Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if GPs are leaving NHS and why?

194 replies

CloudyYellow · 20/11/2022 07:15

Seems like numbers are going down and it sounds like the job is unsustainable.

OP posts:
jonnyjannoo · 20/11/2022 10:36

@Neanov nurse practitioners and paramedic practitioners are not band 4 Confused

Mango101 · 20/11/2022 10:31

The biggest factor right now is pension tax.

Guitarbar · 20/11/2022 10:30

damekindness · 20/11/2022 10:01

*"I'd rather see a doctor than someone who has done a 2 year postgraduate course"
*
Yes so would I if given the choice - but the reality is that if I'm unwell and I want to get an appointment it's better to have the option of a PA or nurse than no care at all.

I'd happily see a nurse, a PA though no thank you. Nothing personal against them, but their training is not fit for the purpose in which they are being utilised.

eggandonion · 20/11/2022 10:23

I know a married gp couple who retired a few years ago in their mid fifties, big practice at the edge of London.
My gp has just retired, aged 68, from a big practice in a city in Ireland.
Losing working age staff, in good health, with excellent pensions they say, can't help?

Winniethepig · 20/11/2022 10:14

My sister is a GP - it is definitely about stress and money. I asked her about it recently and how things were going in her practice and she is completely overloaded and doesn't have time to treat people the way she would like to treat them (thoroughly).

She has offers all the time to go to private health companies and is considering it.

She feels bad for doing so, mostly because the NHS is treated like a religion and there is a tacit expectation she should work extra for free out of the goodness of her heart.

HelensToenail · 20/11/2022 10:13

Yes I don't live in a big place but personally know 2 german doctors who went home because of brexit

so that repeated all over the country

maddy68 · 20/11/2022 10:02

Lost so many that went back to their countries after Brexit.

damekindness · 20/11/2022 10:01

*"I'd rather see a doctor than someone who has done a 2 year postgraduate course"
*
Yes so would I if given the choice - but the reality is that if I'm unwell and I want to get an appointment it's better to have the option of a PA or nurse than no care at all.

Bestcatmum · 20/11/2022 10:01

Be sure its hellish working for the NHS. .y GP went to Sustria. Ingersoll say and great working balance.
I only managed it because I e been working there for 41 years and have become accustomed and hardened to the stress. They call us lifers.
If I was new I'd run away screaming.

3rdtimelucky2022 · 20/11/2022 09:57

I’m a recently qualified GP and have only been working as a GP for a few months and I can’t see how I can sustain it long term. Already looking into other options inc private/alternative careers/locum.

the job is relentless and you just get unhappy and thankless patients.

an average day includes:
50-70 patient contacts
20-30 blood/imaging results to action
15 documents to action (which can be complex things like new cancer diagnoses)
30 prescription requests to action
plus all the extra tasks/queries that come through from patients/staff!

we get 10 mins allocated for face to face appointments and inevitably patients expect and deserve more than this so leads to us always running late. This further annoys patients.

we get regular complaints because patients are unhappy with the service of which many aspects are out of our control, such as:

  • strict referral criterias from hospital meaning we can refer majority of patients
  • we no longer have any access to things like CT/MRI/heart scans so patients can’t get what we think they need
  • long waiting lists for hospital appointment (most a year or more where I am).
  • any many many other issues!

at the end of the day I’m frazzled, stressed and exhausted. Honestly when another patient complains I feel broken. then you look on social media and see another post on social media/mumsnet about how crap GPs are and how they’re not seeing patients.

one of my colleagues at another close practice recently committed suicide due to her work as a GP and I’m not willing to risk my life.

burnout is rife and we aren’t protecting our doctors. I have trained in UK and loved medicine but the realities of everyday GP is grim. Things need to change. We need more GPs, more protection and more respect.

felded · 20/11/2022 09:52

There are too few medical school places, demand is already very high and most applicants are rejected. That's the real problem. We've not trained enough for decades

yep

Of course the real elephant in the room is the aging and sick population with no proper care strategy. That is essentially collapsing the health service.

yep

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 20/11/2022 09:51

I have done 16 different medical/surgical specialties since I graduated med school - including ones thought of as hard/emotionally taxing. A&E, Palliative Care, ITU, Paeds, Acute Medicine, Psych, Oncology. Ones with brutal shift work rotas, overwhelming demand, high risk patients etc
GP is BY FAR the hardest, most soul destroying and exhausting specialty I've ever done and the people who do it are also often viewed with such disdain.
It's relentlessly awful. It's really lonely too. It's just almost unexplainably crap.

