Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who won't work otherwise they lose benefits

420 replies

Alphavilla · 20/11/2022 09:15

Came across BBC article recently quoting a 20 year old man saying he had cut out Netflix and booze to cut his costs in these difficult times. However apparently he could not work more than his 16 hours otherwise he would lose his benefits. My DH is a manager in large organisation and he finds it difficult to get shifts/jobs covered as the employees claim they can't add more hours to their part time shift because they would lose entitlement to benefits. So there is work to be had, but it seems it is more lucrative not to work. What has gone wrong?

OP posts:
Shiningsilverargent · 20/11/2022 12:12

It's a no-brainer for most people and the 10% benefit increase (and higher taxes) in the budget will see even more people drop out of work

PMSL. Yes, absolutely. Someone earning £125k is about to give up their job for an extra....£7-20 a week on benefits?

EhLov · 20/11/2022 12:10

France have a very sensible benefits system to avoid the ‘life on benefits’ trap.

You receive in benefits, a proportion of your most recent earnings, for a set time period.

If you have no income, ever, to evidence, you receive a low amount that drops with time.

It stops those between well paid jobs falling off a financial cliff, and avoids those who’ve never worked living well long term on government funds.

Archibaldleach · 20/11/2022 12:08

It's because benefits and part time work or no work are much more lucrative (and you have more free time) than full-time work, high taxes and no benefits. It's a no-brainer for most people and the 10% benefit increase (and higher taxes) in the budget will see even more people drop out of work.

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 12:08

ridiculous govt understanding of people’s relationships and finances in 2020s
Ridiculously rich Rishi from Richmond, the cute little manlet with his cashmere sweaters, richer than the king with his vast wealth and luxury, don't worry he'll sort it out for us

IneedanewTV · 20/11/2022 12:07

In local government many people work minimum hours on a contract (their choice) to get tax credits. Then they work additional hours every week (flexitime) take the time off in lieu. It’s standard. We have the hours for them to work full time but they choose not too so we just employ more people.

liveforsummer · 20/11/2022 12:06

OriginalUsername2 · 20/11/2022 11:59

You can earn £77 a week before benefits are reduced. I’m not sure a lot of people on benefits understand the maths. Above that, 55p is taken from every pound. It’s not “losing benefits”.

However like others have said, a zero hours contract makes a complete mess of your payments and the DWP is a nightmare to deal with.

It's not just that - I work over the 16 hours already but I still can't take on extra. One higher monthly pay automatically reduces my housing benefit. I have to them prove it was a once off. This can mean they want 3 months worth of pay slips going forward and they will pause my housing benefit while they sort it. My rent is £750 and they only pay me £350 as it is but to have that stopped when I earn £950 pm is devastating (trust me I found all this out the hard way). I might also end up with a tax credit overpayment which can affect me for months during the next tax year. Truly not worth the hassle for a few extra hours

Echobelly · 20/11/2022 12:05

The system is wrong, not the people. I've known couples not live together because if they move in, they lose benefits that they can't afford to live without - the system is a mess.

IncompleteSenten · 20/11/2022 12:05

Or companies could pay their staff enough to live on so the government wouldn't have to (very begrudgingly) step in to stop people from starving and freezing.
That'd work too.

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 12:03

The system could be fixed if there was the will I am sure
I agree...and why is there not the will to fix it?
presumably those who could don't want to because they benefit too much from the way things are?

EhLov · 20/11/2022 12:03

It is woeful that it still works like this, yes.

I had a young girl come to me last year and ask how she could move in with her BF, and still retain her financial independence as opposed to a forced joint claim, as they were both on UC.

I had to tell her that, strictly speaking, she can’t.

When I was on ML with my first child, and had to claim benefits to cover my half of the rent as SMP didn’t cover it, the LA literally had no mechanism to just cover my half of the payment.
They needed to know about us as a couple, which was irrelevant in my eyes. His half rent, his money. My half rent, my money.

A brand new benefits system in 2020s that has an intrinsic expectation for a couple to fund each other like it’s the fucking 50s, when many will be late teens, early 20s and only together a few months, just shows a ridiculous govt understanding of people’s relationships and finances in 2020s.

caringcarer · 20/11/2022 12:00

Clearly the benefits system is fucked if people turn down more working hours in order to not lose housing benefit, or only earn a very few pounds more for working extra hours. Stride needs to give benefits system an overhaul to ensure those who work extra hours benefit and those who could work extra hours but choose not to are penalised.

OriginalUsername2 · 20/11/2022 11:59

(I am on benefits)

BloodAndFire · 20/11/2022 11:59

@BlueWalnut
Isn’t it depressing? The system could be fixed if there was the will I am sure. I am glad you’re both ok now.

thank you. We're both with other people now (and neither of us have claimed benefits for years) but I know he's doing well.

I just can't believe that 25 years and however many governments later, the system is still broken in the same way.

OriginalUsername2 · 20/11/2022 11:59

You can earn £77 a week before benefits are reduced. I’m not sure a lot of people on benefits understand the maths. Above that, 55p is taken from every pound. It’s not “losing benefits”.

