Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if GPs are leaving NHS and why?

194 replies

CloudyYellow · 20/11/2022 07:15

Seems like numbers are going down and it sounds like the job is unsustainable.

OP posts:
Parker231 · 20/11/2022 14:58

RosesAndHellebores · 20/11/2022 14:47

@Carriemac my dh is 61. Lawyer. He delivered five 11 hour days last week. I've done about 12 so far this weekend on top of five ten hour days last week. Why is it that medics and their families think they are the only ones who work hard?

Also at my local A&E there is no consultant oversight over the weekend, no orthopaedic oversight for all the broken bones and no emergency surgery facility.

That is one example of mismanagement and leeching costs. An 80 year old with a broke hip is taken to a hospital that can't help her. Triage, bunged on a trolley, not very well cared for pending transfer to the hospital that was 3m rather than 2.5m from her home. The mismanagement and stupidity in the system knows no bounds and the people in it want the public's sympathy.

The NHS needs to sort it's nonsense out if it wants any sympathy from me.

I’ve seen your posts before - a regular NHS basher but knows nothing about it - never worked in the NHS and has a cushy office job as a pen pusher!

Parker231 · 20/11/2022 14:55

DH earned the title of doctor through many years of study and horrendous hours of work. He never expected to be revered but to be respected for the job he does. DH got told he had locked himself away during lockdown - NO - he worked seeing patients face to face, working on a Covid ward and working with church leaders so that patients could understand the benefits of the vaccine.
i rarely saw him for weeks on end. I am so glad he has left but sorry for his old patients as DH’s practice closed down as the other GP’s left to work in other countries or return to their own country and no other GP’s applied to take on the practice - 10,000 patients to then be allocated to other already overwhelmed practices

ButterflyLeg · 20/11/2022 14:48

Lapland
You aren't a doctor - that is clear. I suspect you may also go by the username passport123 also.
Your a very bored individual with loads of time on your hands. But there is no way you are a doctor. You sound like a child

RosesAndHellebores · 20/11/2022 14:47

@Carriemac my dh is 61. Lawyer. He delivered five 11 hour days last week. I've done about 12 so far this weekend on top of five ten hour days last week. Why is it that medics and their families think they are the only ones who work hard?

Also at my local A&E there is no consultant oversight over the weekend, no orthopaedic oversight for all the broken bones and no emergency surgery facility.

That is one example of mismanagement and leeching costs. An 80 year old with a broke hip is taken to a hospital that can't help her. Triage, bunged on a trolley, not very well cared for pending transfer to the hospital that was 3m rather than 2.5m from her home. The mismanagement and stupidity in the system knows no bounds and the people in it want the public's sympathy.

The NHS needs to sort it's nonsense out if it wants any sympathy from me.

Endpress · 20/11/2022 14:46

Isn’t some of it about pension tax? The gov could alleviate that? We never talk about public sector pensions but it does seem to be a factor for consultants etc who probably have more than £1m in their pension due to their age. I can see being a GP could be a hellish job with the timescales and lack of follow on care facilities.

Lapland123 · 20/11/2022 14:46

ButterflyLeg

you say that is me ‘moaning’ . Fool.

That is me answering the OPs question as to why GPS are leaving the NHS

Duh

🙄

ButterflyLeg · 20/11/2022 14:46

Yes you really should look at why so many people are frustrated and disappointed in GPS that would be an obvious thing to do in my eyes if I was a GP and felt like the whole world was against me and my profession. Perhaps there something in it?

Did I say I personally think doctors deserve a bashing? No I didn't lol . You're making things up

You sound very silly and I doubt you actually are a qualified doctor of any sort

Telling me there's something wrong with me 🙄😂 gone on them give us a proper diagnosis, what's wrong me with doc?!

Newlifestartingatlast · 20/11/2022 14:46

UmbilicusProfundus · 20/11/2022 08:49

Well Medical school places have actually increased in recent years but it’s the shit working conditions that drive doctors away. A significant number of graduates never start, and yet more leave during and after foundation training to other careers or other countries. An additional factor now is the pensions issue whereby senior doctors are having to reduce working hours to avoid huge tax charges.

