Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

is my colleague unreasonable?

60 replies

ipal · 20/11/2022 01:49

I am based in the North of England and I am on a fully remote employment contract for a company in London. The reason why the company recruited a fully remote team is because they find it difficult to hire people in London with my specific skill set. They have a team in London as well and before the pandemic this team worked in the office of my company in London. During the pandemic, everyone in London worked from home and now the company is asking everyone in London to return 2 days a week to the office and the remaining 3 days they can work at home. A London-based colleague of mine had a bit of a run-in with our boss during a zoom call, because she said she only wants to work at the office 1 day, not 2 days. Our boss told her in a nice but firm way that basically she has no other choice to work at the office for 2 days. Today we had a teamevent and she told me that she had asked for a meeting with our boss next week. She said that she will tell my boss it's unfair that she has to work 2 days in the office if there's other people like myself who are on a fully remote contract.

So I am wondering - is my colleague unreasonable or does she have a point? I can see both sides. On the one hand I think a company can set the rules of your employment. On the other hand I can understand her that she finds it hard commuting to the office in London and I think the company should work together with her.

What does mumsnet think?

OP posts:
emptythelitterbox · 20/11/2022 02:45

I say this has zero to do with you so stay out of it.

The employees should have refused to go back to the office.

Tiani4 · 20/11/2022 02:26

London weighting for those working in inner London is often calculated at around £8,000-9,000 a year and £5,000 -7,000 for outer London weighting

For those commuting in , which was daily weekdays pre covid pandemic and for many even post pandemic is now less than daily couple times a week

(Before lots of posters reply, yes, many NMW or manual casual jobs not every firm pay anywhere near that level extra within London so it's not across the board.. that's not the point, it's illustrative)

As I said you are on different contracts

If your colleague feels she us underpaid for the requirements of her job, she Is able to make a business case to renegotiate her wages, her arrangements or seek alternative employment.

Tiani4 · 20/11/2022 02:16

Absolutely stay out of this. You have different contracts.

Her contract may have London weighting or additional amount added to it for office based requirements, whereas yours was written and interviewed for differently.

It's for your employer to sort out with her if she is unable to fulfil her contract.

Your colleague should not be trying to draw you into this.

She would be better considering if she has a business case to make to her employer on her own merits, rather than the tactic she is trying to use right now.

(You'd be wise not to let yourself be used as a pawn in this. The fact you're asking MN shows that she's drawn you in too much already!)

MarshaMelrose · 20/11/2022 02:15

I think both her position and her management's position are reasonable. But her management ultimately pay her wages so I guess they call the shots.

lifeinthehills · 20/11/2022 02:12

It depends on her contract and the needs of her role, which can't be compared to anyone else. Some things are just easier face to face. If she wants to renegotiate her contract, she can see if that is an option.

Luredbyapomegranate · 20/11/2022 02:10

Stay absolutely out of it.

It’s perfectly reasonable they want her in twice a week, for lots of jobs some face time is really important. They knew when they hired you couldn’t commute, and either they think it’s less important for your role, or they were willing to suck it up to get the right person. You were hired under different circumstances so while it might be galling for her, it isn’t unfair.

ipal · 20/11/2022 02:09

greeandorange · 20/11/2022 02:05

What are her reasons for not wanting to go in?

I would stay out of it as well, thing she won't realise is by pushing back it unfortunately makes her look a bit silly and it won't go unnoticed by HR.

Her reason is her commute. She says that although she lives in London the commute is quite long to the office.

OP posts:
greeandorange · 20/11/2022 02:05

What are her reasons for not wanting to go in?

I would stay out of it as well, thing she won't realise is by pushing back it unfortunately makes her look a bit silly and it won't go unnoticed by HR.

Booklover3 · 20/11/2022 02:02

You both have different contracts. I would stay out of it as much as you can.

Blanketpolicy · 20/11/2022 02:00

I would keep out of it and stay neutral. Your employment contract was always remote based, hers was office based, if she talks about it again say the same thing, at a push say you can see the pros and cons of both, but it is not relevant to you as your employment contract is remote.

If she wants to try to renegotiate her own contract it has nothing to do with yours.