However like others have said, a zero hours contract makes a complete mess of your payments and the DWP is a nightmare to deal with.

napody · 20/11/2022 11:59

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 20/11/2022 09:20

The problem is that lots of large organisations contract people on low hours and hope that they'll pick up shifts at the employers need. If you are on a benefit that pays your housing cost then you can afford potentially to give up that benefit if you are contracted and guaranteed 40 hrs work and therefore salary a week. You cannot afford to give it up if there's a possibility you will get 4 or 12 extra hours, because how do you then pay the rent?

So impressed with this. 5 minutes after the OP: problem explained.
Sometimes I wonder how people have missed the whole discussion of zero hours contracts etc over the past decade. Employers have moral responsibilities, many are ignoring them.

Peteryougit · 20/11/2022 11:58

Florenz · 20/11/2022 11:52

That's not really in question at this point. Corbyn lost 2 elections, people didn't want to vote for him. He was unelectable. If he was electable he'd have been elected.

I think the benefits system is out of control. It was only ever supposed to be a few quid while someone was in between jobs. People were never supposed to spend their whole lives reliant on benefits, only working part time and not working full time because it made them worse off to do so. If Labour promised to reform the benefits system to make it so that working people were ALWAYS better off than benefit claimants, it would be a guaranteed vote-winner for them, and they are supposed to be the party for working people after all. LABOUR MEANS WORK would be a good three word election slogan for them.

But people do work full time and still have to claim top up benefits due to high rents.

Some jobs just don’t pay enough full time for people to be able to afford to pay rent.

Of everyone moved to cheaper areas, who would do all the lower paid jobs in London, for example? And I don’t mean cleaning or careworn - I mean people who work for local authorities etc where the pay isn’t great.

Mawface · 20/11/2022 11:58

PurpleButterflyWings · 20/11/2022 11:56

@Notanotherwindow
·
It's not about being self reliant or attitude.

Say you are on a 16 hour contract and get universal credit to help with rent etc. Your boss asks you to work an extra shift which takes you to 22 hours. You get paid more that month which triggers your universal credit to be removed.

Then next week you only get your 16 hours. You can't afford to pay rent and your UC has been stopped as the system thinks you now work 22 hours a week and don't need it. Now you have to wait for it to be reviewed which takes 6 weeks, during which you can't pay rent or bills or food.

Unless you can count on those extra shifts every week, they cause more problems than they solve and you are worse off.

100% this. Spot on!

This isn't even true! You have to be offer the threshold for 6 months before it's stopped.

PurpleButterflyWings · 20/11/2022 11:56

This.

@Alphavilla

I know many people have said pretty much what I am about to say, but nevertheless... this is my take on it...

Until employers stop being selfish and grabby, and give actual PROPER contracts to people, like at least 24-28 hours, (that will enable people to be able to afford to live without benefits a bit easier - or just have a small top-up,) then no, people will NOT work more hours than 16.

As the poster above said, it will screw with their benefit payments for their rent and council tax. I have seen it happen multiple times to people... If they work a few extra hours in any given week, (even just 4 to 7 hours,) they end up with benefit overpayments, and they end up in a mess financially.

Where my brother works, they have about 12 people who have just 4 and 8 hour contracts, but they do extra hours quite often because the employer needs them to. They are often asked to do more than 16 too (some weeks) but they refuse, and the shift manager ends up doing it. If they offered real, proper decent contracts, people will do the hours.

4 and 8 hour per week contracts are a piece of shit. Even 10 to 12 ones are pretty useless. DH gets fed up of his job sometimes, and has applied some 5 or 6 times in the past few years, to supermarkets and shops and other customer service type roles. ALL the jobs had no more than 10-12 hours guaranteed. No-one can live on that amount of hours!

Yeah, they will offer extra hours sometimes, but they don't HAVE to. And they sometimes don't. Indeed, I have seen 'salaried managers' work extra hours cleaning and serving the public themselves to save on labour, and give the '4-8 hour contract' people JUST the 4-8 hours. And from mid January through to mid March, when custom is a bit low, the employees get dropped to 4-8 hours a week again.

If employers want people to do more hours, GIVE THEM THE HOURS IN THE FIRST PLACE. Stop with the shitty low hour contracts. Pre 2005-ish, this was not even a thing. When DH applied for the job he's in now (customer service role,) circa 2003, every job he looked at was 18 hours, 24 hours, 32 hours, and 40 hours a week contract. There were no 4-8 hour contracts. They're farcical. As I said, don't offer people wanky hours like this, and then cry off when they won't do lots of extra hours when YOU want them to.

PurpleButterflyWings · 20/11/2022 11:56

@Notanotherwindow
·
It's not about being self reliant or attitude.

Say you are on a 16 hour contract and get universal credit to help with rent etc. Your boss asks you to work an extra shift which takes you to 22 hours. You get paid more that month which triggers your universal credit to be removed.

Then next week you only get your 16 hours. You can't afford to pay rent and your UC has been stopped as the system thinks you now work 22 hours a week and don't need it. Now you have to wait for it to be reviewed which takes 6 weeks, during which you can't pay rent or bills or food.

Unless you can count on those extra shifts every week, they cause more problems than they solve and you are worse off.

100% this. Spot on!

BloodAndFire · 20/11/2022 11:56

scaredoff · 20/11/2022 11:42

What a great idea. If only we had a political party to vote for with the will to do that. Oh, that's right, we did . . . but they were "unelectable".

See my post above. I have every sympathy with those at the sharp end of the benefits system having been there myself.

Unfortunately I'm also Jewish so voting for an actual antisemite and his gang wasn't an option (i didn't vote for the Tories either).

Perhaps if Labour had prioritised the British working classes rather than pursuing a weird vendetta against an ethnic minority we might not be in this shithole now.

😡

BlueWalnut · 20/11/2022 11:55

BloodAndFire · 20/11/2022 11:52

It is so depressing that it STILL works like this.

Back in the late 90s I was a teenager living with my partner who had cancer. He was in receipt of sickness-based income support and therefore also housing benefit, council tax benefit, free prescriptions, hospital travel.

I wanted to work, tried temping, but as soon as I declared any earnings they cut ALL of his money and benefits for weeks.

There was no way that I as a teenager, without even A-levels, could afford the rent on a flat plus full living costs for two adults, one of whom was on chemotherapy and attending hospital multiple times a week.

I literally had no choice but to add myself to his benefit claim. It was depressing and infuriating.

(I'd like to point out that my partner recovered fully in the end, I later acquired three university degrees & my husband and I are now higher-rate taxpayers. People who need state support when their lives are in crisis are not lazy scumbags who just want to mooch off others.)

Isn’t it depressing? The system could be fixed if there was the will I am sure. I am glad you’re both ok now.

IncessantNameChanger · 20/11/2022 11:53

I get £69 pw carers allowance and in theory can work when that disabled child is at school and keep the benefit if I earn under £150 I think pw. So I'd have to be on a guaranteed £190 pw before I was tempted. But the few jobs I have done while on CB have been short contracts so it's not worth the hassle of going over. Stopping then restarting for just a few months of work. I'd rather earn just below if I'm 100% honest. My stint on carers is a limited period of my life to give my disabled child the best chance of being independent.

I lost the point of me earning my corporate wage if it meant he goes straight into supported living at 18 until he dies of old age. He has much better chances of supporting himself as a adult if I pour myself into him right now. Hopefully I will be back at work next year and my efforts mean he will be independent.

Either way I didn't choose this, making the right desision at the right time with two shit outcomes as my two options. I would much prefer to still be working full time with non disabled child but sometimes life dishes you up shit.

Like if your a high flyer and have a stroke or car crash. You find yourself on the same pile of dung as me.

BloodAndFire · 20/11/2022 11:52

Notanotherwindow · 20/11/2022 09:41

It's not about being self reliant or attitude.

Say you are on a 16 hour contract and get universal credit to help with rent etc. Your boss asks you to work an extra shift which takes you to 22 hours. You get paid more that month which triggers your universal credit to be removed.

Then next week you only get your 16 hours. You can't afford to pay rent and your UC has been stopped as the system thinks you now work 22 hours a week and don't need it. Now you have to wait for it to be reviewed which takes 6 weeks, during which you can't pay rent or bills or food.

Unless you can count on those extra shifts every week, they cause more problems than they solve and you are worse off.

It is so depressing that it STILL works like this.

Back in the late 90s I was a teenager living with my partner who had cancer. He was in receipt of sickness-based income support and therefore also housing benefit, council tax benefit, free prescriptions, hospital travel.

I wanted to work, tried temping, but as soon as I declared any earnings they cut ALL of his money and benefits for weeks.

There was no way that I as a teenager, without even A-levels, could afford the rent on a flat plus full living costs for two adults, one of whom was on chemotherapy and attending hospital multiple times a week.

I literally had no choice but to add myself to his benefit claim. It was depressing and infuriating.

(I'd like to point out that my partner recovered fully in the end, I later acquired three university degrees & my husband and I are now higher-rate taxpayers. People who need state support when their lives are in crisis are not lazy scumbags who just want to mooch off others.)

Florenz · 20/11/2022 11:52

scaredoff · 20/11/2022 11:42

What a great idea. If only we had a political party to vote for with the will to do that. Oh, that's right, we did . . . but they were "unelectable".

That's not really in question at this point. Corbyn lost 2 elections, people didn't want to vote for him. He was unelectable. If he was electable he'd have been elected.

I think the benefits system is out of control. It was only ever supposed to be a few quid while someone was in between jobs. People were never supposed to spend their whole lives reliant on benefits, only working part time and not working full time because it made them worse off to do so. If Labour promised to reform the benefits system to make it so that working people were ALWAYS better off than benefit claimants, it would be a guaranteed vote-winner for them, and they are supposed to be the party for working people after all. LABOUR MEANS WORK would be a good three word election slogan for them.

scaredoff · 20/11/2022 11:46

Consumerism is a cancer - except when it involves businesses destroying workers' security of employment so they can increase profits to buy more stuff with. Then it's really great.