HelensToenail · 20/11/2022 09:50

Poor work-force planning going back decades is a major background factor - there was a particularly large cohort of GPs reaching retirement age over the last 10 years and insufficient new GPs trained to replace them

I suspect more Physicians Assistants, telemedicine and overseas recruitment was the plan to fit this gap

So this bit was entirely foreseeable and the mitigation was insufficient

Guitarbar · 20/11/2022 09:41

Grumpybutfunny · 20/11/2022 09:37

@Guitarbar That's a very old fashioned view when most of the big cases require a MDT. If your talking about medicines hatred of PAs most of them come from BMS degrees (which is now causing staffing issues for labs but that's a whole other argument) who share the core modules with medicine others have significant post graduate experience as nurses etc. It would be interesting if we let other members of the NHS team sit the final year medicine exams I'm sure many nurses etc could pass them with flying colours as they have learnt the content over many years services vs in a lecture theatre, the problem with that approach would be the staffing to do clinical placements for them to upgrade their degrees.

It's not an old fashioned view, just sick of a medicine being devalued and degraded as a professional and people willing it along to save a bit of money. It's putting patients at risk, not that people care as long as PAs get to play doctors.

Grumpybutfunny · 20/11/2022 09:37

@Guitarbar That's a very old fashioned view when most of the big cases require a MDT. If your talking about medicines hatred of PAs most of them come from BMS degrees (which is now causing staffing issues for labs but that's a whole other argument) who share the core modules with medicine others have significant post graduate experience as nurses etc. It would be interesting if we let other members of the NHS team sit the final year medicine exams I'm sure many nurses etc could pass them with flying colours as they have learnt the content over many years services vs in a lecture theatre, the problem with that approach would be the staffing to do clinical placements for them to upgrade their degrees.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 20/11/2022 09:36

Most of the older GPs retired after COVID. They’ve not been replaced.
2/3 of current GP trainees in a recent research paper stated that they have no intention of EVER working full time. A large number said they have no intention of working in the UK either. So we are paying circa £50k for people to be trained to do a job they have no intention of doing. similarly, medical students will be trained here at great expense and then will be off somewhere else to work.

This is due to pay and conditions. If you treat people like crap then they won’t do it. It’s a crazy situation when we pay millions to train people to do a job and then can’t treat them well and pay them sufficiently to try and keep them here to do that job. And no-this isn’t necessarily Tory bashing-this is successive governments whichever side of the house they are.

Did you hear the health secretary this week saying; “well, what do consultants do on the weekend? We should get them in working!” No-you should pay and employ MORE consultants so that a weekend service would be viable-but don’t forget you’d also need more nurses/GPs/OTs/physios/
porters/support staff etc etc

And no-they don’t all get paid £125k and no, the pension is also not worth it as it once was because the government are now coming after consultants for their pension pot and have decided to tax them on it before they reach retirement despite the fact that they have already paid tax on that money when they earned it before it went to their pension. So many doctors are now getting surprise tax bills of £75k for their pension subscription. This is leading to doctors taking earlier retirement before their pension pot gets too large. End result-no older wiser doctors to mentor the new ones, leading to more stress and challenge for those newly qualified. Et voila-Madness.

Guitarbar · 20/11/2022 09:27

Grumpybutfunny · 20/11/2022 09:21

@Neanov the NHS needs to save money tho we as a country can't afford it! I love the PA at our surgery, you can get an appointment usually same day, in and out within 5/10minutes as she usually running to time and she can actually work the video consult tool properly. Yes for more serious issues you need a GP to refer to secondary care but for the mundane issues our PA is great. I think the NHS could save a fortune having them based in pharmacy style walk in services. I also wonder if dropping the honour Dr tittle from medics might help people being more accepting of paramedics, nurses, PA etc providing primary care.

Reasons for leaving the NHS or doing less NHS hours
*They negotiated a good pay deal (better for agenda for change)
*Burn out
*Unpaid but expected overtime
*Real terms pay cut
*Unreasonable targets
*Changing population/attitudes to GP services
*Delays in secondary care
*Growing chronic disease burden and the effects that has on acute care

I'm a scientist in secondary care we are at the stage financially (I'm only 32, was a young man) and career wise I could go back to uni to do a MBBS? but actually despite it being something I wanted to do when younger with the current state of the NHS it's not something I can see myself doing (need to make a final decision on that one in the next few months). I don't want to work 50hr weeks, get abused by patient rightly frustrated with the standards and not be able to care for acute patients because of the demands placed on the NHS by social care issues.

