has anything classed more a luxury like a night away, getting nails done etc then a lot of people start to have issues with this. And everyone has a different definition of what a luxury is. I remember someone being annoyed that someone on benefits got a Camembert in their food shop 😬😂

Onnabugeisha · 20/11/2022 13:46

@Grumpybutfunny
Youre not in favour of any welfare at all based on your list of disgusting “ideas”. I can only conclude you’re one of the smug superior types that has led a charmed life.

I would love it if the state pension was limit to rises that reflect the rise in wages only with a mandate that we all pay into a private scheme from day one.
This would be a race to the bottom. The government is doing the ethical thing and showing societal leadership by raising state pension in line with the triple lock. They need to shame businesses into raising wages in a similar fashion. Also pensioners have no options to increase income unlike able bodied working age people.

Appropriate work found and ring fenced from those with disabilities to enable them to engage in society and earn a living. The wages for this should be linked to a person ability to work, with even says 2-3hour a week providing a minimum income equivalent to current benefits. This would likely to be more costly than the current system but I believe it is worth while.
What should be done is increase disability benefits because the disabled have the highest rates of poverty and deaths due to inability to heat home or feed themselves. Not require they work for the pittance they need to survive.

An end to the current housing system for benefit claimants make it so housing benefit only pays for HMO style accommodation. Everyone deserve a roof over their heads but they should be funding it. I agree with a pp, this is bringing back the workhouses. Before long, they’ll be splitting off the men from the women and children, and then splitting the children off from the women. So that all the men and women can work all day doing your litter picking and such…

No ability to claim out of work benefits it should be funded through an insurance scheme to which you pay into from day one of working. Make work scheme mandatory for those without paid employment (litter picking, street cleaning, factory work etc) to provide an income limited to the current level of benefits. This is batshit. It’s like you don’t know that JSA is based on your National Insurance payments records. NI is a type of insurance. It’s just nationalised so some corporation isn’t making a profit off it.

People need to live within their means so if you can afford no children don't have them, can only afford one (us) have one etc. Yes well, most often people have the children when they can well afford them and it’s after the children are here that disaster strikes and they then need help.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 20/11/2022 13:45

Teresa777 · 20/11/2022 13:35

@Livpool Yup, it's a bit eugenicsy isn't it.

Back to the notion of deserving and undeserving poor that the set up of the welfare state was supposed to eliminate.

Whit3Pumpkin84 · 20/11/2022 13:45

I think the middle are struggling though and unfortunately are being pitched by the wealthy not struggling against the lowest earners.

When the middle and the lowest earners start pulling together I think we’d all give the Tories a real run for their money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread