Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brothers kids exclude my dc, feeling so sad for them

394 replies

Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 05:00

We live in London & travel hime to visit my elderly father very frequently who absolutely adores my kids & vice versa. My dc are always so excited to see their cousins who are the same age unfortunately the feeling is not mutual... My sil has never been inclusive & my brother would never even ask my husband out for a pint even though he's heading out himself. We've accepted this even though we would love to feel more welcome when I come home. I'm crying my eyes out here for my dc though.. We had a get together at home for my father's birthday at my brothers. My dc were so delighted to be spending time with their cousins. When we arrived my nieces & nephews didn't acknowledge my kids & kept playing on their screens. I could tell my dc were crushed. They sat with them anyway but mine don't have devices so we're clueless & felt awkward. Then my bro announced he was taking his dc to the town hall as something was on, my eldest piped up can I go too... My niece replied "it's only for people from Littleton" (not name of my village). The night before there was another event in the village, we were travelling down from London but I told my sil my kids would love to go with their cousins. She was very unenthusiastic, then said oh we won't be staying long & besides the dc will be with their pals... So upset at how insular they are, my dc are crushed & I feel there's a reverse snobbery towards us as we're from London. We need to come down to my village as often as we can to see my father who has a wonderful relationship with my dc but the obvious contempt their cousins have for them is heartbreaking.
I won't discuss it with sil & my bother as they have never included us when we're home.

OP posts:
Sunnydays0101 · 20/11/2022 13:52

If your children and their cousins were close previously, it’s an age thing and happens. Lower your children’s expectations - remind your children prior to each visit that they might not see their cousins this visit. Allow your children to bring their devices and perhaps they could all link into a game together.

treadcarefully · 20/11/2022 13:50

I'm trying to put myself in your brother and his family's shoes.
They live there full time, and you maybe come twice a month and have expectations of all being together and doing stuff together including the children. Perhaps if it was every couple of months they would make more effort but every other week means their day to day lives are disrupted to a degree. I'm not taking sides but try and see it from their point of view. I do think it's an opportunity for the cousins to have a great relationship with each other but you can't force it.
Going forward make your own plans for your visits and enjoy spending time with your dad. Your db and sil might not feel under pressure then to do stuff together and may well join in more.

Gumreduction · 20/11/2022 13:49

I can’t shake the feeling that, based on your posts OP, I wouldn’t be that keen spending time with you and your Impossibly perfect children.

Pinkdelight3 · 20/11/2022 13:48

Well they travel to see their grandfather, they're extremely close to him & have a very special bond. Spending their time with him is absolutely not a chore. They learn so much from him & enjoy his company immensely.

Okay, I'm now thinking this is a tone thing. The way you talk about your side of things is OTT gushy to me and some others on here and perhaps to your DB/SiL, but obviously to some others it's fine. So just chalk it up to different strokes and either find a way dial down your expectations or keep crying cos it'll keep happening as not everything will fit with your kind, proud, special, inclusive way.

Greytea · 20/11/2022 13:46

Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 13:31

Well they travel to see their grandfather, they're extremely close to him & have a very special bond. Spending their time with him is absolutely not a chore. They learn so much from him & enjoy his company immensely.

Really? I find that hard to believe. All three of your pre-teen DC are extremely close to their “elderly” grandfather?

Or is it more like his house is like a holiday home to you that you visit on weekends, like some other private school parents may have?

Or are you actually taking on “caring” responsibilities for him because he is now struggling?

RosesAndHellebores · 20/11/2022 13:40

OP thinking this through a bit. Who gets the shopping in for when five of you descend. Do you bring it and pay for it?

Who changes the beds, washes the towels, etc.

If it's your sil I can understand why she's a bit "off" with you.

Gruffling · 20/11/2022 13:39

Talk to your brother, it's the only way you will know what is going on.

How are your DCs social lives? The arrangement sounds disruptive for them. As much as you love your dad I think you should prioritise DC.

I get it, I've been that person trying so hard to build relationships with extended family who were not interested. In retrospect, it would have been better to spend time strengthening relationships with friends that wanted to spend time with us.

It could be that your brother's family are just maintaining the relationships for the sake or your dad. Consider the reality that when he is gone, you won't see them much and prepare yourself and your family to be resilient by building friendships outside of the family.

MichelleScarn · 20/11/2022 13:39

Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 13:31

Well they travel to see their grandfather, they're extremely close to him & have a very special bond. Spending their time with him is absolutely not a chore. They learn so much from him & enjoy his company immensely.

So what are you doing when you visit, I see its been asked loads! Are you doing caring and household tasks for your DF when you visit? Can't imagine there's DIY tasks your DH needs to do every fortnight.
Now have the image of your dc and you gathered at the feet of your DF wholesomely, and judging everyone else while they run around hosting!

Northernparent68 · 20/11/2022 13:37

HeraldicBlazoning · 20/11/2022 11:27

I think some people have this idea that just because you share a bit of DNA wih people, that friendship is guaranteed.

For every person who is best friends with their cousins, there is another who hasn't seen their cousins for years and wouldn't recognise them if they passed in the street. It's nothing to feel "sad" about or try to force the friendship. It is what it is.

Valid point, most people I know do not see their cousins regularly

Stripedbag101 · 20/11/2022 13:36

Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 13:31

Well they travel to see their grandfather, they're extremely close to him & have a very special bond. Spending their time with him is absolutely not a chore. They learn so much from him & enjoy his company immensely.

Is this true? Your twelve year old gets so much enrichment from visiting his of her grandfather every other weekend that they would rather do that than ice skate or got to the cinema or the pool with their school friends? I find this really really hard to believe.

I am sure they love their elderly grandfather and enjoy seeing him. But this all seems a bit OTT.

my best friend has an amazing holiday home, lots of water toys and speed boats etc. her 13 year old son has started protesting going - he wants to ‘hang’ with his friends. That is a normal part of growing up. Your kids seem straight out of an Enid blyton book!

diddl · 20/11/2022 13:33

Your dislike of your brother & sil comes through in spades.

Perhaps their kids have picked it up & decided that they're no longer interested in your family?

Do you often ask if your kids can tag along to stuff without either you or your husband?

C8H10N4O2 · 20/11/2022 13:32

Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 13:31

Well they travel to see their grandfather, they're extremely close to him & have a very special bond. Spending their time with him is absolutely not a chore. They learn so much from him & enjoy his company immensely.

But they need their cousins there as well?

Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 13:31

Jourdain11 · 20/11/2022 13:21

I did read your post, but I wasn't talking about your family, I was referring to the fact that you say all their school friends are away every weekend. Even every second weekend is quite a lot though! What if they want to do other things or see friends at home, or just relax at the weekend rather than setting off in the car to spend a weekend with cousins who aren't enthusiastic about socialising with them?

Well they travel to see their grandfather, they're extremely close to him & have a very special bond. Spending their time with him is absolutely not a chore. They learn so much from him & enjoy his company immensely.

OP posts:
Greytea · 20/11/2022 13:31

How old is your “elderly” father?
Does he need care? Does he have disabilities? Does he need help with things?
Is he lonely?
Does he have a social life?

My lovely parents live five hours away and are in their mid-late 80s. It would be impossible for me to visit them twice a month. Same with my sister. I’m curious as to why you visit him so often.

Both you and your brother’s family are wealthy. Is your father too?

When you visit, I assume you all stay with your father. Does he have to get all the beds changed for five people and do the shopping for you all?

Is it a lovely house? In a lovely location?

Jourdain11 · 20/11/2022 13:22

Pinkdelight3 · 20/11/2022 13:10

If you read her post, she's not saying you're away, she's referring your post saying the other families from your DC's school are away every weekend. There really is a pattern to your posts that you're righteous and can't possibly be at fault.

Ha, thank you - you put that more succinctly than I did!

EarringsandLipstick · 20/11/2022 13:21

There really is a pattern to your posts that you're righteous and can't possibly be at fault.

I feel I'm reading a different thread as I don't see this?

However OP, I had assumed this was a long-standing problem. If it's only been a recent thing, why not ask DB?

Jourdain11 · 20/11/2022 13:21

Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 13:07

If you read my post, we're not away every weekend either!

I did read your post, but I wasn't talking about your family, I was referring to the fact that you say all their school friends are away every weekend. Even every second weekend is quite a lot though! What if they want to do other things or see friends at home, or just relax at the weekend rather than setting off in the car to spend a weekend with cousins who aren't enthusiastic about socialising with them?

Pinkdelight3 · 20/11/2022 13:10

Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 13:07

If you read my post, we're not away every weekend either!

If you read her post, she's not saying you're away, she's referring your post saying the other families from your DC's school are away every weekend. There really is a pattern to your posts that you're righteous and can't possibly be at fault.

Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 13:07

Jourdain11 · 20/11/2022 11:43

I also have 3 children (although mine are a bit younger, 10, 9 and 7) and I can't imagine them being particularly up for forced socialising every other weekend with family or family friends who happen to be a similar age. I'm surprised your 12 year old isn't kicking back against it a bit more - they are getting to an age where they'll have stuff they want to do on a weekend rather than being ferried off to see family for the whole weekend every fortnight.

We are also in London and although my DC don't go to private school, they have friends who do. My DD9 does hockey (at a club, not at school) and I'd say 80% of the kids there are from private schools and although some of them are away some weekends, none of them are away every weekend! I'm sure your kids have friends who stay in London at weekends and they'd probably like to see them and do activities and so on!

If you read my post, we're not away every weekend either!

