Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if GPs are leaving NHS and why?

194 replies

CloudyYellow · 20/11/2022 07:15

Seems like numbers are going down and it sounds like the job is unsustainable.

OP posts:
Qazwsxefv · 20/11/2022 15:24

RosesAndHellebores · 20/11/2022 15:08

@Qazwsxefv 28/56 day prescribing is absurd. Surely the CCGs have more weight in relation to these matters than the public and ought to be pushing back regarding the nonsense of it.

CCGs got abolished in the last (unneeded and mid pandemic) wholesale reorganisation of the nhs. It’s now ICBs and ICS and other acronyms. There too busy recruiting all the people who used to work for the CCG and designing new logos or whatever…..

but we now have (another) new health secretary so they I am sure will soon design the next top down redesign so no work will again be done….

(ccg prescribing advisor was probably for 28 day scripts because they never actually had to deal with patients who’s repeats are now due on different days of the month and are pissed off about it)

Zone2NorthLondon · 20/11/2022 15:23

mumsneedwine · 20/11/2022 15:18

@keeptalkinghappytalk you don't need A stars for medicine. Most need AAA and a few AAB. You don't need a full cv as most Unis don't even read the personal statement.
The issue as has been said is number of training places, both during and after Uni. Doctors train on the job so are taught be doctors (& nurses) while working. Less of them around so can't increase training places.
GPs and all HCP are treated like dirt. So they leave. The whole thing needs a shake up and a reset if it's ever going to work again.

UCL condition Offer 2022. And 2023 required A* AA
Theres a private uni (Buckingham) has a lower offer but the fees are astronomical

Avrenim · 20/11/2022 15:22

CCGs don't exist any more, they had yet another reorganisation into part of ICBs or Integrated Care Boards in most of England. Leaving behind, in some cases, lovely empty suites in town centre locations while all those Band 8a minimum administrators jostle for position and the best Golden Goodbye and lucrative deals with local businesses they can negotiate.

While the clinicians and AHPs and social workers and others who actually do the real work are left in despair about so many things.

Blip · 20/11/2022 15:22

My local practice has 12 GPs and all of them are part time. I think full time GPs are now rare due to the pressures of the job and also because the pay is good enough for part time hours to live quite well on which is not true for a lot of jobs.

mumsneedwine · 20/11/2022 15:22

@Zone2NorthLondon what is M SAT ? UCL use BMAT. A few Unis do want an A star but most don't. And you don't have to apply to those if you don't want to.

mumsneedwine · 20/11/2022 15:20

@mumda not the case. Consultants get a tax bill now if they put too much in their pension - it's not a choice as they either opt in or out. So they opt in. But then they work more hours, get paid more and so go over their limit. Which is then taxed (twice). So they work less. They don't want to but who the hell works more for less pay ?
Even the government admits this is a stupid law and intends to change it.

Zone2NorthLondon · 20/11/2022 15:19

UCL is A* AA entry, fiercely competitive entry plus interview and M-SAT

Luncheonmeatsandwich · 20/11/2022 15:19

Where is this A&E that doesn't have Consultant oversight at the weekend?

No one is saying that other professionals don't work long hours - simply that a GP working 3-4 days a week is not really taking it easy.

Qazwsxefv · 20/11/2022 15:18

A hospital with and A and E but no emergency surgery or orthopaedics is not good.

it’s either because

  1. they do need an A and E there but they cannot get enough staff to fill the surgery and orthopaedic slots to run a safe serviceit - so not enough doctors, nurses and theatre staff - not mismanagement but lack of staff
  2. they don’t need an A and E there and that hospital is not staffed for an A and E but when it was going to be closed the public and the local MP kicked up a massive fuss and it’s kept open anyway
  3. complete incompetence by the very senior nhs management who make these decisions

none of these reasons for this admitted shit show are due to doctors

also where/if the ambulance service decides to take patients is nothing to do with doctors and defiantly nothing to do with GPs. Paramedics are independent practitioners and professionals and make their own decisions. GPs have no authority over them. If as a GP I think a patient needs to go to hospital urgently I call 999 just like a member of the public does. The ambulance crew who attend will make their own independent assessment of the patient and may then decide to take them to hospital of their choice or not. Weather or not that is a good use of resources is another discussion but it’s not within the remit of GPs to change

mumsneedwine · 20/11/2022 15:18

@keeptalkinghappytalk you don't need A stars for medicine. Most need AAA and a few AAB. You don't need a full cv as most Unis don't even read the personal statement.
The issue as has been said is number of training places, both during and after Uni. Doctors train on the job so are taught be doctors (& nurses) while working. Less of them around so can't increase training places.
GPs and all HCP are treated like dirt. So they leave. The whole thing needs a shake up and a reset if it's ever going to work again.

Pluto46 · 20/11/2022 15:16

Workload and the any number of perpetually offended looking to be aggrieved by literally anything

Zone2NorthLondon · 20/11/2022 15:16

Where to begin..
part time GP is actually 39+ hr a week FT is minimum 60+ hr per week
Excessive workload
QOF targets
stress
pressure
some practices have an oppressive culture (they are a for profit business after all)

mumda · 20/11/2022 15:14

UmbilicusProfundus · 20/11/2022 08:49

Well Medical school places have actually increased in recent years but it’s the shit working conditions that drive doctors away. A significant number of graduates never start, and yet more leave during and after foundation training to other careers or other countries. An additional factor now is the pensions issue whereby senior doctors are having to reduce working hours to avoid huge tax charges.

It's not a tax charge, it's just there's a cap on how much you can put in your pension every year, with an overall cap.
I think its 40k a year.

When you can put 40K in your pension you've got something to worry about perhaps.
The lifetime allowance for most people is £1,073,100 in the tax year 2022/23 and has been frozen at this level until the 2025/26 tax year.

It just means they can't squirrel away as much money and therefore get taxed on it. So they opt to earn less.

The answer logically is pay them less to start with. Which you would do if you have trained as many as other countries do (as someone has said above).
One of the reasons doctors come to this country is I assume the pay.

RosesAndHellebores · 20/11/2022 15:12

@Parker231 thanks for the assumption that I have a cushy job as a pen pusher. I expect you think DH does too. Do you really think that highly paid roles in the public sector are cushy. What I can tell you is that the NHS and my GP practice have zero respect for the time of those who pay the high taxes to fund the bloody awful service.

I don't believe you have ever shared what your job and/or professional qualifications are. All we know is what your partner does.

Wherediditallgo · 20/11/2022 15:10

My friend was a health visitor before children, she had about 7years out and when she looked at going back the only return to work courses were for general nursing. She was told she would have to do shift work as part of that- totally impractical with children and a husband working away. She is now doing something completely different.

ButterflyLeg · 20/11/2022 15:08

@Qazwsxefv I totally agree. Some of it is misplaced. Doctors surely recognise this and shouldn't be taking it personally then?!!!

RosesAndHellebores · 20/11/2022 15:08

@Qazwsxefv 28/56 day prescribing is absurd. Surely the CCGs have more weight in relation to these matters than the public and ought to be pushing back regarding the nonsense of it.

KnickerlessParsons · 20/11/2022 15:07

GPS don't really work for the NHS, or at least not immediately. The current system dates back to when the NHS was initially created and is overdue for an overhaul IMO.

keeptalkinghappytalk · 20/11/2022 15:07

Training places post A level remain a key to long term increase in numbers... we allow only the thinnest slice of the student population to become Drs, demanding ultra high results plus good cv so as to restrict entry to med schools. I watched my ( comp school no graduates in family' ) nephew aim for 4 a stars a few years ago ... he did it but many other bright kids ruled out ... who would have been happily accepted for training in many of the countries we recruit doctors from. Yes that too .. low UK numbers mean we steal qualified staff from poor countries...

RosesAndHellebores · 20/11/2022 15:06

No indeed @RedWingBoots but he has other significant responsibilities and a wrong decision could end up in someone dying.

