Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

is my colleague unreasonable?

60 replies

ipal · 20/11/2022 01:49

I am based in the North of England and I am on a fully remote employment contract for a company in London. The reason why the company recruited a fully remote team is because they find it difficult to hire people in London with my specific skill set. They have a team in London as well and before the pandemic this team worked in the office of my company in London. During the pandemic, everyone in London worked from home and now the company is asking everyone in London to return 2 days a week to the office and the remaining 3 days they can work at home. A London-based colleague of mine had a bit of a run-in with our boss during a zoom call, because she said she only wants to work at the office 1 day, not 2 days. Our boss told her in a nice but firm way that basically she has no other choice to work at the office for 2 days. Today we had a teamevent and she told me that she had asked for a meeting with our boss next week. She said that she will tell my boss it's unfair that she has to work 2 days in the office if there's other people like myself who are on a fully remote contract.

So I am wondering - is my colleague unreasonable or does she have a point? I can see both sides. On the one hand I think a company can set the rules of your employment. On the other hand I can understand her that she finds it hard commuting to the office in London and I think the company should work together with her.

What does mumsnet think?

OP posts:
OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/11/2022 06:51

CapMarvel · 20/11/2022 23:07

If she is doing a role which can be done remotely she is not unreasonable to request WFH on the same terms as other people who do fully WFH.

If the business is struggling to recruit and the employee has in demand skills ultimately she might decide to walk.

She can request it. The business doesn’t have to support it just because others do it. And they can remove any London premium from her pay if they do agree it.

FrangipaniBlue · 20/11/2022 23:26

But the business need to recruit people from outside London us not the same as the business need for people to be physically in the office, in fact the two are at odds with each other.

If you and your colleague are doing the same job and you are managing to do it perfectly well remotely, then what is the "business need" for your colleague to be in the office?

She's being unreasonable is she's pissed of at you, but she's not unreasonable to be pissed off with your employer and is perfectly within her right to have a discussion with management and try to renegotiate her contract.

As other have said, it's not really any of your concern though, let her crack on!

CapMarvel · 20/11/2022 23:07

If she is doing a role which can be done remotely she is not unreasonable to request WFH on the same terms as other people who do fully WFH.

If the business is struggling to recruit and the employee has in demand skills ultimately she might decide to walk.

ipal · 20/11/2022 22:59

FrangipaniBlue · 20/11/2022 22:20

Your colleague is not being unreasonable IMO.

There are 2 people where I work who were recruited close together during the pandemic.

By virtue of living nowhere near an office person A was given a home based contract. Person B lives half an hour from an office and so was given an office based contract.

Both have (successfully) worked remotely for the last 12-18 months.

Recently, our employer decided that those with office based contracts must go in 2-3 days per week. The reason given is that it has been deemed this is how they can be most effective in their roles.

Person A and person B do EXACTLY the same job in the same team. Person B has to go into an office 2-3 days per week "to be effective" but that doesn't apply to person A who never has to go into an office.

If I was person B I'd be royally pissed off.

It might be unfair , but what I learned so far in my career is that everything is based on business needs. Meaning my company didn't give me and some other colleagues remote contracts because they love us so much and wanted to do something nice for us. They struggled to hire people in London, that's why they were willing to hire people who live far away and can never come into the office. That doesn't mean they don't want people that live in London not to come in at all.

A company can treat people differently in that regard as wfh isn't a legal right.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 20/11/2022 22:40

@ipal
I understand your perspectives, and if an agent can do what's required where ever they are, then what reasons can hq, require the asset to be in the office ?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/11/2022 22:37

I am just of the viewpoint that using the argument "it is unfair" is not a good argument to use when she talks with our manager

You're right it's not, but if she wants to make herself sound like a 3 year old that's on her

As PPs have said the key here is her contract, and while you were recruited on a fully WFH basis she wasn't
Nothing wrong with negotiating these things, but obviously the company's needs matter too and you may have no way of knowing how the London staff WFH worked out for the business

billy1966 · 20/11/2022 22:30

She can use any argument she likes but it is unlikely to work.

Yours is a very different contract to hers but if she wishes to argue the point let her.

Many people I know are loathe to be in the office more than 2 days a week.

CrimboLimbo · 20/11/2022 22:20

Yeah she’s totally unreasonable but it reflects poorly on her, not you.

if she wants to change her contract terms then she needs to put in a flexible working application. That’s all really.

FrangipaniBlue · 20/11/2022 22:20

Your colleague is not being unreasonable IMO.

There are 2 people where I work who were recruited close together during the pandemic.

By virtue of living nowhere near an office person A was given a home based contract. Person B lives half an hour from an office and so was given an office based contract.

Both have (successfully) worked remotely for the last 12-18 months.

Recently, our employer decided that those with office based contracts must go in 2-3 days per week. The reason given is that it has been deemed this is how they can be most effective in their roles.

Person A and person B do EXACTLY the same job in the same team. Person B has to go into an office 2-3 days per week "to be effective" but that doesn't apply to person A who never has to go into an office.

If I was person B I'd be royally pissed off.

hotdiggetydog · 20/11/2022 22:07

Flipping heck has no one read the post? She's asking if her colleague is being unreasonable not "what should I do"

All this don't get involved advice, completely unsolicited.

Littlewhitecat · 20/11/2022 22:00

Stay out of it - your contact is nothing to do with her. I work in a similar situation and you wouldn't believe the number of London colleagues who get paid London weighting but are refusing to go to the office 2 days a week and also think they should keep their enhanced salary. One moved to bloody Newcastle 2 years ago but thinks she should keep her extra money and work at home 🤦‍♀️

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 20/11/2022 21:20

Returning for 40% of the week rather than 100% is pretty flexible!

Ocampa · 20/11/2022 19:34

If employers are simply expecting staff to return to their contractual place of work, for the same number of days, and the arrangement is the same as pre covid, people really don't have a leg to stand on. Preferring to work from home isn't a strong business case to refuse to return to the office.

Maybe, but with the staff shortages going on companies should think about what they need to offer employees to keep them onboard. Being flexible can help retain your staff.

LolaSmiles · 20/11/2022 19:26

It's understandable you're not happy if your name gets brought up, but it does show worse on her than you.

She needs to negotiate her contract and responsibilities with her manager based on her own strengths and role, not telling tattle tales that it's not fair someone on a total different contract has different terms

rookiemere · 20/11/2022 19:01

She is being ridiculous OP. She presumably gets London weighting in her salary. My view is that I worked in the office pre covid - we always had a bit of flexibility but people were expected in 3-4 days, going in for 2 only is a bonus. Sure she may have a commute, but unless her contract says differently then her employers can pick the location she works at.

If it's so hard to recruit staff in London, then she can find another role quite easily.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 20/11/2022 18:36

HR here.

The organisation I now work for sent everyone home during Covid. They now want them back in 2-3 days a week. The idiots that moved away despite having contracts requiring them to work from London are now kicking up a fuss about being told to get themselves into the office (at their expense) or lose their London weighting.

They have no legal legs to stand on.

ipal · 20/11/2022 18:32

I am just of the viewpoint that using the argument "it is unfair" is not a good argument to use when she talks with our manager. It would be physically impossible for me to commute to London every day and for many others.

She should rather talk about her strengths and use this as a reason why the company should be accommodating her request.

I know I am probably getting way to emotionally involved in this, since I am talking about it on mumsnet.

I think deep down I just find it annoying that my name will be brought up in a management meeting about a matter that has nothing to do with me.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 20/11/2022 18:31

I think you should stay out of it but I do think enforced office attendance is unreasonable. I have said this before but a WFH-first policy is one of the best things to have ever happened in working life.

ipal · 20/11/2022 18:27

I am not getting involved. It is between her and management and if she wants to negotiate a new contract, she certainly can.

I ki

OP posts:
MintJulia · 20/11/2022 09:15

parsniiips · 20/11/2022 06:12

Were you not doing this before covid?

No, I on-boarded during covid. And we've moved office twice.

parsniiips · 20/11/2022 06:16

MarshaMelrose · 20/11/2022 05:51

If people were paying the cost of travelling before the pandemic, what's the problem with paying for travelling after the pandemic? They did, after all, save a lot of money during the pandemic by not travelling then.

I was thinking this. I've seen many threads where staff are resisting going back to the office.

If employers are simply expecting staff to return to their contractual place of work, for the same number of days, and the arrangement is the same as pre covid, people really don't have a leg to stand on. Preferring to work from home isn't a strong business case to refuse to return to the office.

Those who always worked remotely and their contract states that, should continue to do so.

parsniiips · 20/11/2022 06:12

MintJulia · 20/11/2022 03:54

Stay out of it, it's not your problem.

I'm in the same situation as your colleague. My boss wants me to return to the office 2 days a week, where currently it is one. That's fine if he's prepared to pay me the extra £400 a month gross it will cost in train, parking & petrol. I'm not paying out an extra 10% of my salary on a management whim.

Skills are so expensive in London, your colleague will be able to choose for themselves..

Were you not doing this before covid?

MissMarplesGoddaughter · 20/11/2022 06:07

Stay out of this. Do NOT get involved.

MarshaMelrose · 20/11/2022 05:51

If people were paying the cost of travelling before the pandemic, what's the problem with paying for travelling after the pandemic? They did, after all, save a lot of money during the pandemic by not travelling then.

MintJulia · 20/11/2022 03:54

Stay out of it, it's not your problem.

I'm in the same situation as your colleague. My boss wants me to return to the office 2 days a week, where currently it is one. That's fine if he's prepared to pay me the extra £400 a month gross it will cost in train, parking & petrol. I'm not paying out an extra 10% of my salary on a management whim.

Skills are so expensive in London, your colleague will be able to choose for themselves..