Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

is my colleague unreasonable?

60 replies

ipal · 20/11/2022 01:49

I am based in the North of England and I am on a fully remote employment contract for a company in London. The reason why the company recruited a fully remote team is because they find it difficult to hire people in London with my specific skill set. They have a team in London as well and before the pandemic this team worked in the office of my company in London. During the pandemic, everyone in London worked from home and now the company is asking everyone in London to return 2 days a week to the office and the remaining 3 days they can work at home. A London-based colleague of mine had a bit of a run-in with our boss during a zoom call, because she said she only wants to work at the office 1 day, not 2 days. Our boss told her in a nice but firm way that basically she has no other choice to work at the office for 2 days. Today we had a teamevent and she told me that she had asked for a meeting with our boss next week. She said that she will tell my boss it's unfair that she has to work 2 days in the office if there's other people like myself who are on a fully remote contract.

So I am wondering - is my colleague unreasonable or does she have a point? I can see both sides. On the one hand I think a company can set the rules of your employment. On the other hand I can understand her that she finds it hard commuting to the office in London and I think the company should work together with her.

What does mumsnet think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/11/2022 13:52

GnomeDePlume · 21/11/2022 13:14

Equipment cost is the same whether someone is home working 5 days or 1 day per week

Never heard of accident risk being used as a reason for people being pulled back into the office

IME people take less sick leave when working from home as they are better able to manage minor ailments from home

It’s a H+S nightmare if you look at the legal implications.

(I’m a HR director.)

GnomeDePlume · 21/11/2022 13:14

Equipment cost is the same whether someone is home working 5 days or 1 day per week

Never heard of accident risk being used as a reason for people being pulled back into the office

IME people take less sick leave when working from home as they are better able to manage minor ailments from home

KatherineJaneway · 21/11/2022 12:13

Presumably she is contracted and paid to work in the London office, so it is not reasonable of your colleague to refuse to come in. Also assume the commute will have been the same as before the pandemic and, if she moved further away, she needs to live with that additional travel time as a consequence.

I know personally I am more productive at home but value my in-office days to create and maintain relationships with a wide range of my colleagues who I do not normally work directly with and some tasks can be done much better in person.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/11/2022 11:41

GnomeDePlume · 21/11/2022 10:54

Businesses insisting people come back into the office when there is no actual need are missing an opportunity to give employees a cost saving without any cost to the business.

This could save the business in terms of giving big cost of living pay raises.

It does cost the business to have people working at home.

*Home workers are entitled to claim travel
costs to attend work sites.
*if they have equipment needs, eg a specialist chair or desk the organisation needs to supply 2 - one at home and one at work.
*if the employee falls over at home it’s potentially an industrial accident over which they have no control
*increased sick leave/claims from employees who have worked hunched up over a dining table and now have MSK issues or agoraphobia
*They have to pay to heat and light and equip offices with 20% (or less) occupancy.
*It doesn’t help green credentials when fewer people travel but then heat their houses rather than
one office.

GnomeDePlume · 21/11/2022 10:54

Businesses insisting people come back into the office when there is no actual need are missing an opportunity to give employees a cost saving without any cost to the business.

This could save the business in terms of giving big cost of living pay raises.

EBearhug · 21/11/2022 10:45

Her commute is not the employer's problem.

We had quite a few people on home-based contracts before covid - this means if they attend the office, they claim travel expenses (although currently you need to get such travel approved by someone high up as a money-saving thing.) Some people were already on contracts with adjusted hours allowing them to work round school pick-ups and things like that.

Most of us were on normal 40 hours a week, 8- 17:30 contracts, but in practice, had a lot of flexibility (I usually worked from home once a week; starting/finishing times often varied, which HR encouraged because it meant we're not all sitting in traffic queues at the same time, so improves our green credentials, and departments as a whole are available for longer.)

Since covid, those of us on office-based contracts have changed to hybrid contracts, which means we are expected to ne in at least one day a week (some departments are teo or three days a week.) If you don't want to do that, you are meant to renegotiate your contract to a home-based one. In practice, I don't think many have, they're just not coming in. However, we are a department which is spread across about 7 or 8 offices in 5 countries, so we are almost never in the same place at the same time, and have been accustomed to using video conferencing since the technology has been available for it. (Other departments are different, especially legal and financial, which tend to be in-country; I'm tech.)

There's been guidance that office days should focus on face-to-face meetings and collaboration - if you're just going to spend the day on the phone, you might as well be at home.

But ot all comes down to the business and what they want. If someone can show the benefit to the business of being on a home-based contract, then put in a request for that, but the cost (time or money) of an individual's commute isn't something they'll be interested in.

Adultchildofelderlyparents · 21/11/2022 10:28

Is there a difference in your employment contracts? Are you a fixed-term contractor and she a permanent employee? If so then I think it's reasonable for you to be fully remote and her go into the office sometimes. As an employee she benefits from being employed in more ways than just being paid to do a job, so it's fair for her to contribute time in the office - there is a lot more benefit to both staff and company from being in the office than just physical presence.
If you are both equal in employment terms then I think she is reasonable to raise it. You might have specialist skills that are difficult to recruit but if they are willing to make reasonable adjustments for you then they should for everyone, regardless of location. But as I say, if you are a fixed-term contractor then fair enough for only you to stay fully remote.
(For context, I'm a fully remote fixed-term contractor)

balalake · 21/11/2022 10:26

It is for her to raise in a separate conversation. Personal view is that two days a week from what you describe adds little to the business that could not be achieved by one day a week, perhaps varied as to which day.

You were recruited on a fully remote contract, people can be on different arrangements.

EndlessRain · 21/11/2022 10:18

I expect you (or someone equivalent to her in a remote role) is paid less. Presumably she can ask to go onto a remote contract and take the associated reduction in pay.

But agree with others, it's not any of your business.

Cw112 · 21/11/2022 10:17

I personally don't think commute is a good enough reason because she knew what her commute would be when she applied for the job and accepted it on the understanding that she could get herself there as required by the company. I think it does absolutely no harm for her to ask the question but if they've said no then I think it's unreasonable for her to continue pushing it. If you've come in on a contract that was always going to involve remote working then that's completely different. The company aren't obligated to uphold her request. As others have said I'd stay out of it completely and let her argue it herself if that's what she wants to do .

theemmadilemma · 21/11/2022 10:16

parsniiips · 20/11/2022 06:16

I was thinking this. I've seen many threads where staff are resisting going back to the office.

If employers are simply expecting staff to return to their contractual place of work, for the same number of days, and the arrangement is the same as pre covid, people really don't have a leg to stand on. Preferring to work from home isn't a strong business case to refuse to return to the office.

Those who always worked remotely and their contract states that, should continue to do so.

This.

I appreciate some people are finding it shit. But if you were employed in an office based role as part of your contract, then it is what it is.

Either negotiate, find a new role, or suck it up.

Notonationalism · 21/11/2022 10:00

@MintJulia apologies in that case, they shouldn’t try to change the terms in which you were employed, that’s crap. Hope you get a decent outcome x

SellFridges · 21/11/2022 09:35

I’m a bit tired of people using “commute” as a reason for not wanting to abide by requests for people to return to the office. It’s a lifestyle choice ultimately. I live close to my office, and made a choice to do so as I don’t like to commute for hours. Others didn’t used to mind it…

We should be focused on having mature conversations about the future of workplaces and working hours, and people dragging their puppy, childcare and long commute muddies the water.

CommaCommaDashDash · 21/11/2022 09:27

I think she'll have to expect her her employer stick to the terms of the contract, it opens up a can of worms otherwise
Where she goes with that is her decision

CapMarvel · 21/11/2022 09:20

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/11/2022 06:51

She can request it. The business doesn’t have to support it just because others do it. And they can remove any London premium from her pay if they do agree it.

Well, quite. But it's not an unreasonable request in of itself.

starfishmummy · 21/11/2022 09:16

MarshaMelrose · 20/11/2022 05:51

If people were paying the cost of travelling before the pandemic, what's the problem with paying for travelling after the pandemic? They did, after all, save a lot of money during the pandemic by not travelling then.

I'm inclined to agree. DH used to commute to London and he has made a huge saving in commuting costs by working from home, even going in twice a week he's still saving.

MintJulia · 21/11/2022 09:14

Notonationalism · 21/11/2022 07:36

@MintJulia ypu mean your employer wants you to resume your pre pandemic working arrangement now that we are no longer in a pandemic?

No, I was recruited during lockdown, and work location is Remote.

I go in once a week to maintain relationships. He wants two days, but that's an extra £250 a week in train & parking.

We'll work it out eventually - He'll probably meet me half way in terms of annual pay rise.

AloysiusBear · 21/11/2022 08:41

I am just of the viewpoint that using the argument "it is unfair" is not a good argument to use when she talks with our manager. It would be physically impossible for me to commute to London every day and for many others.

I would see it differently. Are you doing the same role? If it is possible for you to do that same role 100% remotely, why isn't it possible for her to?

Either you are not meeting the requirements of the role fully but thats being tolerated in your case & not hers (not fair?), or she doesn't actually need to be in the office and is being made to go in due to some ridiculous managememt desire for presenteeism (stupid).

Guitarbar · 21/11/2022 08:31

How successful she is at pushing back will be based on how likely they are to be able to replace her probably. I would expect them to remove London weighting though if she pushes to have remote working or going in less than the business are stipulating I'd expect them to take her London weighting. Of course that's a tough one as she lives in London so does have higher costs for rent etc, but it's calculated on where you work rather than where you live.

fruitsaladsweets · 21/11/2022 08:30

It's not unfair because it's part of her contract, and it's not part of yours. You were hired on different terms.

She can try to negotiate a new contract if she wants to.

I would just stay out of it if I were you, it doesn't concern you.

ZenNudist · 21/11/2022 08:27

Takes me ages

ZenNudist · 21/11/2022 08:26

I'm in a similar position to you in that I'm a northern outpost of a London team but I have a local office too. It takes me Ges to get into London for the odd team meeting and i am paid less than London staff in same role.

Are you not occasionally expected to travel to London at great inconvenience? Are you paid less? Your situation is nog comparable with a full time London based staff member. 2 days a week is more than reasonable.

Notonationalism · 21/11/2022 07:36

@MintJulia ypu mean your employer wants you to resume your pre pandemic working arrangement now that we are no longer in a pandemic?

emptythelitterbox · 21/11/2022 07:34

I think it's fine for her to refuse to go back into the office.
She can put her resume out and find something else that is WFH in case they say no.
That's what I'd do if I still worked for someone else. I'd just find something else and leave.

girlmom21 · 21/11/2022 07:10

Length of commute isn't an argument isn't really an excuse if she did it pre-covid.

Two days is still very flexible.