Qazwsxefv · 20/11/2022 15:05

@RosesAndHellebores
28 day prescribing is a mandate from on high about saving the nhs money. Obviously months don’t have 28 days And some meds still come in 30s. The computer system cannot work it out. Meds get out of sync on the the repeats. It’s hell for GPs and takes up so much time but we can’t get out of it - again direct anger at health sec!

I am not shocked that working full time means working more than 35hrs/week. That would be weird. I am shocked that working 40+hrs a week is considered part time just because I am only in the surgery for three days a week.

RedWingBoots · 20/11/2022 15:03

@RosesAndHellebores different jobs have different pressures.

I don't think your husband can kill someone quickly if they don't redirect them to A&E if needed, or slowly if they don't do send them for the right tests on time or chase consultants for advice.

RosesAndHellebores · 20/11/2022 15:00

@Parker231 I remember your posts. My GP practice was better in lock down than before. But for many people their experience was far worse. My dd's MH team is still only available digitally. Many affiliated services are still only available digitally with far too many admin staff wfh. I am aware of one hospital consultant tearing her hair out because everything is taking twice as long to get done. It is unacceptable.

Also my DH undertook years of study and gruelling hours to earn his title. He had to wait until he was 55 to get it.

Qazwsxefv · 20/11/2022 15:00

@ButterflyLeg

depends what it’s about

bashing because your doctor has missed something they shouldn’t of/made a mistake with your medication or worse been racially/sexually or similar inappropriate =justified and I understand the anger. We’re not all perfect. Doctors can be arsewipes just like any other person can be and should be called out on it and penalised.

However Sometimes errors are due to systemic failings such as overwork and poor it and control systems and these should be fixed (more expensive so not done) rather than hanging the individual dr (cheaper and so more often done) -see the Hadiza bower-gaba case - much easier to convict one doctor for manslaughter than admit your whole hospital system was unsafe and negligent

bashing of GPs for something they cannot control or when the bash is better directed as the health secretary does get your back up. I know It’s shit for patients right now. There are not enough doctors to provide a decent service and people in the system have been saying this for years. Moaning at the doctors that are still left who are trying to keep things going with ever increasing demand but less resource really dosent help.

common non deserved moans I hear:

  1. Waiting times for GP appointments (this is because there are not enough GPs so there are not enough appointments)
2. Waiting times for hospital appointments and scans/tests (this is the hospitals problem and also due to their not being enough of them)
  1. The care they received in hospital(also the hospitals problem)
4. Waiting times for ambulances (ambulance trusts problem and not enough of them)
  1. Delays in letters/results or not being able to see what the hospital wrote down (due to the nhs shit it system, governments problem)
6.fancy drug not being funded on the nhs (nice/prescribing committees problem) 7.waiting times for counselling or total lack of counselling or other psychological therapies (mental health trusts problem/funding ) 8.previously available drug disappearing (brexit/global supply issue) 9.GP only having 10mins to see you (funding) 10.massive wait on the phones to talk to GP (can sometimes be individual surgery related but often due to too much demand for not enough apts caused by the surgery having too many patients for its number of doctors because they are not allowed to cap lists and other surgeries have folded, and sometimes due to an actual physical lack of phone lines at rural surgeries - as in no more lines at the exchange available and these are the places where internet lines are less available) 11.lack of care package for themselves or relative (social cares problem/funding) 12.Gp refusing to fill out insurance form/marathon form/gym form in an nhs apt (nhs doesn’t pay for these services - health secs problem) 13.Gp not prescribing benzos for phobias (BNF/mrha says we can’t anymore - regulators problem)

none of these can be fixed by the individual GP. Most are stuff our union/professional body are campaigning for improvement in. Please direct anger at the health sec and the big wigs.

ButterflyLeg · 20/11/2022 14:59

Doctors should be respected for their work for as long as they are doing a good job. Same as a cleaner, bus driver, scientist or any other person doing any other job.

Having worked closely with doctors, I have observed that most doctors feel they should be respected unreservedly and can not abide being challenged or questioned. And as most folks know that kind of attitude is daft at best and downright dangerous more often than not