I'd rather see a doctor than someone who has done a 2 year postgraduate course to fill a role no one really knows the parameters of but was created to be a cheaper way to fill gaps of actual qualified and suitably trained doctors thanks. The fact they get paid double that of a junior doctor is frankly insulting as well.

Simonjt · 20/11/2022 09:24

Diverging · 20/11/2022 09:22

There’s certainly loads (most?) working 2 or 3 days a week.

So a 24 hour week, or a 36 hour week. The GPs I know work a minimum of 12 hour days (apart from Saturday shifts that are generally 8).

giraffesoxks · 20/11/2022 09:23

Diverging · 20/11/2022 09:22

There’s certainly loads (most?) working 2 or 3 days a week.

Force them to work 5 days and watch then all leave then

Guitarbar · 20/11/2022 09:23

Kazzyhoward · 20/11/2022 08:02

There are too few medical school places, demand is already very high and most applicants are rejected. That's the real problem. We've not trained enough for decades.

The issue is not with completing the university element of the degree, but in having enough training places in medical settings, no point training tonnes of people if they can't complete the training. It's like many student nurses have had placements cancelled as there aren't enough placements spots and mentors for them- and we have a chronic shortage so the cycle continues.

People leave the land of GP because its shite. Long, long hours, pay isn't as good as it is elsewhere, and you get abuse from people who read the DM and assume you're lazy and don't do anything. There has been a shortage for a while but its definitely getting worse.

Diverging · 20/11/2022 09:22

There’s certainly loads (most?) working 2 or 3 days a week.

Grumpybutfunny · 20/11/2022 09:21

@Neanov the NHS needs to save money tho we as a country can't afford it! I love the PA at our surgery, you can get an appointment usually same day, in and out within 5/10minutes as she usually running to time and she can actually work the video consult tool properly. Yes for more serious issues you need a GP to refer to secondary care but for the mundane issues our PA is great. I think the NHS could save a fortune having them based in pharmacy style walk in services. I also wonder if dropping the honour Dr tittle from medics might help people being more accepting of paramedics, nurses, PA etc providing primary care.

Reasons for leaving the NHS or doing less NHS hours
*They negotiated a good pay deal (better for agenda for change)
*Burn out
*Unpaid but expected overtime
*Real terms pay cut
*Unreasonable targets
*Changing population/attitudes to GP services
*Delays in secondary care
*Growing chronic disease burden and the effects that has on acute care

I'm a scientist in secondary care we are at the stage financially (I'm only 32, was a young man) and career wise I could go back to uni to do a MBBS? but actually despite it being something I wanted to do when younger with the current state of the NHS it's not something I can see myself doing (need to make a final decision on that one in the next few months). I don't want to work 50hr weeks, get abused by patient rightly frustrated with the standards and not be able to care for acute patients because of the demands placed on the NHS by social care issues.

giraffesoxks · 20/11/2022 09:20

TheVanguardSix · 20/11/2022 09:15

My former husband was a GP who stopped one year ago (personal stuff I won’t get into now). 30+ years a GP. Most of his 12 hour days were spent doing admin work (dealing with rejected after rejected referral letter because the meticulous to the point of absurd box ticking exercise went wrong), or in time-wasting meetings about how much money they would flush down the toilet for yet another NHS initiative that would fail like all the others, or chasing targets in order to outrun CQC inspectors breathing down their necks. You’d almost forget there were patients to treat!
I pay privately myself. I can’t afford it but I do it because I get results. I’d never go back to my NHS surgery. Can’t even book a phone consultation let alone see a doctor. Oh but I can see my GP for Botox injections.

Having been married to a GP I'm confused by your disdain- it's not an individual GPs fault if the booking at their practice is fucked, and they are entirely entitled to work elsewhere privately on their days off.

chopc · 20/11/2022 09:20

@RedRosesPinkLilies are you sure of your facts? If you were a qualified GP you would need to go through the induction and refresher scheme - the length of which can be as short as three months depending on your needs

giraffesoxks · 20/11/2022 09:18

I left medicine 4 years after graduating. I couldn't bare further training in any area but GP was right down the bottom of my list.
The risk, the unachievable workload and public disdain are just 3 reasons why I couldn't ever do it. I take my hat off to colleagues who can and do.
All this 'why are they all part time' bollocks when often a working day is 8am-8.30PM realistically, of course they're not going to do 5 days a week! Nurses work those hours and no-one berates them for 'only' working 3-4 days a week!

This is not to say that I think general practice is a perfect service. As a user of the service I share the frustrations that others have. But not enough to continue my training and put myself through that hell.

Swipe left for the next trending thread