OP posts:
Cantsleep4am · 20/11/2022 13:02

Porcinimushroom · 20/11/2022 11:31

Do you look down on them? You keep posting about how yoire fronm London, you holiday, have weekends away your kids are privately educated, every post smacks of showing off and pointing out how very provincial they are.

id be curious to see their view on this. I suspect it would be very different indeed/

No I'm not I'm responding to questions asked. I was asked why my kids don't do activities at the weekend or attend parties.. The answer simply is activities are catered for in after school clubs & due to the dcs friends leaving London at the weekend parties happen midweek. That is because the school they attend. End of. I didn't voluntarily give the information.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 20/11/2022 13:02

Porcinimushroom · 20/11/2022 11:53

They don't leave the village. They're going to a nearby city in a couple of weeks Christmas shopping but that's it!

As in lifestyle we love to travel with the dc, once or twice a year. My bro & sil in law rarely leave the village with their dc for days out & don't holiday

Their friends in the village are carefully chosen & would be similarly wealthy to them. In the past their dc have made comments about certain children in the village who they don't like & won't play with.. Sil or bro would chip in with a bitchy comment about the family.. Not nice.. Sil also from the village

Dc go to a private day school (no weekend school & matches are sporadic) all their activities are built into their school week which frees up family time at the weekend. Alot of their friends families also travel out of London at the weekend

when we arrived with dad the kids just ignored us all.. It was beyond rude

My dc are really inclusive & play with everyone which I am so proud of them for

When we arrived my nieces & nephews didn't acknowledge my kids & kept playing on their screens. I could tell my dc were crushed. They sat with them anyway but mine don't have devices so we're clueless & felt awkward

I never said my dc were clueless & awkward

ant then,,

However in recent months they seem to have grown resentful to my three & we don't know where it stems from.

I think everyone else is starting to understand where it stems from

you.

I'd love to see where you deduce this? The posts from OP just seem to be giving context, no idea where the snide 'you' is coming from.

susan12345678 · 20/11/2022 13:01

I wonder whether visiting every other weekend is too much, it may feel quite invasive for the other family, it is their 'territory' as it were.

They may feel as though you intend to muscle in on their closeness to your father and maintain a high profile in the family for you and your dc while they still do all the actual caring work & practical help.

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/11/2022 12:53

The views of the world you’re expressing op sound very black and white. Your children are inclusive, you’re proud of your dcs. Your brother, wife and dcs are not nice and beyond rude.

Reading between the lines, I am imagining that you or probably your dcs have insulted or upset your n&ns. Perhaps you or they didn’t mean to, but it does sound that way if things have changed over recent months. Perhaps they feel judged by you. That wouldn’t surprise me at all.

If you want to fix this, I would stop acting like the victim in this and try to sort it out with your brother and/or SIL. Firstly to apologise if you’ve done something wrong as you’ve noticed an atmosphere and ask if maybe you could talk about it as you’ve noticed an atmosphere.

You aren’t going to get anywhere though if you don’t actually tackle the issue of judging your family and way of being favourably in relation to theirs. If you have 3 dcs in London all in private school, you aren’t really living in the real world and must have a very large income. I lived in a similar bubble a few years ago and didn’t realise I was… until I wasn’t.

As for schooling, my dd changed from state secondary to private school so I have experience of both schools. I can very much assure you your dcs aren’t being as inclusive as you may think in your bubble. My dd isn’t either as certain friends have fallen by the wayside. Children, who she would hang out at school in the popular crowd, the ones getting sanctions and getting in fights. There are an awful lot of children, who your dcs will not have ever encountered.

momlette · 20/11/2022 11:57

Also I think you have very high expectations of the reaction you want. People are just going about their lives. This makes me think in turn you are unable to manage your kids’ expectations. It feels like they are trying to send a message and you haven’t got it nor have your kids and now they have resorted to rudeness to shake you off. Give them some space and don’t put your hopes and expectations on to them. They will come to you if they want to see you. Sometimes kids just don’t hit it off so don’t force it.

Porcinimushroom · 20/11/2022 11:53

They don't leave the village. They're going to a nearby city in a couple of weeks Christmas shopping but that's it!

As in lifestyle we love to travel with the dc, once or twice a year. My bro & sil in law rarely leave the village with their dc for days out & don't holiday

Their friends in the village are carefully chosen & would be similarly wealthy to them. In the past their dc have made comments about certain children in the village who they don't like & won't play with.. Sil or bro would chip in with a bitchy comment about the family.. Not nice.. Sil also from the village

Dc go to a private day school (no weekend school & matches are sporadic) all their activities are built into their school week which frees up family time at the weekend. Alot of their friends families also travel out of London at the weekend

when we arrived with dad the kids just ignored us all.. It was beyond rude

My dc are really inclusive & play with everyone which I am so proud of them for

When we arrived my nieces & nephews didn't acknowledge my kids & kept playing on their screens. I could tell my dc were crushed. They sat with them anyway but mine don't have devices so we're clueless & felt awkward

I never said my dc were clueless & awkward

ant then,,

However in recent months they seem to have grown resentful to my three & we don't know where it stems from.

I think everyone else is starting to understand where it stems from

you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread