Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who won't work otherwise they lose benefits

420 replies

Alphavilla · 20/11/2022 09:15

Came across BBC article recently quoting a 20 year old man saying he had cut out Netflix and booze to cut his costs in these difficult times. However apparently he could not work more than his 16 hours otherwise he would lose his benefits. My DH is a manager in large organisation and he finds it difficult to get shifts/jobs covered as the employees claim they can't add more hours to their part time shift because they would lose entitlement to benefits. So there is work to be had, but it seems it is more lucrative not to work. What has gone wrong?

OP posts:
GeorgeorRuth · 20/11/2022 11:44

Pride doesn't pay bills. Hard cash does that. In this day and age, with the technology we have, it should be possible to update circumstances instantly, not wait weeks for it to be done. The system needs to be agile.
When the DC were small, DH couldn't do overtime. Any change in income took min 6 weeks to process, and it was then also calculated for the whole next year.

The other really novel option is that people are paid proper wages that don't require top ups. 😉

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 11:43

It’s fucked but I don’t blame them. I’d do the same
Unfortunately I have to agree, the rich and powerful make the rules to suit the rich and Powerful, they set up these complex systems with loopholes which only they have the ability; the money and connections to exploit thereby making themselves richer.
All we can do is use our initiative to play the system as best we can ☹️

CaptainCreepsBourgeMobile · 20/11/2022 11:42

Not coming back, op?

scaredoff · 20/11/2022 11:42

Beautiful3 · 20/11/2022 10:24

It's the zero hour contract that's messing it up for those on a low income. People need guaranteed hours/income to afford rent and bills. I've always worked full time jobs until I had children. I've been looking for a part time job that's not zero hour based. As I cannot live on 6 hours one week and 12 the next. I need a stable income to leave benefits. I rely on benefits at thr moment. Zero hour contracts really should be abolished.

What a great idea. If only we had a political party to vote for with the will to do that. Oh, that's right, we did . . . but they were "unelectable".

BlueWalnut · 20/11/2022 11:42

Notanotherwindow · 20/11/2022 09:41

It's not about being self reliant or attitude.

Say you are on a 16 hour contract and get universal credit to help with rent etc. Your boss asks you to work an extra shift which takes you to 22 hours. You get paid more that month which triggers your universal credit to be removed.

Then next week you only get your 16 hours. You can't afford to pay rent and your UC has been stopped as the system thinks you now work 22 hours a week and don't need it. Now you have to wait for it to be reviewed which takes 6 weeks, during which you can't pay rent or bills or food.

Unless you can count on those extra shifts every week, they cause more problems than they solve and you are worse off.

This. It’s a major reason for people needing to use food banks for a few weeks. Zero and part time hours contracts combined with the flawed UC system is to blame. Not benefit claimants.

Gloryofthe80s · 20/11/2022 11:41

CrossStichQueen · 20/11/2022 11:36

These people don’t want to work if there is a system they can milk dry. At least their pension contributions will be reduced so it will bite them in the ass in old age 😆

Vile Post!

Who are "these people" ?
Disabled people?
Carers?
Young people leaving care?

looks like Jack Monroe had entered the chat.

EhLov · 20/11/2022 11:41

OP I read the same article.

I believe it was really poorly covered in the article, but the lad was in Supported Accomodation and so would have been on old style Housing Benefit paid from the LA not UC, as SA rent is sky high and falls under the local council to cover.

Of that, he’d only pay a service charge for bills, hence him saying his ‘rent’ was only £25 or something.

Therefore he’s on the old system work-wise where he can’t go over X hours.

He’s fortunate to have such a secure and affordable housing setup, but it’s very hard to incentivise to leave that. I believe he was a care leaver.

If he moved in to private housing, he’d immediately move on to UC instead, and then be able to work more while keeping 63p of every pound of his UC too.

But then of course he’d have to pay private rents and a deposit, and private landlords simply don’t take people who earn less than £30,000 these days, never mind 16 hours of work and a bit of benefits.

It’s a horrible messy situation and the government haven’t got a clue.

TalkSomeSense2 · 20/11/2022 11:40

Minimalme · 20/11/2022 09:29

Your DH large company should offer secure contracts and decent pay op.

Maybe let him know we have solved his problem. And your welcome.

Such a simplistic view. But well done for solving the whole work/cost of living/benefits/wages debate in just twelve words.

Honeyandlemonnn · 20/11/2022 11:39

Whats wrong is your husbands company not offering permanent contracts

scaredoff · 20/11/2022 11:38

monkeysmum21 · 20/11/2022 09:37

To me, the shocking bit is that an adult expect to be praised for cutting out booze and Netflix when he can’t afford it.

I assume this is the article the OP was referring to:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-63629083

Where does it say he expects to be praised?

ReedRite · 20/11/2022 11:38

Gloryofthe80s · 20/11/2022 11:32

These people don’t want to work if there is a system they can milk dry. At least their pension contributions will be reduced so it will bite them in the ass in old age 😆

Yeah, you keep telling yourself that.

