Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’m hurting because I wasn’t asked

37 replies

TheScruffyVelveteenRabbit · 20/11/2022 07:37

I’ve NC as this could be outing and not sure if SIL is on here.

I have a brother who has four children. His wife, my SIL, has two sisters, I am my brother’s only sibling.

My brother and SIL have every right to choose and I respect their decisions but my AIBU is am I out of line to feel very hurt.

They have had each of the children christened and have 2 girls and 2 boys. The girls have 2 god mothers and 1 god father and the boys 2 god fathers and 1 god mother. They choose SIL’s sisters as god mothers twice, but I was never asked. They have friends as the others. DB and SIL and her sisters and I are all of equal levels of religion, believers and occasional attendees at church. I would take the role seriously and have been very hurt by the decision.

Just to say again, I know it’s their choice but why would they do this? I’ve never given them reason to think I’d be unsuitable.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsToothyBitch · 20/11/2022 09:45

YANBU, it's hurtful. Only you will know if you think it was intentional. Your SiLs family sound a bit wrapped up in each other.

Did your brother get any say? My mum didn't get to pick either of my godmothers. They're great but they're not who she would've picked. My dad "accidentally" asked his nephews wife when he asked his nephew to be godfather (as agreed) as it seemed a logical solution in the moment and my maternal grandma decided to ask her niece/mums cousin as she wanted to feel in charge of something! Neither were discussed, only my godfather was agreed and Mum's best friend and her own much loved niece didn't get a look in. Mum is still resentful!

Lovetoridemybicycle · 20/11/2022 09:45

It does hurt, I had something similar years ago. My brother had his two kids christened on the same day. They asked all the god parents to stand up. My other brother and all my cousin's stood up as did the sister and cousin of my SIL. I was the only one from our generation who wasnt. I just looked at my husband and mouthed WTF.
Now 15 years on guess who is now the closest to the pair of them!

DifficultBloodyWoman · 20/11/2022 09:37

@Kaybeeeee I deliberately didn’t choose a married couple (which turned out to be harder than I thought) because of possible divorces etc. And I figured a godparent’s partner would be a figure in DC’s life by default anyway.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 20/11/2022 09:35

There are a number of reasons you may not have been asked. If you really want to know, you would have to ask your brother. But here are a few suggestions:

  • Does your brother even care about the christening? If, like my DH, he isn’t bothered, he may have left these decisions to SIL.
  • Do they think you don’t care/don’t practice your religion as much as SIL’s family? Or are they silently judging your moral choices about god/lifestyle/marriage/living together?
  • Do you actually meet the requirements of their church to be a godparent? Are you baptised/confirmed/in communion with the church/living in line with church principles?
  • Reciprocity - I’m guessing they are not godparents to your children based on your OP. Are they godparents to SIL’s nieces and nephews? Do they feel obligated to reciprocate the honor?
Kaybeeeee · 20/11/2022 09:33

I get it, OP. Whilst they have every right to choose whomever they like, not being chosen can cause hurt feelings.

My sister and I were incredibly close. I was single and childless at the time and she asked my married brother and SIL to be godparents of baby 1. They lived a 4 hour flight away. She told me that she wanted married couples to be the godparents. For baby 2, despite me being the most involved relative for baby 1, she chose her close friend and the husband. Ironically, the husband cheated and that married couple are now divorced.
For baby 3, I was asked. I turned her down. By this stage I was quite happy being an involved, loving Aunty - I didn’t need the title, I didn’t need to be a third choice and I found it puzzling about why the ‘married couples’ rule no longer applied.

I say all this to say that you can be hurt by their choices, but ultimately they are free to make their choices and don’t owe you an explanation or a special title. You can feel hurt, but keep it to yourself and try to move past it.

Abraxan · 20/11/2022 09:06

I guess it's hurtful as they have chosen other siblings over you. It may be best to speak to your brother and simply ask why.

Fwiw we deliberately chose non family members as god parents for Dd. Two couple who were good friends of ours.

We felt that family already played a big role in our child's life and considered for parents to be extending her family further.

Onlyforcake · 20/11/2022 09:03

Anyone choosing one family over another is obviously benefiting from that conscious choice (generally ive noticed its dither childcare or wealth on mn). Your brother isn't going to be around for you long term as you age UNLESS he benefits from it. In life people only stick with those they benefit from This is a warning sign to shore up your support network elsewhere. Your brother has chosen his.

boredOf · 20/11/2022 08:58

That's mean of them.

Limer · 20/11/2022 08:57

Sounds like your SIL is doing all the choosing, and your DB is letting her. Have a word with him.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 20/11/2022 08:54

Hesma · 20/11/2022 08:51

Ask your brother… he has the answers MN doesn’t. Explain how you’re feeling

Agreed. Ask your brother.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 20/11/2022 08:53

TheScruffyVelveteenRabbit · 20/11/2022 08:48

They are obviously my brother’s children as much as they are his wife’s so I don’t quite understand your point?

They are his children but it doesn't work like that in reality.

Hesma · 20/11/2022 08:51

Ask your brother… he has the answers MN doesn’t. Explain how you’re feeling

TheScruffyVelveteenRabbit · 20/11/2022 08:48

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 20/11/2022 07:51

Well this is what happens. Of course she will choose her family over her husbands. Men get absorbed into their wife's family.
I would choose my brother over my husband's sister.

They are obviously my brother’s children as much as they are his wife’s so I don’t quite understand your point?

OP posts:
HotIceCube · 20/11/2022 08:15

I agree that in one of my brother’s case, he has become absorbed into SIL family and this kind of thing has happened countless times over the years. My DM has been left very hurt at times, I’ve felt hurt occasionally but as time as gone by it does hurt less, it’s to be expected now so it’s just the way it is.