Thought this had now been sorted? Was in news recently

Carriemac · 20/11/2022 14:45

very nasty

Lapland123 · 20/11/2022 14:41

ButterflyLeg

really? Your response to this thread is that they should understand why they are getting a ‘bashing’?
and then some nonsense that they think their earned title means they think they should be ‘revered?’
do they deserve a ‘bashing’? What other people do you believe deserve a ‘bashing’?

there is something very wrong with you if that’s your response to the clear problems detailed by doctors on this thread. Something very wrong and nasty.

ButterflyLeg · 20/11/2022 14:39

Lapland123 · 20/11/2022 12:04

Pay -erosion

pension and tax situation

workload-10 mins per patient

politicians bashing them

newspapers bashing them

public bashing them like a few ignorants on this thread saying they ‘only work 3 days a week’ when the hours worked are that of a full time job. It’s like they are so dumb they can’t do basic math. Oh wait…

Here's you moaning about the 'bashing'

ButterflyLeg · 20/11/2022 14:36

Lapland123 · 20/11/2022 14:34

ButterflyLeg

have you not read the thread? What on earth are you on about? 🙄

Yes I have, and noticed a few posters moaning about lack of respect which is why I asked.

BorsetshireBanality · 20/11/2022 14:35

Look up Symphony Healthcare.

Carriemac · 20/11/2022 14:35

Im married to a consultant and since Friday morning he's been home - 830 last night til 11 am this morning. hope to
see him around 7 pm. he's 62, and mentally and physically exhausted.
he has Monday as a rest day and then back in Tuesday.
he's paid well, but we would be better if financially if he retired tomorrow.
so i get the rage when some politician says the consultants aren't in at weekend s - one weekend. in 4 DH works all weekend to cover his acute speciality

Lapland123 · 20/11/2022 14:34

ButterflyLeg

have you not read the thread? What on earth are you on about? 🙄

BorsetshireBanality · 20/11/2022 14:33

An elderly relative who lives in a South Somerset market town told me that all the gps upped and left the local practice when it got taken over by a private consortium as some sort of trial. Whether this is 100% true or not I don’t know, but it’s scary. The terms and conditions offered to the gps must have been really poor for this to happen.

Lapland123 · 20/11/2022 14:32

The latest ignorance is the health secretary to say we need consultants working at weekends. Um, doesn’t the fool know we already do?
I thought the ‘#iminworkjeremy’ campaign taught some people something. Perhaps Jeremy Hunt could tell him about it.

when I was contacted to work 24 hours as NHS consultant, which was 3 x8 hour days, I would gladly have swapped to go to work Saturday at 9 and work until Sunday morning at 9. Of course, that’d be me free for the rest of the week. It sounds great.

if they want a consultant- delivered service ( which is what he is suggesting) rather than a consultant- led service, gonna need a whole lot more consultants.

if they are trying to train up and fill gaps with Allied health professionals and PAs, then of course they need to be part of the unsocial hours too. Currently they often are not ( certainly not where I worked, where AHP worked office hours).

I left for private practice- it is lovely and I’d recommend it to anyone.

ButterflyLeg · 20/11/2022 14:25

To the doctors who feel they are being bashed by the media and public... do you not understand why you are getting this bashing?! Do you believe because you earned title of 'Doctor' that this should result in automatic reverence?

Qazwsxefv · 20/11/2022 14:20

Training wise it’s the lack of post grad training places that’s the issue not the med school numbers - less GPs means less trainers so less training places so less GPs and so on. At some point it will hit a terminal decline and then we really are screwed

I have nothing against PAs or allied health professionals but those who don’t have their own professional registration and insurance-mainly PAs are therefore practicing using the “supervisory” doctors legal liability, registration and insurance. As a trainee GP the PA/allied health professional is often my “senior” on a shift and so we have the bizarre situation where I am legally/professionally/financially responsible for my supervisors choices. I’m not doing down PAs here I just want them to be responsible for their own actions just as I am for mine.

The hours are shit and not reflected in the ones payed or reported. Every consult with a patient creates an equal amount of time needed to do the paperwork and this isn’t factored into the day at all. Same for repeat prescription checking, checking blood results, reading and actioning letters, auditing all of the above, mandated written reflection, practice meetings. All of this takes up probably double the time actually spent offering appointments but the public just see it as the doctors being “closed” and think we’re lazy.

im part time - I’m paid 50% of the standard trainee salary because of this and I still work 36 hours a week over three days in the week and one weekend shift a month (I’m paid for 24) if I was full time I would easily be working 70+ hours mon-fri and the out of hours and being paid for 48

and I pay for my professional exams to be fully qualified GP out of my own pocket (these are £1000s) and my resuscitation and safeguarding training. I don’t get leave to study for the exams so do so in my annual leave. As a trainee GP (qualified dr) I get 20mins rather than ten per patient, a half day of zoom “training” a week on how to be a GP and usually have a named supervisor I can discuss cases with if I am stuck on what to do (but since were so busy we’re asked to only seek help if we really need to). People coming to see me get the same service as if it was a fully qualified GP.

we do at least get our insurance paid for now (we didn’t used to a few years ago)

I spend a lot of time wondering if it’s worth continuing

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 20/11/2022 14:02

I don't mind who sees patients as long as they're trained correctly for it.
The trouble is if the 'easy/simple' patients get directed to the PAs/CNPs then GPs effectively become a Complex Care Consultant, with none of the recognition, resources or time.
In a day of ten min appointments you might run over for an unwell and complicated patient, or a suicidal one etc and then make up the time with an easy tonsillitis or UTI or something.
If these patients aren't seeing GPs anymore their patient load just expands and the work each patient contact of this type generates can be immense, as is the risk, the worry, the follow up.
If that's the direction of travel for GPs then it needs to be done honestly and in a supported way otherwise you're just setting a group of conscientious, caring and hard working people up to fail - and endangering the population.

RosesAndHellebores · 20/11/2022 14:02

Why is it that doctors think they are the only ones for whom full time means working more than 35hpw.

I work as a director in a public sector organisation. I earn about the same as a GP. My contract of emoyment says "as required". I usually work about 55hpw. It is the norm. I have also blown my annual allowance re my pension scheme. I am privileged to have done so - it is evidence of how much I earn and the size of my pension. I made 125 people redundant last summer. How many NHS staff were made redundant last summer. If I continually complained about my job and pay to my stakeholders I would be dismissed.

DH has a senior role in his field. He works about 55hpw. (Not the 70+ when he was a young man).

When I was diagnosed with thyroid disease in the late 80s, my physician (the late, great Sir Richard Bayliss) said to me "look once this is sorted out, you'll just need a little pill every day". The only inconvenience will be a yearly blood test and collecting a prescription once a year. Then they introduced 28 day prescribing, now 56 day. I have to tiddle about six times a year - usually the practice buggers it up once at least. Multiply that by every patient. If my GP has time to tiddle up the wall for unnecessary nonsense, overwork is their problem, not mine.

MissyB1 · 20/11/2022 13:41

My dh is a consultant and his specialty definitely provide 7 day cover in the hospital, in fact across two hospitals! Most of the other specialties do exactly the same. I wish the Government would stop insisting that Consultants won’t work weekends- that shows their bloody ignorance!
And yes the pension tax will mean that Dh has to take retirement between 58-60 (the calculations are deliberately tricky to do).

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 13:16

Feels like the UK is about to experience a crash in life expectancy
you're either robustly fit and healthy .....or you're dead ☹️

Parker231 · 20/11/2022 13:11

DrFoxtrot · 20/11/2022 12:55

@Parker231 do you mind me asking what your DH does now? Or a vague idea of the area of work he's moved into?

DH is French Canadian - came to the uk when he was 21 on a scholarship. We moved to Quebec earlier this year and DH works three days a week in a large medical clinic. Standard eight hour days. There is a lot wrong with the Canadian healthcare system but nothing like as bad as in the UK.

DrFoxtrot · 20/11/2022 12:55

@Parker231 do you mind me asking what your DH does now? Or a vague idea of the area of work he's moved into?