CanTheMousePLEASEGoToHell · 20/11/2022 11:37

Alysskea · 20/11/2022 09:26

Yes I agree it’s the system! It’s a complete mess. Wages are too low, hours are unreliable and not enough of them. A lot of people in his position would be taking a huge pay cut if they took on more work because benefits are now so inflexible that even a couple of hours extra would leave them unable to live.

Yes this! I remember when I was a manager in retail and one of the women (who I’m really good friends with now) wouldn’t work more than 16 hours a week. If we asked her to stay a hour or two after her shift she’d say, ‘yeah I’ll stay but remember to not pay me!’ I remember asking her why and she used to say if she does overtime here and there it really fucks up her benefits. She’d get paid more but then it gets taxed and she’d be worse off.

One of my friends works the bear minimum and does two days a week. If she worked more hours, her rent wouldn’t get paid and she’d basically struggle more even though she’s working more. It’s fucked but I don’t blame them. I’d do the same

zingally · 20/11/2022 11:36

Then maybe OPs partner needs to work for an organisation that provides decent contracts and a living wage?

CrossStichQueen · 20/11/2022 11:36

These people don’t want to work if there is a system they can milk dry. At least their pension contributions will be reduced so it will bite them in the ass in old age 😆

Vile Post!

Who are "these people" ?
Disabled people?
Carers?
Young people leaving care?

ReedRite · 20/11/2022 11:35

Nagado · 20/11/2022 11:30

I think this thread needs to go in Classics, so it’s really easy to find the next time someone asks who keeps voting in the Tories. The lack of understanding and empathy from some of you is bloody terrifying.

Some of us have been poor before. Bones of our arses poor. But unless you’ve grown up the same way as this poor little sod, you have no idea how tough it has been for him. He’s grown up in the care system, so no support from a loving mum and/or dad, no watching and learning how to budget or where to make cuts, or how to get through life. And how many kids get through the care system completely unscathed, do you think? Never being able to put down roots? Not knowing if the friends you have this year will still be in your life next year?

So he hasn’t done what a lot of kids would do. He hasn’t got in with the wrong crowd or decided to make his money the easier way. He’s doing his best to stand on his own two feet and do things the right way. He’s in supported accommodation, which would cost him more a month than lots of you are paying in mortgages for your big fancy houses with gardens. And these aren’t luxury properties. He’s not living in a naice area, with naice neighbours ferrying their children to school in their Audi’s each morning. He’s living somewhere that will evict him promptly if the rent isn’t paid. The fact that he’s there in the first place is a good indication that he doesn’t have the skills or the ability to either work full time or cope with independent living. And some of you are wondering why he doesn’t fancy trusting the system not to fuck up his rent payment if he does a few extra hours one week?

Yes, we’ve all had to make cut backs. But if I get rid of my Netflix, I’ve got a DH to keep me company. I’ve got books. I’ve got friends and family. Go and look at your DC. Imagine them all alone in a room, in a building full of vulnerable people. They’ve got no support from family. Would you be happy telling them they can’t have one of the few things that give them any pleasure in life? Or would you be shouting that they couldn’t be expected to stare at their four walls each night without it tipping them over the edge. Why is it ok for this lad, but not your own DC?

👏👏👏

teraculum29 · 20/11/2022 11:35

Notanotherwindow · 20/11/2022 09:41

It's not about being self reliant or attitude.

Say you are on a 16 hour contract and get universal credit to help with rent etc. Your boss asks you to work an extra shift which takes you to 22 hours. You get paid more that month which triggers your universal credit to be removed.

Then next week you only get your 16 hours. You can't afford to pay rent and your UC has been stopped as the system thinks you now work 22 hours a week and don't need it. Now you have to wait for it to be reviewed which takes 6 weeks, during which you can't pay rent or bills or food.

Unless you can count on those extra shifts every week, they cause more problems than they solve and you are worse off.

Thats not true,
UC is not automatically closed on first 0 payment, if I remember correctly its up to 6 months of 0 payment

megletthesecond · 20/11/2022 11:33

I won't change my job (18 hrs) as I won't be entitled to parental leave for the first year of a new job and could be dismissed for the first two years. I'd be insane to risk it.

I won't increase my hours partly because it might trigger a change to UC and all the mess that that brings. I have teen with MH issues so it's more prudent to sit tight until she's at college. The system is indeed a bit crap.

Gloryofthe80s · 20/11/2022 11:32

These people don’t want to work if there is a system they can milk dry. At least their pension contributions will be reduced so it will bite them in the ass in old age 😆

FinallyHere · 20/11/2022 11:32

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 20/11/2022 09:20

The problem is that lots of large organisations contract people on low hours and hope that they'll pick up shifts at the employers need. If you are on a benefit that pays your housing cost then you can afford potentially to give up that benefit if you are contracted and guaranteed 40 hrs work and therefore salary a week. You cannot afford to give it up if there's a possibility you will get 4 or 12 extra hours, because how do you then pay the rent?