I feel for you, OP and it is hurtful. If you can, I’d speak to your brother and just let him know quietly that you were hurt. Don’t then let it fester, it’ll eat you up. There might be more bumps in the road with similar scenarios along the way, knowing that the hurt will ease will make you stronger each time.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 20/11/2022 08:12

LolaSmiles · 20/11/2022 08:07

I'm not saying the wives expect it I just think that's what happens. Maybe because women seem to take the lead with organising events, seeing family etc.
I see it everywhere, in most relationships of friends and family

It's the husband's fault of course
On day to day things I can see how it's not necessarily expected, eg shall we go for Sunday lunch with my parents, but on big things it seems to be expected.

I also think it seems to be expected when you read the threads about posters being disappointed when they find they're having a boy. It's all about how the boy will grow to a man and then you lose them to their wife and her family, but you get to keep daughters for life. I often think it says a lot about how those posters probably see their husbands.

In OP's situation both her brother and SIL have made the decision to have multiple christenings as their family has grown and it's all about friends and her family. They've both been hurtful.

Maybe so. I do have two boys and I kinda expect them to go into their wives families although I hope not obviously!
I'd say my husband is like this for sure although I do suggest visiting his parents and them coming to us but a lot of the time he just doesn't get round to organising it and I'm not organising everything for both sides of our family.
For the op, yes I do agree it is hurtful. I'm just not surprised.

Badgerandfox227 · 20/11/2022 08:08

I can imagine this is hurtful, I don’t understand why people exclude the husbands side of the family. So much nicer to have both sides equally involved.

When I had my DC christened I made sure my DH sister was a godmother and that it was equal selection on both sides for that reason.

SIL sadly didn’t do the same, but that’s her choice.

LolaSmiles · 20/11/2022 08:07

I'm not saying the wives expect it I just think that's what happens. Maybe because women seem to take the lead with organising events, seeing family etc.
I see it everywhere, in most relationships of friends and family

It's the husband's fault of course
On day to day things I can see how it's not necessarily expected, eg shall we go for Sunday lunch with my parents, but on big things it seems to be expected.

I also think it seems to be expected when you read the threads about posters being disappointed when they find they're having a boy. It's all about how the boy will grow to a man and then you lose them to their wife and her family, but you get to keep daughters for life. I often think it says a lot about how those posters probably see their husbands.

In OP's situation both her brother and SIL have made the decision to have multiple christenings as their family has grown and it's all about friends and her family. They've both been hurtful.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 20/11/2022 08:04

Did SIL do the majority of the organising for the christening. If so maybe her sisters were chosen because she led the choosing of GPs and chose who she is closest to?

I agree with the poster who said you need to reframe the situation. Just because you weren’t chosen doesn’t mean they don’t value or love you. Their choice isn’t a reflection on you. There could be so many reasons SILs sisters were chosen instead- could be anything as innocuous as it being the tradition in her family etc.

you can still be a great and close aunty to the children.

I would’t make this in to a bigger issue than it should be. Im not sure that asking them why would really achieve much either, unless you have a very open and truthful relationship where issues can be discussed and resolved easily (let’s be honest for many that’s not the case).

xJ0y · 20/11/2022 08:00

ps, so much experience reframing hurtful experiences

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 20/11/2022 07:58

LolaSmiles · 20/11/2022 07:56

Well this is what happens. Of course she will choose her family over her husbands.Men get absorbed into their wife's family.
I would choose my brother over my husband's sister.
I'd choose my sister over my SIL, who I love dearly, if it came to it, but it wouldn't in most circumstances because i would never expect my DH to push his family into the background.

It's awful that some many wives seem to think their husband gets absorbed into their family and it's awful so many husbands haven't got a backbone to say their family matters too.

I'm not saying the wives expect it I just think that's what happens. Maybe because women seem to take the lead with organising events, seeing family etc.
I see it everywhere, in most relationships of friends and family

It's the husband's fault of course

libraryday · 20/11/2022 07:58

SIL probably organised it and your brother went along with it. He's probably not thought any more about it. As a PP said, some men get absorbed into wife's family so that family is favoured.

My brother would be the same. It's rubbish.

LolaSmiles · 20/11/2022 07:56

Well this is what happens. Of course she will choose her family over her husbands.Men get absorbed into their wife's family.
I would choose my brother over my husband's sister.
I'd choose my sister over my SIL, who I love dearly, if it came to it, but it wouldn't in most circumstances because i would never expect my DH to push his family into the background.

It's awful that some many wives seem to think their husband gets absorbed into their family and it's awful so many husbands haven't got a backbone to say their family matters too.

Chomolungma · 20/11/2022 07:55

I expect SIL suggested it and your brother thought you wouldn't mind. Clearly he was wrong though. I agree about asking him.

xJ0y · 20/11/2022 07:55

You are not being unreasonable to be hurt. That is your reaction and you're entitled to it. But I think the hurt feelings pass quicker if you try and re-frame it now. You've felt the hurt. You haven't reprimanded yourself for feeling hurt (don't) but now. Feel hurt, be kind to yourself. You WERE worthy of being asked to a God Parent but for reasons that have very little to do with your character, they chose the other side of the family basically. Convenience? Breath.

Now Re-frame.

You are now free from having to be a role model to this child.
If you forget her bd so be it.
You are free to buy her the plastic tat she wants
Without making a judgement on your brother's marriage is it possible that your SIL makes more decisions in the relationship than you brother does.

girlmom21 · 20/11/2022 07:53

You're their auntie, you don't need to stand in a church and say you'll guide them to be able to do it.

What's your relationship with your nieces and nephews like?

Do you have children? Do the godparents have children?

A lot of the choice is around knowing the children would still be brought up the way you want them to be brought up if you're not around. Maybe they're not close enough to you to know whether you could do that.