This ^

Let's stop blaming people and look at the employers who prefer not to guarantee longer hours and expect employees to carry the risk. It's really not fair to expect people to pick up a few hours at the employers need, if the employer is not prepared to guarantee the hours.

The government likes to boast of high levels of employment without mentioning how many of those are on zero hours contracts who have no guarantee of earnings.

Especially the low paid need a steady income to be able to budget.

Nagado · 20/11/2022 11:30

I think this thread needs to go in Classics, so it’s really easy to find the next time someone asks who keeps voting in the Tories. The lack of understanding and empathy from some of you is bloody terrifying.

Some of us have been poor before. Bones of our arses poor. But unless you’ve grown up the same way as this poor little sod, you have no idea how tough it has been for him. He’s grown up in the care system, so no support from a loving mum and/or dad, no watching and learning how to budget or where to make cuts, or how to get through life. And how many kids get through the care system completely unscathed, do you think? Never being able to put down roots? Not knowing if the friends you have this year will still be in your life next year?

So he hasn’t done what a lot of kids would do. He hasn’t got in with the wrong crowd or decided to make his money the easier way. He’s doing his best to stand on his own two feet and do things the right way. He’s in supported accommodation, which would cost him more a month than lots of you are paying in mortgages for your big fancy houses with gardens. And these aren’t luxury properties. He’s not living in a naice area, with naice neighbours ferrying their children to school in their Audi’s each morning. He’s living somewhere that will evict him promptly if the rent isn’t paid. The fact that he’s there in the first place is a good indication that he doesn’t have the skills or the ability to either work full time or cope with independent living. And some of you are wondering why he doesn’t fancy trusting the system not to fuck up his rent payment if he does a few extra hours one week?

Yes, we’ve all had to make cut backs. But if I get rid of my Netflix, I’ve got a DH to keep me company. I’ve got books. I’ve got friends and family. Go and look at your DC. Imagine them all alone in a room, in a building full of vulnerable people. They’ve got no support from family. Would you be happy telling them they can’t have one of the few things that give them any pleasure in life? Or would you be shouting that they couldn’t be expected to stare at their four walls each night without it tipping them over the edge. Why is it ok for this lad, but not your own DC?

Beezknees · 20/11/2022 11:29

Zero hours contracts have their place but are only good for young people who need the flexibility, teens still living at home or students, who want to reduce or increase their hours around their studies. They should never be allowed for people who need to work to pay their rent and bills.

Peteryougit · 20/11/2022 11:25

Hooverphobe · 20/11/2022 11:16

All I can say to anyone/everyone is to put in a claim. You might be pleasantly surprised.

the entire thing must be “by design” because there must be 100s of 1000s of us in the public sector making substantial claims.

so it’s not just a case of “Tesco getting the tax-payer to pay” - the government itself doesn’t pay (all) their workers a modern liveable wage.

Yep, dh was working for a London LA while we were claiming top up housing benefit.

He doesn’t work in the HB department, but he had work colleagues who did and guess what, most of them were claiming HB too just to be able to afford to live a decent distance from where they worked.

The whole thing is backwards.

Babyroobs · 20/11/2022 11:25

When Universal credit came in a few years ago it looked hopeful that people might be made to look for more work but doesn't really seem to have panned out like that. For example a couple with school aged children where one of them is the main earner, the main worker only has to earn something like £670 a month currently ( and this is the new revised earnings ! ) for the other of the couple to stay home if they wish and be put in the light touch group meaning they don't really have any work commitments. It is absolutely ludicrous that the level is so low and both are not expected to work when they could still be getting hundreds a month in benefits. I accept that it may be difficult for both to work full time and also don't personally think that is a good quality of life for a family with kids but for the other parent to have to not really look for work at all is crazy. It's just like going back to the old tax credits system where a couple only had to work 24 hours between them to get topped up with working tax credits ! Of course on Uc there is still the incentive to work as you get to keep 45p of Uc for each pound you earn but after taking into account travel costs, paying a bit towards childcare etc, many won't feel incentivized to look for work even when there is plenty around.

WickedStepmomNOT · 20/11/2022 11:25

The government says zero hours contracts can work for some people - well not for me. When I was on one, 8 hours 2 days pw, I went into work one day as usual only to be told no hours for you today. No notice given, and Id spent over £5 on a travel card. I asked if they could just give me an hour s work to cover the travelcard but they said no. It actually cost me money to go to work that day - then got stick at the jobcentre for not working my 'agreed hours'!

Beezknees · 20/11/2022 11:24

happyfishcoco · 20/11/2022 11:15

It's a fault of the system!!

It does not make sense at all!

this system encourages people not to work!!!

"The system" does not encourage people not to work. It's low wages and high childcare costs that are the problem. Universal Credit is less than minumum wage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread